Crisisonomy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.64
-
pISSN : 2466-1198 / eISSN : 2466-1201
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/cemtp
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Social Contexts of Regulatory Policy and the Influence of Interests on Regulatory Sciences - On the Controversy on the Regulatory Policy on Alien Golden Apple Snails (Pomacea canaliculata) -
- Crisisonomy
- Abbr : KRCEM
- 2020, 16(9), pp.131-155
- DOI : 10.14251/crisisonomy.2020.16.9.131
- Publisher : Crisis and Emergency Management: Theory and Praxis
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy > Public Policy in general
- Received : August 19, 2020
- Accepted : September 1, 2020
- Published : September 30, 2020
Na Yeong Kim 1, Ji Min Shin 1, Cho Su Nam 1
1서울대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
The regulatory policies related to environmental issues involve various social contexts and interested parties.
We examined how the social contexts on Golden Apple Snail (Pomacea canaliculata) have made the regulatory policy sluggish for a long time, and how the regulatory science has been used and interpreted differently by each ministry of the central government in South Korea. We analyzed relevant newspapers, reports and papers of related ministries and affiliated research institutes over 20 years. The regulatory policy on Golden Apple Snail was not free from the political, economic, and social contexts influenced by international and domestic changes, and the implementation and interpretation of regulatory science were also related to the interests of ministries such as the Ministry of Environment and the Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry.
This study is expected to contribute to understanding the characteristics of regulatory policies and regulatory sciences in particular domestic contexts.
Statistics
-
489 Viewed
-
4 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[web]
Agrinet
/ 2005
/ Need to Scrutinize Harmfulness of the Golden Apple Snail
/ http://www.agrinet.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=15365
[web]
Agrinet
/ 2019
/ Controversial Move to Designate Golden Apple Snail as An Ecosystem Disturbance Creature
/ https://www.agrinet.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=172542
[web]
Asia Economy Daily
/ 2020
/ Provincial Assemblyman Cho Kwang-young, Calls for Measures to Manage the Wintering Golden Apple Snail
/ https://www.asiae.co.kr/article/2020071615233612885
[journal]
방상원
/ 2008
/
Ecological Risk of Alien Apple Snails Used in Environmentally-friendly Agriculture and the Urgent Need for Its Risk Management in Korea
/ 환경생물
/ 한국환경생물학회
26(3)
: 129~137
[web]
Busan Ilbo Newspaper
/ 2003
/ Experience Event to catch Apple Snail
/ http://www.busan.com/view/busan/view.php?code=20030717000325
[web]
Chosun Media Blog
/ 2005
/ Misunderstanding about Golden Apple Snail
/ http://blogs.chosun.com/bowler1/2005/04/18/%EC%99%95%EC%9A%B0%EB%A0%81%EC%9D%B4%EC%97%90-%EA%B4%80%ED%95%9C-%EC%98%A4%ED%95%B4/
[web]
Chungcheong Today
/ 2003
/ Emergency for Farmers Preparing for Introduction in the Province
/ http://www.cctoday.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=39624
[web]
Chungcheong Today
/ 2007
/ Win FTA with Eco-Friendly Farming Methods
/ http://www.cctoday.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=230622
[web]
Chungcheong Today
/ 2019
/ What about Chungwon Life Rice Using Environmentally Friendly Agriculture?
