‘적극적 대표성’이라는 블랙박스 해독하기:사회적 구성주의적 시각과 사례연구방법론 활용의 모색

KWI HEE BAE (배귀희); 임승후

‘적극적 대표성’이라는 블랙박스 해독하기:사회적 구성주의적 시각과 사례연구방법론 활용의 모색

Korean Society and Public Administration
Abbr : KSPA
2010, 20(4), pp.63-92
Publisher : Seoul Association For Public Administration
Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration

KWI HEE BAE ¹, 임승후 ²

¹숭실대학교
²서울대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

The concept of representative bureaucracy or representation is essential to understanding contemporary democracy. Many studies on representative bureaucracy or quota program for employment of female public servant have been conducted based on empiricism or logical positivism. However, such efforts do not provide clear explanation of missing link in the relationship between passive and active representation or policy effect in the perspective of gender. In order to overcome these limitation of prior studies this paper is to suggest alternative way of studying representative bureaucracy by employing a case study method based on the social constructivism. This research may contribute to understanding representative bureaucracy in terms of collaborative or positive sum games, not conflictual or zero-sum games.

KEYWORDS

active representation, social constructivism, case study method

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 강민아 / 2007 / An Exploratory Application of the Mixed Methods Research: Application of Surveys and Focus Group Interviews for Regional Public Health Issue Decision Making / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 41(4) : 415~437

[confproc] 권경득 / 1996 / 한국 대표관료제의 성찰과 전망 / 한국정치학회 연례학술대회 발표논문

[journal] 권경득 / 2005 / Affirmative Action of the Korean Government / 한국인사행정학회보 / 한국인사행정학회 4(1) : 23~52

[report] 김근세 / 2001 / 한국 중앙정부의 대표관료제에 관한 연구 / 중앙인사위원회 연구보고서

[journal] 김대성 / 2008 / Gender Identity and Its Policy Implication in Feminist Administrative Theory :Social Constructivism Applied / 한국거버넌스학회보 / 한국거버넌스학회 15(1) : 35~56

[journal] 김복규 / 1999 / 지방여성공무원의 고용실태와 평등고용 촉진에 관한 연구: 대구시 사례 / 한국행정학보 33(2) : 183~198

[confproc] 김병섭 / 2005 / 한국의 정부개혁: 성과, 문제, 그리고 과제 / 한국행정학회 하계학술대회 발표논문

[book] 김병섭 / 2008 / 편견과 오류 줄이기: 조사연구의 논리와 기법 / 법문사

[journal] 김선혁 / 2004 / 비교정책학의 현재와 미래: 신제도주의, 사회적 구성주의, 신비교행정학을 중심으로 / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 13(3) : 259~278

[confproc] 김영미 / 2000 / 공직에서의 여성: 여성공무원 대표성을 중심으로 / 한국정치학회 기획학술회의 발표논문

[journal] 김영미 / 2003 / 여성공무원 채용목표제에 관한 논의 / 사회과학연구 16 : 2~18

[confproc] 김혁 / 2003 / 차별보상정책과 미국 관료제의 여성 대표성: 차별보상정책을 통한 대표관료제의 달성수준에 대한 평가를 중심으로 / 한국행정학회 춘계학술대회 발표논문

[confproc] 김혜란 / 2008 / 거버넌스 관점에서의 성인지예산 / 한국행정학회 하계학술대회 발표논문

[book] 남궁근 / 2006 / 행정조사방법론 / 법문사

[journal] 박상희 / 2006 / An Analysis of the Effects of Affirmative Action on the Representative Bureaucracy in Korea / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 40(4) : 179~203

[confproc] 배귀희 / 2005 / 사회적 구성주의 관점에서 대표 관료제에 관한 고찰: 여성공무원을 중심으로 / 한국행정학회 춘계학술대회 발표논문

[journal] 배귀희 / 2008 / An Analysis of the Effects of Quota Program for Employment of Female Public Servants in Korea / 정책분석평가학회보 / 한국정책분석평가학회 18(1) : 233~262

[journal] 서원석 / 2002 / 대표관료제와 여성채용목표제 / Administration Focus : 31~35

[journal] 심준섭 / 2005 / Evaluation and Proposal on Research Methods for Public Administration : Focusing on Triangulation / 국가정책연구 / 국가정책연구소 19(1) : 31~63

[journal] 심준섭 / 2008 / Methodological Triangulation in Public Administration: Combination of Quantitative and Qualitative Methods / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 17(2) : 3~31

