Journal of History of Modern Art 2024 KCI Impact Factor : 0.43
-
pISSN : 1598-7728 / eISSN : 2733-9793
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/kahoma
KJCKorea
Journal Central
The Survival of Images: Aby Warburg’s Methodological Challenge
- Journal of History of Modern Art
- 2024, (55), pp.7~36
- DOI : 10.17057/kahoma.2024..55.001
- Publisher : 현대미술사학회
- Research Area : Arts and Kinesiology > Art > Arts in general > Art History
- Received : April 18, 2024
- Accepted : May 28, 2024
- Published : June 30, 2024
1강릉원주대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This paper examines the meaning of ‘the afterlife of antiquity’ in the context of contemporaneity. The afterlife of antiquity refers to the phenomenon in which ancient motifs appear in early Renaissance art. Aby Warburg considered, but did not clearly define this concept or establish a methodology to study it. However, the Warburg Institute took the survival of antiquity as a Hauptproblem for cultural study, and after moving to London, attempted to take a critical approach to the concept by translating the term. In this process, survival is confused with revival, and Georges Didi-Huberman criticizes it as an attempt to establish an objective and chronological art history. According to Didi-Huberman, survival is not a chronological but an anachronistic phenomenon in which images from the past are experienced in the present, thus making art history rather impure. In fact, in Warburg’s manuscript, antiquity is presented as multiple, and survival is described not as a one-time event but as a structural phenomenon that recurs in different times and places. In other words, Warburg’s antiquity is heterochronic, and surviving images confuse the history of art through memory and empathy. The afterlife of images achieves in advance the modern concept of time, nonsynchronous contemporaneity.
Statistics
-
376 Viewed
-
0 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2024 are currently being built.
[book]
다나카 준
/ 2013
/ 아비 바르부르크 평전
/ 휴먼아트
[book]
리처드 도킨스
/ 2009
/ 이기적 유전자
/ 을유문화사
[journal]
신승철
/ 2013
/
Afterlife with Image: Life and Death in Portraiture
/ 미술이론과 현장
16
: 139~174
[journal]
신승철
/ 2017
/
“You live and do me no harm.” Aby Warburg's thought-space and image
/ 미학예술학연구
52
: 3~39
[journal]
신승철
/ 2021
/ 사유공간을 위한 이미지학자의 투쟁
/ 서울리뷰오브북스
4(겨울)
: 164~175
[book]
아서 단토
/ 2004
/ 예술의 종말 이후
/ 미술문화
[book]
알레이다 아스만
/ 2018
/ 기억의 공간: 문화적 기억의 형식과 변천
/ 그린비
[book]
에드워드 버넷 타일러
/ 2018
/ 원시문화 1
/ 아카넷
[journal]
장원
/ 2014
/
The Problem of Historicism in Gombrich's Art Historical Studies : From Hegel, Beyond Hegel
/ 미학예술학연구
40
: 215~248
[book]
조르조 아감벤
/ 2009
/ 목적없는 수단: 정치에 관한 11개의 노트
/ 난장
[book]
지그문트 프로이트
/ 2016
/ 정신분석의 탄생
/ 열린책들
: 11~193
[book]
지그문트 프로이트
/ 2016
/ 정신분석의 탄생
/ 열린책들
: 185~331
[book]
질 들뢰즈
/ 2004
/ 차이와 반복
/ 민음사
[book]
테리 스미스
/ 2013
/ 컨템포러리 아트란 무엇인가
/ 마로니에북스
[book]
Avenarius, Richard
/ 1876
/ Philosophie als Denken der Welt gemäß dem Prinzip des kleinsten Kraftmaßes Prolegomena zu einer Kritik der reinen Erfahrung
/ Fues
[book]
Bartlett, Frederic C.
/ 1932
/ Remembering: A Study in Experiment and Social Psychology
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Bing, Gertrud
/ 1965
/ A. M. Warburg
/ Journal of the Warburg and Courtauld Institutes
28
: 299~313
[book]
Bloch, Ernst.
/ 1990
/ Heritage of our Times
/ University of California Press
[book]
Chirolla, Gustavo
/ 2017
/ Art History after Deleuze and Guattari
/ Leuven University Press
: 91~104
[book]
Clausberg, Karl.
/ 2009
/ Frosch und Frankenstein: Bilder als Medium der Popularisierung von Wissenschaft
/ transcript
: 325~338
[book]
Didi-Huberman, Georges
/ 2002
/ L’Image survivante. Histoire de l’art et temps des fantômes selon Aby Warburg
/ Les Éditions de Minuit
[journal]
Didi-Huberman
/ 2003
/ Artistic Survival: Panofsky vs. Warburg and the Exorcism of Impure Time
/ Common Knowledge
9
: 273~285
[book]
Didi-Huberman, Georges
/ 2003
/ The Art Historian: National Traditions and Institutional Practices
/ Yale University Press
: 128~143
[book]
Gombrich, Ernst H
/ 1969
/ In Search of Cultural History
/ Clarendon Press
[book]
Gombrich, Ernst H.