/ https://www.cctoday.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=2032044
[web]
CJ Hello Newspaper
/ 2019
/ Golden Apple Snail is on the Verge of Eviction...Eco-Friendly Agriculture ‘Emergency’
/ https://www.ytn.co.kr/_ln/0106_201911090320332024
[web]
Gwangju Daily Newpaper
/ 2003
/ Launched Investigation into Damage from Golden Apple Snail on Rice
/ http://kjdaily.com/
[web]
Gwangju Daily Newspaper
/ 2003
/ Towards the Nation’s Top Cultural and Eco-Friendly Agricultural County
/ http://www.kjdaily.com/read.php3?aid=10558257079265035
[web]
Gwangju Daily Newspaper
/ 2007
/ ‘Report of Ecosystem’in Gosanbong Peak, Hampyeong
/ http://www.kjdaily.com/read.php3?aid=117906840082375036
[web]
Hankook Ilbo
/ 2005
/ Golden Apple Snail gnawing at the Farmer’s Heart
/ https://www.hankookilbo.com/paoin?Page=2&SearchDate=20050221
[web]
Hankyoreh
/ 2011
/ [Because] Eco-Friendly Farming Methods Using Golden Apple Snail can Destroy Eco System
/ http://www.hani.co.kr/arti/opinion/because/461724.html
[journal]
Hyun, Jae Hwan
/ 2016
/ The Concept of Regulatory Science and Policy Trends
/ BioNpro
27
: 16~18
[journal]
Jasanoff, Sheila
/ 1987
/ Contested Boundaries in Policy-relevant Science
/ Social Studies of Science
17(2)
: 195~230
[book]
Jasanoff, Sheila
/ 2005
/ Designs on Nature : Science and Democracy in Europe and the United States
/ Princeton University Press
[web]
Jemmin Ilbo
/ 2010
/ Signs of Climate Change Throughout the Province, such as Rapid Reproduction of Some Animals and Plants
/ http://www.jemin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=253351
[web]
Jeonbuk Domin Newspaper
/ 1994
/ Let’s Beat the UR Waves
/ http://www.bigkinds.or.kr
[web]
Jeonbuk Domin Newspaper
/ 1994
/ Let’s Jump over UR
/ http://www.bigkinds.or.kr
[other]
Jeonbuk Domin Newspaper
/ 1996
/ Using Golden Apple Snail from South America to Get Rid of Weeds
[web]
Jeonbuk Domin Newspaper
/ 2004
/ Buan County, Expand Eco-Friendly Agriculture
/ http://www.domin.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=496343
[web]
Jeonbuk Ilbo
/ 2001
/ [Environmental Features] Golden Apple Snail and Ecosystem
/ http://www.jjan.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=39242
[journal]
Jeong, Jae Hwa
/ 2006
/ Asia’s FTA Fever : Asia Economic Integration and FTA
/ Chindia Journal
4
: 20~22
[journal]
Jeong, Jeong Hwa
/ 2002
/ The Policy Conflict over Development and Preservation Issues within Central Government : Searching for the Strategies and Determinants of the Ministry of Environment
/ The Korea Policy Journal
2
: 185~197
[web]
Joongang Ilbo
/ 2019
/ Golden Apple Snail, A Leading Player in Eco-Friendly Farming Methods→An Environmental Destructor, and a ‘Sinner’ after 27 Years
/ https://news.joins.com/article/23609251
[web]
Joongbu Ilbo
/ 2008
/ The Ministry of Environment vs. Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
/ http://www.joongboo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=270507
[web]
Joongbu Ilbo
/ 2008
/ Green Alternative Farming Methods Are Urgently Needed
/ http://www.joongboo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=270608
[web]
Joongbu Ilbo
/ 2008
/ Opposes the Designation of Golden Apple Snail as an Ecological Disturbance Species
/ http://www.joongboo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=271590
[report]
Kim, Do Ik
/ 2007
/ Wintering Ecology of Golden Apple Snail in the North Jeolla Province and Field Application of Control Technology of It
/ Rural Development Administration
: 59~78
[journal]
김도익
/ 2007
/
Management of Golden Apple Snail (Pomacea canaliculata: Ampullariidae) Using Duck and Fish Trap
/ 한국응용곤충학회지
/ 한국응용곤충학회
46(1)
: 117~122
[report]
Kim Hyun Ju
/ 2007
/ Survey on the Over-wintering of Golden Apple Snail and Its damage to Rice in Yongnam Area
