Crisisonomy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.64
-
pISSN : 2466-1198 / eISSN : 2466-1201
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/cemtp
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Differences in Social Context of Disaster Reconstruction between Korea and China - A Comparative Study of Typhoon Rusa and Sichuan Earthquake -
- Crisisonomy
- Abbr : KRCEM
- 2017, 13(11), pp.195-218
- DOI : 10.14251/crisisonomy.2017.13.11.195
- Publisher : Crisis and Emergency Management: Theory and Praxis
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy > Public Policy in general
- Received : October 31, 2017
- Accepted : November 27, 2017
- Published : November 30, 2017
1한국열린사이버대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
In disaster reconstruction process, various issues reflect the political and social context of society regardless of physical characteristics of disasters. This study compared the post-disaster issues of the 2008 Sichuan earthquake in China and the 2002 Typhoon Rusa in Korea. The issues can be classified into four types such as physical reconstruction, social resilience, recurrence prevention, and regional development. In China’s case, as the central government initiated the issues as a major player, the issues of efficient reconstruction were found noticeable and strongly connected to the issue of nationwide economic development. However, bureaucratic inefficiency and low trust level were also found in China. In Korea, public input was relatively strong and pluralized including NGOs, private firms, interest groups and the public. Civil participations in Korea were well organized and local voices were relatively strong in connection with their interests.
Statistics
-
470 Viewed
-
21 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[other]
Asia Today
/ 2011
/ China Sichuan, Constructing Earthquake Shelter of One-million Capacity
[other]
Beijing Times
/ 2012
/ China Red Cross, Investigate the Branch’s Donation Problem
[journal]
최희천
/ 2014
/
The Differences of Social Contexts between Korea and China: A Comparative Study on Disaster Issues of Typoon Rusa and Sichuan Earthquake
/ 중국연구
/ 중국연구소
60
: 221~245
[thesis]
Choi, Hee Cheon
/ 2010
/ Derivation of an Effective Disaster Governance Model from the Types of Disaster Issues:Focused on Comparative Analysis over the Recent Disaster Cases in Korea
/ Ph.D
/ University of Seoul
[journal]
최희천
/ 2010
/
An study of existing assumptions of disaster management phases : with comparing over response and recovery phase
/ Crisisonomy
/ 위기관리 이론과 실천
6(1)
: 201~218
[other]
Dong-A.com
/ 2012
/ Wang Lijun’s Exile Trial to U.S. …Re-ignition of China’s Power Struggle
[other]
Gangwon Province
/ 2003
/ 2002 White Book for Flood Disaster
[book]
George, D Haddow
/ 2011
/ Introduction to Emergency Management
/ Elsevier
[journal]
Gotham, Kevin Fox
/ 2008
/ From 9/11 to 8/29: Post-Disaster Recovery and Rebuilding in New York and New Orleans
/ Social Forces
87(2)
: 1039~1062
[journal]
Hills, Alice
/ 1998
/ Seduced by Recovery: The Consequences of Misunderstanding Disaster
/ Journal of Contingencies &Crisis Management
6(3)
: 162~170
[web]
/ http://ko.wikipedia.org/
/ http://ko.wikipedia.org/
[web]
/ http://www.onefoundation.cn/
/ http://www.onefoundation.cn/
[journal]
현승효
/ 2016
/
Analyzing the Lawmaking Process of the Sewol Special Law by Evolutionary Game Theory - The Flows of Social Disaster Issues and Policy - making Process of Responsibility Attribution -
/ Crisisonomy
/ 위기관리 이론과 실천
12(6)
: 67~81
[other]
Journalist Association of Korea
/ 2012
/ Sichuan Earthquake 4 Year … Three Time’s Surprise
[confproc]
Kates, R. W.
/ 2006
/ Reconstruction of New Orleans after Hurricane Katrina: A Research Perspective
/ Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America
103(40)
: 14653~14660
[confproc]
Kim, Gyum Hun
/ 2009
/ Hebei Spirit Oil Spill Accident
/ Korean Association of Environmental Sociology Conference
[book]
Kim, Ki Seok
/ 2013
/ East Japan Earthquake and Japan’s Course
/ Hanul Publishing Group
[journal]
Kotze, Astrid Von
/ 1996
/ Why Disasters Are a Gender Issue
/ Women and the Environment
12(29)
: 22~26
[journal]
Kreps, G. A.
