Meritocracy in the awarding of research grants? Evidence from Social Science Korea

Jong-Kil Kim (김종길); Kim, Keuntae (김근태)

Meritocracy in the awarding of research grants? Evidence from Social Science Korea

Korean Social Science Journal
Abbr : KSSJ
2016, 43(1), pp.1~13
Publisher : Korean Social Science Research Council
Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
Published : June 1, 2016

Jong-Kil Kim ¹, Kim, Keuntae ¹

¹덕성여자대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

In 2010, the Korean government launched a new funding scheme for social scientists, Social Science Korea (SSK). Contrary to conventional grant programs, the SSK adopted a competition scheme among research teams by eliminating those who failed to pass annual evaluations, while, at the same time, emphasizing cooperation and interdisciplinary research. Substantial research has documented the determinants of receiving research grants in Western countries, but little is known about how these determinants operate in Korean academia. Using results from the stage evaluations of the SSK, we estimate logistic regression models. The results indicate that factors of meritocracy, such as publication record, strongly affect the likelihood of success, but so do political factors, such as a PI obtaining his or her doctoral degree from a foreign institution. The importance of a PI’s gender and age, and of being located in Seoul, is not supported by the data.

KEYWORDS

Social Science Korea, Meritocracy, Universalism, Particularism, Accumulative advantage

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] Bazeley, P. / 1998 / Peer review and panel decisions in the assessment of Australian Research Council project grant applicants: what counts in a highly competitive context? / Higher Education 35(4) : 435~452

[journal] Burris, V. / 2004 / The academic caste system: Prestige hierarchies in PhD exchange networks / American Sociological Review 69(2) : 239~264

[journal] 천영돈 / 2013 / A Study of Factors Influencing the Costs of Funding as a Function of Research Area and Financial Institutions / 품질경영학회지 / 한국품질경영학회 41(1) : 163~180

[journal] 조혜선 / 2007 / The Matthew Effect:Accumulative Advantage among Korean Scientists / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 41(6) : 112~141

[book] Cole, J. R. / 1973 / Social stratification in science / University of Chicago Press

[book] Cole, S. / 1978 / Peer review in the National Science Foundation: Phase one of a study: Prepared for the Committee on Science and Public Policy of the National Academy of Sciences (Vol. 2788) / National Academies

[journal] DiPrete, T. A. / 2006 / Cumulative advantage as a mechanism for inequality : A review of theoretical and empirical developments / Annual Review of Sociology 32(1) : 271~297

[journal] Ginther, D. K. / 2011 / Race, ethnicity, and NIH research awards / Science 333(6045) : 1015~1019

[journal] Horrobin, D. F. / 1996 / Peer review of grant applications: A harbinger for mediocrity in clinical research? / Lancet 348(9037) : 1293~1295

[journal] 장덕희 / 2009 / Comparison of Research Funding Scale and Research Performance Between Male and Female Researchers / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 18(3) : 97~124

[journal] Kim, K. / 2015 / Trends in determinants of entry into the academic career: The case of South Korea, 1980–2010 / PLoS ONE 10(10) : e0141428~

[journal] Keuntae Kim / 2016 / Inequality in the scientific community: the effects of cumulative advantage among social scientists and humanities scholars in Korea / Higher Education / Springer Nature 73(1) : 61~77

[journal] Konrad, A. M. / 1990 / Do you get what you deserve? Factors affecting the relationship between productivity and pay / Administrative Science Quarterly 35(2) : 258~285

[journal] 권해수 / 2009 / A Study on Structural Crisis of the Public Administration Education for Academic Future Generations in Korea / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 43(1) : 299~320

[journal] Laudel, G. / 2006 / The ‘‘quality myth’’ : Promoting and hindering conditions for acquiring research funds / Higher Education 52(3) : 375~403

[journal] 이준석 / 2013 / Academic Caste System in Public Administration? Academic Stratification by Network of Prestige in Korea / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 47(1) : 321~349

[journal] Long, J. S. / 1995 / Scientific careers : Universalism and particularism / Annual Review of Sociology 21 : 45~71

[journal] Masso, J. / 2009 / Competition for public project funding in a small research system : The case of Estonia / Science and Public Policy 36(9) : 683~695

[journal] Merton, R. K. / 1968 / The Matthew Effect in science : The reward and communication systems of science are considered / Science 159(3810) : 56~63

[book] Merton, R. K. / 1973 / The normative structure of science. In The sociology of science / University of Chicago Press : 267~278

[other] Ministry of Education, Science and Technology / 2011 / Social science research support project implementation plan / Ministry of Education, Science and Technology

[journal] Mitroff, I. I. / 1979 / Peer review at the NSF : A dialectical policy analysis / Social Studies of Science 9(2) : 199~232

[book] OECD. / 2014 / OECD science, technology and industry outlook 2014 / OECD Publishing

[journal] Park, C. / 2007 / Gender in academic career tracks : The case of Korean biochemists / Sociological Forum 22(4) : 452~473

[journal] Pohlhaus, J. R. / 2011 / Sex differences in application, success, and funding rates for NIH extramural programs / Academic Medicine 86(6) : 759~767

[journal] Shin, J. C. / 2012 / Higher education development in Korea : Western university ideas, Confucian tradition, and economic development / Higher Education 64(1) : 59~72

[book] Shin, J. C. / 2013 / Institutionalization of world-class university in global competition Vol. 6 / Springer : 147~163

[journal] van Arensbergen, P. / 2012 / The selection of scientific talent in the allocation of research grants / Higher Education Policy 25(3) : 381~405

[journal] Viner, N. / 2004 / Institutionalized biases in the award of research grants : A preliminary analysis revisiting the principle of accumulative advantage / Research Policy 33(3) : 443~454

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korean Social Science Journal 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.06