Modern English Education 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.55
-
pISSN : 1598-0782 / eISSN : 2586-6141
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/meeso
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Teacher views on writing feedback: experience, belief and practice
- Modern English Education
- Abbr : MEESO
- 2018, 19(1), pp.49-61
- DOI : 10.18095/meeso.2018.19.1.05
- Publisher : The Modern English Education Society
- Research Area : Humanities > English Language and Literature > English Language Teaching
- Published : February 28, 2018
심주연 1, JAEYEON HEO 2
1한신대학교
2고려대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This study examined how Korean writing teachers view their writing feedback practice, focusing primarily on writing teachers’ perceptions, experiences, and perceived difficulties regarding writing feedback process. The sixteen-week study employed a narrative case study involving writing teachers’ in-depth interviews, their reflective journal diary, and students’ writing drafts. Overall, the findings showed that teachers perceived their writing feedback process as interactive communication tools, which helped them have a clearer picture of students’ needs, levels, and capabilities. In addition, writing feedback practice enabled teachers to gain pedagogical learning by reflecting their feedback process, and eventually leading to shaping further feedback practice. The interview data also pointed to teachers’ concerns and difficulties arisen from their feedback process: (i) frustration with students’ same errors; (ii) inactive participation of low-level students in feedback process; and (iii) dilemma between a feedback giver and a grader. This study suggested the need for further work in order to maximize reciprocal benefits to teachers and students through writing feedback process. To achieve this, representative samples and various data collection methods are recommended to listen to more teachers’ voices and yield deeper insight into writing teachers’ feedback process.
Statistics
-
333 Viewed
-
64 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
Basturkmen, H.
/ 2004
/ Teachers’stated beliefs about incidental focus on form and their classroom practices
/ Applied Linguistics
25(2)
: 243~272
[journal]
Bitchener, J.
/ 2005
/ The effect of different types of corrective feedback on ESL student writing
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
14(3)
: 191~205
[book]
Black, P.
/ 2003
/ Assessment for learning : Putting it into practice
/ Open University Press
[journal]
Borg, S.
/ 2003
/ Teacher cognition in language teaching : A review of research on what language teachers think, know, believe, and do
/ Language Teaching
36(2)
: 81~109
[journal]
Borg, S.
/ 2004
/ The apprenticeship of observation
/ ELT Journal
58(3)
: 274~276
[journal]
Burns, A.
/ 1992
/ Teacher beliefs and their influence on classroom practice
/ Prospect
7(3)
: 56~66
[journal]
Carless, D.
/ 2006
/ Differing perceptions in the feedback process
/ Studies in Higher Education
31(2)
: 219~233
[journal]
조수경
/ 2015
/
Writing Teacher Views on Teacher Feedback: A Shift from Grammar Corrector to Motivator
/ Journal of Asia TEFL
/ 아시아테플
12(3)
: 33~59
[book]
Clark, C. M.
/ 1986
/ Handbook of research on teaching
/ Macmillan
: 255~296
[journal]
Connelly, F. M.
/ 1990
/ Stories of experience and narrative inquiry
/ American Educational Research Association
19(5)
: 2~14
[thesis]
Corpuz, V. F.
/ 2011
/ Error correction in second language writing: Teachers’ beliefs, practices and students’ preferences
/ Master’s
/ Queensland University of Technology
[journal]
Darling, S.
/ 2003
/ Using self-assessment in early intervention training
/ Journal of Early Intervention
25(3)
: 219~227
[book]
Dörnyei, Z.
/ 2007
/ Research methods in applied linguistics
/ Oxford University Press
[journal]
Eckstein, G.
/ 2013
/ Implementing and evaluating a writing conference program for international L2 writers across language proficiency levels
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
22(3)
: 231~239
[journal]
Ellis, R.
/ 2008
/ The effects of focused and unfocused written corrective feedback in an English as a foreign language context
/ System
36(3)
: 353~371
[book]
Ferris, D. R.
/ 2003
/ Response to student writing: Implications for second language students
/ Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
[journal]
Ferris, D.
/ 2014
/ Responding to student writing : Teachers’philosophies and practices
/ Assessing Writing
19(1)
: 6~23
[book]
Ferris, D.
