Theories of Explaining Causes of Large Scale Blackouts: Current Literature and a Future Research Framework

Park, Hyunsoo (박현수)

Theories of Explaining Causes of Large Scale Blackouts: Current Literature and a Future Research Framework

Crisisonomy
Abbr : KRCEM
2013, 9(5), pp.153-186
Publisher : Crisis and Emergency Management: Theory and Praxis
Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy > Public Policy in general

Park, Hyunsoo ¹

¹연세대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Recently large scale blackouts have been a global issue to be addressed. Korea also faces highly unlikely but catastrophic large scale blackouts due to the complexity of its interconnected grid systems. There are different explanations on the causes of large scale blackouts in different fields. At first, therefore, this article categorizes them as techno-economic approaches and complex & network theories. The latter observe the cascading outage itself as a physical phenomenon independent of the social organization of technological events, while the former searches for the causes of large scale blackouts in the physical structure of interconnected transmission systems and market design. Because they do not deal with organizational and institutional problems in their explanations, this paper includes organizational & institutional approaches – Normal Accident theory, High Reliability Organizational theory, and New Institutionalism – to explain social causes of large scale blackouts. Finally, a theoretical framework is outlined that makes an attempt to synchronize different theories in different fields to show multi-dimensions of explaining large scale blackouts and to guide future policy direction.

KEYWORDS

large scale blackout, normal accident, a culture of reliability, symbolism, power relations

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] Apt, J. / 2006 / Power Play: A More Reliable U.S. Electric System / Issues in Science and Technology 22(4) : 51~58

[journal] Apt, J. / 2004 / Electrical Blackouts: A Systemic Problem / Issues in Science and Technology 20(4) : 55~61

[journal] Bak, P. / 1991 / Self-Organizing Criticality / Scientific America 264(1) : 46~53

[journal] Bak, P. / 1988 / Self-Organizing Criticality / Physical Review A38(1) : 364~374

[book] Bijker, W. E. / 1987 / The Social Construction of Technological Systems: New Directions in the Sociology and History of Technology / The MIT Press

[journal] Boffey, P. M. / 1978 / Investigators Agree N.Y. Blackout of 1977 Could Have Been Avoided / Science 201(4360) : 994~998

[book] Brand, W. E. / 1966 / Northeast Electric Bulk Power Supply / Public Utilities Fortnightly : 65~88

[thesis] Bruijne, M. L. / 2006 / Network Reliability: Institutional Fragmentation and the Reliability of Service Provision in Critical Infrastructures / 박사 / Delft University of Technology.

[journal] Carlson, J. M / 1999 / Highly Optimized Tolerance: A Mechanism for Power Laws in Designed Systems / Physical Review E60(2) : 1412~1427

[confproc] Carlson, J. M / 2002 / Complexity and Robustness / Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.(PNAS) 99(3) : 2538~2545

[journal] Carreras, B. A. / 2002 / Critical Points and Transitions in an Electric Power Transmission Model for Cascading Failure Blackouts / CHAOS 12(4) : 985~994

[confproc] Carreras, B. A. / 2004 / Evidence for Self-Organized Criticality in a Time Series of Electric Power System Blackouts / IEEE Transactions on Circuits and Systems I: Regular Papers 51(9) : 1733~1740

[book] Casazza, J. / 2005 / Blackouts and Blunders: the Failure of Electric Power Policies in the United States / Power Engineers Supporting Truth

[confproc] Casazza, J. / 2005 / Contributions of the Restructuring of the Electric Power Industry to the August 14, 2003 Blackout / Technical Workshop on Competition and Reliability in North America Energy Markets

[book] Cetina, K. K. / 1999 / Epistemic Cultures: How the Sciences Make Knowledge / Harvard University Press

[other] Chang, K. / 2003 / Technology and Brain Power Used to Tame an Aging Grid / The New York Times : A1~A12

[journal] Clarke, L. / 1993 / Social Organization and Risk: Some Current Controversies / Annual Review of Sociology 19 : 375~399

[book] Clarke, L. B. / 1989 / Acceptable Risk? Making Decisions in a Toxic Environment. Berkerly and Los Angeles / University of California Press

[book] Clarke, L. B. / 1999 / Mission Improbable / The University of Chicago Press

[book] Collins, H. / 1998 / The Golem at Large: What You Should Know About Technology / Cambridge University Press

