Journal of Regulation Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.78
-
pISSN : 1738-7132
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/ksrs2002
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Searching for Substantial Conditions in Applying CBA of Risk Regulatory
- Journal of Regulation Studies
- 2009, 18(1), pp.207-243
- Publisher : 한국규제학회
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration
Cha Min Yuh 1, Tae-Yun Kim 2
1국회예산정책처
2한양대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Decision making on risk regulation should be based on cost-benefit analysis rather than no-risk criterion. However actually we encounter some problems such as methodology and data problems when applying the CBA. Therefore we need some substantial conditions in order to solve these problems. So far most studies are focused on the monetization and quantification of related cost and benefit and relevant methodological debate. This study focuses on finding substantial conditions which will motivate CBA of risk regulatory to revitalize and proliferate in the practical analysis process. For this purpose, this study reviews the relevant theories in respects of rationale of risk regulatory and CBA and elicits the implications through which substantial conditions are constructed. Finally, we reconcetualize this substantial conditions into practical guidelines, apply them to the consumer product safety case and identify its usefulness.
Statistics
-
418 Viewed
-
105 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[book]
국회예산정책처
/ 2008
/ 2007년도 정부 규제영향분석서 평가
/ 국회예산정책처
[other]
규제개혁위원회
/ 2006
/ 규제영향분석 및 자체심사 업무지침
[book]
기술표준원․한국규제학회
/ 2005
/ 공산품 안전관리 제도 규제영향분석에 관한 연구
[journal]
김서용
/ 2004
/
Cognitive and Cultural Judgement Biases in Cost-Benefit Analysis
/ 행정논총
/ 한국행정연구소
42(2)
: 55~88
[journal]
김순양
/ 1998
/ 사회적 규제와 중간집단의 역할:보건․위생영역의 자율규제를 중심으로
/ 규제연구
7(1)
: 107~153
[book]
김태윤
/ 2004
/ 비용편익분석의 이론과 실제:공공사업평가와 규제영향분석
/ 박영사
[journal]
김태윤
/ 2000
/ 우리나라 규제영향분석 발전방안:미국 및 우리나라의 사례연구를 토대로
/ 규제연구
9(1)
: 111~148
[journal]
노진철
/ 2004
/
위험사회학-위험과 사회의 관계에 대한 사회이론화
/ 경제와 사회
/ 비판사회학회
(63)
: 98~123
[journal]
노진철
/ 2004
/
Verstarkung des Interventionsstaates：Vom Mythos ‘verkurzter Modernisation’ zur Reflexion der Risiko-Gesellschaft
/ 현상과 인식
/ 한국인문사회과학회
28(4)
: 141~167
[journal]
노화준
/ 2005
/
A study on the Institutions of Regulatory Impact Analysis for the Quality Regulation Development
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
14(4)
: 165~192
[journal]
안종범
/ 2000
/ 비용편익분석에서의 분배가중치:정치적 가중치 이용의 이론적 근거
/ 재정논집
15(1)
: 207~221
[journal]
엄영숙
/ 1999
/ 식품위험규제에 대한 법경제학적 이해
/ 규제연구
8(1)
: 181~210
[journal]
이성우
/ 2004
/
Issues and Techniques for Regulatory Impact Analysis
/ 규제연구
/ 한국규제학회
13(1)
: 45~72
[journal]
이성우
/ 2000
/ 규제영향분석 제도의 효과적 집행방안
/ 한국정책학회보
9(2)
: 141~162
[book]
이성우
/ 2003
/ 규제영향분석방법론의 실용적 체계화
/ 한국행정연구원
[journal]
이혜영
/ 2007
/
A Capacity Study for the Effective Implementation of RIA
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
16(2)
: 181~210
[journal]
임성진
/ 2005
/
The Theory of Cost-Benefit Analysis and Application Model for Water Conservation Programs
/ 정치·정보연구
/ 한국정치정보학회
8(1)
: 98~124
[journal]
임현진
/ 2000
/ 한국사회의 위험과 안전:이론적 모색과 경험적 고찰
/ 사회과학
39(2)
: 1~25
[book]
임현진 외
/ 2002
/ 한국사회의 위험과 안전
[journal]
조택
/ 2004
/ 산업안전보건규제의 경제적 타당성 분석의 필요성
/ 경영계
: 32~34
[journal]
최병선
/ 2006
/
Regulation theory and policy in the context of the new institutional economics : disputes and expansions
/ 행정논총
/ 한국행정연구소
44(2)
: 179~216
[journal]
최병선
/ 1994
/ 위험문제의 특성과 전략적 대응
/ 한국행정연구
3(4)
: 27~49
[book]
최병선
/ 1992
/ 정부규제론
/ 법문사
[book]
한국소비자보호원
/ 2005
/ 공산품 안전제도 개선 위해사례 연구
[book]
최병선
/ 2004
/ 공산품 안전검정 제도 개선방안 연구
[book]
Beck, U
/ 1997
/ Riskogesellschaft(위험사회)
/ 새물결
[book]
Ackerman, F
/ 2002
/ Prospering with Precaution:Employment,Economics,and the Precautionary Principle,"Tufts Univ,2002,available online at
/ Tufts Univ.
[book]
Adams, J
/ 1995
/ Risk, 5th impression
/ UCL Press
[journal]
Anderson, C
/ 1991
/ Hazards of Risk Assessment
/ Nature
(351)
[journal]
Antle, J. M.
/ 2000
/ No Such Thing as A Free Safe Lunch: The Cost of Food Safety Regulation in the Meat Industry
/ Amer. J. Agr. Econ.
/ American Agricultural Economics Association
82(20)
: 310~322
[journal]
Armstrong, A. G.
