KJCKorea
Journal Central

@article{ART001407650},
author={Kwanbo Kim and KYUNGJIN CHAE and 김명수},
title={A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method},
journal={Journal of Regulation Studies},
issn={1738-7132},
year={2009},
volume={18},
number={2},
pages={3-33}

TY - JOUR
AU - Kwanbo Kim
AU - KYUNGJIN CHAE
AU - 김명수
TI - A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method
JO - Journal of Regulation Studies
PY - 2009
VL - 18
IS - 2
PB - 한국규제학회
SP - 3
EP - 33
SN - 1738-7132
AB - The purpose of this article is to construct the sustainable 'Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions' and calculate its fairness indices for evaluating the fairness of subcontracting transaction. First, the fairness concepts are categorized into three types for constructing the fairness evaluation system of subcontracting transaction: 1) procedural fairness, 2) result (outcome) fairness, and 3) mutual interaction (win-win cooperation) fairness. Second, both evaluation sectors (items) and detailed evaluation indicators are drawn from the subcontracting-related laws and win-win (cooperation) agreement and are linked to the concepts of subcontracting transaction fairness. Third, based on these findings, AHP (analytic hierarchy process) analysis is conducted to explore the degree of mutual importance and weight of evaluation sectors and their indicators. Finally, the 'Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions is created. The system includes three evaluation sectors: subcontracting contract conclusion, subcontracting contract execution, and subcontracting win-win cooperation. Also the system has 11 evaluation indicators and 22 detailed measurement indicators. The primary level analysis result of AHP has shown that subcontracting contract execution is the most important sector in the construction, manufacturing, and repair industries, while subcontracting contract conclusion is the most important item in the service industries. The secondary level analysis result of AHP with 11 evaluation indicators has demonstrated that subcontracting price decision and adjustment in the subcontracting contract execution is the most important indicator across all industries. The comprehensive weight and overall ranking results of all evaluation indicators have represented that subcontracting price payment is first, unfair subcontracting price reduction is second, and subcontracting decision and adjustment is third in all industries. The sectoral fairness index (SFI) and the composite fairness index (CFI) are calculated to apply the ‘Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions.'
KW - Fairness;Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions; AHP;Fairness Index;Win-Win Cooperation
DO -
UR -
ER -

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE and 김명수. (2009). A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method. Journal of Regulation Studies, 18(2), 3-33.

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE and 김명수. 2009, "A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method", Journal of Regulation Studies, vol.18, no.2 pp.3-33.

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE, 김명수 "A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method" Journal of Regulation Studies 18.2 pp.3-33 (2009) : 3.

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE, 김명수. A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method. 2009; 18(2), 3-33.

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE and 김명수. "A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method" Journal of Regulation Studies 18, no.2 (2009) : 3-33.

Kwanbo Kim; KYUNGJIN CHAE; 김명수. A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method. Journal of Regulation Studies, 18(2), 3-33.

Kwanbo Kim; KYUNGJIN CHAE; 김명수. A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method. Journal of Regulation Studies. 2009; 18(2) 3-33.

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE, 김명수. A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method. 2009; 18(2), 3-33.

Kwanbo Kim, KYUNGJIN CHAE and 김명수. "A Preliminary Study for Constructing the Fairness Evaluation System of Subcontracting Transactions: Application of AHP Method" Journal of Regulation Studies 18, no.2 (2009) : 3-33.