A Study on the Utilization of Digital Forensic System for the Activation of Punitive Damage System - Based on the case of Intellectual Property infringement - (징벌적손해배상제도활성화를위한디지털포렌식활용방안연구 - 지식재산 침해 사건을 중심으로 -)

JongSeong Kim (김종성); JUNG SEHEE (정세희); SunKyung Lee (이선경)

doi:10.29056/jsav.2022.12.06

A Study on the Utilization of Digital Forensic System for the Activation of Punitive Damage System - Based on the case of Intellectual Property infringement -

Journal of Software Assessment and Valuation
Abbr : JSAV
2022, 18(2), pp.47-61
DOI : 10.29056/jsav.2022.12.06
Publisher : Korea Software Assessment and Valuation Society
Research Area : Engineering > Computer Science
Received : November 18, 2022
Accepted : December 20, 2022
Published : December 31, 2022

JongSeong Kim ¹, JUNG SEHEE ², SunKyung Lee ³

¹중앙대학교 산업보안연구소
²중앙대학교 대학원 융합보안학과
³한국저작권보호원

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Currently, in the case of intellectual property infringement crimes, crimes occur mainly in the online environment, and at this time, online data acts as an important factor to prove the facts about illegal acts. On the other hand, the punitive damage compensation system aims to prevent repeating of similar illegal acts by requiring the perpetrator to pay more than the actual amount of damage when the perpetrator compensates for the damage caused by the tort. In order for punitive damages to be established, the causal relationship between intentional and illegal acts must be distinguished. However, due to the nature of online data, it can be easily forged or falsified, making it difficult to prove the facts about illegality. Therefore, we suggested direct utilization of digital forensic results for intentionality judgment and related institutional reform measures, focusing on crimes using digital devices. So, we want to contribute to the objective judgment standard of the punitive damages system by expanding the scope of digital forensic utilization.

KEYWORDS

Punitive Damages, Digital Forensics, Digital Crime, Intellectual Property Infringement, Online Crime, Judgment of Intent

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[web] S.J. OH / 2022 / [Judicial precedent commentary] Determination of validity in copyright infringement and establishment of general tort Seoul High Court 2012.12.20. Sentencing 2012 Na 17150Judgment / The Korean Legal News / http://news.koreanbar.or.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=9415

[report] W. Y. Jung / 2022 / [First half of 2020Ministry of Justice research report]Analysis of precedents on punitive damages in Korea and limitations and improvement measures in application / Korea Law School

[web] W.S. WOO / 2013 / [legislative debate] A Study on Support for Victims in Crimes of Infringement of Intellectual Property Rights / Ministry of Government Legislation / https://www.moleg.go.kr/mpbleg/mpblegInfo.mo?mid=a10402020000&mpb_leg_pst_seq=133263

[web] Industrial Policy Team / 2012 / Investigation of domestic companies'intellectual property leakage damage and policy tasks / Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry / http://www.korcham.net/nCham/Service/Economy/appl/KcciReportDetail.asp?SEQ_NO_C010=20120925607&CHAM_CD=B001

[web] T.H. KO / 2021 / [Planning] 'Content = Free'... Illegal site sharing is a 'criminal' / Gyeonggi Newspaper / https://www.kgnews.co.kr/news/article.html?no=681317

[web] J. H. LEE / 2021 / 3,500 music creators "OTT copyright infringement, please punish" / NEWSIS / https://newsis.com/view/?id=NISX20211206_0001677503

[web] G.J. LEE / 2021 / 71% of technology leaks were done by insiders... Techniques such as cloud abuse are also evolving / Asia Econom,y / https://www.asiae.co.kr/article/2021111610002962132

[journal] J. M. LEE / 2006 / A Study on Necessity and Possibility on the Introduction of Punitive Damages / DONG-A LAW REVIEW / Dong-A University Law Research Institute (38) : 187~243

