Journal of Korean Medicine for Obesity Research 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.43
-
pISSN : 1976-9334 / eISSN : 2288-1522
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/jkomor
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Comparison of the Effects of Cognitive Behavioral Therapy and Behavioral Treatment on Obesity Treatment by Patient Subtypes: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis
- Journal of Korean Medicine for Obesity Research
- Abbr : J Korean Med Obes Res
- 2020, 20(2), pp.178-192
- DOI : 10.15429/jkomor.2020.20.2.178
- Publisher : The Society of Korean Medicine for Obesity Research
- Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > Korean Medicine
- Received : October 26, 2020
- Accepted : November 21, 2020
- Published : December 30, 2020
Jin-Young Cha 1, Seo-Young Kim 2, Shin In-Soo 3, Young-Bae Park 1, Young-Woo Lim 1
1누베베 미병연구소
2누베베 한의원 분당점
3동국대학교 교육대학원
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Objectives: The present study aimed to compare the impacts of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and behavioral treatment (BT) on weight loss and psychological outcomes among patients with three different subtypes of obesity: simple obesity, obesity with binge eating disorder, and obesity with depression.
Methods: Embase, PubMed, the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials, Research Information Sharing Service, and Korean Studies Information Service System were systematically searched for randomized controlled trials conducted on or before May 2020, that used CBT to treat obesity. Methodological quality was assessed using Cochrane’s risk of bias tool 2 and publication bias was evaluated through the funnel plot using the trim and fill method, Egger’s test, and Begg and Mazumdar rank correlation test. A meta-analysis was conducted using a random-effects model and the standardized mean difference with 95% confidence interval (CI) was used to determine effect size.
Results: Twenty-one randomized controlled trials with a total of 22 intervention arms and 2,590 patients were included. Our study results revealed that the effects of CBT, compared with BT, on weight loss distinctly differed across all patient subgroups. In the simple obesity group, CBT was more effective than BT (Hedges’ g=0.138, CI=0.012~0.264); however, in the obesity with binge eating disorder group, BT was more effective than CBT (Hedges’ g=-0.228, CI=-0.418~-0.038); in the obesity with depression group, the effect of CBT was not statistically different from that of BT (Hedges’ g=0.276, CI=-0.307~0.859). Further studies with larger sample sizes are required to confirm the outcomes observed in this study.
Conclusions: Our results indicated that the effects of CBT on obesity treatment vary based on patient subtype. Therefore, our findings suggest that CBT or BT should be selectively recommended as a treatment strategy for different obesity subtypes.
Statistics
-
232 Viewed
-
1 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[web]
World Health Organization
/ 2020
/ Obesity and overweight
/ World Health Organization
/ https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and-overweight
[book]
Dobbs R
/ 2014
/ Overcoming obesity: an initial economic analysis
/ McKinsey Global Institute
[journal]
Shaw K
/ 2005
/ Psychological interventions for overweight or obesity
/ Cochrane Database Syst Rev
2
[journal]
Castelnuovo G
/ 2017
/ Cognitive behavioral therapy to a id weight l oss in obese p atients : current p erspectives
/ Psychol Res Behav Manag
10
: 165~173
[journal]
Da rby A
/ 2009
/ The rising prevalence of comorbid obesity and eating disorder behaviors from 1995 to 2005
/ Int J Eat Disord
42(2)
: 104~108
[journal]
de Wit L
/ 2010
/ Depression and obesity : a meta-analysis of community-based studies