[report] 여성가족부 / 2001 / 정부 부처내의 성인지적 정책형성을 위한 지침마련 및 제도화방안 연구

[journal] 원숙연 / 2003 / The Dynamics between State Policy and Gender Relations: A Theoretical Approach to the Gender Policy Regime / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 37(2) : 227~241

[confproc] 원숙연 / 2004 / 여성정책의 실질적 기능화: 일-가정 양립지원정책을 중심으로 / 한국행정학회 춘계학술대회 발표논문

[confproc] 원숙연 / 2004 / ‘젠더’, 더미변수(dummy variable)를 넘어서: 젠더 관점을 통한 조직연구의 지향과쟁점 / 한국행정학회 하계학술대회 발표논문

[journal] 원숙연 / 2007 / Gendered Underlying Mechanisms for Perception of Female Mangers in Organizations: A Theoretical Review / 한국여성학 / 한국여성학회 23(4) : 151~175

[journal] 윤견수 / 2005 / Reflections and Suggestions about Qualitative Research Methods of Korean Public Administration / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 39(2) : 1~22

[confproc] 윤견수 / 2007 / 사례분석인가, 사례집필인가? / 서울대학교 행정대학원 SD 세미나

[journal] 윤창근 / 2009 / A Study on the Shift from Passive Representation to Active Representation: A Focus on Critical Mass and the Effect of Discretion on Active Representation / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 47(3) : 25~50

[report] 이향순 / 1997 / 미국의 고용평등제도에 관한 연구: 적극적 조치를 중심으로 / 한국노동연구원

[journal] 임도빈 / 2009 / Qualitative Methodology: Approach and Application / 정부학연구 / 정부학연구소 15(1) : 155~187

[confproc] 전재성 / 2006 / 현실주의적 구성주의와 구성주의적 현실주의 / 한국국제정치학회 연례학술대회

[book] 정정길 / 1998 / 정책결정론 / 대명출판사

[journal] 최신융 / 2004 / Applying affirmative action in private sector for gender-equity in employment / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 38(6) : 327~348

[book] 하연섭 / 2003 / 제도분석: 이론과 쟁점 / 다산출판사

[book] 한국노동연구원 / 2006 / 노동시장차별과 적극적 고용개선조치 I / 한국노동연구원

[journal] 홍미영 / 2002 / An Analysis of the Effects of Quota Program for Employment of Female Public Servants in Korea / 지방과 행정연구 14(1) : 97~114

[journal] Andrews, R. / 2005 / Representative Bureaucracy, Organizational Strategy, and Public Service Performance: An Empirical Analysis of English Local Government / Journal of Public Administration and Theory 15(4) : 489~504

[book] Berger, P. L. / 1966 / The Social Construction of Reality: A Treatise in the Sociology of Knowledge / Anchor Books

[book] Brewer, J. / 1989 / Multimethod Research: A Synthesis of Styles / Sage

[journal] Brudney, J. L. / 2000 / From Organizational Value to Organizational Roles: Examining Representative Bureaucracy in State Administration / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 10(3) : 491~512

[book] Bryman, A. / 2002 / The Debate about Quantitative and Qualitative Research: A Question of Method or Epistemology?. in: Social Surveys / Sage

[book] Burr, V. / 1995 / An Introduction to Social Constructionism / Routledge

[book] Butler, J. / 1990 / Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity / Routledge

[journal] Cayer, N. J. / 1980 / Minorities and Women in State and Local Government: 1973-1975 / Public Administration Review 40 : 443~450

[book] Creswell, J. W. / 2007 / Designing and Conducting Mixed Methods Research / Sage

[book] Denzin, N. K. / 1989 / The Research Act: A Theoretical Introduction to Sociological Methods / McGraw-Hill

[journal] Dolan, J. / 2000 / The Senior Executive Service: Gender, Attitudes, and Representative Bureaucracy / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 10(3) : 513~529

[journal] Dolan, J. / 2002 / Representative Bureaucracy in the Federal Executive: Gender and Spending Priorities / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 12(3) : 353~375

[book] Dolan, J / 2003 / Preface and Theoretical Underpinnings: Why Does the Social Background of Public Administrations Matter?. in: Representative Bureaucracy: Classic Readings and Continuing Controversies / Sharpe

[journal] Fox, C. J. / 1987 / Bases in Public Policy Implementation Evaluation / Policy Studies Review 7(1) : 128~141

[book] Gergen, K. J. / 1985 / Social Constructionist Inquiry: Context and Implications. in: The Social Construction of the Person / Springer-Heidelberg

[book] Giddens, A. / 1979 / Central Problems in Social Theory: Action, Structure, and Contradiction in Social Analysis / University of California Press

