The Effect of Sejong City Relocation on the Quality of Policy-making (행정기관의 세종시 이전이 정책결정의 질에 미치는 효과)

Kim, Chan-woo (김찬우); Ha, Hyue-Su (하혜수)

The Effect of Sejong City Relocation on the Quality of Policy-making

Korean Society and Public Administration
Abbr : KSPA
2019, 30(2), pp.137-163
Publisher : Seoul Association For Public Administration
Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration
Published : August 31, 2019

Kim, Chan-woo ¹, Ha, Hyue-Su ²

¹서울대학교행정대학원
²경북대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

The purpose of this study is to analyze the effect of central government 's transfering into Sejong City on the quality of policy decisions. The effects were measured based on the three theories (geographical proximity, decision making under time pressure, and group discussion) presented in previous studies. For this purpose, we used the survey results of 254 public officials in 10 central government departments. Using DID analysis We found two major results. First, the opportunities for face-to-face contact and the reduction of group discussion opportunities have had a negative impact on the quality of policy decisions. Second, the effect of relocation of Sejong city was different according to the rank, the work personality and residence. Therefore, in the future policy, it is necessary to prepare an alternative considering the position and the work personality with increasing the opportunity of face-to-face contact and group discussion.

KEYWORDS

Sejong City Relocation, Central Government, Policy Making Process

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[confproc] 김귀영 / 2006 / 조직루틴관점에서 본 팀제도입에 관한 연구 / 한국행정학회 학술발표논문집 : 219~235

[journal] 김동욱 / 2010 / A Study on Information Sharing in Korea: Focused on the CCL(Creative Commons License) / 한국지역정보화학회지 / 한국지역정보화학회 13(4) : 53~74

[journal] 김동원 / 2013 / An Authority Distribution Model between President and Prime Minister / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 22(3) : 315~345

[journal] 김상봉 / 2006 / A Study on the Strategic and Development direction of the New Multi-functional Administrative City / 한국지방자치학회보 / 한국지방자치학회 18(2) : 49~66

[journal] 김원동 / 2006 / 노무현 정부의 공공기관 이전 정책 / 사회과학연구 45(1) : 139~172

[report] 김찬동 / 2005 / 거버넌스 효율성을 위한 정치행정시스템: 국정운영조정과 정책조정 사례를 중심으로 / 한국행정학회

[confproc] 김찬동 / 2005 / 행정중심복합도시와 국정효율성 확보방안 / 서울행정학회 학술대회 발표논문집 : 65~102

[thesis] 김찬우 / 2019 / 세종시 이전에 따른 중앙부처 공무원의 대응방식 변화연구 / Doctoral / 서울대학교 대학원

[journal] 나태준 / 2005 / Above and Beyond the Multifunctional Administrative City Construction / 사회과학논집 / 사회과학연구소 35 : 43~67

[journal] 류기철 / 2009 / 세종시 수정론, 어떻게 볼 것인가? / 사회과학연구 26(2) : 73~88

[journal] 류현숙 / 2013 / An Empirical Study on the issues and concerns associated with the diversification of government ministers in Sejong city. / 현대사회와 행정 / 한국국정관리학회 23(3) : 203~224

[journal] 박재희 / 1996 / 정부기능 효율화를 위한 제 3 섹터 활용방안 / 기본연구과제 1996 : 1~191

[journal] 안선민 / 2017 / The Effects of the Relocation of Central Government Bodies to Sejong City on Government Officials’ Job Satisfaction: Focusing on Moderating Effect of Participative Decision Making / 한국행정논집 / 한국정부학회 29(2) : 297~324

[journal] 안선민 / 2017 / An Analysis of the Effects of Hierarchical Culture on the Use of ICT: A Study of Central Government Relocated to Sejong City / 한국거버넌스학회보 / 한국거버넌스학회 24(1) : 65~97