/ Psychiatry Res
178(2)
: 230~235
[journal]
Jacob A
/ 2018
/ Impact of cognitive-behavioral interventions on weight loss and psychological outcomes : a meta-analysis
/ Health Psychol
37(5)
: 417~432
[journal]
Mannan M
/ 2016
/ Is there a bi-directional relationship between depression and obesity among adult men and women? Systematic review and bias-adjusted meta-analysis
/ Asian J Psychiatr
21
: 51~66
[journal]
Wadden TA
/ 2003
/ Behavioral treatment of obesity
/ Endocrinol Metab Clin North Am
32(4)
: 981~1003
[journal]
Stahre L
/ 2007
/ A randomized controlled trial of two weight-reducing short-term group treatment programs for obesity with an 18-month follow-up
/ Int J Behav Med
14(1)
: 48~55
[journal]
Peckmezian T
/ 2017
/ A systematic review and narrative synthesis of interventions for uncomplicated obesity:weight loss, well-being and impact on eating disorders
/ J Eat Disord
5
: 15~
[journal]
Palavras MA
/ 2017
/ The efficacy of psychological therapies in reducing weight and binge eating in people with bulimia nervosa and binge eating disorder who are overweight or obese-a critical synthesis and meta-analyses
/ Nutrients
9(3)
: 299~
[journal]
Brownley KA
/ 2016
/ Binge-eating disorder in adults : a systematic review and meta-analysis
/ Ann Intern Med
165(6)
: 409~420
[journal]
Peat CM
/ 2017
/ Comparative effectiveness of treatments for binge-eating disorder : systematic review and network meta-analysis
/ Eur Eat Disord Rev
25(5)
: 317~328
[journal]
Faulconbridge LF
/ 2018
/ Combined treatment for o besity a nd d epression : a pilot s tudy
/ Obesity(Silver Spring)
26(7)
: 1144~1152
[book]
American Psychiatric Association
/ 2013
/ Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders
/ American Psychiatric Association
[journal]
Liberati A
/ 2009
/ The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate health care interventions : explanation and elaboration
/ PLoS Med
6
: e1000100~
[journal]
Grilo CM
/ 2005
/ A randomized controlled comparison of guided self-help cognitive behavioral therapy and behavioral weight loss for binge eating disorder
/ Behav Res Ther
43(11)
: 1509~1525
[journal]
Wilson GT
/ 2010
/ Psychological treatments of binge eating disorder
/ Arch Gen Psychiatry
67(1)
: 94~101
[journal]
Grilo CM
/ 2011
/ Cognitive-behavioral therapy, behavioral weight loss, and sequential treatment for obese patients with binge-eating disorder : a randomized controlled trial
/ J Consult Clin Psychol
79(5)
: 675~685
[journal]
Linde JA
/ 2011
/ A randomized controlled trial of behavioral weight loss treatment versus combined weight loss/depression treatment among women with comorbid obesity and depression
/ Ann Behav Med
41(1)
: 119~130
[journal]
Pagoto S
/ 2013
/ Randomized controlled trial of behavioral treatment for comorbid obesity and depression in women : the be active trial
/ Int J Obes(Lond)
37(11)
: 1427~1434
[journal]
Munsch S
/ 2007
/ Arandomized comparison of cognitive behavioral therapy and behavioral weight loss treatment for overweight individuals with binge eating disorder
/ Int J Eat Disord
40(2)
: 102~113
[journal]
Grilo CM
/ 2013
/ Self-help for binge eating disorder in primary care : a randomized controlled trial with ethnically and racially diverse obese patients
/ Behav Res Ther
51(12)
: 855~861
[journal]
Lawlor ER
/ 2020
/ Third-wave cognitive behaviour therapies for weight management : a systematic review and network meta-analysis
/ Obes Rev
21(7)
: e13013~
[journal]
Carrière K
/ 2018
/ Mindfulness-based interventions for weight loss : a systematic review and meta-analysis
/ Obes Rev
19(2)
: 164~177
[journal]
Hayes SC
/ 2011
/ Open, aware, and active : contextual approaches as an emerging trend in the behavioral and cognitive therapies
/ Annu Rev Clin Psychol
7
: 141~168
[web]
Higgins JPT
/ 2019
/ Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions, Version 6.0 (updated July 2019)