/ 2004
/ Teaching ESL composition:Purpose, process, and practice
/ Taylor & Francis, Inc
[journal]
Ferris, D. R.
/ 2013
/ Written corrective feedback for individual L2 writers
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
22(3)
: 307~329
[book]
Gass, S.
/ 2000
/ Stimulated Recall Methodology in Second Language Research
/ Lawrence Erlbaum Associates
[journal]
Goldstein, L.
/ 2004
/ Questions and answers about teacher written commentary and student revision : Teachers and students working together
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
13(1)
: 63~80
[journal]
Goldstein, L.
/ 1990
/ Student input and negotiation of meaning in ESL writing conferences
/ TESOL Quarterly
24(3)
: 443~460
[book]
Grabe, W.
/ 1996
/ Theory and practice of writing
/ Addison Wesley Longman
[book]
Hairston, M.
/ 1986
/ Training the new teacher of college composition
/ NCTE
: 117~124
[journal]
Hawe, E.
/ 2008
/ Oral feedback in the context of written language
/ Australian Journal of Language and Literacy
31(1)
: 43~58
[journal]
허재연
/ 2015
/
Korean Students’ Perspectives on L2 Writing Difficulty, Needs, and Challenges
/ Studies in English Education
/ 글로벌영어교육학회
20(2)
: 161~188
[book]
Hilgers, T. L.
/ 2000
/ Self-assessment and development in writing: A collaborative inquiry
/ Hampton Press
: 1~24
[journal]
Hyland, F.
/ 1998
/ The impact of teacher written feedback on individual writers
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
7(3)
: 255~286
[journal]
Hyland, K.
/ 2003
/ Genre-based pedagogies : A social response to process
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
12(1)
: 17~29
[book]
Hyland, K.
/ 2006
/ Feedback in second language writing
/ Cambridge University Press
: 206~224
[thesis]
Iguchi, M.
/ 2011
/ Integration, identity and beyond: A narrative case study of two Japanese women living in Britain
/ doctoral
/ Warwick University
[book]
Ivanic, R.
/ 1998
/ Writing and identity: The discoursal construction of identity in academic writing
/ John Benjamins
[journal]
Jean, G.
/ 2011
/ Grammar learning in English and French L2 : Students’ and teachers’ beliefs and perceptions
/ Foreign Language Annals
44(4)
: 465~492
[book]
Johnson, K. E.
/ 2002
/ Teachers’ narrative inquiry as professional development
/ Cambridge University Press
: 1~14
[book]
Jovchelovitch, S.
/ 2000
/ Qualitative researching with text, image and sound: A practical handbook
/ Sage
: 57~74
[journal]
Keh, C. L.
/ 1990
/ Feedback in the writing process : A model and methods for implementation
/ ELT Journal
44(4)
: 294~304
[journal]
김미경
/ 2003
/
Lessons Learned from Twelve Korean Teachers of College-level EFL Writing
/ 영어학
/ 한국영어학회
3(2)
: 181~210
[journal]
Kim, Tae-Young
/ 2008
/ Korean L2 writers’ previous writing experience: L1 literacy development in school
/ Second Language Studies
27(1)
: 103~154
[book]
Kvale, S.
/ 2009
/ Interviews: Learning the craft of qualitative research interviewing
/ Sage
[journal]
Lasagabaster, D.
/ 2005
/ Error correction:Students’ vs. teachers’ perceptions
/ Language awareness
14(2)
: 112~127
[book]
Lave, J.
/ 1991
/ Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Lee, I.
/ 2003
/ L2 writing teachers’ perspectives, practices and problems regarding error feedback
/ Assessing Writing
8(3)
: 216~237
[journal]
Lee, I.
/ 2005
/ Error correction in the L2 writing classroom:What do students think?
/ TESL Canada Journal
22(2)
: 1~16
[journal]
Lee, I.
/ 2008
/ Understanding teachers’ written feedback practices in Hong Kong secondary classrooms
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
17(2)
: 69~85
[journal]
Lee, I.
