과학기술정책 형성과 결정에서 정당 정책이념의 역할에 관한 연구:사회적 구성주의 관점과 비교역사적 분석

LEE SEOG-MIN (이석민)

과학기술정책 형성과 결정에서 정당 정책이념의 역할에 관한 연구:사회적 구성주의 관점과 비교역사적 분석

Korean Society and Public Administration
Abbr : KSPA
2010, 20(4), pp.215-238
Publisher : Seoul Association For Public Administration
Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration

LEE SEOG-MIN ¹

¹서울대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

To date, there has been minimal research regarding the role of politics or “party policy ideas” in the study of policy determination and formation because most researchers have been depending on the positivism approach. For this reason, this paper employed the Social constructivism and comparative historical analysis. This article also aimed to analyze the role of the party policy ideas by dwelling upon the study of science and technology (S&T) policy in the United States and Germany. To be concrete, this study explored how the party policy ideas has an effect on the formation of party S&T policy, and how ruling party policy ideas influences government S&T policy determination. The result of this study suggested that party policy ideas played a certain role in the course of the formation of party’s S&T goals and strategies. Ruling party policy ideas, moreover, affected S&T policy determination of each country, and also accidental political, economic, and social factors in history made an impact on the success, weakening, and failure of the party policy ideas. As a result, the study recommends that political factors be included in studying the government S&T policy.

KEYWORDS

Party policy ideas, Social Constructivism, Science & Technology Policy

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[book] 강용호 / 2001 / 독일의 과학기술동향 / 주독한국대사관

[journal] 김득갑 / 2004 / 유럽 정권 교체기의 경제정책 / CEO Information 450

[journal] 김선혁 / 2004 / 비교정책학의 현재와 미래: 신제도주의, 사회적 구성주의, 신비교행정학을 중심으로 / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 13(3) : 259~278

[journal] 김성수 / 2002 / 동서독 혁신체제 통합의 10년 / 과학기술정책 134(12)

[book] 김태일 / 1995 / 한국정당정치연구의 과제와 방법. in: 한국정당정치론 / 나남

[journal] 류상영 / 2003 / The Korea-Japan Economic Relations and the Flying-Geese Model / 국제정치논총 / 한국국제정치학회 43(2) : 175~199

[book] 박흥기 / 2003 / 독일의 사회적 시장경제: 이론적 기초와 실제 / 한국비교경제학회

[thesis] 신기영 / 1995 / 통화정책에서의 정책이념과 제도에 관한 연구 / 석사 / 서울대학교

[journal] 신동민 / 2002 / 2002년 예산으로 본 독일 과학기술정책의 방향 / 과학기술정책 133(12)

[journal] 은재호 / 2009 / Policy ideas and policy changes in the French welfare State: A contextual analysis of an alternative model construction process / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 43(1) : 69~96

[journal] 이석민 / 2009 / Science & Technology Policy Types in National Innovation System.: a Comparative Case Study on the United States and Germany / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 18(3) : 159~186

[book] 이성덕 / 2006 / 미국 국가 R&D 시스템의 특성과 참여주체 / 한국산업기술재단

[journal] 이영범 / 2008 / Social Construction of Target Population and Policy Design: Focusing on the Selection Process of IPTV Service Provider / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 17(3) : 1~32

[journal] 임혜란 / 2005 / The U.S. Trade Policy in the Bush Administration: the Role of Ideas and Interests / 한국과 국제정치 / 극동문제연구소 21(2) : 93~123

[journal] 장용석 / 2008 / ACA, 미국 혁신정책 10개년 종합계획 / 과학기술정책 168(2)

[journal] 최영식 / 2001 / 조 지 W. 부 시 행 정 부 의 신 과 학 기 술 정 책 / 과학기술정책 129(11)

[journal] 황신준 / 2000 / 사회적 시장경제, 질서자유주의, 사회민주주의 / 국제경제연구 6(3) : 145~165

[book] 홍성욱 / 2004 / 현대 과학연구의 지형도.｢과학은 얼마나｣ / 서울대학교 출판부

[book] Averch, Harvey A. / 1985 / A Systematic Analysis of Science and Technology Policy / John Hopkins University Press

[book] Bentele, karlheinz / 1979 / Kartellbildung in der allgemeinen Forschungsförderung / Politikverflechtung Ⅲ

[other] Bloomberg / 2006 / Germany Should Rethink Nuclear Power Phaseout, Minister Says. January 10

[book] Blyth, Mark / 2002 / Great Transformation: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century / Cambridge University Press

[journal] Blyth, Mark / 2003 / Structures do not Come with an Instruction Sheet: Interest, Ideas and Progress in Political Science / Perspective on Politics 4 : 695~706

[journal] Branscomb, Lewis / 1992 / Does America Need a Technology Policy? / Harvard Business Review : 24~33

[book] Branscomb, Lewis M. / 1999 / Challenges to Technology Policy in a Changing World Economy. in: Investing in Innovation, Creating A Research and Innovation Policy That works / The MIT Press : 3~39

[other] / 1984 / Bundesministerium für Forschung und Technologie(BMFT). (1984). Bundesbericht Forschung 1984. Bonn

[other] / 1988 / Bundesministerium für Forschung und Technologie(BMFT). (1988). Bundesbericht Forschung 1988. Bonn

[book] Bush, Vannevar / 1945 / Science, The endless frontier Charter document for the U.S. National Science Foundation / Government Printing Office

