Korean Journal of Occupational Therapy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.81
-
pISSN : 1226-0134 / eISSN : 2671-4450
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/kjot
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Effects of a Nonpharmacological Treatment Program for Alcohol Addiction: A Meta-Analysis
- Korean Journal of Occupational Therapy
- Abbr : Korean J of Occup Ther
- 2011, 19(4), pp.51-67
- Publisher : Korean Society Of Occupational Therapy
- Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > Working Therapeutics
Cha Yu Jin
1,
박수현
2
1세명대학교
2연세대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Objective : The purpose of this study was to determine the clinical effectiveness of nonpharmacological treatment programs for alcohol addiction on quality of life, psychosocial functionality, and a reduction of alcohol consumption through a meta-analysis.
Search strategy : Data were collected from online search engines using search words from domestic and foreign article databases, and from a manual search from related journals.
Selection criteria : The study employed Level I Randomized Control Trial (RCT) nonpharmacological treatment programs for alcohol addiction from 1990 to May 2011, and selected articles that utilized standardized assessment instruments to measure the relevant dependent variables.
Data collection and analysis : Two researchers carried out the literature selection independently and reached an agreement through a discussion when in disagreement. The effective size with the standardized mean difference, a heterogeneity test, a sensitivity test, and a publication bias test upon the selected articles was determined using the Comprehensive Meta-Analysis 2.0 program.
Results : There were a total of 6,726 participants in the 9 selected articles. The effective sizes for quality of life, psychosocial functionality, and alcohol consumption were 0.24, 0.35, and 0.31 respectively. The effective size of psychosocial functionality and alcohol consumption was statistically significant (p <.001), which demonstrates a “small effect size”. This result is reliable, as significant statistical heterogeneity and publications bias were not found.
Conclusion : Nonpharmacological treatment programs for alcohol addiction proved to be effective for psychosocial functionality and alcohol consumption. This can be utilized effectively in evidence-based occupational therapy for individuals with alcohol addiction by occupational therapists in the mental health field
Statistics
-
602 Viewed
-
1 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
강대혁
/ 2011
/
Current Status of Mental Health Service and the Role of Psychiatric Occupational Therapists in Korea
/ 대한작업치료학회지
/ 대한작업치료학회
19(1)
: 15~27
[journal]
권구영
/ 2002
/ 우리나라 알코올 중독 치료 현황의 이해 를 위한 기술적 연구
/ 사회복지리뷰
7(단일)
: 77~110
[journal]
권용실
/ 2002
/ 알코올리즘 환자 들의 퇴원 후 경과에 대한 연구
/ 중독정신의학회지
6
: 114~119
[journal]
김동배
/ 2005
/
A Meta- analysis of the Variables Related to Depression in Elderly
/ 한국노년학
/ 한국노년학회
25(4)
: 167~187
[thesis]
김민주
/ 2005
/ 비입원 알코올중독자의 재발방지를 위한 미술치료 사례연구
/ 석사
/ 영남대학교
[thesis]
김성용
/ 2002
/ 스트레스 정도, 대처유형 및 가족지지정 도가 알코올 중독 심각도에 미치는 영향-알코올 중 독환자를 중심으로
/ 석사
/ 대불대학교
[journal]
김성준
/ 1999
/ 비궤양성 소화불량에서 Helicobacter pylori 박멸치료후 증상개선에 대한 메타분석
/ 예방의학회지
32(4)
: 427~434