/ Rural Development Administration
: 38~58
[journal]
김현주
/ 2007
/
Over-wintering of the Apple Snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Gastropoda: Ampullariidae) and Its Over-wintering Habitat in the Yeongnam District
/ 한국응용곤충학회지
/ 한국응용곤충학회
46(3)
: 437~444
[other]
Kim Hyun Ju
/ 2012
/ Apparatus for Bocking Outflow of Apple Snails. Korean Intellectual Property Office
/ Public Utility Model 20-2012-0004453
[report]
Kim Jong Min
/ 2007
/ Detailed Studies on Invasive Alien Species and Their Management (II)
/ National Institute of Environmental Research
[report]
Kim Nam Young
/ 2017
/ Investigating Ecological Risk of Alien Species(Ⅳ)
/ National Institute of Ecology
[web]
Korea Herald
/ 2019
/ The Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs, Strives to Manage Golden Apple Snail, which is Harmful to the Ecosystem...Prepare Management Guidelines
/ http://biz.heraldcorp.com/view.php?ud=20191213000026
[web]
Kukmin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Check the Environmental Hot Issue. / ‘Occupation Forces’ Golden Apple Snail Assault Ecosystem Alert
/ https://www.esqi.com/board/zboard.php?id=board_01&page=54&sn1=&divpage=1&sn=off&ss=on&sc=on&select_arrange=vote&desc=desc&no=530
[web]
Kwangju Ilbo
/ 2004
/ ‘Golden Apple Snail Farming’ Will Decrease
/ https://www.kinds.or.kr/
[web]
Kwangju Ilbo
/ 2004
/ Survey on the Damage of The Farming Method using Golen Snail
/ https://www.kinds.or.kr/
[web]
Kwangju Ilbo
/ 2008
/ Confused with Golden Apple Snail Farming...Only the Peasants are in Trouble
/ http://www.kwangju.co.kr/article.php?aid=1212917794302931012&search=%BF%D5%BF%EC%B7%B7%C0%CC%20%B3%F3%B9%FD%20%C8%A5%BC%B1
[other]
Kwangju Ilbo
/ 2008
/ Confusion over the Farming Methods using Golden Apple Snail ... Only the Peasants are in Trouble
[journal]
권오도
/ 2010
/
Weedy Control Efficacy and Injury of Rice Plant by Golden Apple Snail(Pomacea canaliculata) in Environment-friendly Rice Paddy Fields
/ Weed&Turfgrass Science
/ 한국잡초학회
30(3)
: 282~290
[other]
Kyeongin Ilbo
/ 1990
/ Golden Apple Snail, New High-Income Source for Farmin
[web]
Kyeongin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Concentrated Promotion of the Top 10 Agricultural and Livestock Products of Yangpyeong-gun
/ http://www.kyeongin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=101077
[web]
Kyeongin Ilbo
/ 2003
/ Assessment Conference on Eco-friendly Rice Production System Using Golden Apple Snail
/ http://www.kyeongin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=101472
[web]
Kyunghyang Shinmun
/ 2003
/ ‘Let’s Eat Bath and Blue Road and Get Rid of It’, Ministry of Environment Recommends 52 Dishes
/ http://news.khan.co.kr/kh_news/khan_art_view.html?artid=200310291840591&code=940701
[web]
Kyungnam Domin Newspaper
/ 2001
/ The Foreign Golden Apple Snails are the Main Culprits of Environmental Destructi on
/ https://www.idomin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=24201
[web]
Kyungnam Domin Newspaper
/ 2003
/ Ideas for Local Governm ent Agricultural Competitiveness ②
/ https://www.idomin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=92022
[web]
Kyungnam Domin Newspaper
/ 2006
/ [5/31 Local Election Ground Debate] Geochang-gun County Mayor’s FTA Sense of Crisis. ‘One voice’ to Increase Competitiveness
/ http://www.idomin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=185389
[web]
Kyungnam Domin Newspaper
/ 2008
/ ‘Eco-Friendly’ Golden Apple Snail, Threatening the Ecosystem
/ https://www.idomin.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=261587&page=3&total=101
[web]
Kyungsang Ilbo
/ 2004
/ Come and See Golden Apple Snail that Farms Rice
/ https://m.ksilbo.co.kr/news/quickViewArticleView.html?idxno=95934
[web]
Kyungsang Ilbo