[book] 양현모 / 2007 / 한반도 평화, 번영을 위한 로컬 거버넌스 활성화 방안: 지방자치단체 남북 교류를 중심으로 / T'ongil Yŏn'guwŏn

[confproc] 양현모 / 2010 / 독일 통일과 연방정부의 분할-‘세종시’건설에 대한 시사점을 중심으로 / 한독사회과학회 국제학술대회 : 1~30

[book] 오석홍 / 2002 / 한국의 행정 / 법문사

[confproc] 이원호 / 2004 / 인문지리 1-경제, 교통, 지역개발 분야] 지역간 실업격차와 빈곤형성에 관한 연구 / 대한지리학회 학술대회논문집 : 69~69

[book] 이종수 / 2005 / 새행정학 / 대영출판사

[journal] 임병호 / 2008 / A Simulated Evaluation on City's Competitiveness through Survey with Experts / 국토계획 / 대한국토·도시계획학회 43(3) : 55~69

[journal] 임병호 / 2009 / Analyze of a Consciousness of Government Official According to The Relocation of Public Organization to Provinces / 국토지리학회지 / 국토지리학회 43(3) : 325~337

[journal] 임형백 / 2011 / A Critical Consideration of Multifunctional Administrative City and Suggestions / 한국정책연구 / 경인행정학회 11(3) : 235~257

[confproc] 장시영 / 2003 / 정부청사입지와 대전 서구의 사회. 경제적 변화 / 대한지리학회 학술대회논문집 : 125~128

[confproc] 전영평 / 2005 / 행정중심도시와 국정관리의 효율성 / 한국행정학회 Conference 자료 : 9~23

[journal] 전영평 / 2010 / A Critical Review on Sejong City Project in the Context of Administrative Governance System / 사회과학연구 / 사회과학연구원 17(1) : 75~95

[confproc] 조경호 / 2010 / R & D 정부조직의 문화와 공무원의 조직몰입 / 한국행정학회 학술발표논문집 : 1636~1652

[journal] 조명래 / 2010 / 행정중심복합도시 촉진방안 / 열린충남 52 : 8~26

[journal] 채원호 / 2005 / Evaluating the Relative Effectiveness of Capital Relocation Models / 지방정부연구 / 한국지방정부학회 9(2) : 159~178

[confproc] 최용환 / 2011 / 세종시의 국정효율성 확보방안 / 학술세미나 : 11~35

[journal] 최진혁 / 2015 / Development Challenges of Sejong Metropolitan Autonomous City due to the Decentralization and Balanced Regional Development: Focus on the Relocation of Government Ministries and Agencies / 사회과학연구 / 사회과학연구소 26(4) : 143~170

[confproc] 하혜수 / 2010 / 세종시 수정안의 성립불가성: 논거와 해법 / 한국정책학회 기획세미나 2010(1) : 1~14

[journal] 하혜수 / 2018 / The Effect of Geographic Dispersion on Decision Quality : The Case of Sejong City / 지방행정연구 / (재) 한국지방행정연구원 32(2) : 91~118

[report] 한국능률협회 / 2012 / 세종시 이전에 따른 행정효율성 진단 및 지원방안 연구

[report] 한국행정연구원 / 2017 / 중앙부처 세종시 이전 이후 정책결정과정 실태조사

[journal] 한인영 / 2008 / National Survey on Experience of School Violence at Elementary School：Retrospective Reports by Adults / 아동학회지 / 한국아동학회 29(1) : 155~167

[confproc] 허준영 / 2013 / 세종시 행정효율성 강화방안 모색을 위한 독일사례 연구 / 한국지방정부학회 학술대회 논문집 : 1~18

[journal] 허준영 / 2015 / Administrative Inefficiency of Geographically Dispersed Central Government Bodies: Case study on Sejong-City in Korea Using Grounded Theory / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 49(3) : 127~159