[journal] Collins, H. M. / 1981 / The Place of the 'Core-Set' in Modern Science: Social Contingency with Methodological Propriety in Science / History of Science xix : 6~19

[book] Collins, H. M. / 1985 / Changing Order: Replication and Induction in Scientific Practice / SAGE Publication

[confproc] Cook, D. C. / 1967 / Co-Ordination and the Small Electric Power System / Public Utilities Fortnightly : 19~27

[book] DiMaggio, P. J. / 1988 / Interest and Agency in Institutional Theory, In Institutional Patterns and Organizations: Culture and Environment / Ballinger Publishing Company

[journal] DiMaggio, P. J. / 1983 / The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields / American Sociological Review 48(2) : 147~160

[book] Dobson, I. / 2004 / Complex Systems Analysis of Series of Blackouts: Cascading Failure, Criticality, and Self-organization / Bulk Power System Dynamics and Control

[other] Dobson, I. / 2002 / An Initial Complex Systems Analysis of the Risks of Blackouts in Power Transmission Systems / Power System and Communications Infrastructures for the Future

[book] Ebers, M. / 1997 / Explaining Inter-Organizational Network Formation: The Formation of Inter-Organizational Networks / Oxford University Press

[confproc] EW. / 1977 / Con Ed Seeks Light, Less Heat, on System Blackout / Electrical World : 25~28

[confproc] EW / 1977 / FPC, Con Ed at Odds on Blackout / Electrical World : 22~

[confproc] Fairely, P. / 2004 / The Unruly Power Grid / IEEE Spectrum : 22~27

[other] Firestone, D. / 2003 / Warning Long Ignored on Aging Electric System / The New York Times

[book] Fligstein, N. / 1979 / The Structural Transformation of American Industry: An Institutional Account of the Causes of Diversification in the Largest Firms, 1919-1979, In The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis / The University of Chicago Press

[book] FPC / 1967 / Prevention of Power Failures: Volume I - Report of the Commission / Federal Power Commission

[book] Friedland, R. / 1991 / Bringing Society Back In: Symbols, Practices, and Institutional Contradictions, In The New Institutionalism in Organizational Analysis / The University of Chicago Press

[confproc] Friedlander, G. D. / 1966 / The Northeast Power Failure: A Blanket of Darkness / IEEE Spectrum : 54~73

[confproc] Friedlander, G. D. / 1967 / Prevention of Power Failure: The FPC Report of 1967 / IEEE Spectrum : 53~61

[book] Galison, P. / 1997 / Image and Logic: A Material Culture of Microphysics / The University of Chicago Press

[book] Geertz, C. / 2000 / Local Knowledge: Further Essays in Interpretative Anthropology / Basic Books

[journal] Gellings, C. W / 2004 / Transforming the Electric Infrastructure / Physics Today 57(12) : 45~51

[other] Guare, J. / 1994 / Six Degrees of Separation / U.S. UA Home Video

[journal] Hogan, W. W. / 2003 / Electricity Is a Federal Issue / Wall Street Journal

[journal] Hogan, W. W / 2004 / Shedding Light / Wall Street Journal

[book] Hughes, T. P. / 1930 / Networks of Power: Electrification in Western society, 1880-1930 / The Johns Hopkins University Press

[web] Joskow, P. L. / 2003 / August 17th. The Blackout / http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/hepg/Papers/joskow_blackout_v1.2a_8-17-03.pdf

[book] Joskow, P. L. / 2005 / The Difficult Transition to Competitive Electricity Markets in the United States, In Electricity Deregulation: Choices and Challenges / The University of Chicago Press

[web] Kirschen, D. / 2003 / August 27th. Why Investments Do Not Prevent Blackouts / http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/hepg/Blackout.htm

[book] Lagendijk, V. / 2008 / Electrifying Europe: The Power of Europe in the Construction of Electricity Networks / Aksant Academic Publishers

[book] LaPorte, T. R / 1991 / Social Response to Large Technical Systems: Control or Anticipation / Kluwer Academic Publishers

[journal] LaPorte, T. R. / 1994 / A Strawman Speaks Up: Comments on The Limits of Safety / Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 2(4) : 207~211

[journal] LaPorte, T. R. / 1991 / Working In Practice but Not in Theory: Theoretical Challenges of High Reliability Organizations / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 1(1) : 19~47

[journal] LaPorte, T. R. / 1994 / A Rejoinder to Perrow / Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 2(4) : 221~227