[journal] Cantner, Uwe / 2001 / Classifying technology policy from an evolutionary perspective / Research Policy 20 : 759~775

[journal] Carroll, James D. / 1985 / Supply Side Management in the Reagan Administration / Public Administration Review 45 : 807~

[journal] Chiang, Jong-Tsong / 1991 / From ‘mission-oriented’ to ‘diffusion-oriented’ paradigm, the new trend of U.S. industrial technology policy / Technovation 11(6) : 339~356

[journal] Chung, Sunyang / 1997 / Technology policy between diversity and onve best practice - A comparisn of Korean and German promotion schemes for new production technologies / Technovation 17(11) : 675~693

[book] Clinton, William J. / 1993 / Technology for america’s economic growth, a new direction to build economic strength / The White House Office of The Press Secretary

[journal] Cox, Robert Henry / 2001 / The Social Construction of an Imperative: Why Welfare Reform Happened in Denmark and the Netherlands but Not in Germany / World Politics 53 : 463~498

[book] Elzinga, Aant / 1995 / Changing Policy Agendas in Science and Technology. in: Handbook of Science and Technology Studies / Sage

[book] Ergas,H. / 1987 / The Importance of Technology Policy. in: Economic Policy and Technological Performance / Cambridge Universicy Press

[journal] Geiger, Roger L. / 1997 / What Happened after sputnik? Shaping University Research in the United States / Minerva 35(4) : 349~367

[book] Goldstein, Judith / 1993 / Ideas & Foreign Policy:Beliefs, Institutions, and Political Change / Cornell University Press

[book] Goldstein, Judith / 1993 / Ideas, Interests, and American Trade Policy / Cornell University Press

[book] Hall, peter / 1986 / Governing the Economy / Oxford University press

[report] Hauknes, Johan / 1999 / Technological infrastructures and innovation policies

[book] Howell, Thomas / 1992 / Creating Advantage, Semiconductors and Government Industrial Policy in the 1990s / SIA

[book] Ingram, H. / 2007 / Social Construction and Policy Design. in: Theories of the Policy Process / Westview Press : 93~126

[journal] Kevles, Daniel J. / 1990 / Cold War and Hot Physics, Science. Security. and the American State. 1945-56 / Historical Studies in the Physical Science 20(2)

[book] Kleinman, Daniel L. / 1995 / Politics on the Endless Frontier, Postwar Research Policy in the United States / Duke University Press

[book] Lawson, kay / 1976 / The Comparative Study of Political Parties / St. Martin’s Press

[book] Lundvall, B. / 1992 / National Systems of Innovation / Pinter publisher

[journal] Mahoney, James / 2004 / Comparative-Historical Methodology / Annual Review of Sociology 30 : 81~101

[journal] Marshall, Eliot / 1993 / R&D Policy that Emphasizes the ‘D’ / Science 25926 : 1816~1819

[confproc] McCartney, Paul T. / 2006 / Partisan Worldviews and Foreign Policy in the Post-Cold War Era / American Political Science Association; 2006 Annual Meeting

[journal] Merkel, Angela Dorothea / 2006 / German Science Policy 2006 / Science 313 : 1~14

[book] Mowery, David C. / 1992 / Science and Technology Policy in Interdependent Economies / Kluwer Academic Publishers

[book] Nelson, R. / 1993 / Technical innovation and national systems. in: National Innovation Systems / Oxford University Press

[journal] Nexon, Daniel / 2005 / Zeitgeist? New Idealism in the Study of International Change / Review of International Political Economy 12(4) : 700~719

[book] Porter, Michael E. / 1990 / The Competitive Advantage of Nations / The Free Press

[journal] Prange, Heiko / 2003 / Rethinking the impact of globalisation on the nation-state: the case of science and technology policies in Germany / German Politics 12(1) : 23~42

[journal] Press, Frank / 1981 / Science and Technology in the White House, 1977 to 1980: Part Ⅰ / Science 9 : 139~145

[book] Schavan, Annette / 2005 / Wir sind noch keine bildungshungrige Gesellschaft / General Anzeiger : 12~27

[journal] Shariff, Naubahar / 2006 / Emergence and Development of National Innovation Systems Concept / Research Policy 35 : 745~766

[book] Smith, Bruce L. R. / 1977 / The State of Academic Science: The Universities in the Nation’s Research Effort : Summary of Major Findings / Change Magazine Press

[book] Smith, Bruce L. R. / 1990 / American science policy since World War II / Brookings Institution

[book] Stoneman, Paul / 1987 / The Economics Analysis of Technology Policy / Clarendon Press

[report] Teich, Albert H. / 1988 / AAAS Report ⅫⅠ. Research and Development FY 1988 / American Association for the Advancement of Science

[journal] Ware, Alan / 1996 / Political Parties and Party System / Oxford University Press

[journal] Widmaier, Wesley W. / 2003 / Constructing Monetary Crises : New Keynesian Understanding and Monetary Cooperation in the 1990s / Review of International Studies 29(19) : 61~77

[book] Wollmann, Hellmut / 1989 / Entwicklungslinien Der Technologiepolitik In Deutschland. in: Bestimmungs faktoren, Zielsetzungen Und Politische Zustandigekeiten Im Wandel / Dezentrale Technologiepolitik

[journal] Zacher, Hans F. / 1982 / Social Market Economy, Social Policy and the Law / Zeitschrift Für Gesamte Staatwissenschaft. Band 138 : 367~388

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korean Society and Public Administration 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.89