Exploratory Study On the Policy Learning after Major Conflagration Events: Significant Fire Cases in Korea (화재사건 이후 정책학습에 관한 탐색적 연구: 국내 대형화재 사고 사례를 중심으로)

LEE DONG KYU (이동규); HA MIN JI (하민지); 김춘석

Exploratory Study On the Policy Learning after Major Conflagration Events: Significant Fire Cases in Korea

Crisisonomy
Abbr : KRCEM
2013, 9(4), pp.31-58
Publisher : Crisis and Emergency Management: Theory and Praxis
Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy > Public Policy in general

LEE DONG KYU ¹, HA MIN JI ², 김춘석 ³

¹동아대학교
²성균관대학교
³성균과대학교 대학원

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This article aims to develop policy change model by discover the patterns of policy changes after Major Conflagration Events though describe the variance of the policy change after focusing events. This study analyzes cases of policy change and policy learning, on what difference has been made on a policy decision and policy alternatives after Major Conflagration Events. It explains the dynamic process of policy change after several disasters just like Significant Fire Cases in Korea. This analysis shows that not all disaster events became a big issue through the media and formal agendas in the National Assembly. Also policy alternatives as a result of policy change weren’t made for a long-term perspective on the prevention of disasters. In addition to instrumental policy learning occurred, it wasn’t a result of feedback. Therefore disaster management policy need to be made in order to prevent various disasters from various problem, and through the means of learning and social learning made at the same time, policy should have a specific and long-term perspective.

KEYWORDS

event-related policy learning of birkland, focusing events, policy learning

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] 권기헌 / 2008 / 정책학개론 / 박영사

[journal] 김영평 / 2008 / The Limits of Rationality and the Management of Contradictions / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 46(3) : 1~33

[journal] 박남훈 / 2009 / Study On Policy Learning Failure by Political Decision / 국가정책연구 / 국가정책연구소 23(2) : 67~98

[book] 유훈 / 2009 / 정책변동론 / 대영문화사

[journal] 이동규 / 2013 / A Study on the Concept and Typology from Policy Science Perspectives: Based on the Birkland's Focusing Event Ideas / 한국위기관리논집 / 위기관리 이론과 실천 9(2) : 1~22

[journal] 이동규 / 2013 / Reframing Policy Process Approach of Focusing Events to Analyze the Effects of Catastrophes / 한국치안행정논집 / 한국치안행정학회 9(4) : 143~166

[journal] 이동규 / 2012 / Exploratory Study on the Policy Process after Catastrophes Events / 한국치안행정논집 / 한국치안행정학회 9(2) : 167~194

[journal] 이동규 / 2012 / After Focusing Event Policy Process by Issue Initiator: Focusing On Theory and Model of 'Cobb & Elder', and 'Birkland' / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 21(3) : 91~124

[journal] 이동규 / 2011 / Exploration of Focusing Event Related Policy Change Model: The Case Studies of A Series of Child Sexual Violence Events and Policy Change in Korea / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 20(3) : 107~132

[thesis] 이동규 / 2011 / 초점사건 이후 정책변동 연구 : 한국의 대규모 재난 사례를 중심으로 / 박사 / 성균관대학교

[journal] Alink, Fleur. / 2001 / Institutional Crises and Reforms in Policy Sectors: The Case of Asylum in Europe / Journal of European Public Policy 8(2) : 286~306

[book] Baumgartner, Frank R. / 1993 / Agendas and Instability in American Politics / University of Chicago Press

[book] Berke, Philip / 1992 / Planning for Earthquakes: Risk, Politics, and Policy / Johns Hopkins University Press

[journal] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2009 / Media Framing and Policy Change after Columbine / American Behavioral Scientist 52(10) : 1405~1425

[journal] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2009 / Disasters, Lessons Learned, and Fantasy Documents / Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 17(3) : 146~156

[book] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2006 / Encyclopedia of Media and Politics / CQ Press

[book] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2006 / Handbook of Public Policy Analysis / CRC Press

[book] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2006 / Lessons of Disaster: Policy Change after Catastrophic Events / Georgetown University Press

[book] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2005 / An Introduction to the Policy Process: Theories, Concepts, and Models of Public Policy Making / M. E. Sharpe

[journal] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2004 / Learning and Policy Improvement after Disaster: The Case of Aviation Security / American Behavior Scientist 48(3) : 341~364