[journal] 허준영 / 2015 / A Study on Perceptual Discrepancies Due to the Relocation of Government Complex: Comparing Perceptions of Public Managers in Sejong City and those in Seoul City / 한국사회와 행정연구 / 서울행정학회 26(2) : 115~139

[journal] Ahituv, N. / 1998 / The effects of time pressure and completeness of information on decision making / Journal of management information systems 15(2) : 153~172

[book] Allen, T. / 2007 / The organization and architecture of innovation / Routledge

[journal] Audretsch, D. B. / 1996 / R&D spillovers and the geography of innovation and production / The American economic review 86(3) : 630~640

[journal] Baik, B. / 2010 / Local institutional investors, information asymmetries, and equity returns / Journal of financial economics 97(1) : 81~106

[journal] Baron, R. S. / 1976 / Reaffirmation of social comparison views of choice shifts: Averaging and extremity effects in an autokinetic situation / Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 33(5) : 521~

[journal] Bishop, G. D. / 1974 / Informational influence in group discussion / Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 12(1) : 92~104

[journal] Bodnaruk, A. / 2009 / Proximity always matters: Local bias when the set of local companies changes / Review of finance 13(4) : 629~656

[book] Brown, R. / 1974 / Further comment on the risky shift

[book] Burnstein, E. / 1982 / Contemporary Problems in Group Decision-making / Academic Press

[journal] Busemeyer, J. R. / 2002 / Survey of decision field theory / Mathematical Social Sciences 43(3) : 345~370

[journal] Busemeyer, J. R. / 1993 / Decision field theory: a dynamic-cognitive approach to decision making in an uncertain environment / Psychological review 100(3) : 432~

[journal] Busemeyer, J. R. / 1985 / Decision making under uncertainty: a comparison of simple scalability, fixed-sample, and sequential-sampling models / Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition 11(3) : 538~

[journal] Christersson, M. / 2012 / Impacts of organizational relocation: a conceptual framework / Journal of Corporate Real Estate 14(4) : 226~243

[journal] DeFond, M. L. / 2011 / The geography of SEC enforcement and auditor reporting for financially distressed clients / SSRN

[journal] Diederich, A. / 2003 / Simple matrix methods for analyzing diffusion models of choice probability, choice response time, and simple response time / Journal of Mathematical Psychology 47(3) : 304~322

[journal] Diederich, A. / 1997 / Dynamic stochastic models for decision making under time constraints / Journal of Mathematical Psychology 41(3) : 260~274

[journal] Egidi, M. / 1997 / The emergence of path-dependent behaviors in cooperative contexts / International Journal of Industrial Organization 15(6) : 677~709

[journal] Feldman, D. C. / 1998 / Moving on out: When are employees willing to follow their organization during corporate relocation? / Journal of Organizational Behavior: The International Journal of Industrial, Occupational and Organizational Psychology and Behavior 19(3) : 275~288

[journal] Gaylord, M. / 1986 / Relocation stress: A definition and a need for services / Employee Assistance Quarterly 2(1) : 31~36

[journal] Greitemeyer, T. / 2003 / Preference-consistent evaluation of information in the hidden profile paradigm: Beyond group-level explanations for the dominance of shared information in group decisions / Journal of personality and social psychology 84(2) : 322~

[journal] Heath, C. / 1995 / Interaction with others increases decision confidence but not decision quality: Evidence against information collection views of interactive decision making / Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes 61(3) : 305~326

[journal] Hwang, M. I. / 1999 / Information dimension, information overload and decision quality / Journal of information science 25(3) : 213~218

[journal] Iselin, E. R. / 1988 / The effects of information load and information diversity on decision quality in astructured decision task / Accounting, organizations and Society 13(2) : 147~164

[journal] Ivković, Z. / 2005 / Local does as local is: Information content of the geography of individual investors' common stock investments / The Journal of Finance 60(1) : 267~306

[book] Janis, I. L. / 1977 / Decision making: A psychological analysis of conflict, choice, and commitment / free press