[book] Guba, F. G. / 1998 / Competing Paradigms and Qualitative Research. in: The Landscape of Qualitative Research: Theories and Issues / Sage Publications

[journal] Hall, G. / 1977 / Equal Employment Opportunity for Minorities in Municipal Government / Social Science Quarterly 57 : 864~872

[journal] Hindera, J. J. / 1993 / Representative Bureaucracy: Imprimis Evidence of Active Representation in the EEOC District Offices / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 3(4) : 415~429

[journal] Hindera, J. J. / 1998 / Representative Bureaucracy: The Theoretical Implications of Statistical Interaction / Political Research Quarterly 51(3) : 655~671

[journal] Hopf, T. / 1998 / The Promise of Constructivism in International Relations Theory / International Security 23(1) : 171~200

[journal] Hozler, H. J. / 2000 / What Does Affirmative Action Do? / Industrial and Labor Relations Review 53(2) : 240~271

[journal] Keiser, L. R. / 2002 / Lipstick and Logarithms: Gender, Institutional Context, and Representative Bureaucracy / The American Political Science Review 96(3) : 553~564

[journal] Kellough, J. E. / 1990 / Integration in the Public Workplace: Determinants of Minority and Female Employment in Federal Agencies / Public Administration Review 50 : 557~566

[journal] Kelly, R. M. / 2001 / The Gendered Bureaucracy: Agency Mission, Equality of Opportunity, and Representative Bureaucracies / Women & Politics 22(3) : 1~34

[book] Kingsley, J. D. / 1944 / Representative Bureaucracy / Antioch Press

[journal] Koelble, T. A. / 1995 / The New Institutionalism in Political Science and Sociology / Comparative Politics 27 : 231~243

[book] Krantz, H. / 1976 / The Participatory Bureaucracy: Women and Minorities in a More Representative Public Service / Lexington Books

[book] Krislov, S. / 1981 / Representative Bureaucracy and the American Political System / Praeger

[journal] Laner, M. / 2000 / “Sex” versus “Gender”: A Revisited Plea / Sociological Inquiry 70(4) : 462~474

[thesis] Lee, Yong Wook / 2003 / The Japanese Challenge to the Neoclassical Economic Orthodoxy: Identity and Interest in Japans’ Policies Toward the East Asian Miracle and the Asian Monetary Fund / 박사 / University of Southern California

[journal] Lim, H. H. / 2006 / Representative Bureaucracy: Rethinking Substantive Effects and Active Representation / Public Administration Review 66(2) : 193~204

[book] Lipsky, M / 1978 / Toward a Theory of Street-Level Bureaucracy. in: American Politics and Public Policy / MIT Press

[journal] Lowi, T. J. / 1964 / American Business, Public Policy, Case-studies and Political Theory / World Politics 16 : 677~715

[book] Lukes, S. / 1992 / 3차원적 권력론 / 나남

[journal] Luton, L. S. / 2007 / Deconstructing Public Administration Empiricism / Administration & Society 39(4) : 527~544

[book] McNabb, D. E / 2002 / Research Methods in Public Administration and Nonprofit Management: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches / M. E. Sharpe

[journal] Meier, K. J / 1975 / Representative Bureaucracy: An Empirical Analysis / American Political Science Review 69(3) : 526~542

[book] Meier, K. J. / 1993 / Representative Bureaucracy: A Theoretical and Empirical Exposition. in: Research in Public Administration / JAI Press

[journal] Meier, K. J. / 2001 / Structure and Discretion: Missing Links in Representative Bureaucracy / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 11(4) : 455~470

[journal] Meier, K. J. / 1976 / Representative Bureaucracy and Policy Preference: A Study in the Attitudes of Federal Executives / Public Administration Review 36(4) : 458~469

[journal] Meier, K. J. / 2005 / Race, Sex and Clarence Thomas: Representation Change in the EEOC / Public Administration Review 65(2) : 171~179

[journal] Meier, K. J. / 1992 / Active Representation in Educational Bureaucracies: Policy Impacts / American Review of Public Administration 22 : 157~171

[journal] Meier, K. J. / 1999 / Representative Bureaucracy and Distributional Equity: Addressing the Hard Question / The Journal of Politics 61(4) : 1025~1039

[book] Mosher, F. C. / 1968 / Democracy and the Public Service / Oxford University Press

[journal] Nachmias, D. / 1973 / Measuring Bureaucratic Representation and Integration / Public Administration Review 33 : 590~597

[book] Naff, K. C. / 1998 / Representative Bureaucracy. in: International Encyclopedia of Public Policy and Administration / Westview Press : 1958~1960

