Modern English Education 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.55
-
pISSN : 1598-0782 / eISSN : 2586-6141
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/meeso
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Meta-Analysis of the Effects of Storytelling on English Language Learning
- Modern English Education
- Abbr : MEESO
- 2022, 23(2), pp.33-51
- DOI : 10.18095/meeso.2022.23.2.33
- Publisher : The Modern English Education Society
- Research Area : Humanities > English Language and Literature > English Language Teaching
- Received : April 30, 2022
- Accepted : June 9, 2022
- Published : June 30, 2022
1부산대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
The aim of the current meta-analysis was to determine overall effects of storytelling on English language learning and teaching with further analysis of different effects across school levels, outcome variables (such as language skills and affective effects), and across storytelling types. Although storytelling-related meta-analyses have already been conducted, the previous meta-analysis on storytelling did not analyze affective effects or include theses/dissertations. The current study analyzed cognitive and affective effects of storytelling through 277 samples from 18 journal articles, 63 master’s theses and three doctoral dissertations in order to generalize more samples of empirical research on storytelling under Korean EFL context from 2000 to 2021. As a result, the overall effect of storytelling was g = .613. Likewise, effects of the cognitive domain (g = .627) and the affective domain (g = .599) were similar with the overall effect size of storytelling. Vocabulary and attitude were more effective than other subtypes of cognitive and affective domains respectively. Storytelling was more effective with a more directly interactive type when learners started to study English in elementary or secondary school. Finally, educational implications and limitations are discussed.
KEYWORDS
Statistics
-
174 Viewed
-
56 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
안정주
/ 2016
/
An analysis of research trends in the use of storytelling in primary school English education: Focusing on Korea citation index journals
/ 초등영어교육
/ 한국초등영어교육학회
22(4)
: 5~30
[thesis]
An, Ju-Hyun
/ 2005
/ The study on effects of teaching methods of English reading through balanced language approach in the elementary school - 4th grade in the elementary school -
/ 석사
/ Chung-Ang University
[thesis]
안성은
/ 2014
/ 도구를 활용한 아동의 효율적인 영어 어휘 습득 연구 : 초등학교 2학년을 대상으로
/ 석사
/ 상명대학교 교육대학원
[journal]
배지영
/ 2012
/
The Effects if TPRS(Teaching Proficiency through Reading and Story telling) on Elementary School Students’ English Literacy Ability
/ 교과교육학연구
/ 교과교육연구소
16(3)
: 749~770
[thesis]
Bae, Sojeong
/ 2021
/ The effect of conversational storytelling instruction on EFL learners’ interactional competence
/ 석사
/ Ewha Womans University
[thesis]
Bae, Yoon Jung
/ 2010
/ The effect of the writing activity through the format of blended learning on classroom accomplishments and affective attitude
/ 석사
/ Busan University of Foreign Studies
[thesis]
Bang, Mary
/ 2002
/ An application of children’s stories to English education for the third grade elementary students - Focusing on listening -
/ 석사
/ Chuncheon National University of Education
[journal]
Braunstein, L.
/ 2006
/ Adult ESL learners’ attitudes towards movement (TPR) and drama (TPR Storytelling) in the classroom
/ CATESOL Journal
18(1)
: 7~20
[book]
Brown, H. D.