[book]
김영근
/ 2007
/ 정신사회작업치료학
/ 정문각
[journal]
김익진
/ 2009
/
Alcoholism and Humanities Therapy
/ 인문과학연구
/ 인문과학연구소
21(21)
: 327~343
[journal]
김종성
/ 2004
/ 알코올 중독의 진단과 치료
/ 가정의학회지
25(11)
: 256~261
[thesis]
배인희
/ 2005
/ 단주집단교육 프로그램이 입원 알코올의 존자의 우울과 금주자기효능감에 미치는 효과
/ 석사
/ 경희대학교
[report]
보건복지부
/ 2008
/ 2006년 정신질환실태 역학조사 요약보고서
/ 보건복지부
[web]
보건복지부
/ 정신보건법 전부개정안
/ http://www. mw.go.kr/front/jb /sjb0403ls.jsp?PAR_MENU_ID=03&MENU_ID=0 30403
[journal]
성상경
/ 2003
/ 알코올리즘 입원 치료프로그램 참가자들의 퇴원 후 단기경과
/ 중독정신의학회지
7(7)
: 2~
[book]
송혜향
/ 1992
/ 메타분석분석법
/ 자유아카데미
[thesis]
유성희
/ 2009
/ 성인여성의 애착유형과 중독성향간의 관계
/ 석사
/ 숙명여자대학교
[journal]
이경희
/ 2010
/
A Meat-Analysis on the effect of Abstinence Programs for Alcoholics
/ 정신보건과 사회사업
/ 한국정신보건사회복지학회
(36)
: 35~63
[thesis]
임영란
/ 2000
/ 알코올 의존 환자를 위한 인지행동치료 의 효과 검증 및 심리적 위험 인자에 대한 구조 모형 분석
/ 박사
/ 고려대학교
[thesis]
황동섭
/ 2003
/ 알코올중독환자의 재발예방을 위한 집단 활동프로그램에 관한 연구: 인지 행동적 접근법을 중심으로
/ 석사
/ 동국대학교
[journal]
Allen, J. P
/ 1998
/ Matching alcoholism treatments to client heterogeneity: Treatment main effects and matching effects on drinking during treatment
/ Journal of Studies on Alcohol
59(6)
: 631~639
[journal]
Babor, T. F
/ 2008
/ Treatment for persons with substance use disorders: Mediators, moderators, and the need for a new research approach
/ International Journal of Methods in Psychiatric Research
17(1)
: 45~49
[journal]
Baker, A. L.
/ 2009
/ Randomized controlled trial of cognitive behavioural therapy for coexisting depression and alcohol problems: Short-term outcome
/ Addiction
105(1)
: 87~99
[journal]
Bertholet, N
/ 2005
/ Reduction of alcohol consumption by brief alcohol intervention in primary care: Systematic review and metaanalysis
/ Archives of Internal Medicine
165(9)
: 986~995
[book]
Borenstein, M
/ 2009
/ Introduction to meta-analysis
/ Wiley and sons, Ltd
[journal]
Carey, K. B
/ 2009
/ Computer delivered interventions to reduce college student drinking: A meta analysis
/ Addiction
104(11)
: 1807~1819
[journal]
Chang, G
/ 1999
/ Brief intervention for alcohol use in pregnancy: A randomized trial
/ Addiction
94(10)
: 1499~1508
[journal]
Chen, M. D
/ 2011
/ Effects of exercise on quality of life in stroke survivors
/ Stroke
42(3)
: 832~837
[book]
Cohen, J
/ 1988
/ Statistical power analysis for the social sciences: Hillsdale
/ Erlbaum
[journal]
Daeppen, J. B
/ 2007
/ Brief alcohol intervention and alcohol assessment do not influence alcohol use in injured patients treated in the emergency department: A randomized controlled clinical trial
/ Addiction
102(8)
: 1224~1233
[journal]
Egger, M.
/ 1997
/ Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test
/ British Medical Journal
315(7109)
: 629~634
[journal]
Elonheimo, H
/ 2009
/ Psychosocial correlates of police-registered youth crime. A finnish population-based study
/ Nordic Journal of Psychiatry
63(4)
: 292~300
[journal]
Glass, G. V
/ 1976
/ Primary, secondary, and metaanalysis of research
/ Educational Researcher
5(10)
: 3~8
[book]
Gordon, D. M
/ 2009
/ The history of occupational therapy in Willard & Spackman's occupational therapy (11th ed.,)
/ Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
: 202~215
[journal]
Gr nbæk, M
/ 2007
/ A randomized controlled trial of Minnesota day clinic treatment of alcoholics
/ Addiction
102(3)
: 381~388
[journal]
Harris, R. P.
