KJCKorea
Journal Central

@article{ART002466545},
author={Choi Dong-Hyun and Jang Woo Chang},
title={A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』},
journal={The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics},
issn={1229-8328},
year={2019},
volume={32},
number={2},
pages={111-134},
doi={10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111}

TY - JOUR
AU - Choi Dong-Hyun
AU - Jang Woo Chang
TI - A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』
JO - The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics
PY - 2019
VL - 32
IS - 2
PB - 대한한의학원전학회
SP - 111
EP - 134
SN - 1229-8328
AB - Objectives : To identify differences in perspective between 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』 in regards to Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang through comparative analysis of relevant verses of the two texts. Methods : Comparative analysis was undertaken based on the hypothesis that the two texts are relatively unrelated to each other in their transmission. Relevant verses were examined to identify their differences, followed by analysis of the overall context based on these variations to determine the difference in perspective between the two texts. Results & Conclusions : While in 『Songbenshanghanlun』 the relationship between the two patterns were ambiguous and conflicting at times, in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 the relationship was clear-cut, and similar patterns that could be mistaken were systematically explained. From the perspective of 『Songbenshanghanlun』, the key traits of 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 could be summarized into two. First, in 『Songbenshanghanlun』, it says that if there are exterior symptoms, Baihutang cannot be applied, which naturally excludes Baihujiarenshentang. However in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』, exterior symptoms constitute the Baihujiarenshentang pattern. Second, in 『Songbenshanghanlun』 contraindication of Baihutang concerning miscellaneous symptoms are reduced in the form of footnotes which meaning is unclear, while in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 the three points of contraindication of Baihutang are listed separately under verse no. 170, with relevant verses listed organically, explaining in great detail the Baihutang pattern, its relation to similar patterns and treatment.
KW - Baihutang;Baihujiarenshentang;Jinguiyuhanjing;Songbenshanghanlun
DO - 10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111
ER -

Choi Dong-Hyun and Jang Woo Chang. (2019). A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』. The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics, 32(2), 111-134.

Choi Dong-Hyun and Jang Woo Chang. 2019, "A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』", The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics, vol.32, no.2 pp.111-134. Available from: doi:10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111

Choi Dong-Hyun, Jang Woo Chang "A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』" The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics 32.2 pp.111-134 (2019) : 111.

Choi Dong-Hyun, Jang Woo Chang. A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』. 2019; 32(2), 111-134. Available from: doi:10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111

Choi Dong-Hyun and Jang Woo Chang. "A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』" The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics 32, no.2 (2019) : 111-134.doi: 10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111

Choi Dong-Hyun; Jang Woo Chang. A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』. The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics, 32(2), 111-134. doi: 10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111

Choi Dong-Hyun; Jang Woo Chang. A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』. The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics. 2019; 32(2) 111-134. doi: 10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111

Choi Dong-Hyun, Jang Woo Chang. A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』. 2019; 32(2), 111-134. Available from: doi:10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111

Choi Dong-Hyun and Jang Woo Chang. "A Comparative Study on the Baihutang and Baihujiarenshentang Patterns in 『Jinguiyuhanjing』 and 『Songbenshanghanlun』" The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics 32, no.2 (2019) : 111-134.doi: 10.14369/jkmc.2019.32.2.111