/ Cochrane
/ http://www.training.cochrane.org/handbook
[book]
Lipsey MW
/ 2001
/ Practical meta-analysis. Applied social research methods series (Vol. 49)
/ Sage Publications
[journal]
Becker BJ
/ 1988
/ Synthesizing standardized mean-change measures
/ Br J Math Stat Psychol
41(2)
: 257~278
[book]
Borenstein M
/ 2009
/ Introduction to meta-analysis
/ Wiley
[journal]
Werrij MQ
/ 2009
/ Adding cognitive therapy to dietetic treatment is associated with less relapse in obesity
/ J Psychosom Res
67(4)
: 315~324
[journal]
Tanco S
/ 1998
/ Well-being and morbid obesity in women : a controlled therapy evaluation
/ Int J Eat Disord
23(3)
: 325~339
[journal]
Ames GE
/ 2005
/ Changing weight-loss expectations : a randomized pilot study
/ Eat Behav
6(3)
: 259~269
[journal]
Ramirez EM
/ 2001
/ A comparison of weight control and weight control plus body image therapy for obese men and women
/ J Consult Clin Psychol
69(3)
: 440~446
[journal]
Annesi JJ
/ 2012
/ Supported exercise improves controlled eating and weight through its effects on psychosocial factors : extending a systematic research program toward treatment development
/ Perm J
16(1)
: 7~18
[journal]
Annesi JJ
/ 2013
/ Mediation of social cognitive theory variables in the relationship of exercise and improved eating in sedentary adults with severe obesity
/ Psychol Health Med
18(6)
: 714~724
[journal]
Jamal SN
/ 2016
/ Effectiveness of a group support lifestyle modification(GSLiM)programme among obese adults in workplace : a randomised controlled trial
/ PLoS One
11(8)
: e0160343~
[journal]
Befort CA
/ 2008
/ Motivational interviewing fails to improve outcomes of a behavioral weight loss program for obese African American women : a pilot randomized trial
/ J Behav Med
31(5)
: 367~377
[journal]
Annesi JJ
/ 2010
/ Relations of changes in self-regulatory efficacy and physical self-concept with improvements in body satisfaction in obese women initiating exercise with cognitive-behavioral support
/ Body Image
7(4)
: 356~359
[journal]
Egger M
/ 1997
/ Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test
/ BMJ
315(7109)
: 629~634
[journal]
Begg CB
/ 1994
/ Operating characteristics of a rank correlation test for publication bias
/ Biometrics
50(4)
: 1088~1101
[journal]
Manzoni GM
/ 2016
/ Virtual reality-enhanced cognitive-behavioral therapy for morbid obesity : a randomized controlled study with 1 year follow-up
/ Cyberpsychol Behav Soc Netw
19(2)
: 134~140
[journal]
Marcon ER
/ 2017
/ What is the best treatment before bariatric surgery? exercise, exercise and group therapy, or conventional waiting: a randomized controlled trial
/ Obes Surg
27(3)
: 763~773
[journal]
Rodriguez-Hernandez H
/ 2009
/ Adding cognitive behavioural treatment to either low-carbohydrate or low-fat diets : differential short-term effects
/ Br J Nutr
102(12)
: 1847~1853
[journal]
Sterne JA
/ 2000
/ Publication and related bias in meta-analysis : power of statistical tests and prevalence in the literature
/ J Clin Epidemiol
53(11)
: 1119~1129
[journal]
Amrhein V
/ 2019
/ Scientists rise up against statistical significance
/ Nature
567(7748)
: 305~307
[journal]
Wasserstein RL
/ 2016
/ The ASA"s statement on p-value : context, process, and purpose
/ Am Stat
70(2)
: 129~133
[journal]
Ranganathan P
/ 2015
/ Common pitfalls in statistical analysis : Clinical versus statistical significance
/ Perspect Clin Res
6(3)
: 169~170
[journal]
Markowitz S
/ 2008
/ Understanding the relation between obesity and depression : causal mechanisms and implications for treatment
/ Clin Psychol Sci Prac
15
: 1~20
[journal]
Grilo CM
/ 2009
/ DSM-IV psychiatric disorder comorbidity and its correlates in binge eating disorder
/ Int J Eat Disord
42(3)
: 228~234
[journal]
Straus S
/ 2010
/ Registering systematic reviews
/ CMAJ
182(1)
: 13~14