[book] Patton, M. Q. / 1990 / Qualitative Evaluation and Research Methods / Sage

[book] Ragin, C. C. / 1991 / Introduction: The Problem of Balancing Discourse on Cases and Variables in Comparative Social Sciences. in: Issues and Alternatives in Comparative Social Research / E. J. Brill

[journal] Rehfuss, J. A. / 1986 / A Representative Bureaucracy? Woman and Minority Executives in California Career Service / Public Administration Review 45(5) : 454~470

[journal] Riccucci, N. M. / 2004 / Linking Passive and Active Representation: The Case of Frontline Workers in Welfare Agencies / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 14(4) : 585~597

[journal] Riccucci, N. M. / 1997 / The Representativeness of State-Level Bureaucratic Leaders: A Missing Piece of the Representative Bureaucracy Puzzle / Public Administration Review 57(5) : 423~430

[book] Ripley, R. B. / 1980 / Congress, the Bureaucracy, and Public Policy / Dorsey Press

[book] Ruggie, J. / 1998 / Constructing the World Polity: Essays on International Institutionalization / Routledge

[journal] Saidel, J. R. / 2005 / Agency Leaders, Gendered Institutions, and Representative Bureaucracy / Public Administration Review 65(2) : 158~170

[journal] Saltzstein, G. H. / 1979 / Representative Bureaucracy and Bureaucratic Responsibility: Problems and Prospects / Administration & Society 10 : 464~475

[book] Selden, S. C. / 1997 / The Promise of Representative Bureaucracy: Diversity and Responsiveness in a Government Agency / M. E. Sharpe

[journal] Selden, S. C. / 1998 / Bureaucracy as a Representative Institution: Toward a Reconciliation of Bureaucratic Government and Democratic Theory / American Journal of Political Science 42(3) : 719~744

[journal] Smith, R. / 1980 / Representative Bureaucracy: A Research Note on Demographic Representation in State Bureaucracies / Review of Public Personnel Administration 1 : 1~14

[journal] Snizek, W. / 1992 / Job Characteristics, Gender Stereotypes and Perceived Gender Discrimination in the Work Place / Organization Studies 13(3) : 403~427

[journal] Sowa, J. / 2003 / Administrative Discretion and Active Representation: An Expansion of the Theory of Representative Bureaucracy / Public Administration Review 63(6) : 700~710

[book] Stanley, L. / 2002 / Should ‘Sex’ Really Be ‘Gender’ or ‘Gender’ Really Be ‘Sex’. in: Gender: A Sociological Reader / Routledge

[book] Stanley, L. / 1990 / Feminist Praxis: Research, Theory and Epistemology in Feminist Sociology / Routledge

[book] Tashakkori, A. / 1998 / Mixed Methodology: Combining Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches / Sage

[journal] Thompson, F. J. / 1976 / Minority Groups in Public Bureaucracies: Are Passive and Active Representation Linked? / Administration & Society 8(2) : 201~226

[book] Truman, D. / 1971 / The Governmental Process / Alfred A. Knopf

[book] Waldo, D. / 1948 / The Administrative State: A Study of the Political Theory of American Public Administration / Ronald Press

[journal] Wendt, A. E. / 1987 / The Agent-Structure Problem in International Relations Theory / International Organization 49(4) : 489~721

[journal] Wendt, A. E. / 1992 / Anarchy is What States Make of It: The Social Construction of Power Politics / International Organization 46(2) : 391~425

[journal] Wendt, A. E. / 1994 / Collective Identity Formation and the International State / American Political Science Review 88(2) : 384~396

[book] West, C. / 2002 / Doing Gender. in: Gender: A Sociological Reader / Routledge

[journal] Wilkins, V. M. / 2006 / Exploring the Causal Story: Gender, Active Representation, and Bureaucratic Priorities / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 17 : 77~94

[book] Yin, R. K. / 1994 / The Qualitative-Quantitative Debate: New Perspectives / Jossey-Bass

[book] Yin, R. K. / 2003 / Case Study Research: Design and Methods / Sage Publications

[journal] Yishai, Y. / 1997 / (UN)Representative Bureaucracy / Administration & Society 28(4) : 441~465

[web] / 대한민국 정책포털 공감코리아 / www.korea.kr

[web] / 여성가족부 홈페이지 / www.mogef.go.kr

[web] / 중앙인사위원회 홈페이지 / www.csc.go.kr

[other] 기호일보 / 2005 / 무관요원, 여군･군무원･부사관까지 확대

[other] 아시아경제 / 2009 / 여대생 학군장교 2014년 도입 검토

[other] 조선일보 / 2007 / 서울교육청 ‘男교사 할당제’ 재추진

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korean Society and Public Administration 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.89