[journal] Kahn, K. B. / 1997 / An empirical study of the relationships among co‐location, integration, performance, and satisfaction / Journal of Product Innovation Management 14(3) : 161~178

[journal] Kedia, S. / 2011 / Do the SEC's enforcement preferences affect corporate misconduct? / Journal of Accounting and Economics 51(3) : 259~278

[journal] Keinan, G. / 1987 / Decision making under stress: Scanning of alternatives under physical threat / Acta Psychologica 64(3) : 219~228

[journal] Knoben, J. / 2006 / Proximity and inter‐organizational collaboration: A literature review / International Journal of Management Reviews 8(2) : 71~89

[journal] Kocher, M. G. / 2006 / Time is money—Time pressure, incentives, and the quality of decision-making / Journal of Economic Behavior & Organization 61(3) : 375~392

[journal] Kruglanski, A. W. / 1983 / The freezing and unfreezing of lay-inferences: Effects on impressional primacy, ethnic stereotyping, and numerical anchoring / Journal of experimental social psychology 19(5) : 448~468

[journal] Laursen, K. / 2011 / Exploring the effect of geographical proximity and university quality on university–industry collaboration in the United Kingdom / Regional studies 45(4) : 507~523

[journal] Lawson, M. B. / 1994 / When organizational relocation means family relocation: An emerging issue for strategic human resource management / Human Resource Management 33(1) : 33~54

[journal] Malloy, C. J. / 2005 / The geography of equity analysis / The Journal of Finance 60(2) : 719~755

[book] Maule, A. J. / 1993 / State, stress, and time pressure. In Time pressure and stress in human judgment and decision making / Springer : 83~101

[journal] Mullen, B. / 1994 / Group cohesiveness and quality of decision making: An integration of tests of the groupthink hypothesis / Small Group Research 25(2) : 189~204

[journal] Noe, R. A. / 1993 / Willingness to accept mobility opportunities: Destination makes a difference / Journal of Organizational Behavior 14(2) : 159~175

[journal] Raghunathan, S. / 1999 / Impact of information quality and decision-maker quality on decision quality: a theoretical model and simulation analysis / Decision Support Systems 26(4) : 275~286

[journal] Schulz-Hardt, S. / 2006 / Group decision making in hidden profile situations: dissent as a facilitator for decision quality / Journal of personality and social psychology 91(6) : 1080~

[journal] Shaw, A. T. / 2000 / On the analytical dimension of proximity dynamics / Regional studies 34(2) : 169~180

[journal] Shields, M. D. / 1983 / Effects of information supply and demand on judgment accuracy: evidence from corporate managers / Accounting Review : 284~303

[journal] Smith, J. F. / 1982 / A cost-benefit mechanism for selecting problem-solving strategies: Some extensions and empirical tests / Organizational Behavior and Human Performance 29(3) : 370~396

[journal] Stasser, G. / 1988 / Computer simulation as a research tool: The DISCUSS model of group decision making / Journal of experimental social psychology 24(5) : 393~422

[journal] Sutter, M. / 2003 / Bargaining under time pressure in an experimental ultimatum game / Economics Letters 81(3) : 341~347

[journal] Svenson, O. / 1990 / Choices and judgments of incompletely described decision alternatives under time pressure / Acta Psychologica 75(2) : 153~169

[journal] Woodworth, R. S. / 1899 / Accuracy of voluntary movement / The Psychological Review: Monograph Supplements 3(3) : i~

[journal] Young, D. L. / 2012 / Decision making under time pressure, modeled in a prospect theory framework / Organizational behavior and human decision processes 118(2) : 179~188

[journal] Zakay, D. / 1985 / Post-decisional confidence and conflict experienced in a choice process / Acta Psychologica

[journal] Zur, H. B. / 1981 / The effect of time pressure on risky choice behavior / Acta Psychologica 47(2) : 89~104

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korean Society and Public Administration 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.89