[book] Lawton, L. / 1932 / An Economic History of Soviet Russia: Volume I / The Macmillan Company

[journal] Lovins, A. B. / 2003 / Enlightening Blackouts / RMI Solutions: Newsletter xix : 5~6

[book] Lovins, A. B. / 1982 / Brittle Power: Energy Strategy for National Security / Brick House Publishing Company

[journal] Manion, M. / 2002 / Technological Catastrophes: Their Causes and Prevention / Technology in Society 24 : 207~224

[journal] Metz, W. D. / 1977 / New York Blackout: Weak Links Tie Con Ed to Neighboring Utilities / Science 197(4302) : 441~442

[journal] Meyer, J. W. / 1977 / Institutionalized Organizations: Formal Structures as Myth and Ceremony / The American Journal of Sociology 83(2) : 340~363

[book] Meyer, J. W. / 1992 / The Structure of Educational Organizations, In Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality / Sage Publications

[book] Meyer, J. W. / 1992 / Organizational Environments: Ritual and Rationality / Sage Publications

[journal] Milgram, S. / 1967 / The Small-World Problem / Psychology Today 1(1) : 60~67

[web] Nadis, S. / 2004 / Let There Be Light. Kennedy School Bulletin / http://www.ksg.harvard.edu/ksgpress/bulletin/spring2004/features/let_light.html

[confproc] Nedic, D. P / 2005 / Criticality in a Cascading Failure Blackout Model / Fifteenth Power Systems Computation Conference. Liege, Belgium

[journal] Newman, D. P. / 2011 / Exploring Complex Systems Aspects of Blackout Risk and Mitigation / IEEE Transactions on Reliability 60(1) : 134~143

[journal] Newman, M. E. / 2001 / Random Graphs with Arbitrary Degree Distributions and Their Applications / Physical Review E64 : 026111~026117

[book] Nye, D. E. / 1940 / Electrifying America: Social Meanings of a New Technology, 1880-1940 / The MIT Press

[other] NYT / 1965 / Aladdin's Lamp Black Out / The New York Times

[journal] Perrow, C. / 1977 / The Bureaucratic Paradox: The Efficient Organizations Centralize in Order to Decentralize / Organizational Dynamics 5 : 3~14

[journal] Perrow, C. / 1985 / Review: Overboard with Myth and Symbols / The American Journal of Sociology 91(1) : 151~155

[book] Perrow, C. / 1986 / Complex Organizations: A Critical Essay / McGraw-Hill, Inc

[journal] Perrow, C. / 1994 / The Limits of Safety: The Enhancement of a Theory of Accidents / Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 2(4) : 212~220

[book] Perrow, C. / 1999 / Normal Accidents: Living with High-Risk Technologies / Princeton University Press

[book] Perrow, C. / 2002 / Organizing America: Wealth, Power, and the Origins of Corporate Capitalism / Princeton University Press

[book] Perrow, C. / 2006 / Disasters Ever More? Reducing U.S. Vulnerabilities, In Handbook of Disaster Research / Springer

[book] Perrow, C. / 2007 / The Next Catastrophe: Reducing Our Vulnerabilities to Natural, Industrial, and Terrorist Disasters / Princeton University Press

[book] Perry, R. W. / 2006 / What Is a Disaster?, In Handbook of Disaster Research / Springer

[book] Pfeffer, J. / 1981 / Power in Organizations / Ballinger Publishing Company

[journal] Pidgeon, N. / 1997 / The Limits to Safety? Culture, Politics, Learning and Man-Made Disasters / Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 5(1) : 1~14

[journal] Pinch, T. J. / 1984 / The Social Construction of Fact and Artefacts: Or How the Sociology of Science and the Sociology of Technology Might Benefit Each Other / Social Studies of Science 14(3) : 399~441

[confproc] Priest, A. J. G. / 1967 / Utility Service Outages and Interruptions: The "Big Blackout" / Public Utilities Fortnightly : 19~25

[book] Quarantelli, E. L. / 2006 / A Heuristic Approach to Future Disasters and Crises: New, Old, and In-Between Types, In Handbook of Disaster Research / Springer : 16~41

[book] Rasmussen, J. / 1987 / New Technology and Human Error / John Wiley & Sons

[book] Reason, J. / 1990 / Human Error / Cambridge University Press

[book] Reason, J. / 1997 / Managing the Risks of Organizational Accidents / Ashgate Publishing Company