/ 2005
/ Refuting Golden Apple Snail’s Damage to the Ecosystem
/ http://www.ksilbo.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=121707
[journal]
Lee Sang Beom
/ 2017
/ Organic Rice Cultivation Technology Using Golden Apple Snails
/ Organic Technology Journal
4
: 1~11
[journal]
이상범
/ 2002
/
Physiological and ecological characteristics of the apple snails
/ 한국환경농학회지
/ 한국환경농학회
21(1)
: 8~
[journal]
이상범
/ 2019
/
The Environmental Adaptability of Pomacea canaliculata used for Weed Control in Wet Rice Paddies and Crop Damage Caused by Overwintered Golden Apple Snails
/ 한국환경농학회지
/ 한국환경농학회
38(1)
: 23~33
[thesis]
Lim, Jae Hyung.
/ 1995
/ Factors Affecting the Implementation Process of Environmental Policy: Focusing on the Regulatory Policy of Water Pollution
/ MA
/ Dankook University
[web]
Ministry of Agriculture, Food and Rural Affairs
/ 2019
/ Thorough Mmanagement of Golden Apple Snail Is Not an Option but a Necessity! Press Release
/ www.mafra.go.kr›bbs›mafra›download
[web]
Ministry of Environment
/ 2005
/ The Results of the 2004Survey on the Inhabitation, Distribution of Wintering Grounds, and Ecological Hazards of the Golden Apple Snails
/ https://www.me.go.kr/home/web/board/read.do?boardMasterId=1&boardId=83655
[web]
Munhwa Ilbo
/ 1994
/ New Interest in Special Crops since the UR Settlement, The Flood of Bad Seeds has Caused Farmers to Suffer
/ www.kinds.or.kr
[web]
Naeil Newspaper
/ 2004
/ Ministry of Environment, Are You Willing to Manage Foreign Fish Species?
/ http://www.lenok.net/index.php?document_srl=9978&mid=story
[web]
National Association of Eco-Friendly Farmers
/ 2019
/ [Statem ent] The Ministry of Environment, Immediately Withdraws the Amendment to the Notice to Designate Golden Apple Snail as an Ecosystem Disturbance Creature!
/ http://www.ofkorea.org/sub/sub03_02.php?boardid=column&mode=view&idx=103&sk=&sw=&offset=&category=
[report]
National Institute of Agricultural Science and Technology
/ 2007
/ Studies on Ecological Characteristics and Control Methods of Golden Apple Snail, Pomacea canaliculata Lamarck. Third Year Completion Report
/ Rural Development Administration
[web]
Newsis
/ 2019
/ An Ecosystem-threatening Golden Apple Snail, Must be Collected Thoroughly After Utilization
/ https://newsis.com/view/?id=NISX20191212_0000858994
[web]
Nongamin Newpaper
/ 2003
/ Golden Apple Snail Reaching a Deadlock
/ http://www.agrinet.co.kr/news/articleView.html?idxno=40949
[journal]
박희제
/ 2010
/
과학자들의 연구주제 선택 결정 요인들
/ 경제와 사회
/ 비판사회학회
(85)
: 211~236
[report]
Park Hyeong Man
/ 2007
/ Development of the Control Methods against the Golden Apple Snail, Pomacea canaliculata Lamarck
/ Rural Development Administration
: 79~93
[report]
Park Hyeong Man
/ 2007
/ Survey of the Over-wintering Sites in Central Region of Korea, and Investigation on Biological Characteristics of the Golden Apple Snail
/ Rural Development Administration
: 1~14
[confproc]
Park Hyeong Man
/ 2005
/ Investigation of Wintering Area and Development of Control Technology of Golden Apple Snails
/ Regular Meeting and Spring Conference of the Korean Society of Pesticide Science
: 84~
[web]
Policy Brief
/ 2008
/ There Is No Golden Apple Snail that Can Overcome the Cold in Winter
/ Rural Development Admini stration
/ http://www.korea.kr/news/pressReleaseView.do?newsId=155296524&pageIndex=4954&repCodeType=&repCode=&startDate=2008-02-29&2018-12-26&srchWord
[other]
/ 2020
/ Regulations on Administrative Organizations and Capacity Standards for Local Governments
/ Revision of Other Laws 2020. 3. 11. Presidential Decree No. 350515. 16(7)
[other]
Rothstein, Henry
/ 1999
/ Regulatory Science, Europeanisation and the Control of Agrochemicals
/ LSE Research Articles Online
: 1~19
[report]
Rural Development Administration.