/ 2007
/ Teaching by principles: An interactive approach to language pedagogy
/ Pearson Education
[thesis]
Byeon, Se-mi
/ 2008
/ A study on improving English reading ability and interest through Internet-based storytelling
/ 석사
/ Wonkwang University
[thesis]
Chae, Chang-mok
/ 2004
/ A study on teaching-learning elementary English utilizing the digital storytelling
/ 석사
/ Cheong-ju National University of Education
[journal]
채희숙
/ 2019
/
A Meta-Analysis of Extensive Reading Researches
/ 언어연구
/ 한국현대언어학회
35(1)
: 69~83
[journal]
장진태
/ 2011
/
Teaching Vocabulary with Elementary School Students using Word Association and Story-telling Techniques
/ 교과교육학연구
/ 교과교육연구소
15(3)
: 807~828
[journal]
장진태
/ 2016
/
A study of storytelling techniques and flow through mind-mapping
/ 외국어교육연구
/ 외국어교육연구소
30(3)
: 161~186
[thesis]
Cho, Gahyun
/ 2008
/ The effect of storytelling-based English instruction on the development of phrasal verbs of elementary school students
/ 석사
/ Hankuk University of Foreign Studies
[thesis]
Cho, Hyun Ju
/ 2006
/ Using cartoons for English education at elementary schools - With emphasis on teaching the 6th graders -
/ 석사
/ Dankook University
[thesis]
Cho, Jin-Gyu
/ 2005
/ The effect of an English reading/listening story program on communicative ability and affective domain
/ 석사
/ Busan National University of Education
[journal]
최은수
/ 2017
/
Effects of primary English education using children’s literature: A meta-analysis
/ 영어교육
/ 한국영어교육학회
72(2)
: 167~194
[thesis]
Choi, Ji Eun
/ 2001
/ A study of content-based storytelling teaching and learning
/ 석사
/ Seoul National University of Education
[thesis]
Choi, Su-Jung
/ 2008
/ The effect of differentiated teaching-learning methods of storytelling on the development of vocabulary ability
/ 석사
/ Busan National University of Education
[thesis]
Choi, Sun-Mee
/ 2006
/ The effect of TPRS(Total Physical Response Storytelling) on elementary school students’ communicative ability in English
/ 석사
/ Gyeng-In National University of Education
[thesis]
Choi, Yoon Young
/ 2004
/ The effect of storytelling on English listening in the elementary school
/ 석사
/ Kyungpook National University
[journal]
추성엽
/ 2021
/
Development of an AI Chatbot-Based Teaching Model for English Picture Book Retelling Activities
/ 현대영어교육
/ 현대영어교육학회
22(4)
: 37~50
[thesis]
Chun, Eun Gu
/ 2008
/ A study of enhancing communicative competence through storytelling in elementary English classes
/ 석사
/ Wonkwang University
[book]
Cohen, J.
/ 1988
/ Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences
/ Routledge
[thesis]
Ha, Soo-Jung
/ 2003
/ A study on the use of cartoon materials for the learning English
/ 석사
/ Kookmin National University of Education
[journal]
한소현
/ 2015
/
A comparative study of phonics instruction with the whole language approach for literacy improvement in elementary English education
/ Foreign Languages Education
/ 한국외국어교육학회
22(1)
: 279~303
[book]
Harmer, J.
/ 2012
/ The practice of English language teaching
/ Pearson Education Limited
[thesis]
Heo, Eun Hwa
/ 2013
/ The effects of using English storybooks on 5th-graders’ reading ability and affective domains
/ 석사
/ Gwangju National University of Education
[journal]
허숙
/ 2018
/
The Effects of Storytelling-based Instruction on English Speaking Ability in the Korean EFL University Classroom
/ 언어학 연구
/ 한국중원언어학회
(49)
: 583~623
[thesis]
Hong, Eun Hye
/ 2012
/ A study of the effects of reading activities by using CD-ROM English storybook on English reading ability
/ 석사
/ Kookmin University
[thesis]
Hwang, Kyung Ock
/ 2006
/ Improving English communicative competence through storybooks in elementary school
/ 석사
/ Konkuk University
[book]
Hwang, Sung Dong
/ 2015
/ Meta-analysis using R
/ Hakjisa
