건강영향을 고려한 산업단지 개발의 계획 적정성 평가방법론 연구 (A Study on a Plan Adequacy Evaluation for Industrial Complex Development Considering Health Impact)

신문식 (Moonshik Shin); 이영수 (Youngsoo Lee); 하종식 (Jongsik Ha)

A Study on a Plan Adequacy Evaluation for Industrial Complex Development Considering Health Impact

Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment
Abbr : J EIA
2020, 29(2), pp.93-111
Publisher : Korean Society Of Environmental Impact Assessment
Research Area : Engineering > Environmental Engineering
Received : December 23, 2019
Accepted : April 13, 2020
Published : April 30, 2020

Moonshik Shin ¹, Youngsoo Lee ², Jongsik Ha ³

¹서울시립대학교 환경공학과
²도화엔지니어링
³한국환경정책·평가연구원

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Health Impact Assessment (HIA) in Korea is conducted for specific development projects within Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) system. However, as HIA is being carried out in the implementation stage of the development project, it sometimes has failed to take proper actions despite the significant adverse health impact. Considering an environment conflict regarding adverse health impact in developing industrial complex and the current application of HIA in EIA system, it is necessary to come up with an adequacy evaluation in the industrial complex development considering health impact. This study proposes an adequacy evaluation method considering health impact for the industrial complex development and embodies the method by applying it to actual cases. Referring to methodologies of US EPA’s CalEnviroScreen 3.0 and US ATSDR’s Public Health Assessment, this study proposed using indicators divided by community characteristic, background exposure and development burden as an adequacy evaluation method to consider health impact. Five indicators for community characteristic, three indicators for background exposure and seven indicators for development burden were selected through literature survey, and the weights for each indicator were calculated through Analytic Hierarchy Process’s survey of experts related to HIA. Through a pilot application in the three government-led industrial complex development projects, the method was further elaborated by clarifying the evaluation data and subdividing the evaluation criteria for each indicator. Adequacy criteria of plan considering health impact could be presented in three ways to be linked to the government’s policy stance on the industrial complex development criteria of total score, criteria of total score and community characteristic score, and criteria of total score and community characteristic allowed by development burden.

KEYWORDS

Health Impact Assessment, Plan Adequacy Evaluation, community characteristic indicators, background exposure indicators, development burden indicators

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[other] Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry / 2005 / Public Health Assessment Guidance Manual

[journal] Alwahaibi A / 2016 / Respiratory and allergic health effects in a young population in proximity of a major industrial park in Oman / J Epidemiol Community Health 70(2) : 174~180

[other] California Environmental Protection Agency / 2017 / CalEnvironScreen 3.0

[other] Environmental Protection Agency / 2009 / Sociodemographic data used for identifying potentially highly exposed population / US EPA : 20460~

[other] Environmental Protection Agency / 2015 / Guidance for the Assessment of Environmental Factors – Separation Distances between Industrial and Sensitive Land Uses

[other] Gordis L. / 2008 / Epidemiology

[journal] 하종식 / 2018 / A Study on the Application of Potential Exposed Population for a Receptor-oriented Health Impact Assessment / 환경영향평가 / 한국환경영향평가학회 27(2) : 194~202

[other] Health Canada / 2004 / Canadian Handbook on Health Impact Assessment / International Commission on Non-Ionizing Radiation

[journal] Protection / 2000 / Guideline for limiting exposure to time-varying electric magnetic fields(1Hz to 100kHz) / Health Physics 99(6) : 818~836

[book] John K / 2008 / Health Impact Assessment: Concepts, theory, techniques, and applications / Oxford University Press

[report] Isabella K / 2009 / Life prevalence of upper respiratory tract diseases and asthma among children residing in rural area near a regional industrial park: cross-sectional study / Rural Remote Health : 1092~

[journal] Kim H / 2016 / Relationship between residential district and heat-related quality of life in Chungnam industrial complex area / Environmental Health and Toxicology 31

[other] Korea Environment Institute / 2015 / 2015 Environment Assessment – Basic teaching materials for education programs

[report] Korea Environment Institute / 2017 / Improvement of Risk Assessment in Health Impact Assessment

[journal] Manoj K / 2017 / A study of trace element contamination using multivariate statistical techniques and health risk assessment in groundwater of Chhaprola Industrial Area, Gautam Buddha Nagar, Uttar Pradesh, India / Chemosphere 166 : 135~145

[journal] Peiyue L / 2014 / Origin and assessment of groundwater pollution and associated health risk : a case study in an industrial park, northweat China / Environmental geochemistry and health 36(4) : 693~712

[journal] Miguel A Lopez-N / 2013 / The effect of social trust on citizen’s health risk perception in the context of a petrochemical industrial complex / International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 10(1) : 399~416

[other] Ministry of Environment / 2011 / Manual for Assessment of Health Impact Items

[report] Ministry of Environment / 2015 / Regulations on Environmental Impact Assessment

[other] Ministry of Environment / 2016 / Integrated Guidelines for Development and Location of Industrial Complexes

[other] Ministry of Environment / 2016 / Integrated Guidelines for Development and Operation of Farming Industrial Complexes

[report] Ministry of Environment / 2017 / Comprehensive Evaluation of Environmental Pollution Exposure and Health Impact Monitoring Projects for Local Residents in the Country’s Mountain Area

[report] Ministry of Environment / 2017 / A Study on the Improvement of Health Impact Assessment Method

[report] Ministry of Environment / 2018 / A Study on the Improvement of Health Impact Assessment System on the receptor’s demand

[report] Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport / 2017 / Integration standard of industrial complex planning

[journal] Sasty TL / 1990 / How to make a decision : The Analytic Hierarchy Process / European Journal of Operational Research 48 : 9~26

[journal] Jingang S / 2018 / A method to determine the protection zone of chemical industrial park considering air quality, health risk and environmental risk : a case study / Environmental geochemistry and health 40(2) : 915~922

[journal] Pannawadee S / 2013 / Health risk assessment of Volatile Organic Compounds in a high risk group surrounding Map Ta Phut industrial estate, Rayoung Provice / J Med Asso Thail 96 : S73~S81

[journal] Josep T / 2009 / Asbestos-related diseases in a population near a fibrous cement factory / Archivos de Bronconeumologia 45(9) : 429~434

[other] World Health Organization / 2007 / Electromagnetic fields and public health: Exposure to extremely low frequency fields (WHO fact sheets, No.322)

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.51

A Study on a Plan Adequacy Evaluation for Industrial Complex Development Considering Health Impact

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.51

A Study on a Plan Adequacy Evaluation for Industrial Complex Development Considering Health Impact

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (3)

REFERENCES (30) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.