/ 2008
/ There Is No Golden Apple Snail that Can Overcome the Cold in Winter
[web]
Segye Ilbo
/ 2007
/ Serious Disturbance of Native Ecosystem Caused by Exotic Species such as Carassius Cuvieri with Good Appetite
/ http://www.segye.com/newsView/20070510000366
[journal]
서홍렬
/ 2010
/
A Study on the Ecology of the Golden Apple Snail, Pomacea canaliculata (Lamark) in Chungnam and Jeonbuk Province of Korea
/ 한국환경생태학회지
/ 한국환경생태학회
24(6)
: 772~780
[report]
Seo Hong Yul
/ 2007
/ Study on the Over-wintering Ecology and the Evaluation of Yield Loss in Rice of the Golden Apple Snail, Pomacea Canaliculata(Lamarck)in Chungnam and Jeonbuk Province
/ Rural Development Administration
: 15~37
[web]
Seoul Economic Daily
/ 1999
/ [NewsBriefing] From 22nd, The Eco-friendly Agricultural Products Fair
/ https://www.sedaily.com/NewsView/1HNXX2OVQ2
[web]
Seoul Shinmun
/ 2001
/ Golden Apple Snail Destructing the Ecosystem
/ http://www.seoul.co.kr/news/newsView.php?id=20010731025005
[web]
Seoul Shinmun
/ 2005
/ Worried that Wang Woorong Might Become the Second Bullfrog
/ https://www.seoul.co.kr/news/newsView.php?id=20050221026001
[web]
Seoul Shinmun
/ 2008
/ What Should We Do with Golden Apple Snail?
/ http://www.seoul.co.kr/news/newsView.php?id=20081115001005
[other]
Statistics Korea
/ 2009
/ 2008 Fishery Production Trend Survey Results (Provisional) Press Release
[other]
Statistics Korea.
/ 2019
/ 2018 Fishery Production Trend Survey Results(Provisional)Press Release
[other]
Statistics Korea.
/ 2020
/ 2020 Fishery Production Trend Survey Results(Provisional)Press Release
[web]
Uljin News
/ 2008
/ Conversion of Golden Apple Snail Farming, Is There No Abnormality?
/ http://uljinnews.com/news/view.php?no=2637
[web]
Uljin Times
/ 2005
/ Let’s Not Use Imported Golden Apple Snail as Eco-friendly Farming Materials!
/ http://www.uljintimes.co.kr/news/article.html?no=754#0BsE
[report]
Won Chang Man
/ 2005
/ Wildlife Survey
/ National Institute of Environmental Research
[journal]
Wynne, Brian
/ 1992
/ Uncertainty and Environmental Learning : Reconceiving Science and Policy in the Preventive Paradigm
/ Global Environmental Change
2(2)
: 111~127
[web]
Youngnam Ilbo
/ 2006
/ Spread Eco-Friendly Golden Apple Snail Farming Again
/ www.kinds.or.kr