[journal] Roberts, K. H. / 1990 / Some Characteristics of One Type of High Reliability Organization / Organization Science 1(2) : 160~176

[journal] Rochlin, G. I. / 1987 / The Self-Designing High-Reliability Organization: Aircraft Carrier Flight Operation at Sea / Naval War College Review (Autumn) : 76~90

[journal] Rudolph, J. W. / 2002 / Disaster Dynamics: Understanding the Role of Quantity in Organizational Collapse / Administrative Science Quarterly 47 : 1~30

[journal] Sachtjen, M. L. / 2000 / Disturbances in a Power Transmission System / Physical Review E61(5) : 4877~4882

[book] Sagan, S. D. / 1993 / The Limits of Safety: Organizations, Accidents, and Nuclear Weapons / Princeton University Press

[journal] Sagan, S. D. / 1994 / Toward a Political Theory of Organizational Reliability / Journal of Contingencies and Crisis Management 2(4) : 228~240

[book] Scott, W. R. / 1998 / Organizations: Rational, Natural, and Open Systems / Prentice Hall

[book] Scott, W. R. / 2001 / Institutions and Organizations / Sage Publications, Inc

[book] Scott, W. R. / 2000 / Institutional Change and Healthcare Organizations: From Professional Dominance to Managed Care / The University of Chicago Press

[web] Seppa, T. O. / 2003 / Blackouts: Lessons Learned? / http://www.cat-1.com/files/papers/BlackoutLesson.pdf

[book] Shrivastava, P. / 1992 / Bhopal: Anatomy of a Crisis / Paul Chapman Publishing Ltd

[journal] Strogatz, S. / 2001 / Exploring Complex Networks / Nature 410(8) : 268~276

[other] Strogatz, S. / 2003 / How the Blackout Came to Life / The New York Times

[journal] Talukdar, S. N. / 2003 / Cascading Failures: Survival versus Prevention / The Electricity Journal 16(9) : 25~31

[journal] Turner, B. A. / 1976 / The Organizational and Interorganizational Development of Disasters / Administrative Science Quarterly 21(3) : 378~397

[book] Turner, B. A. / 1997 / Man-Made Disasters / Butterworth- Heinemann

[book] Vacca, R. / 1973 / The Coming Dark Age / Anchor/Doubleday Company Inc

[journal] Vaughan, D. / 1990 / Autonomy, Interdependence, and Social Control: NASA and the Space Shuttle Challenger / Administrative Science Quarterly 35(2) : 225~257

[book] Vaughan, D. / 1996 / The Challenge Launch Decision: Risky Technology, Culture, and Deviance at NASA / The University of Chicago Press

[journal] Vaughan, D. / 1999 / The Dark Side of Organizations: Mistake, Misconduct, and Disaster / Annual Review of Sociology 25 : 271~305

[journal] Vaughan, D. / 1999 / The Role of the Organization in the Production of Techno-Scientific Knowledge / Social Studies of Science 29(6) : 913~943

[journal] Vaughan, D. / 2004 / Theorizing Disaster: Analogy, Historical Ethnography, and the Challenger Accident / Ethnography 5(3) : 315~347

[journal] Watts, D. J. / 1999 / Networks, Dynamics, and the Small-World Phenomenon / The American Journal of Sociology 105(2) : 493~527

[book] Watts, D. J. / 1999 / Small World: The Dynamics of Netwroks between Order and Randomness / Princeton University Press

[confproc] Watts, D. J. / 2002 / A Simple Model of Global Cascades on Random Networks / Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America(PNAS) 99(9) : 5766~5771

[book] Watts, D. J. / 2003 / Six Degrees: The Science of a Connected Age / W. W. Norton & Company

[journal] Watts, D. J. / 1998 / Collective Dynamics of 'Small-World' Networks / Nature 393 : 440~442

[journal] Weick, K. E. / 1987 / Organizational Culture as a Source of High Reliability / California Management Review XXIX(2) : 112~127

[journal] Weick, K. E. / 1990 / The Vulnerable System: An Analysis of the Tenerife Air Disaster / Journal of Management 16(3) : 571~593

[journal] Weick, K. E. / 1993 / Collective Mind in Organizations: Heedfull Interrelating on Flight Decks / Administrative Science Quarterly 38(3) : 357~381

[book] Westrum, R. / 1991 / Technologies and Society: The Shaping of People and Things / Wadsworth Publishing Company

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Crisisonomy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.64