Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.81
-
pISSN : 1598-1487 / eISSN : 2671-7247
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/jksarm
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Study on the Preliminary Analysis for the No-Gun Ri Massacre Documentation Strategy
- Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management
- Abbr : JRMASK
- 2015, 15(4), pp.173~194
- DOI : 10.14404/JKSARM.2015.15.4.173
- Publisher : Korean Society of Archives and Records Management
- Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science > Archival Studies / Conservation
Kim Youseung
1,
Ryu， Ban-Dee
1
1중앙대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
The study reports a preliminary analysis for the No-Gun Ri massacre documentation strategy based on Hackman and Wornow-Blewett’s implementation model, as an appraisal and selection method for No-Gun Ri Digital Archives. It intends to review the theoretical background for this process, inlcuding a history of the No-Gun Ri massacre and the development of documentation strategy. From the theoretical analysis, this study identified the No Gun Ri documentation strategy processes in 5 categories: “cooperative collecting”, “collecting in specific areas”, “identifing missing areas” and “advisory group”. With these 5 categories, this study discusses the application of the Hackman and Wornow-Blewett’s implementation model in the No Gun Ri case and reviews the strategy’s pros and cons. As a result, firstly, we classfy focusing groups into “victims and bereaved family”, “government”, “civil society”, “the press” and “literature and art”. Secondly, we also classify documentation categories into “massacre records”, “investigation activity records” and “cherish memory”.
Statistics
-
700 Viewed
-
253 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
권순명
/ 2009
/
A Study on Documentation Strategy for Archiving Locality
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(21)
: 41~84
[journal]
김장환
/ 2015
/
A Case Study on Documentation Strategy Applying the Institutional Functional Analysis Methodology
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(44)
: 5~49
[book]
김정희
/ 2005
/ 노근리, 그 해 여름
/ 사계절
[journal]
김화경
/ 2012
/
Acquisition Strategy for Constructing Local Archives: The Case of Busan Sanbokdoro Archives
/ 한국기록관리학회지
/ 한국기록관리학회
12(2)
: 143~161
[journal]
김화선
/ 2014
/
Three ways to narrate Nogeun-ri incident
/ 아동청소년문학연구
/ 한국아동청소년문학학회
(15)
: 283~311
[report]
노근리사건조사반
/ 2001
/ 노근리사건 조사결과보고서
[book]
노근리에서 매향리까지 발간위원회
/ 2001
/ 주한미군문제해결운동사 : 노근리에서 매향리까지
/ 깊은자유
[journal]
노용석
/ 2015
/
From Individual Funeral to Social Commemoration - The historical process and symbolic meaning in the exhumation of civilian massacres around Korean war -
/ 역사와경계
/ 부산경남사학회
(95)
: 207~242
[journal]
설문원
/ 2010
/
Directions of Implementing Documentation Strategies for Local Regions
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(26)
: 103~149
[journal]
설문원
/ 2011
/
A Study on Documenting Locality in Digital Environment
/ 한국기록관리학회지
/ 한국기록관리학회
11(1)
: 207~230
[journal]
설문원
/ 2012
/
Designing a Space-based Locality Documentation Model
/ 한국비블리아학회지
/ 한국비블리아학회
23(4)
: 437~455
[journal]
설문원
/ 2012
/
Directions of Archival Contents Development for Documenting Localities
/ 한국도서관·정보학회지
/ 한국도서관·정보학회
43(2)
: 317~342
[journal]
설문원
/ 2012
/
Building Participatory Digital Archives for Documenting Localities
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(32)
: 3~44
[journal]
설문원
/ 2014
/
A Design of Narrative Structure for Documenting Environmental Conflicts : Case of Mi-ryang Transmission Towers Construction Conflicts
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(42)
: 287~326
[journal]
설문원
/ 2013
/
Implementing Space-based Networked Documentation for Donghae-Nambu Railway Areas in Busan Metropolitan City
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(36)
: 233~269
[journal]
엄찬호
/ 2013
/
For the Massacre of Civilians in the Korean War, Anger and Healing
/ 인문과학연구
/ 인문과학연구소
(36)
: 585~607
[book]
오연호
/ 1999
/ 노근리 그 후
/ (주)월간 말
[journal]
오정희
/ 2015
/
A Study of the Use of Documentation Strategies for Presidential Records Collection
/ 한국기록관리학회지
/ 한국기록관리학회
15(1)
: 89~125
[book]
이동희