[journal]
황성온
/ 2018
/
A Meta-analysis of the Effects of Storytelling-based activities for Young Children
/ 학습자중심교과교육연구
/ 학습자중심교과교육학회
18(17)
: 447~468
[journal]
임병빈
/ 2005
/
How to Improve Listening and Speaking Skills by Using Storytelling in the Elementary School English classes
/ 언어연구
/ 한국현대언어학회
21(2)
: 71~90
[thesis]
Jang, Eun Young
/ 2010
/ A study on developing and applying a TPRS English teaching model for low graders in the elementary school
/ 석사
/ Jeju National University
[thesis]
Jang, MiYoung
/ 2003
/ The development and application of English storytelling programs for special skill and aptitude class
/ 석사
/ Inchon National University of Education
[thesis]
Jang, Suk Hyeon
/ 2015
/ Effects of English teaching for elementary school students through storytelling
/ 석사
/ Jeonju University
[thesis]
Jang, Young-Hwa
/ 2005
/ Some effects of storytelling on elementary English learning - Focused on listening ability & attitude -
/ 석사
/ Jeju National University
[thesis]
Jeon, Ji-Sook
/ 2002
/ A study of English learning effects through storytelling in elementary classrooms
/ 석사
/ Ulsan University
[thesis]
Jeon, Young Hee
/ 2002
/ A study on the effects of the storytelling in elementary school English education - With a focus on the whole language approach -
/ 석사
/ Chunchon National University of Education
[journal]
정미희
/ 2016
/
The effects of story retelling on middle school students’ English speaking ability and learning attitudes
/ 영어교육연구
/ 팬코리아영어교육학회
28(3)
: 131~163
[thesis]
Jeong, Nae-hwa
/ 2009
/ A study of English fairy tales on the application methods for effective English teaching and learning at elementary school
/ 석사
/ Chungju National University
[thesis]
Jeong, Soon-young
/ 2012
/ Effects of storytelling on the English proficiency of elementary school students
/ 박사
/ Chosun University
[book]
Jo, Il-Jae
/ 2009
/ How to teach English literary texts for English education
/ Wooyong
[thesis]
Jo, Woo Rin
/ 2011
/ A study on the effect of shared reading activities for English story on the vocabulary ability of elementary students
/ 석사
/ Korea National University of Education
[thesis]
Jo, Young Ae
/ 2009
/ The effect of English learning in elementary students through the application of storytelling
/ 석사
/ Daegu National University of Education
[thesis]
Jung, Ahreum
/ 2019
/ A study on teaching English writing to 5th grade students in elementary school by using digital storytelling
/ 석사
/ Korea National University of Education
[journal]
정윤희
/ 2012
/
The Effect of Storytelling-Enhanced English Lessons on Primary School Students' Oral Skills and Learning Attitudes
/ 교육과학연구
/ 교육과학연구소
43(1)
: 63~89
[thesis]
Kang, Hye-Soon
/ 2006
/ A study on the effect of storytelling-based instruction on elementary schools students’ reading skills and affective domain
/ 석사
/ Jeju National University
[thesis]
Kang, Hyo-Jin
/ 2005
/ Teaching reading through English storybooks in elementary school
/ 석사
/ Konkuk University
[thesis]
Kim, Eun-Hye
/ 2005
/ The effects of task-based English learning through storytelling on elementary school students' English listening and speaking abilities
/ 석사
/ Jeonju National University of Education
[thesis]
Kim, Hye-Eun
/ 2003
/ A study of teaching methods of English reading through phonics and storybooks
/ 석사
/ Chung-Ang University
[journal]
김혜미
/ 2019
/
A Meta-analysis of English Education Researches Using Blended Learning and Flipped Learning
/ 학습자중심교과교육연구
/ 학습자중심교과교육학회
19(21)
: 241~258
[thesis]
Kim, Hyun Ju
/ 2012
/ The effects of learning contextualized vocabulary through storybook
/ 석사
/ Hankuk University of Foreign Studies
[journal]
김현숙
/ 2006
/
A study on the effectiveness of English fairy tales through the Internet in elementary school.