/ 1984
/ Sociological Inquiry and Disaster Research
/ Annual Review of Sociology
10
: 309~330
[journal]
Kubicek, Paul
/ 2002
/ The Earthquake, Civil Society, and Political Change in Turkey: Assessment and Comparison with Eastern Europe
/ Political Studies
50
: 761~778
[confproc]
Lee, Jae Eun
/ 2008
/ Searching New Approach for Securing Safety in Emergnecy Management
/ Proceedings of the Korean Association for Public Administration Summer Conference
[journal]
이주호
/ 2014
/
Overcoming the Crisis in Disaster Area by Social Economy - Focused on the Disaster Effects and Recovery Issues of Hebei Spirit Oil Spill -
/ Crisisonomy
/ 위기관리 이론과 실천
10(6)
: 1~26
[journal]
이시재
/ 2008
/
A Study on Social Impacts of the Hebei Spirit Oil Spill Accident in Korea
/ ECO
/ 한국환경사회학회
12(1)
: 109~144
[other]
MK News
/ 2013
/ [Moon YuGeun’s Reading China] China’s Earthquake Response and Lessons
[other]
Naeil Shinmoon
/ 2010
/ Times, Quite Differences between Sichuan and Haiti
[other]
National Institute for Disaster Prevention
/ 2003
/ 2002 Disaster White Book
[other]
Newsis
/ 2008
/ China, All Safe Earthquake Area’s Nuclear Facilities
[other]
Newsis
/ 2008
/ China, Sichuan Earthquake Damage 126Trillion Won
[journal]
Picou, J. Steven
/ 2004
/ Disaster, Litigation, and the Corrosive Community
/ Social Forces
82(4)
: 1493~1522
[other]
The Hankook Ilbo
/ 2009
/ [Correspondent Column] Oh!Sichuan
[other]
The Hankyoreh
/ 2008
/ [People Behind News] Sorrow of Death of Only Child Leads Getting Second Child
[other]
The Hankyoreh
/ 2009
/ Distribution or Growth?, Intensified Struggle in China’s Communist Party
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2009
/ Peak Recovering under ‘Construction of Pretty House’ Slogan
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2010
/ [Correspondennt Choi Heon Gyu’s China Today] China, Auditing Earthquake Donation Management in Distrust
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2010
/ Preserve Chang Tribe in Sichuan Damage
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2010
/ Disappearance Risk of Kungfu Star Li Lianjie’s Donation Foundation
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2011
/ Sichuan Earthquake 3 year. Light And Shadow
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2013
/ <Correspondennt’s Column -Park Young Seo> China Red Corss’ Falling
[other]
The Herald Business
/ 2013
/ 745 Trillion Investment …Sichuan ‘Mega Projects’
[other]
The Joongang Ilbo
/ 2013
/ [Opinion] China’s Split between People and Government
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Call for Disaster Declaration about 'Whole East Kangwon Area'
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Requiring Disaster Declaration about Jeongseon-gun
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Requiring Disaster Declaration about Doam Area
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Request for Demolishing Doam-Dam and Compensation
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Spreading Request for Removal of Doam-Dam
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Sorrow of Tenant in Flood Area
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Call for Extension of Levee instead of Restoration
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Resist because of Worry for Repeated Flood
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Permission about 'Limited City-Gun Area vs. Province Area'
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Spreading Request for Closing Doam-Dam
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Economic Slump of East Kangwon Area
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Highway Construction Increase Flood Damage
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ Call for Retaining Wall around Agricultural Waterway
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2002
/ People Charges of Fake Reporting for Flood Damage
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Request Completion of Restoring Construction of Retaining Wall by June
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Worry about Poor Construction because of Excessive Short Period
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Difficulty in Flood Recovery in Donggang River’s Seopsae Area
[other]
The Kangwondomin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Fake Reporting and Subsidy Receiving about Abalone Loss in Typhoon Rusa
[other]
The Kyunghyang Shinmun
/ 2008
/ China, Tent Villagse in Streets … Fearing Secondary Shock
[other]
The Kyunghyang Shinmun
/ 2009
/ Continuing Debate about Earthquake Causes
[other]
The Kyunghyang Shinmun
/ 2010
/ Sichuan Province, 'Recommend Patriotism' … Oppressive Cellphone Color-Ring
[other]
The Munhwa Ilbo
/ 2009
/ Sichuan Earthquake’s Absurd Relief Houses
[other]
The Munhwa Ilbo
/ 2011
/ Among 29,692 Recovery Projects, 94% Cases Completion
[other]
The Munhwa Ilbo
/ 2013
/ China, Debating Poor Earthquake Recovery of Center-Empty Bricks
[other]
The Segye Times
/ 2013
/ Debate about Molded Earthquake Donation
[other]
The Seoul Shinmun
/ 2009
/ [Sichuan Earthquake 1 Year]Beichuan Xian, Still 15,000 People Uncovered
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2009
/ <Sichuan Earthquake 1 Year> Dujiangyan, Under Peak Reconstruction
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2009
/ China Sichuan, GDP 13.5% Up because of Increased Demand for Earthquake Recovery
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2010
/ Debate of Donation Transparency about Sichuan Earthquake
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2010
/ China Sichuan, Speedy Earthquake Recovery
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2011
/ Sichuan Earthquake 3 year, Crossing Condolence and Recovering
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2011
/ China, Explosion Causes 20 Casualties during Construction Workers’ Group Fighting
[other]
Yonhap News
/ 2012
/ Damage of Minority Tribial Culture during Sichuan Earthquake Recovering