[journal] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2004 / Everything Has Changed-Or Has It? Policy Change in the Months after September 11 / Review of Policy Research 21(2) : 177~198

[other] Birkland, Thomas A. / 2001 / Our Political System Will Keep Doing Its Job / Albany Times Union

[journal] Birkland, Thomas A. / 1998 / Focusing Events, Mobilization, and Agenda Setting / Journal of Public Policy 18(3) : 53~74

[journal] Birkland, Thomas A. / 1997 / Factors Inhibiting a National Hurricane Policy / Coastal Management 25(4) : 387~403

[book] Birkland, Thomas A. / 1997 / After Disaster: Agenda Setting, Public Policy, and Focusing Event / Georgetown University Press

[thesis] Birkland, Thomas A. / 1995 / Toward a Theory of Focusing Events and Agenda Setting / 박사 / University of Washington

[journal] Burstein, Paul. / 1991 / Policy Domains: Organization, Culture, and Policy Outcomes / Annual Review of Sociology 17 : 327~350

[journal] Busenberg, G. J. / 2001 / Learning in Organizations and Public Policy / Journal of Public Policy 21 : 173~189

[journal] Cohen, Michael / 1972 / A Garbage Can Model of Organizational Choice / Administrative Science Quterly 17 : 1~25

[journal] Chen, P. / 2003 / Advocating Online Censorship: Australian / Journal of Public Administration 62(2) : 41~64

[book] Drennan, Lynn T. / 2007 / Risk and Crisis Management in the Public Sector / Routledge

[book] Dye, Thomas R. / 1992 / Understanding Public Policy / Prentice-Hall

[journal] Dudley, G. / 1999 / Competing Advocacy Coalitions and the Process of Frame Reflection: A Longitudinal Analysis of EU Steel Policy / Journal of European Public Policy 6(2) : 225~248

[journal] Elliot, C. / 2001 / The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Application to the Policy Process for the Development of Forest Certification in Sweden / Journal of European Public Policy 8(4) : 642~661

[journal] Fenger, M. / 2001 / Interdependency, Beliefs and Coalition Behavior: A Contribution to the Advocacy Coalition Framework / Policy Sciences 34 : 157~170

[confproc] Gould, S. J. / 1994 / Tempo and Mode in the Macroevolutionary Reconstruction of Darwinism / Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A 91(15) : 6764~6771

[journal] Green, M. / 2004 / Advocacy Coalitions and Elite Sport Policy Change in Canada and the United Kingdom / International Review for the Sociology of Sport 39(4) : 387~403

[book] Handmer, John / 2007 / The Handbook of Disaster and Emergency Policies and Institutions / EARTHSCAN

[book] Hoppe, Robert. / 1993 / Handling Frozen Fire / Westview Press

[journal] Howlett, M. / 1998 / Predictable and Unpredictable Policy Windows: Institutional and Exogenous Correlates of Canadian Federal Agenda-Setting / Canadian Journal of Political Science 31 : 495~524

[book] Howlett, M. / 2003 / Studying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and Policy Subsystems / Oxford University Press

[journal] Jenkins-Smith, H. / 1994 / Evaluating the Advocacy Coalitions Framework / Journal of Public Policy 14 : 175~203

[book] Jenkins-Smith, H. / 1993 / The Study of Public Policy Processes, In Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach / Westview Press : 1~9

[book] Jones, Bryan D. / 1994 / Reconceiving Decision-Making in Democratic Politics: Attention, Choice, and Public Policy / University of Chicago Press

[book] Kingdon, John W. / 1995 / Agenda Setting in Public Policy: The Essential Readings, Theodoulou & Cahn Matthew A / Prentice Hall : 105~113

[book] Kingdon, John W. / 1995 / Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies / Harper Collins

[book] Kingdon, John W. / 1984 / Agendas, Alternatives, and Public Policies / Little Brown

[book] Knoke, David. / 1982 / The Social Organization of National Policy Domains: An Exploration of Some Structural Hypotheses, In Social Structure and Network Analysis / Sage

[journal] Krasner, Stephen D. / 1984 / Review: Approaches to the State: Alternative Conceptions and Historical Dynamics / Comparative Politics 16(2) : 223~246

[journal] Kṻbler, D. / 2001 / Understanding Policy Change with the Advocacy Coalition Framework: An Application to Swiss Drug Policy / Journal of European Public Policy 8(4) : 623~641