/ 2009
/ A new look at an old problem: How teachers can liberate themselves from the drudgery of marking student writing
/ Prospect: An Australian Journal of Teaching/Teachers of English to Speakers of Other Languages (TESOL)
24(2)
: 34~41
[journal]
Lee, I.
/ 2010
/ Writing teacher education and teacher learning: Testimonies of four EFL teachers
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
19(3)
: 143~157
[journal]
Lee, H. H.
/ 2016
/ Investigating teacher perceptions of feedback
/ ELT Journal
71(1)
: 60~68
[journal]
Leki, I.
/ 1991
/ The preferences of ESL students for error correction in college-level writing classes
/ Foreign Language Annals
24(3)
: 203~218
[journal]
Li, J.
/ 2011
/ Academic tutors’ beliefs about and practices of giving feedback on students’written assignments : A New Zealand case study
/ Assessing Writing
16(2)
: 137~148
[journal]
Montgomery, J. L.
/ 2007
/ Teacher-written feedback : Student perceptions, teacher self-assessment, and actual teacher performance
/ Journal of Second Language Writing
16(2)
: 82~99
[journal]
Mori, R.
/ 2011
/ Teacher cognition in corrective feedback in Japan
/ System
39(4)
: 451~467
[book]
Murry, G.
/ 2009
/ Qualitative research in applied linguistic
/ Palgrave Macmillan
: 45~65
[journal]
Nicole, D.
/ 2010
/ From monologue to dialogue : Improving written feedback processes in mass higher education
/ Assessment and Evaluation in Higher Education
35(5)
: 501~517
[journal]
Nicol, D.
/ 2006
/ Formative assessment and self-regulated learning : A model and seven principles of good feedback practice
/ Studies in Higher Education
31(2)
: 199~218
[journal]
박영예
/ 2015
/
An analysis of types and characteristics of feedback in elementary school English teachers’ talk.
/ 현대영어교육
/ 현대영어교육학회
16(1)
: 153~173
[book]
Patton, M. Q.
/ 1987
/ How to use qualitative methods in evaluation
/ SAGE Publications
[book]
Patton, M. Q.
/ 2002
/ Qualitative research and evaluation methods
/ Sage
[book]
Richards, J. C.
/ 2005
/ Professional development for language teachers: Strategies for teacher learning
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Sadler, D. R.
/ 1983
/ Evaluation and the improvement of academic learning
/ Journal of Higher Education
54(1)
: 60~79
[journal]
Sadler, D. R.
/ 1989
/ Formative assessment and the design of instructional systems
/ Instructional Science
18(2)
: 119~144
[journal]
Shulman, L. S.
/ 2004
/ How and what teachers learn : A shifting perspective
/ Journal of Curriculum Studies
36(2)
: 257~271
[journal]
심주연
/ 2015
/
The continuing professional development of Korean English teachers: An in-depth look at longer-term impact
/ 영어교육연구
/ 팬코리아영어교육학회
27(1)
: 69~90
[journal]
심주연
/ 2014
/
Writing Feedback: The Benefits of Conferences
/ 영어어문교육
/ 한국영어어문교육학회
20(3)
: 165~189
[book]
Strauss, A.
/ 1990
/ Basic of qualitative research:Ground theory procedures and techniques
/ Sage
[journal]
Truscott, J.
/ 1996
/ The case against grammar correction in L2 writing classes
/ Language Learning
46(2)
: 327~369
[book]
Weissberg, R.
/ 2006
/ Feedback in second language writing
/ Cambridge University Press
: 246~265
[journal]
Wold, L. S.
/ 2003
/ An examination of teachers’"learning to act on reflection"
/ Literacy Research and Instruction
42(3)
: 52~74
[journal]
Zamel, V.
/ 1985
/ Responding to student writing
/ TESOL Quarterly
19(1)
: 79~101
[journal]
양태선
/ 2010
/
Effects of Ongoing Feedback on Students’ Attitudes towards Writing
/ 영어어문교육
/ 한국영어어문교육학회
16(1)
: 171~188
[journal]
Young, P.
/ 2000
/ ‘I might as well give up’: Self-esteem and mature students’ feelings about feedback on assignments
/ Journal of Further and Higher Education
24(3)
: 409~418