Journal of Korean society of Dental Hygiene 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.8
-
pISSN : 2287-1705 / eISSN : 2288-2294
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/jksdh
pISSN : 2287-1705 / eISSN : 2288-2294
Article Review Policy of the Journal of Korean Society of Dental Hygiene
Established in March 2001
Revised March 2006
Revised March 2008
Revised March 2011
Revised in February 2021
Revised in April 2024
Article 1 (Purpose) The purpose of these regulations is to regulate matters related to the review of articles submitted to the Journal of Korean Society of Dental Hygiene in accordance with Article 4, Paragraph 4 of the Regulations of the Editorial Board of the Korean Society of Dental Hygiene.
Article 2 (Review and Acceptance) The review and acceptance of articles shall be in accordance with these regulations.
Article 3 (Review and Authorship) Articles shall be reviewed only for original research reports in dental hygiene, and master's and doctoral theses in dental hygiene shall also undergo the review process, and if it is stated that it is a thesis, it can only be published with the author of a degree as the first author and the supervisor as the corresponding author or co-author.
Article 4 (Submission) Manuscripts that do not comply with the submission requirements and submission regulations will not be accepted.
Article 5 (Reviewers) The number of reviewers for each article shall not be less than three, and the reviewers shall be appointed by the Editor-in-Chief.
Article 6 (Disclosure of referees) The referees of a paper are not disclosed to the author and are not disclosed to the referees of the same paper.
Article 7 (Review Result) The results of the review shall be written in the form of the review evaluation items and the details of the review comments, and shall be judged as “acceptable for publication”, “acceptable for publication after revision”, “revised and reconsidered”, and “not acceptable for publication”.
1. Papers judged to be as “acceptable for publication” will be accepted without revision.
2. Papers rated as “acceptable for publication after revision” will be accepted by the Editorial Board after the authors have addressed the issues raised by the reviewers.
3. Papers rated as “revised and reconsidered” will be reviewed by the reviewer who rated it as “revised and reconsidered” after the author has addressed the issues raised by the reviewer and decided whether or not to accept it.
4. Criteria for judging a paper “not acceptable for publication” is only when the content of the paper is recognised as falling under one of the following paragraphs.
(a) The subject matter of the research has no relevance to dental hygiene
(b) The research is plagiarised from published work by another person
(c) The results of the research lack reliability or validity
(d) If it is deemed impossible to correct
(e) Violation of the ethical rules of this journal and other research ethics
(f) Other (if the reviewers and editorial board members provide valid reasons for non-publication)
Article 8 (Disclosure of review contents) The contents of the review shall not be disclosed to anyone other than the author.
Article 9 (Unpublishable) If two out of three reviewers consider an article "unpublishable", it will not be accepted.
Article 10 (Review) The reviewers shall accept the review within five days after receiving the review request, and the review results shall be uploaded to the System of Online Manuscript Submission and Review within seven days. However, if the review is not completed after a certain period of time, the Editor-in-Chief may change the reviewers.
Article 11 (Submission of revised manuscripts) If the author fails to submit the revised manuscript according to the revision recommendations of the reviewers or the Editor-in-Chief within 10 days, the publication may be postponed.
Article 12 (Review Fee) Upon completion of the review, a review fee of KRW 20,000 won per article shall be paid to the reviewer's account.
Supplementary Regulations
1. These regulations are effective from 1 March 2001.
2. Amendments to these Rules shall be effective from 1 March 2006.
3. Amendments to these Regulations shall take effect from 1 March 2008.
4. Amendments to these Regulations shall take effect from 1 March 2011.
5. Amendments to these Regulations shall take effect from 1 February 2021.
6. Amendments to these Regulations shall enter into force on 1 April 2024.