The Quality Assessment of Reporting of Intervention Studies on Sasang Constitutional Diet (사상체질 식이 중재연구 보고에 대한 질 평가)

Kim Ji Hwan (김지환); Ju Ah Lee (이주아)

doi:10.7730/JSCM.2020.32.4.11

The Quality Assessment of Reporting of Intervention Studies on Sasang Constitutional Diet

Journal of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine
Abbr : J Sasang Constitut Med
2020, 32(4), pp.11-28
DOI : 10.7730/JSCM.2020.32.4.11
Publisher : The Society of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine
Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > Korean Medicine
Received : December 9, 2020
Accepted : December 18, 2020
Published : December 31, 2020

Kim Ji Hwan ¹, Ju Ah Lee ²

¹가천대학교
²화평통합의학 연구소

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Objectives: The purpose of this study was to evaluate quality of reporting of intervention studies on Sasang Constitutional diet (SCD) based on the Consolidated Standards for Reporting of Trials (CONSORT) and Transparent Reporting of Evaluations with Nonrandomized Designs (TREND) statements. Methods: We searched for Randomized controlled trials (RCT) and Non randomized studies for intervention (NRSI) on SCD in 4 databases and other sources, selected them by the inclusion criteria, and then evaluated quality of reporting of them. Results: 1. A total of 10 studies (1 RCT and 9 NRSI) from 1999 to 2006 were selected and evaluated. The detailed items of up to 78%, at least 40%, and median value of 59% in the CONSORT and TREND statements were not reported. 2. One RCT was reporting 4 (11%) sufficiently, and 4 (11%) insufficiently among the 37 detailed items in the CONSORT statement while it was not reporting 29 (78%) items. 3. Nine NRSI were reporting 7 (12%) items sufficiently, and 2 (3%) items insufficiently among the 58 detailed items in the TREND statement while they were not reporting 15 (26%) items. Twenty (34%) items in the TREND statement were reported in some papers but not in more than half. Conclusions: The quality of reporting of intervention studies on SCD has been assessed to be generally low. Subsequent researchers are recommended to select an appropriate statement for research design, and use it as a checklist from the time of designing the study to the time of reporting.

KEYWORDS

Diet, Intervention, Sasang Constitutional Medicine, CONSORT, TREND, Reporting quality

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 신철민 / 2011 / Tools for Quality Evaluation of Clinical Research Reports / 대한정신약물학회지 / 대한정신약물학회 22(2) : 67~72

[journal] Begg C / 1996 / Improving the quality of reporting of randomized controlled trials. The CONSORT statement / JAMA 276(8) : 637~639

[journal] Schulz KF / 2011 / CONSORT 2010 statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trials / Int J Surg 9(8) : 672~677

[journal] Des Jarlais D. C / 2004 / Improving the reporting quality of nonrandomized evaluations of behavioral and public health interventions : The TERND statement / American Journal of Public Health, Am J Public Health 94(3) : 361~366

[journal] Fuller T / 2012 / Evaluating the impact and use of Transparent Reporting of Evaluations with Non-randomised Designs (TREND)reporting guidelines / BMJ Open 2(6) : e002073~

[journal] 김명희 / 2013 / The Quality of Reporting of Intervention Studies in the Korean Journal of Women Health Nursing (KJWHN): Based on the TREND Guidelines / 여성건강간호학회지 / 한국여성건강간호학회 19(4) : 306~317

[journal] Kim JD / 2013 / Literature on Food Cure and Diet Therapy depending on Sasang Constitutional Medicine / Korean J Agricultural History 12(1) : 91~124

[journal] 정용재 / 2011 / A Study on How Sasang Constitutional Diet Influenced the Formation of Eight Constitutional Diet / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 23(2) : 153~163

[journal] 이봉희 / 2009 / Bibliographical Study on the Constitutional Foods in Korean Medicine / 동의생리병리학회지 / 한의병리학회 23(6) : 1207~1220

[journal] Kim JY / 1995 / The study on validity and application of classification of food as constitution / J. Sasang Const. Med 7(1) : 263~279

[journal] Kim JY / 1996 / Rudimentary Presentation on Menu for Diabetes (1800kcal) in Taeumin, Soumin, and Soyangin based on Food Lists by Constitution / J. Sasang Const. Med 8(1) : 395~411

[journal] 김기영 / 2014 / Herbal Medicine Medical Tourism by Constitution for the Activation Development Study on Food : Focusing on the Literature / 관광연구저널 / 한국관광연구학회 28(3) : 61~74

[journal] Lee EJ / 1998 / The sudy of Constitutional Dietary Therapy / Journal of Sasang Constitutional Medicine 10(2) : 305~349

[journal] Kim EJ / 1999 / The Food Classification in Sasang Constitution and Effects of Tae-eum Constitutional Diet on the Blood Biochemical Parameters and Health Status / J. nutrition& health 32(7) : 827~837

[journal] Lee EJ / 1999 / Constitutional Dietary Therapy in Diabests Medllius / J. Oriental Med 4(1) : 73~83

[journal] 이의주 / 1999 / Constitutional Dietary Therapy in the Hyperlipidemia / 사상체질의학회지 / 사상체질의학회 11(2) : 209~226

[journal] Lim KS / 2000 / Clinical Study of the Constitutional Therapeutic Diet on Hyperlipidemia / Kyung Hee Med 16(1) : 86~93

[journal] Kim KB / 2002 / Effect of Diet Regimen of Sasang Constitution on Health Status / J. East-West nurs. research 7(1) : 18~31

[journal] 전은영 / 2002 / 사상체질식이 적용이 본태성 고혈압 환자의 혈압, 비만도 및 혈중지질에 미치는 효과: 유산소 운동과 저염식이 병용환자를 대상으로 / Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing / 한국간호과학회 32(5) : 673~683

[journal] Moon BK / 2003 / The Effects of Medical Nutrition Therapy on Plasma Lipid Levels of Apo E3 genotype hyperlipidemic Patients according to Sasang Constitutions / J. Sasang Const. Med. 15(1) : 60~71

[journal] 최종인 / 2003 / The Effect of Aerobic Exercise According to Oriental Sasang Constitutional Diet on Blood Lipid(TC, TG), Lung Capacity(VC, FVC) and Body Composition. / 한국체육학회지 / 한국체육학회 42(5) : 735~746

[journal] 김병수 / 2006 / The influence of Selective Food According to Sasang Constitution(SFSC) andAthletes' Physical Endurance, Basic Strength, and Body Composition / Physical Activity and Nutrition / 한국운동영양학회 10(2) : 123~134

[journal] Tripepi G / 2010 / Selection bias and information bias in clinical research / Nephron Clin Pract 115(2) : c94~c99

[journal] Andrade C / 2015 / The primary outcome measure and its importance in clinical trials / Clin Psychiatry 76(10) : e1320~e1323

[journal] Malone HE / 2016 / Fundamentals of estimating sample size / Nurse Res 23(5) : 21~25

[journal] Ho AMH / 2018 / Bias in Before-After Studies : Narrative Overview for Anesthesiologists / Anesth Analg 126(5) : 1755~1762

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.42

The Quality Assessment of Reporting of Intervention Studies on Sasang Constitutional Diet

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of Sasang Constitution and Immune Medicine 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.42

The Quality Assessment of Reporting of Intervention Studies on Sasang Constitutional Diet

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (1)

REFERENCES (26) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.