The Verification of Concordance Coefficient in Sasang Constitutional Factors by Expert (사상체질 전문가의 진단 우선순위 일치도 검증)

jang eun su (장은수); 김호석; Jong Hyang Yoo (유종향); Sang-Hyuk Kim (김상혁); 백영화; Lee Siwoo (이시우)

The Verification of Concordance Coefficient in Sasang Constitutional Factors by Expert

Journal of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine
Abbr : J Sasang Constitut Med
2009, 21(2), pp.79-86
Publisher : The Society of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine
Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > Korean Medicine

jang eun su ¹, 김호석 ¹, Jong Hyang Yoo ¹, Sang-Hyuk Kim ¹, 백영화 ¹, Lee Siwoo ¹

¹한국한의학연구원

Accredited

ABSTRACT

1. Objective This study aimed to know the concordance coefficient and diagnostic trend of 6 Sasang constitution diagnosis factors among experts, which are important to diagnose Sasang constitution. 2. Methods We suggested each 100 cases containing body shape, face, temperament, physiological and pathological symptom and constitutional drug response to 2 groups experts, and researched expert opinions. We analyzed concordance coefficient with Kendall's coefficient of concordance W. 3. Results 1) Experts agreed with 167(82.5%) diagnosis results of cases, but there were 33 cases(17.5%), with which even one expert disagreed 2) The concordance of priority order of Sasang constitutional factors was significantly associated within expert. 3) Experts put the priority concordance to drug response and Face, body shape, voice and Pathological and physiological symptoms in order. 4) In case by case, concordance coefficient was 47(55.9%) in group 1, 9(10.8%) in group 2, 56 (33.5%) in total. 4. Conclusions Expertㄴ made much account of drug responses and faces in diagnosing Sasang constitution. but there were different opinions in concordance coefficient. So Sasang Constitution Diagnosis Guideline is necessary to integrate experts opinions.

KEYWORDS

Sasang Constitution, Concordance Coefficient, Priority Order, Body shape, Face

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] Lee JM / 1996 / Longevity & Life Preservation in Oriental Medicine / Kyuhg Hee Univ. Press

[journal] 함통일 / 2006 / A Study on the Concordance Rate of the Diagnostic Results Among Sasang Constitutional Medicine(SCM) Specialists / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(3) : 124~130

[journal] Huh MH / 1989 / A Study on the Morphological Schematization of Sasangin / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 1(1) : 29~40

[journal] Kim DL / 1989 / A Study on the Pathological Theory of Sasang Constitutional Medicine / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 1(1) : 4~47

[journal] Kwak CK / 2004 / The Study about the Consept of Exterior Disease and Interior Disease of Sasangin Constitutional Symptoms and Diseases / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 16(1) : 1~11

[journal] Song IB / 1994 / A Study on the Existence Process of Constitutional Symptom and Constitutional Pathological Symptom in Sasangin / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 6(1) : 71~79

[journal] Kho WS / 2004 / Study for the Mechanism of Exterior, Interior Disease by the nature and emotion / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 16(2) : 44~51

[journal] Yoon JH / 2000 / Morphological standardization research of Head and Face on the 50's and 60's in Korean according to Sasang Constitution / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 12(2) : 123~131

[journal] Yoon JH / 2000 / The Comparison Research of the Head and Face on the 30's, 40's, and 50's 60's in Korean Men according to Sasang Constitution / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 12(2) : 143~152

[journal] 권석동 / 2007 / Diagnosis Accuracy Rate Comparative Study of Each Sasang Constitutions and Sex Distinction by Body Measurement Method between 3D Body Measuring Instrument and Hand-operating / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 19(1) : 60~77

[journal] Kwak CG / 2006 / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine / A Hardware Error Analysis of 3D Face Automatic Recognition Apparatus (3D-FARA), 18(3) : 49~56

[journal] 김혁 / 2006 / Sound Characteristics of Sasang Constitutional Type Using PSSC-2004 in the Korean Children / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(2) : 55~67

[journal] 설유경 / 2006 / Importance Analysis of Questionnaire for Doctors and Questionnaire for Patients / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(3) : 94~123

[journal] Ham TI / 2004 / The Clinical Study on Ordinary Symptoms and Pathological Symptoms of Strock In-patients based on Sasang Constitutional Medicine / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 16(3) : 34~45

[journal] Huh MH / 1992 / A Study on the Morphological Schematization of Sasangin / J of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 4(1) : 107~148

[journal] 이시우 / 2008 / The Survey on the Sasang Constitution Clinical Study -In the Journal of Sasang Constitutional Medicine- / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 20(2) : 21~29

[journal] Koo JS / 2003 / The analysis of Concordance Coefficient for Sasang Constitutiopn Diadnosis Result by 3 Oriental Medical Doctors / J of Jeahan Oriental Medical Academy 28(4) : 36~39

[journal] 이준희 / 2007 / Survey Study about Sasangin’s Characteristics of Face, Voice, Skin and Pulse Diagnosis / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 19(3) : 126~143

[journal] 장은수 / 2008 / A Study on the Priority Order of Sasang Constitutional Factors in Oriental Medical Clinics / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 20(3) : 133~141

[journal] 김종원 / 2006 / A Study on the Body Shape Classified by Sasang Constitutions and Gender Using Physical Measurements / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(1) : 54~61

[journal] Yoo JH / 2008 / Knowledge and Attitude of Sasang Constitution Investigators on the Sasang Constitution Clinical Study in Korea 20(3) : 118~132

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.42