Korea Social Policy Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 2.47
-
pISSN : 1226-0525
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/kasp
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Significance of Qualitative Evaluation and It’s Congruence in Evaluating Social Policy
- Korea Social Policy Review
- Abbr : KSPR
- 2015, 22(3), pp.165-196
- DOI : 10.17000/kspr.22.3.201509.165
- Publisher : Korean Association of Social Policy
- Research Area : Social Science > Sociology > Medical / Welfare / Social policy
이성우 1, kwak, Byung-Hun 2, OH, SOOGIL 3
1한성대학교
2한국학중앙연구원
3고려사이버대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This article gropes for the use of qualitative evaluation in social policy under consideration of its significance, which can complement quantitative evaluation. It maintains the viewpoint of complementarity. To evaluate social policy or social programs effectively, it requires for evaluators to reflect the points of view of the stakeholders in the context of social realities. Since social policy is value embedded field, qualitative evaluation has compatibility with social policy. Qualitative evaluation seeks to understand social realities including individual, social, structural, and environmental contexts.
Nevertheless existing evaluations of social policy tend to show ‘methodological uniformity’ by standardized indicators and artificial contexts. This article argues to evaluate the value of social policy through qualitative evaluation focusing processes based on interpretation. For qualitative evaluation, we can use in-depth interview, focus group interview, or observation which orient ‘natural communicative process.’
Statistics
-
415 Viewed
-
206 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
김연옥
/ 1998
/ 우리나라 사회복지학 연구경향에 관한 연구: <한국사회복지학>에 실린 경험분석 연구를중심으로
/ 한국사회복지학
35
: 85~105
[journal]
김인
/ 2010
/
Effectiveness and Customer Satisfaction of Caretaker Voucher Service for Postpartum Women and Infants
/ 지방정부연구
/ 한국지방정부학회
13(4)
: 127~151
[journal]
김인숙
/ 2007
/
A Study on the Social Welfare Qualitative Research in Korea: Trends and Implications
/ 한국사회복지학
/ 한국사회복지학회
59(1)
: 275~300
[journal]
김은희
/ 2011
/
A Study on the Integrative Performance Evaluation of Social Welfare Services : Focusing on Social Welfare Centers in Gwangju City
/ 한국행정논집
/ 한국정부학회
23(3)
: 801~827
[journal]
남찬섭
/ 2008
/ 한국 사회복지서비스에서 바우처의 의미와 평가: 바우처 사업의 사회적 맥락을 중심으로
/ 상황과 복지
26
: 7~45
[journal]
문신용
/ 2010
/
Qualitative Performance Evaluation of Family Welfare Service Based on SERVQUAL Method : Focusing on the Healthy Family Support Center
/ 지방정부연구
/ 한국지방정부학회
13(4)
: 153~172
[report]
보건복지가족부
/ 2008
/ 긴급복지지원제도의 사업성과 평가 및 제도개선 방안
/ 보건복지가족부
[journal]
송건섭
/ 2006
/
A Study on the Model Construction and Application of Performance Evaluation in Social Welfare Center: Qualitative Evaluation Using SERVQUAL
/ 한국정책과학학회보
/ 한국정책과학학회
10(1)
: 79~100
[journal]
오윤정
/ 2012
/
Analysis of Research Trends in Social Service Project Evaluation
/ 비판사회정책
/ 비판과대안을위한사회복지학회/비판과대안을위한건강정책학회
(37)
: 249~283
[journal]
오정수
/ 2002
/ 한국 사회복지학계 연구방법론에 대한 반성적 고찰
/ 상황과 복지
13
: 33~46
[journal]
이성우
/ 2008
/
후기 실증주의와 질적 연구방법의 정책분석평가연구에의 적용가능성
/ 정책분석평가학회보
/ 한국정책분석평가학회
18(4)
: 15~42
[journal]
이환범
/ 2010
/
A Study on the Evaluation of Effectiveness for the Improvement of Aged's Job Creation Project
/ 한국지방자치연구
/ 대한지방자치학회
11(4)
: 81~100
[journal]
정순둘
/ 2006
/
Social Worker and Research Utilization in Social Work Practice
/ 한국사회복지학
/ 한국사회복지학회
58(2)
: 251~271
[journal]
정선욱
/ 2013
/
Qualitative Analysis of Program Evaluation Studies Using Qualitative Methods in Social welfare Literature
/ 사회복지연구
/ 한국사회복지연구회
44(4)
: 321~349
[report]
한국보건사회연구원
/ 2014
/ 긴급복지지원제도 사업성과 평가 및 제도개편 방안 연구
[journal]
홍경준
/ 2002
/ 한국 사회복지학계 연구방법론의 동향
/ 상황과 복지
13
: 13~32
[journal]
Alcock, P.
/ 2004
/ The influence of dynamic perspectives on poverty analysis and anti-poverty policy in the UK
/ Journal of Social Policy
33(3)
: 395~416
[book]
Allio, L.
/ 1998
/ The political circumstances of instrument design : The case of privatization in Eastern Europe. In B. Peters & F. van Nispen(eds)
/ Edward Elgar
: 20~149
[journal]
Andenaes, A.
/ 2011
/ From placement to a child on the move: Methodological strategies to give children a more central position in child welfare service
/ Qualitative Social Work
11(5)
: 486~501
[journal]
Andersson, K.
/ 2012
/ Methodological challenges in the implementation and evaluation of social welfare policies
/ International Journal of Social Research Methodology
15(1)
: 69~80
[journal]
Ascher, W.
/ 1987
/ Policy sciences and the economic approach in a ‘post-positivistic’ era
/ Policy Sciences
20
: 3~9
[journal]
Begun, A.