/ 2007
/ 노근리 아리랑
/ 풀길
[journal]
이미영
/ 2009
/
A Case Study on the Documentation in a Disaster Area - On the Basis of Great Hanshin-Awaji Earthquake -
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(21)
: 85~116
[journal]
이승억
/ 2005
/
Analysing Archival Appraisal and Selection Decision : Theoretic Approach
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(12)
: 37~80
[journal]
이승억
/ 2014
/
Archival Appraisal Strategy and policy for documentation of Contemporary Society
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(42)
: 185~211
[journal]
이재곤
/ 2008
/
Historical Characteristic of No Gun-Ri Incident, its Charateristic in the Perspective of International Law, and Future Tasks
/ 법학연구
/ 법학연구소
19(2)
: 235~280
[book]
정구도
/ 2003
/ 노근리는 살아있다
/ 백산서당
[book]
김구현
/ 2008
/ 한국전쟁기 인권침해 및 역사인식의 문제
/ 두남
[book]
정은용
/ 1994
/ 그대, 우리의 아픔을 아는가
/ 도서출판 다리미디어
[journal]
최병수
/ 1999
/ 동란 초기 충북 영동지구의 민간인 살상사건에 관한 연구(1): 노근리의 미군대양민 집단학살사건을 중심으로
/ 인문학지
/ 충북대학교 인문과학연구소
17(1)
: 245~283
[journal]
Abraham, Terry
/ 1991
/ Collection Policy or Documentation Strategy: Theory and Practice
/ American Archivist
54
: 44~52
[journal]
Alexander, Philip
/ 1987
/ The Roots of 128: A Hypothetical Documentation Strategy
/ American Archivist
50
: 518~531
[book]
Bellardo, Lewis
/ 1992
/ A Glossary for Archivist, Manuscript Curators, and Records Managers
/ SAA
[journal]
Boles, Frank
/ 1987
/ Mix Two Parts Interest to One Part Information and Appraise Until Done : Understanding Contemporary Record Selection Processes
/ American Archivist
50
: 356~368
[journal]
Boles, Frank
/ 1996
/ Et Tu Schellenberg? Thoughts on the Dagger of American Appraisal Theory
/ American Archivist
59
: 298~310
[journal]
Cook, Terry
/ 1992
/ Documentation Strategy
/ Archivaria
34
: 181~191
[journal]
Cox, Richard
/ 1989
/ A Documentation Strategy Case Study: Western New York
/ American Archivist
52
: 192~200
[journal]
Cox, Richard
/ 1995
/ The Archival Documentation Strategy, A Brief Intellectual History, 1984-1994, and Practical Description
/ Janus
(2)
: 76~93
[journal]
Cox, Richard
/ 1996
/ The Archival Documentation Strategy and Its Implications for the Apraisal Architectural Records
/ American Archivist
59
: 144~154
[journal]
Duranti, Luciana
/ 1994
/ The Concept of Appraisal and Archival Theory
/ American Archivist
57
: 328~343
[journal]
Ericson, Timothy
/ 1997
/ ‘To Approximate June Pasture’; The Documentation Strategy in the Real World
/ Archival Issues
: 5~20
[journal]
Hackman, Larry
/ 2009
/ The Origins of Documenation Strategies in Context: Recollections and Reflections
/ American Archivist
72
: 436~459
[journal]
Hackman, Larry
/ 1987
/ The Documentation Strategy Process: A Model and a Case Study
/ American Archivist
50
: 12~47
[journal]
Ham, Gerald
/ 1975
/ The Archival Edge
/ American Archivist
38
: 5~13
[book]
Hanley, Charles
/ 2002
/ The Bridge at No Gun Ri: A Hidden Nightmare from the Korean War
/ Henry Holt and Co
[journal]
Helen, Samuels
/ 1986
/ Who Controls the Past?
/ American Archivist
49
: 109~124
[confproc]
Hinding, Andrea
/ 1981
/ Documentation: New Collecting Strategies for the 1980s
/ Options for the80s: Proceedings of the Second National Conference of the Association of College and Research Libraries
/ JAI Press
[journal]
Horton, Robert
/ 2001
/ Cultivating Our Garden: Archives, Community, and Documentation
/ Archival Issue
26
: 27~40
[journal]
Johnson, Elizabeth Snowden
/ 2008
/ Our Archives, Our Selves: Documentation Strategy and the Re-Appraisal of Professional Identity
/ American Archivist
71
: 190~202
[journal]
Malkmus, Doris
/ 2008
/ Documentation Strategy: Mastodon or Retro-Success?
/ American Archivist
71
: 384~409
[journal]
Menne-Haritz, Angelika
/ 1994
/ Appraisal or Documentation: Can We Appraise Archives by Selecting Content?
/ American Archivist
57
: 528~542
[book]
Pearce-Moses, Richard
/ 2005
/ A Glossary of Archival and Records Terminology
/ Society of American Archivists
[journal]
Robert Horton
/ 2001
/ Cultivating Our Garden: Archives, Community, and Documentation
/ Archival Issues
26
: 27~40
[journal]
Zinn, Howard
/ 1977
/ Secrecy, Archives and the Public Interest
/ The Midwestern Archivist
2
: 14~26
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.