[journal] 정해상 / 2004 / A Comparative Study on Punitive Damages with the Theory of Punitive Damages in Korean Civil Law / 중앙법학 / 중앙법학회 6(4) : 241~253

[journal] Roddy, N. E. / 1981 / Punitive Damages in Strict Products Liability Litigation / Wm. &Mary L. Rev 23 : 333~

[book] J.K. LEE / 2019 / Measures to improve the effectiveness of the punitive damages system / Ricon(Korea Construction Policy Institute)

[book] S.S. WOO / 2021 / Industrial Security law / Keduai

[other] / 1995 / Seoul Eastern District Court 1995. 2. 10. Decision 93-19069

[journal] 권인희 / 2012 / Possibility to Award Punitive Damages on Patent Infringement Cases - at the Time of Introduction of Punitive Damages to Fair Subcontract Transactions Act - / 법학논총 / 법학연구소 27 : 27~43

[journal] M.J. Kim / 1996 / Tort and Intention/Fault Theory / The 'GOSHIGYE' a monthly law journal 41(8) : 14~25

[web] D.H. YANG / 2015 / Triple Damage Compensation System under the Subcontracting Act / Korea Ministry of Government Legislation / https://www.moleg.go.kr/mpbleg/mpblegInfo.mo?mid=a10402020000&mpb_leg_pst_seq=133503

[report] S. H. Yang / 2019 / Discussion on introduction of punitive damages system and review of current status of legislation / KIRI : 1~7

[journal] 이점인 / 2017 / A Critical Study on the Punitive Damages under the Korean Legal System / 동아법학 / 법학연구소 (74) : 43~86

[web] J.Y. KIM / 2021 / Beware of the spread of punitive damages / Hankookilbo / https://www.hankookilbo.com/News/Read/A2021081711000003675

[web] Legal newspaper opinion / 2021 / Legislation for punitive damages should be prudent / Lawtimes / https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/Legal-Opinion/Legal-Opinion-View?serial=172348

[journal] 한성훈 / 2015 / Study on the Improvement of Seizure and Seizure of Digital Evidence / 홍익법학 / 법학연구소 16(3) : 343~370

[other] / 2007 / Supreme Court Decision 2005Da35707delivered on December 13, 2007

[web] / Appraisal / Korea Copyright Commission / https://www.copyright.or.kr/business/appraisal/index.do

[journal] 이규대 / 2013 / Digital Forensics on the Handheld Devices / 한국소프트웨어감정평가학회 논문지 / 한국소프트웨어감정평가학회 9(2) : 47~52

[journal] Reith, M. / 2002 / An examination of digital forensic models / International Journal of digital evidence 1(3) : 1~12

[book] S.J. LEE / 2015 / Introduction to Digital Forensics / ilun

[confproc] B. R. RYU / 2017 / A Study on Analysis of Digital Forensics Research Trends / Korea Information Processing Society 2017Spring Conference 24(1) : 306~308

[other] / 2012 / 21ST CENTURY SYSTEMS INC v. PEROT SYSTEMS GOVERNMENT SERVICES INC

[other] Klipsch Group / 2018 / Inc. v. ePRO E-Commerce Ltd. 880 F.3d 620 (2d Cir. 2018), 2018

[other] / 2016 / Tokyo District Court 2013 (wa). 30447April 27. 2016

[web] M.Y. Park / 2021 / Korean Intellectual Property Office, New promotion of digital forensic support business for companies affected by trade secret leakage / Boannews / https://www.boannews.com/media/view.asp?idx=95911&page=1&kind=2

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Software Assessment and Valuation 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.35

A Study on the Utilization of Digital Forensic System for the Activation of Punitive Damage System - Based on the case of Intellectual Property infringement -

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of Software Assessment and Valuation 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.35

A Study on the Utilization of Digital Forensic System for the Activation of Punitive Damage System - Based on the case of Intellectual Property infringement -

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)

REFERENCES (31) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.