@article{ART001512931},
author={이태호 and Il-Gie Song and 노기춘},
title={A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do},
journal={Journal of Studies in Bibliography},
issn={1225-5246},
year={2010},
number={47},
pages={239-266},
doi={10.17258/jib.2010..47.239}
TY - JOUR
AU - 이태호
AU - Il-Gie Song
AU - 노기춘
TI - A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do
JO - Journal of Studies in Bibliography
PY - 2010
VL - null
IS - 47
PB - Korean Society of Bibliography
SP - 239
EP - 266
SN - 1225-5246
AB - To verify the originality of Jinhak-do(進學圖), this study has done a comparative analysis of the organizational structures of Sunghak Sib-do(聖學十圖) and Jinhak-do, and 9 diagrams and comments, closely related.
A comparison of their structures shows that while Sunghak Sib-do is organized into two(pl.1-5, 6-10) and three(pl.1-2, 3-4, 5-10) divisions, aiming at a sage's study, Jinhak-do has 5 divisions such as ‘宇宙論(天道) ￫ 心性論 ￫ 用工先後論 ￫ 聖人敎訓論 ￫ 其他’, which help a novice study from the beginning.
An analysis of 9 diagrams and comments reveals that out of 9 diagrams that Gwon Chun-ran(權春蘭) adopted in Jinhak-do, 6 were based on the diagrams of Sunghak Sib-do, and three were his original diagrams. It is also found that Gwon Chun-ran elaborated and expanded 7 comments of diagrams, based on Sunghak Sib-do and completely replaced 2 comments in his own words. Therefore Jinhak-do did not simply quote Sunghak Sib-do written by Yi Hwang, but relevantly expanded and supplemented its content, and added his original diagrams and comments, when needed. And it covered much wider area as well.
KW - Jinhak-do;Sunghak Sib-do;Gwon Chun-ran;Yi Hwang;Confucian diagram
DO - 10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
ER -
이태호, Il-Gie Song and 노기춘. (2010). A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do. Journal of Studies in Bibliography, 47, 239-266.
이태호, Il-Gie Song and 노기춘. 2010, "A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do", Journal of Studies in Bibliography, no.47, pp.239-266. Available from: doi:10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
이태호, Il-Gie Song, 노기춘 "A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do" Journal of Studies in Bibliography 47 pp.239-266 (2010) : 239.
이태호, Il-Gie Song, 노기춘. A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do. 2010; 47 : 239-266. Available from: doi:10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
이태호, Il-Gie Song and 노기춘. "A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do" Journal of Studies in Bibliography no.47(2010) : 239-266.doi: 10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
이태호; Il-Gie Song; 노기춘. A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do. Journal of Studies in Bibliography, 47, 239-266. doi: 10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
이태호; Il-Gie Song; 노기춘. A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do. Journal of Studies in Bibliography. 2010; 47 239-266. doi: 10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
이태호, Il-Gie Song, 노기춘. A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do. 2010; 47 : 239-266. Available from: doi:10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
이태호, Il-Gie Song and 노기춘. "A Comparative Study of Diagrams of Jinhak-do and Sunghak Sib-do" Journal of Studies in Bibliography no.47(2010) : 239-266.doi: 10.17258/jib.2010..47.239