/ 1981
/ Consumer Safety and the Regulation of Industry
/ Managerial and Decision Economics
2(2)
: 67~73
[book]
Arrow et al
/ 1996
/ Benefit-Cost Analysis in Environmental, Health, and Safety Regulation: A Statement of Principles
/ American Enterprise Institute Press
[book]
Breyer, S.
/ 1993
/ Breaking the Vicious Circle:Toward Effective Risk Regulation
/ Harvard Univ Press
[journal]
Dahlman, C. J.
/ 1979
/ The Problem of Externality
/ The Journal of Law and Economics
: 141~162
[book]
Feintuck, M
/ 2004
/ The Public Interest in Regulation
/ Oxford Univ Press
[journal]
Food Safety Inspection Service
/ 1996
/
/ Federal Register
(61)
: 38805~08855
[book]
Hahn, R . W.
/ 2004
/ An Analysis of the Seventh Government Report on the Costs and Benefits of Federal Regulations
/ AEI- Brookings Joint Center
[book]
Hahn, R W
/ 1996
/ Regulatory Reform: What Do the Government's Numbers Tell Us? In Risk, Costs, and Lives Saved: Getting Better Results from Regulation
/ AEI Press
[journal]
Hahn, R. W.
/ Tracking the Value of Regulation
/ Regulation
26(3)
: 13~21
[book]
Hahn, R. W.
/ 2000
/ Do Federal Regulations Reduce Mortality?
/ AEI Press
[journal]
Harrington, S. E.
/ 2000
/ Rethinking Disaster Policy
/ Regulation
23(1)
: 40~46
[book]
Heinzerling, L.
/ 2002
/ Cost-Benefit Analysis of Environmental Protection
/ Georgetown University
[book]
Hodges, C
/ 2005
/ ,European Regulation of Consumer Product Safety
/ Oxford Univ Press
[journal]
Kahn, B. E.
/ 2005
/ Repeated-Adherence Protection Model(RAP),I'm OK and It's a Hassel
/ Journal of Public Policy and Marketing
[journal]
Kelman, S.
/ 1981
/ Cost-Benefit Analysis: An Ethical Critique
/ Regulation
: 33~41
[book]
Kelman, M.
/ 1987
/ A Guide to Critical Legal Studies
/ Harvard University Press
[report]
Kunreuther, H.
/ 2006
/ Rules Rather than Discretion:Lessons from Hurricane Katrina
/ NBER
[journal]
Kunreuther, H.
/ 2004
/ Neglection Disaster: Why Don't People Insure Against Large Losses?
/ The Journal of Risk and Uncertainty
28(1)
: 5~21
[journal]
Lutter, R.
/ 1999
/ The Role of Economic Analysis in Regulatory Reform
/ Regulation
22(2)
: 38~46
[journal]
Lutter, R.
/ 199
/ The Cost Per Life Saved Cutoff For Safety-Enhancing Regulations
/ Economic Inquiry
37(4)
: 599~608
[journal]
Miller, H.
/ 2000
/ Food Risks and Labeling Controversies
/ Regulation
23(1)
: 35~39
[journal]
Morrall, J.
/ 2003
/ Saving Lives: A Review of the Record
/ Journal of Risk and Uncertainty
27(3)
: 221~237
[book]
Morris, J.
/ 2000
/ Rethinking Risk and the Precautionary Principle
/ Butterworth- Heinemann
[book]
Meyer,R. J.
/ 2006
/ Why We Under-Prepare for Hazards in Daniels, Kettl, and Kunrenther(eds), On Risk and Disaster
/ University of Pennsylvania Press
[journal]
Niskanen, W. A.
/ 2003
/ More lonely Numbers
/ Regulation
26(3)
[journal]
Ogus,A
/ 1997
/ Risk Management and Rational Social Regulation
/ in Baldwin,R.(ed),Law and Uncertainty:Risk and Legal Process,London
[other]
OMB
/ 2000
/ Guidelines to Standardize Measures of Costs and Benefits and the Format of Accounting Statements
[book]
OMB Watch
/ 2005
/ Is Cost-Benefit Analysis Needed?
/ The Watcher
: 18~21
[report]
Parker, R. W.
/ 2004
/ Is Government Regulation Irrational?: A Reply to Morrall and Hahn
/ University of Connecticut School of Law
[journal]
Randal, A.
/ 1974
/ Coasian Externality Theory in a Policy context
/ Natural resources Journal
: 35~54
[journal]
Shapiro, S.
/ Politics and Regulatory Policy Analysis
/ Regulation
29(2)
: 40~45
[book]
Shohet, S.
/ 1996
/ Risk and Emerging Technology: The Case of Process-Based Regulation of Biotechnology in Europe,” in Accident and Design: Contemporary Debates in Risk Management
/ UCL Press
[journal]
Vatn, A.
/ Externalities: A Market Model Failure
/ Environmental and Resource Economics
: 135~151
[other]
Viscusi,W.K.
/ 2006
/ Regulation of Health, Safety, and Environmental Risks. Related Publication 06-11
/ AEI-Brookings Joint Center for Regulatory Studies
[journal]
Viscusi, W. K.
/ 1996
/ Economic Foundations of the Current Regulatory Reform Efforts
/ The Journal of Economic Perspectives
10(3)
: 119~134
[journal]
Viscusi, W. K.
/ 2002
/ Safety at Any Price?
/ Regulation
25(3)
: 54~63
[book]
Viscusi, W. K.
/ 2000
/ Economics of Regulation and Antitrust(3rd Edition)
/ MIT Press
[journal]
Walshe, K.
/ 2004
/ Social Regulation of Healthcare Organizations in the United States: Developing a Framework for Evaluation
/ Health Services Management Research
17(2)
: 79~99
[book]
Wildavsky, A.
/ 1988
/ Searching for Safety
/ Transaction Books