/ 1970
/ Aby Warburg: An Intellectual Biography
/ E. J. Brill
[book]
Hering, Ewald
/ 1921
/ Über das Gedächtnis als eine allgemeine Funktion der organisierten Materie
/ Akademische Verlagsgesellschaft
[book]
Hirsch, Marianne
/ 2012
/ The Generation of Postmemory: Writing and Visual Culture After the Holocaust
/ Columbia University Press
[journal]
Krois, John Michael
/ 2011
/ The priority of “symbolism” over language in Cassirer's philosophy
/ Synthese
179(1)
: 9~20
[book]
Mitchell, W. J. T.
/ 2005
/ What Do Pictures Want? The Lives and Loves Images
/ The University of Chicago Press
[book]
Modell, Arnold
/ 1996
/ The Private Self
/ Harvard University Press
[book]
Moxey, Keith
/ 2013
/ Visual Time : The Image in History
/ Duke University Press
[book]
Raulff, Ulrich
/ 2024
/ Aby Warburg 150: Work, Legacy, Promise
/ Walter de Gruyter
: 58~67
[book]
Saxl, Fritz
/ 1923
/ Vorträge der Bibliothek Warburg. Vorträge 1921-1922
/ B. G. Teubner
: 1~10
[book]
Saxl, Fritz
/ 1970
/ Aby Warburg: An Intellectual Biography
/ E. J. Brill
: 325~338
[book]
Semon, Richard Wolfgang
/ 1921
/ The Mneme
/ Allen & Unwin
[book]
Targia, Giovanni
/ 2019
/ Aby Warburg und die Natur: Epistemik, Ästhetik, Kulturtheorie
/ Walter de Gruyter
: 9~31
[book]
The Warburg Institute
/ 1934
/ A Bibliography of the Survival of the classics, vol. I. The publications of 1931
/ Cassell &Company
[book]
The Warburg Institute
/ 1938
/ A Bibliography of the Survival of the classics. vol. II. The publications of 1921-1933
/ Warburg Institute
[book]
Treml, Martin
/ 2007
/ Nachleben der Religionen: Kulturwissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zur Dialektik der Säkularisierung
/ Wilhelm Fink Verlag
: 25~40
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2001
/ Aby Warburg: Tagebuch der Kulturwissenschaftliche Bibliothek Warburg. Gesammelte Schriften , vol. VII
/ Akademie Verlag
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2010
/ Aby Warburg: Werke in einem Band
/ Suhrkamp
: 39~123
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2010
/ Aby Warburg: Werke in einem Band
/ Suhrkamp
: 198~210
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2010
/ Aby Warburg: Werke in einem Band
/ Suhrkamp
: 373~400
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2010
/ Aby Warburg: Werke in einem Band
/ Suhrkamp
: 424~491
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2010
/ Aby Warburg:Werke in einem Band
/ Suhrkamp
: 683~699
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2010
/ Aby Warburg: Werke in einem Band
/ Suhrkamp
: 567~600
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2012
/ Nachhall der Antike: Aby Warburg. Zwei Untersuchungen
/ diaphanes
: 69~101
[book]
Warburg, Aby
/ 2015
/ Gesammelte Schriften IV. Aby Warburg: Fragmente zur Ausdruckskunde
/ Walter de Gruyter
[journal]
Wedephol, Claudia
/ 2014
/ MNEMONICS, MNEME AND MNEMOSYNE. ABY WARBURG’S THEORY OF MEMORY
/ Bruniana & Campanelliana
20
: 385~402
[confproc]
Wedephol, Claudia
/ 2018
/ Aby Warburgs Begriff der ‘Antike’
/ Forum Internationale Begriffsgeschichte
: 9~14
[book]
Wind, Edgar
/ 1934
/ Kulturwissenschaftliche Bibliographie zum Nachleben der Antike, vol 1. Die Erscheinungen des Jahres 1931
/ B. G. Teubner
: 5~17
[book]
Wind, Edgar
/ 1934
/ A Bibliography of the Survival of the classics, vol. 1. The publications of 1931
/ Cassel &Company
: 5~12
[book]
Wind, Edgar
/ 1936
/ Philosophy and History: Essays Presented to Ernst Cassirer
/ The Clarendon Press
: 255~264
[book]
Wind, Edgar
/ 1930
/ Vierter Kongres für Ästhetik und allgemeine Kunstwissenschaft, Hamburg, 7.-9. Oktober 1930, vol. 25, Beilageheft zur Zeitschrift für Ästhetik und allgemeine Kunstwissenschaft
/ Oktober
: 163~179
[book]
Zolkos, Magdalena
/ 2023
/ The Didi-Huberman Dictionary
/ Edinburgh University Press
[journal]
/ 1936
/ The Uncertainty Principle
/ Science-Spplement
83(2148)
: 6~