/ 멀티미디어 언어교육
/ 한국멀티미디어언어교육학회
9(3)
: 99~126
[thesis]
김지선
/ 2009
/ Effects of using English children's stories on Korean English learners' language skills and learning attitudinal factors
/ 박사
/ 공주대학교 대학원
[thesis]
Kim, Jin-Soo
/ 2006
/ The effects of using literary texts in English classes for the reading comprehension and attitudes of Korean high school students
/ 석사
/ Pusan National University
[journal]
김지영
/ 2016
/
Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Reading Instruction Using English Literature for Children
/ 한국콘텐츠학회 논문지
/ 한국콘텐츠학회
16(4)
: 741~756
[thesis]
Kim, Jin Yeong
/ 2017
/ A meta-analysis of the effectiveness of language learning strategy instruction in the Korean context
/ 석사
/ Pusan National University
[thesis]
Kim, Mijeong
/ 2015
/ Effects of retelling on improving vocabulary retention in elementary English education
/ 석사
/ Gyeongin National University of Education
[journal]
김미령
/ 2013
/
Adult L2 Learners’ Attitude toward Storytelling
/ 현대영어교육
/ 현대영어교육학회
14(2)
: 77~99
[thesis]
Kim, Moon-hee
/ 2000
/ The effects of storytelling on learning of elementary school English
/ 석사
/ Incheon National University of Education
[journal]
김나희
/ 2008
/
Understanding cohesion and coherence features in storytelling: Focus on young learners of English
/ 영어교육연구
/ 팬코리아영어교육학회
20(1)
: 183~206
[thesis]
Kim, Sam Hee
/ 2001
/ A study of English teaching model through storytelling for the third grade of elementary school
/ 석사
/ Seoul National University of Education
[thesis]
Kim, Sookja
/ 2009
/ The digital-storytelling technique and effectiveness reflected on elementary EFL learners’ comprehensibility
/ 박사
/ Sejong University
[journal]
김숙자
/ 2010
/
The Digital-Storytelling Technique and Effectiveness Reflected on Elementary School Students' English Comprehensibility
/ 영어학
/ 한국영어학회
10(2)
: 299~319
[journal]
김순희
/ 2010
/
The effectiveness of teaching reading and writing the English alphabet through the use of Korean stories
/ 초등영어교육
/ 한국초등영어교육학회
16(1)
: 95~119
[journal]
김성연
/ 2011
/
Primary school students’ affective responses to digital storytelling and face-to-face storytelling
/ 초등영어교육
/ 한국초등영어교육학회
17(1)
: 229~251
[book]
King, N.
/ 1996
/ Playing their part: Language and learning in the classroom
/ Heinemann Drama
[journal]
고은주
/ 2017
/
Research Trends of Storytelling Studies in Elementary English Education
/ 영어영문학
/ 미래영어영문학회
22(1)
: 193~220
[journal]
Ko, Kyoung-Seok
/ 2004
/ The effects of the English teaching model through stories on elementary school students’ learning style
/ Journal of the Korea English Education Society
3(2)
: 1~32
[thesis]
Ku, Woo Seo
/ 2013
/ The effect of storytelling-enhanced English lessons on primary school students’ listening and reading skills and learning attitudes
/ 석사
/ Chonnam National University
[thesis]
Kwag, So-ran
/ 2008
/ A study on improving primary school students’ English vocabulary learning ability through shared reading
/ 석사
/ Dong-A University
[thesis]
Kweon, Seong-Hee
/ 2007
/ A study on the method of teaching elementary school English by storytelling
/ 석사
/ Chungju National University
[thesis]
Lee, Eun Young
/ 2002
/ A study on the improvement of reading ability through fairy tales in the elementary school
/ 석사
/ Chuncheon National University of Education
[journal]
이재근
/ 2017
/
The Effects of E/M-learning on EFL Learners: A Meta-analysis
/ 영어영문학21
/ 21세기영어영문학회
30(4)
: 231~260
[journal]
이제영
/ 2021
/
Effects of Utilizing Storytelling on English Competence: A Meta-analysis
/ 언어과학
/ 한국언어과학회
28(1)
: 137~161
[journal]
이제영
/ 2016
/
The Effects of Teaching English Online at the Tertiary Level: A Meta-Analysis
/ 외국학연구
/ 외국학연구소
(37)
: 69~95
[thesis]
Lee, Jung-Hwa
/ 2005