[book] Lasswell, Harold. / 1988 / Politics: Who Gets What, When, and How / St. Martin's Press

[journal] Larsen, J. B. / 2006 / Advocacy Coalitions and Pharmacy Policy in Denmark / Social Science and Medicine 63(1) : 212~224

[journal] Levy, J. / 1994 / Learning and Foreign Policy: Sweeping a Conceptual Minefield / International Organization 48 : 279~312

[journal] Liftin, K. T. / 2000 / Advocacy Coalitions along the Domestic-Foreign Frontier: Globalization and Canadian Climate Change Policy / Policy Studies Journal 28(1) : 236~252

[journal] May, Peter. / 1992 / Policy Learning and Failure / Journal of Public Policy 12(4) : 331~354

[confproc] Mattingly, S. / 1988 / Policy Options: The Los Angeles Experience / Proceedings of Conference XLII : 229~303

[journal] Mintrom, Michael / 1996 / Advocacy Coalitions, Policy Entrepreneurs, and Policy Change / Policy Studies Journal 24(Fall) : 420~434

[journal] Nohrstedt, Daniel. / 2008 / The Politics of Crisis Policymaking: Chernobyl and Swedish Nuclear Energy Policy / Policy Studies Journal 36(2) : 257~278

[journal] Nohrstedt, Daniel. / 2005 / External Shocks and Policy Change: Three Mile Island and Swedish Nuclear Energy Policy / Journal of European Public Policy 12(6) : 1041~1059

[book] Sabatier, Paul / 2007 / The Advocacy Coalition Framework: Innovations and Clarifications, In Theories of the Policy Process / Westview Press : 189~220

[book] Sabatier, Paul A. / 1999 / Theories of the Policy Process / Westview Press

[book] Sabatier, Paul A. / 1993 / Policy Change over a Decade or More, In Policy Change and Learning: An Advocacy Coalition Approach / Westview Press : 13~39

[journal] Sabatier, Paul A. / 1991 / Political Science and Public Policy / Political Sciences and Politics 24(2) : 144~147

[journal] Sabatier, Paul A. / 1988 / An Advocacy Coalition Framework of Policy Change and the Role of Policy-Oriented Learning Therein / Policy Sciences 21 : 129~168

[journal] Sabatier, Paul A. / 1987 / Knowledge, Policy-Oriented Learning, and Policy Change / Knowledge 8(6) : 649~692

[journal] Sabatier, Paul A. / 1986 / Top-Down and Bottom-Up Models of Policy Implementation: A Critical Analysis and Suggested Synthesis / Journal of Public Policy 6(1) : 21~48

[journal] Schlager, Edella / 1996 / A Comparison of Three Emerging Theories of the Policy Process / Political Research Quarterly 49(3) : 651~672

[journal] Smith, A. / 2000 / Policy Networks and Advocacy Coalitions: Explainning Policy Change and Stability in UK Industrial Pollution Policy? / Environmental Planning C: Government and Policy 18 : 95~114

[journal] Solecki, William D. / 1994 / Looking through the Postdisaster Policy Window / Environmental Management 18(4) : 587~595

[thesis] Vergari, Sandra M. / 1996 / Policy Crisis and Policy Change: Toward a Theory of Crisis Policymaking / 박사 / University Michigan.

[journal] Weible, Christopher / 2005 / Comparing Policy Networks: Marine Protectd Areas in California / Policy Studies Journal 33 : 181~202

[journal] Weible, Christopher / 2005 / Comparing Policy Networks: Marine Protected Areas in California / Policy Studies Journal 33(2) : 181~201

[journal] Zafonte, Matthew / 1998 / Shared Beliefs and Imposed Interdependencies as Determinants of Ally Networks in Overlapping Subsystems / Journal of Theoretical Politics 10(4) : 473~505

[journal] Zafonte, Matthew / 2004 / Short-term Versus Long-term Coalitions in the Policy Process: Automotive Pollution Control / Policy Studies Journal 32(1) : 75~108

[book] Zahariadis, Nikolaos. / 2007 / The Multiple Streams Framework: Structure, Limitations, Prospects, In Theories of the Policy Process / Westview Press : 65~92

[book] Zahariadis, Nikolaos. / 2003 / Ambiguity and Choice in Public Policy: Political Manipulation in Democratic Societies / Georgetown University Press

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Crisisonomy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.64