/ 2001
/ Current methods of the U.S. Preventive services task force: A review of the process
/ American Journal of Preventive Medicine
20(3)
: 21~35
[journal]
Haug, N. A.
/ 2008
/ Adoption of evidence-based practices among substance abuse treatment providers
/ Journal of Drug Education
38(2)
: 181~192
[journal]
Jadad, A. R.
/ 1996
/ Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials: Is blinding necessary
/ Controlled Clinical Trials
17(1)
: 1~12
[book]
Jenicek, M
/ 1995
/ Epidemiology: The logic of modern medicine
/ Epimed
[journal]
Kendler, K. S.
/ 1992
/ A population-based twin study of alcoholism in women
/ Journal of the American Medical Association
268(14)
: 1877~1882
[journal]
Kissin, W
/ 2003
/ The longitudinal relationship between self-help group attendance and course of recovery
/ Evaluation and Program Planning
26(3)
: 311~323
[journal]
Kwakkel, G
/ 2004
/ Effects of augmented exercise therapy time after stroke. A meta-analysis
/ Stroke
35(11)
: 2529~2536
[journal]
Lau, J
/ 1997
/ Quantitative synthesis in systematic reviews
/ Annals of Internal Medicine
127(9)
: 820~826
[journal]
Lock, C. A
/ 2006
/ Effectiveness of nurse-led brief alcohol intervention: A cluster randomized controlled trial
/ Journal of Advanced Nursing
54(4)
: 426~439
[book]
Miller, W. R
/ 1991
/ Motivational interviewing: Preparing people to change addictive behavior
/ Guilford
[journal]
Moher, D
/ 1995
/ Assessing the quality of randomized controlled trials: An annotated bibliography of scales and checklists
/ Controlled Clinical Trials
16(1)
: 62~73
[web]
National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism
/ New advances in alcoholism treatment
/ http://pubs. niaaa.nih.gov/publications/aa49.htm.
[journal]
Nielsen, P.
/ 2007
/ Personality guided treatment for alcohol dependence: A quasi randomized experiment
/ American Journal on Addictions
16(5)
: 357~364
[journal]
Noknoy, S
/ 2010
/ RCT of effectiveness of motivational enhancement therapy delivered by nurses for hazardous drinkers in primary care units in Thailand
/ Alcohol and Alcoholism
45(3)
: 263~270
[journal]
Poikolainen, K
/ 1999
/ Effectiveness of brief interventions to reduce alcohol intake in primary health care populations: A meta-analysis. preventive Medicine:
/ An International Journal Devoted to Practice and Theory
28(5)
: 503~509
[journal]
Rosenthal, R
/ 1982
/ Comparing effect sizes of independent studies
/ Psychological Bulletin
92(2)
: 500~
[journal]
Saitz, R
/ 2003
/ Addressing alcohol problems in primary care: A cluster randomized, controlled trial of a systems intervention: The screening and intervention in primary care (SIP) study
/ Annals of Internal Medicine
138(5)
: 372~383
[journal]
Simes, R. J
/ 1987
/ Confronting publication bias: A cohort design for meta analysis
/ Statistics in Medicine
6(1)
: 11~29
[journal]
Simpson, T. L
/ 2005
/ Telephone self-monitoring among alcohol use disorder patients in early recovery: A randomized study of feasibility and measurement reactivity
/ Drug and Alcohol Dependence
79(2)
: 241~250
[journal]
Steultjens, E. M. J
/ 2003
/ Occupational therapy for stroke patients
/ Stroke
34(3)
: 676~687
[journal]
Stoffel, V. C.
/ 2004
/ An evidencebased and occupational perspective of interventions for persons with substance-use disorders
/ American Journal of Occupational Therapy
58(5)
: 570~586
[journal]
Vaillant, G. E
/ 1996
/ The natural history of alcoholism
/ Alcohol Health & Research World
30(3)
: 152~161
[journal]
Wells-Parker, E
/ 1995
/ Final results from a meta analysis of remedial interventions with drink/drive offenders
/ Addiction
90(7)
: 907~926
[report]
WHO
/ 2004
/ Global status report on alcohol 2004
/ World Health Organization.