/ The effects of Internet-based English stories on the elementary school children’s development in listening skills and interest in learning English
/ 석사
/ Jeonbuk National University
[thesis]
Lee, Kee Jeong
/ 2005
/ A study of teaching English reading to 6th grade elementary students through English fairy tales
/ 석사
/ Konkuk University
[thesis]
Lee, Kyong-ah
/ 2004
/ Teaching English vocabulary through stories
/ 석사
/ Hanyang University
[journal]
이승렬
/ 2005
/
The effects of teaching English through storytelling with dramatization on the listening and speaking competence of children
/ 영어어문교육
/ 한국영어어문교육학회
11(4)
: 305~333
[thesis]
Lim, Kyung-mi
/ 2003
/ A study on hearing & speaking instruction using fairy tales elementary school English
/ 석사
/ Chosun University
[thesis]
Lim, Ok-Ju
/ 2003
/ A study on effect of English listening, speaking ability and interest by English story through Internet with reference to the third grade
/ 석사
/ Chung-Ang University
[thesis]
Lim, Soon-Nam
/ 2001
/ A study on the effects of TPR and TPRS on vocabulary acquisition
/ 석사
/ Daegu National University of Education
[thesis]
Lim, Yang-Soo
/ 2001
/ The effects of activity-based learning through storytelling
/ 석사
/ Inchon National University of Education
[thesis]
Lim, Yu-Jin
/ 2003
/ The effect of storytelling on the improvement of listening skill in elementary English education
/ 석사
/ Jeju National University of Education
[journal]
민덕기
/ 2002
/
Teaching English to Elementary School Children Using Digital Storytelling: How to Maximize Narrative Experience
/ 초등영어교육
/ 한국초등영어교육학회
8(2)
: 175~208
[report]
Ministry of Education
/ 2015
/ 2015 revised English curriculum
/ Ministry of Education
[thesis]
Moon, Hyunsook
/ 2004
/ A study on improving vocabulary acquisition through English story books: In elementary school
/ 석사
/ Kookmin University
[thesis]
Noh, Yong-shill
/ 2004
/ The effects of storytelling in elementary school English class focusing on the improvement of communicative competence
/ 석사
/ Changwon National University
[thesis]
Oh, Soon Ja
/ 2001
/ A study on hearing & speaking instruction using fairy tale reciting for elementary school English
/ 석사
/ Daegu National University of Education
[journal]
Oller, J. W.
/ 1983
/ Story writing principle and ESL teaching
/ TESOL Quarterly
17(1)
: 39~53
[thesis]
Pak, Jong-ik
/ 2018
/ The effects of digital storytelling activity on high school English ability
/ 석사
/ Korea National University of Education
[thesis]
Park, Eunhee
/ 2013
/ The effects on reading and writing in English through storytelling based on multiple intelligence - Focusing on year 5 elementary school students
/ 석사
/ Daegu University
[thesis]
Park, Kyung-Hee
/ 2016
/ A meta-analysis on the effect of story telling program
/ 석사
/ Chonbuk National University
[thesis]
Park, Mi-Ja
/ 2004
/ The effects of the classes using storytelling on the elementary school students’ English listening and speaking skills
/ 석사
/ Kongju National University
[journal]
박부남
/ 2016
/
A comparative study of collaborative projects using digital media: Topic-research presentation and digital storytelling
/ Foreign Languages Education
/ 한국외국어교육학회
23(3)
: 133~159
[journal]
박서준
/ 2015
/
Effects of a story-based integrated teaching program on elementary school students’ English ability and affective domains
/ 영어교과교육
/ 한국영어교과교육학회
14(2)
: 217~243
[thesis]
Park, Soon-joo
/ 2002
/ A study on vocabulary teaching using storytelling in elementary English
/ 석사
/ University of Seoul
[journal]
Park, Sunyoung
/ 2007
/ Research on measures to use a storytelling method in primary school English education
/ The Journal of Mirae English Language and Literature
12(2)
: 37~59
[book]
Peck, S.
