A Study on the Reliability Assessment of Sasang Constitution Questionnaire Developed by KIOM for Japanese (일본인 대상자를 통해 살펴본 KIOM 체질 설문지의 신뢰도 평가)

Jong Hyang Yoo (유종향); jang eun su (장은수); Yunyoung, Kim (김윤영); 박기현; Siwoo Lee (이시우)

A Study on the Reliability Assessment of Sasang Constitution Questionnaire Developed by KIOM for Japanese

Journal of Sasang Constitutional Medicine
Abbr : J Sasang Constitut Med
2012, 24(2), pp.8-18
Publisher : The Society Of Sasang Constitutional Medicine
Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > Korean Medicine

Jong Hyang Yoo ¹, jang eun su ², Yunyoung, Kim ³, 박기현 ¹, Siwoo Lee ¹

¹한국한의학연구원
²대전대학교
³안동대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

1. Objectives This study aimed to assessing the reliability of questionnaire for Japanese as one of method to diagnose Sasang Constitution and evaluating the possibility of applying domestic questionnaire to foreign site. 2. Methods A cross-sectional survey approved by IRB (Independent Review Board) at Tohoku University was performed for 119 participants with informed consent at a particular city in Japan using self-reported questionnaires developed by KIOM (Korea Institute of Oriental Medicine). Among the entire samples, 112 were retested. The test-retest reliability was assessed by Kappa for normal variables and internal consistency was evaluated by Cronbach’s alpha. 3. Results Four of 77 questions are impossible to calculate consistency owing to unsymmetric matrix between primary reply and secondary one. Seventeen of them (22%) showed 0.4 or below in Kappa, 56 were ranged from 0.4 to 0.8 and no question marked 0.8 or over. Internal consistency was possibly checked for several questions about character, digestion, sweat, excrement, urine, cold-heat pattern. Cronbach’s alpha for questions except urine and cold-heat pattern was over 0.64. Conclusions On the basis of Kappa value by two self reported questionnaire, 72.7% of questions showed 0.4 or over so that reliability were highly secured. And other questions except for urine and heat-cold pattern marked 0.6 or over in order that internal consistency was also successfully maintained. Accordingly, when subsequently applying KIOM questionnaire to foreign site, domestic questionnaire should be properly adjusted in social and cultural background, lifestyle, etc.

KEYWORDS

Sasang constitution questionnaire, Japanese, Reliability test, Kappa, Cronbach’s alpha

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] Lee JM / 1894 / Dongyisoosebowon

[journal] Park HS / 2002 / A study on clinical application of the QSCCII / J Sasang Constitut Med 14(2) : 35~44

[journal] Kim SH / 1996 / A study on the standardization of QSCCII (Questionnaire for the sasang constitution classification II) / J Sasang Constitut Med 8(1) : 187~246

[journal] Shin DY / 2004 / A study for interpretation and fitness of Sasang Constitution Questionnaire / J Sasang Constitut Med 16(1) : 74~99

[journal] Huh MH / 1992 / A study on the morphological diagramming of four constitutiens / J Sasang Constitut Med 4(1) : 107~148

[journal] 김종원 / 2006 / A Study on the Body Shape Classified by Sasang Constitutions and Gender Using Physical Measurements / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(1) : 54~61

[journal] Hong SC / 1998 / A morphological study of ear, eye, nose and mouth according to the sasang constitution / J Sasang Constitut Med 10(2) : 221~270

[journal] 김윤희 / 2008 / Accuracy of 3D Automatic Face Recognition Apparatus(3D-AFRA) Recognition / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 20(1) : 34~41

[journal] 최경주 / 2006 / A Study on the Reliability and Validity Test of the QSCCⅡ+ (Revised Questionnaire for the Sasang Constitution Classification) / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(1) : 62~74

[journal] 황인홍 / 1994 / 설문지에 의한 연구방법 / 가정의학회지 15(1) : 30~35

[journal] 고병희 / 1987 / 사상체질변증방법론 연구 (제2보) / 대한한의학회지 8(1)

[journal] Kim SH / 1993 / A validation study of questionnaire of sasang constitution classification (QSCC) / Sasang Constitut Med 5(1) : 61~80

[journal] Lee EJ / 1995 / The study on the validity of questionnaire of sasang constitution classification(I) / J Sasang Constitut Med 7(2) : 89~100

[journal] Kim SB / 2000 / A study on the validity to make a diagnosis of Soeumin by QSCCII / J Sasang Constitut Med 12(2) : 94~103

[journal] Koh BH / 1999 / A study on the Sasang Constitutional Distribution Among the People in the United States of America / J Sasang Constitut Med 11(2) : 119~150

[journal] 김경수 / 2006 / A Study on the Reliability of the Questionnaire about Sasang Constitution Classification for Mongolians / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 18(2) : 96~112

[journal] Yoo JH / 2009 / Test-retest method on short form Sasang Classification questionnaire for America (SF_SSCQ-A) / Pilot study 21(1) : 79~84

[journal] Kim JY / 2003 / A statistical analysis of the question categories conderning Sasang constitutional characteristics of mind / J Sasang Constitut Med 15(3) : 124~138

[journal] 김명근 / 2008 / Study on the Relationship Between Personality and Ordinary Symptoms from the Viewpoint of Sasang Constitution and Cold-Hot / 동의생리병리학회지 / 대한동의병리학회 22(6) : 1354~1358

[journal] J Cohen / 1960 / A Coefficient of Agreement for nominal Scales / Educational and psychological measurement 20(1) : 37~46

[book] Fless JL / 1981 / Stastical methods for rates and proportions.2nd ed / John Willey & Sons : 212~235

[journal] JM Cortina / 1993 / What is coefficient alpha? An examination of theory and applications / Journal of Applied Psychology 78(1) : 98~104

[book] 성태제 / 2005 / 타당도와 신뢰도 / 학지사

[book] 채서일 / 2003 / 사회과학 조사방법론 2판 / 학현사

[journal] 백영화 / 2011 / The Association between Sasang Constitution and Quality of Life according to the Personality Pattern / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 23(3) : 330~339

[journal] 유현희 / 2008 / Study on Development of Cold-Heat Pattern Questionnaire / 동의생리병리학회지 / 대한동의병리학회 22(6) : 1410~1415

[book] 성태제 / 2007 / 연구방법론 / 학지사

[journal] Stein AD / 1995 / Reproducibility of responses to telephone interviews: Demographic predictors of discordance in risk factor status / Am J Epidemiol 141(11) : 1097~1105

[journal] Scarlett SL / 2002 / Reliability of self-reported reproductive factors and childhood social class indicators in a casecontrol study in women / Ann Epidemiol 12(4) : 242~247

[book] 허명희 / 2007 / SPSS 설문지 조사 입문 / 한나래 : 3~45

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.42