A Study on the Established Requirements for Records through Precedent Analysis: Focusing on “Inter-Korean Summit Meeting Minutes Deletion” Cases (판례 분석을 통한 기록의 성립 요건 검토: ‘남북정상회담회의록 삭제’ 판례를 중심으로)

Lee, Cheol-hwan (이철환); Youngsam Zoh (조영삼)

doi:10.14404/JKSARM.2021.21.1.041

A Study on the Established Requirements for Records through Precedent Analysis: Focusing on “Inter-Korean Summit Meeting Minutes Deletion” Cases

Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management
Abbr : JRMASK
2021, 21(1), pp.41~56
DOI : 10.14404/JKSARM.2021.21.1.041
Publisher : Korean Society of Archives and Records Management
Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science > Archival Studies / Conservation
Received : January 18, 2021
Accepted : February 2, 2021
Published : February 28, 2021

Lee, Cheol-hwan ¹, Youngsam Zoh ²

¹대통령기록관 기록연구사
²서울기록원 원장

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This study aims to analyze the court ruling on “Inter-Korean Summit Meeting Minutes Deletion,” identify how the established requirements, concept, and scope for the records prescribed in the Public Records Management Act are applied in actual cases, and summarize the future tasks. It analyzes the “approval theory” as the point of establishment for records by the ruling means and how the meaning of approval is determined, and examines the difference between the e-jiwon System and the On-Nara System to understand the meaning of ruling clearly. Moreover, it analyzes how the “Invalidity of Public Documents Crime” in Article 141 in the Criminal Act influences record management. Based on such comprehensive case analyses, the study proposes what tasks the administrative agencies such as the National Archives of Korea and the Ministry of the Interior and Safety should perform.

KEYWORDS

Archival precedent, Approved, Management of presidential archives, Invalidity of public documents, Records invalidity of public documents, e-jiwon system, Administrative information dataset

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] 강태영 / 2017 / 이지원, 대통령의 일하는 방식 / 행복한 책읽기

[report] 국가기록관리 혁신T/F / 2017 / 국가기록관리 혁신 방안 / 국가기록원

[other] 국가기록원 / 2018 / 기록관리성찰백서

[other] 국가기록원 / 2020 / 행정정보데이터세트 기록관리 실행매뉴얼

[journal] 설문원 / 2019 / Exploring the Concepts of Records as Persistent Representation of Activities / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (59) : 5~46

[report] 이젬마 / 2019 / 기록의 개념과 성립요건 / 국가기록원

[journal] 이젬마 / 2020 / A Study on the Judgment of Authoritative Records by Applying the Concept of Authenticity and Reliability / 한국기록관리학회지 / 한국기록관리학회 20(3) : 77~97

[report] 임신영 / 2019 / 기록이란 무엇인가? / 국가기록원

[journal] 장대환 / 2019 / Memory, Records and Archival Justice / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (59) : 277~320

[other] 정진임 / 2013 / NLL 대화록 실종을 둘러싼 기록관리 쟁점들 / 한국국가기록연구원

[thesis] 조영삼 / 2011 / 한국의 대통령기록관리 제도 연구 / 박사 / 명지대학교 기록정보과학전문대학원

[report] 한국법제연구원 / 2019 / ｢공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률｣ 입법평가 및 개선방안 연구

[other] 행정안전부 / 2018 / 행정업무운영 편람

[other] / 공공기관의 기록물 관리에 관한 법률 [시행 2000.1.1.]

[other] / 공공기관의 기록물 관리에 관한 법률 시행령 [시행 2007.4.5.]

[other] / 공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률 [시행 2020.6.4.]

[other] / 공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률 시행령 [시행 2021.1.5.]

[other] / 대통령기록물 관리에 관한 법률 [시행 2007.7.28.]

[other] / 대통령기록물 관리에 관한 법률 [시행 2010.8.5.]

[other] / 대통령기록물 관리에 관한 법률 시행령 [시행 2007.7.28.]

[other] / 대통령기록물 관리에 관한 법률 시행령 [시행 2017.7.26.]

[other] / 사무관리규정 [시행 2007.10.28.]

[other] / 전자정부법 [시행 2020.12.10.]

[other] / 전자정부법 시행령 [시행 2021.1.5.]

[other] / 행정 효율과 협업 촉진에 관한 규정 [시행 2021.1.5.]

[other] / 행정 효율과 협업 촉진에 관한 규정 시행규칙 [시행 2017.10.17.]

[other] / 형법 [시행 2020.10.20.]

[other] / 2020 / 대법원 2015도19296 (2020.12.10.)

[other] / 2021 / 대법원 2016도7104 (2021.1.14.)

[other] / 1971 / 대법원 71도324 (1971.3.30.)

[other] / 1995 / 대법원 95도1395 (1995.11.10.)

[other] / 1998 / 대법원 98도360 (1998.8.21.)

[other] / 2015 / 서울고등법원 2015노622 (2015.11.24.)

[other] / 2015 / 서울중앙지방법원 2013고합1232 (2015.2.6.)

[other] / 2020 / 서울중앙지방법원 2019고합186 (2020.1.13.)

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.81

A Study on the Established Requirements for Records through Precedent Analysis: Focusing on “Inter-Korean Summit Meeting Minutes Deletion” Cases

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.81

A Study on the Established Requirements for Records through Precedent Analysis: Focusing on “Inter-Korean Summit Meeting Minutes Deletion” Cases

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (2)

REFERENCES (35) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.