/ 2001
/ Teaching English as a second or foreign language
/ Heinle & Heinle
: 139~149
[book]
Petty, W. T
/ 1980
/ Developing children’s language
/ Allyn & Bacon
[journal]
Ryu, Seung-Hye
/ 2001
/ A study on storytelling having effect on English listening learning at elementary school
/ English Linguistic Science
6(1)
: 289~315
[thesis]
Son, Hee Jung
/ 2010
/ The effects of storytelling instruction through the application of activities that correspond to the elementary school students’ needs
/ 석사
/ Daegu National University of Education
[thesis]
Song, Juhee
/ 2021
/ Effects of remote learning English reading program on elementary school students’ English proficiency and affective attitude
/ 박사
/ Kyonggi University
[thesis]
Song, Young-Mi
/ 2003
/ A study on effect of teaching language forms by storytelling in elementary English education
/ 석사
/ Korea National University of Education
[journal]
캐시 스파뇰리
/ 2008
/
Using Visual Organizers to Aid the Storytelling of Personal Narratives by Korean College Students
/ 현대영어영문학
/ 한국현대영어영문학회
52(1)
: 323~344
[journal]
석남희
/ 2021
/
Effects of Extensive Reading in L2 Settings in Korea: Meta-analysis
/ Studies in English Education
/ 글로벌영어교육학회
26(2)
: 321~344
[thesis]
Sung, Yong-sook
/ 2002
/ The effect of TPRS(Total Physical Response Storytelling) on vocabulary ability and interest
/ 석사
/ Busan National University of Education
[book]
Wright, A.
/ 2009
/ Storytelling with children
/ Oxford University Press
[thesis]
Yang, Kyungsoo
/ 2018
/ A Study on improving students’ competence of using English vocabularies: Focusing on storytelling education in middle schools
/ 석사
/ Jeonju University
[journal]
유성모
/ 2017
/
Accuracy Comparison of Effect Size Calculation Methods in Meta-analysis
/ Journal of The Korean Data Analysis Society
/ 한국자료분석학회
19(3)
: 1233~1246
[thesis]
Yoon, Jung-ok
/ 2000
/ A study on the use of cartoon activities for the improvement of listening and speaking skills
/ 석사
/ Busan National University of Education
[journal]
윤미선
/ 2011
/
The comparison study of the effect of vocabulary instruction using storytelling and flash cards
/ 영어교과교육
/ 한국영어교과교육학회
10(3)
: 163~185
[journal]
윤택남
/ 2018
/
A Study of Elementary School Students’ Responses Using TPR-S
/ 외국어교육연구
/ 외국어교육연구소
32(4)
: 107~125
[journal]
윤택남
/ 2018
/
A Study on the Educational Significance of Children’s Stories and Storytelling
/ 제주대학교 교육과학연구
/ 교육과학연구소
20(2)
: 1~19
[journal]
윤정민
/ 2020
/
A meta-analysis of the effects of flipped learning on the learners’ English proficiency and affective trai
/ 영어교육연구
/ 팬코리아영어교육학회
32(2)
: 127~148
[thesis]
Yu, Shin Sook
/ 2005
/ A study on the pedagogical model development of elementary school English through story-book reading
/ 석사
/ Seoul National University of Technology
[journal]
윤광진
/ 2017
/
A Meta-Analysis of the Effectiveness of Web-Based English Instruction on L2 Learning.
/ 언어과학연구
/ 언어과학회
(83)
: 193~224
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.