/ 1980
/ Social policy evaluation: An example from drinking age legislation
/ Evaluation and Program Planning
3
: 165~170
[journal]
Biggs, S.
/ 2001
/ Toward critical narrativity: Stories of aging in contemporary social policy
/ Journal of Aging Studies
15
: 303~316
[report]
Blomquist, J.
/ 2003
/ Impact evaluation of social programs: A policy perspective
/ World Bank
[journal]
Brannen, J.
/ 2005
/ Work-family matters in the workplace: The use of focus groups in a study of a UK social services department
/ Qualitative Research
5(4)
: 523~542
[book]
Bryson, J.
/ 2010
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 30~54
[book]
Butcher, T.
/ 2002
/ Delivering welfare
/ Open University Press
[journal]
Cameron, A.
/ 2009
/ Working across boundaries to improve health outcomes: A case study of a housing support an outreach service for homeless people living with HIV
/ Health & Social Care in the Community
17(4)
: 388~395
[book]
Caudle, S.
/ 1994
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 69~95
[book]
Chambers, D.
/ 2000
/ Social policy and social programs: A method for the practical public policy analyst
/ Allyn & Bacon
[journal]
Chen, S.
/ 2010
/ Qualitative research and aging in context: Implications to social study in China
/ Qualitative Sociology Review
VI(1)
: 34~47
[book]
Christians, C.
/ 1989
/ Research methods in mass communication
/ Prentice Hall
: 354~374
[book]
Coffey, A.
/ 2004
/ Reconceptualizing social policy: Sociological perspectives on contemporary social policy
/ Open University Press
[journal]
Colebatch, H.
/ 1995
/ Organizational meanings of program evaluation
/ Policy Sciences
28
: 149~164
[book]
Cook, T.
/ 1985
/ Postpositivist critical multiplism. In R. Shotland & M. Mark(eds). Social science and social policy
/ Sage Publications
: 21~62
[book]
Davies, B.
/ 1978
/ Universality, selectivity and effectiveness in social policy
/ Heinemann Educational
[book]
Davies, H.
/ 2000
/ What works?: Evidence-based policy and practice in public services
/ The Policy Press
: 1~11
[book]
Davies, H.
/ 2000
/ What works?: Evidence-based policy and practice in public services
/ The Policy Press
: 251~275
[book]
Davies, P.
/ 2000
/ What works?: Evidence-based policy and practice in public services
/ The Policy Press
: 291~316
[book]
Dean, D.
/ 1994
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 338~349
[book]
Dean, H.
/ 1998
/ The student's companion to social policy
/ Blackwell Publishers
: 317~322
[journal]
Dellgran, P.
/ 2001
/ Mainstream is contextual: Swedish social work research dissertations and theses
/ Social Work Research
25(4)
: 243~252
[journal]
Doyle, M.
/ 2010
/ Lessons from a community-based participatory research project:Older people’s and researchers’ reflections
/ Research on Aging
32(2)
: 244~263
[journal]
Dryzek, J.
/ 1982
/ Policy analysis as a hermeneutic activity
/ Policy Sciences
14
: 309~329
[book]
Dryzek, J.
/ 2007
/ Public governance
/ Sage Publications
: 330~346
[journal]
Evason, E.
/ 2003
/ Women and pensions: Time for a rethink
/ Social Policy &Administration
37(3)
: 253~270
[journal]
Gage, N. L.
/ 1989
/ The paradigm wars and their aftermath: A “historical” sketch of research on teaching since 1989
/ Educational Researcher
18(7)
: 4~10
[report]
Garbarino, S.
/ 2009
/ Quantitative and qualitative methods in impact evaluation and measuring results. Issues Paper
/ Governance and Social Development Resource Centre
[report]
Gardenhire, A.
/ 2003
/ Intensive qualitative research: Challenges, best uses and opportunities
/ Research Methodology
[web]
General Accounting Office
/ 1998
/ Managing for results: Measuring program results that are under limited federal control
/ http://www.gao.gov/assets/230/226681.pdf
[book]
Gilbert, N.
/ 1974
/ Dimensions of social welfare policy
/ Prentice-Hall
[book]
Gilbert, N.
/ 2002
/ Dimensions of social welfare policy
/ Allyn &Bacon
[book]
Goodin, R.
/ 1988
/ Reasons for welfare: The political theory of the welfare state
/ Princeton University Press
[book]
Government Social Research Unit
/ 2003
/ The magenta book: Guidance notes for policy evaluation and analysis, background paper 1: What is policy evaluation?
/ HM Treasury
[book]
Government Social Research Unit
/ 2004
/ The magenta book : Guidance notes for policy evaluation and analysis, background paper 8 : How do you know why(and how)something works? Qualitative methods of evaluation
/ HM Treasury
[book]
Greener, I.
/ 2013
/ The routledge handbook of the welfare state
/ Routledge
: 419~430
[journal]
Greener, I.
/ 2013
/ Introduction: Evidence and evaluation in social policy
/ Social Policy & Administration
47(4)
: 355~358
[book]
Goldenkoff, R.
/ 2004
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 340~362
[book]
Greve, B.
/ 2013
/ The routledge handbook of the Welfare State
/ Routledge
: 3~9
[journal]
Guba, E.
/ 1987
/ What have we learned about naturalistic evaluation?
/ Evaluation practice
8(2)
: 23~43
[journal]
Hartman, A.
/ 1990
/ Editorial: Many Ways of Knowing
/ Social Work
35(1)
: 3~4
[book]
Hatry, H.
/ 2004
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 547~570
[journal]
Healy, P.
/ 1986
/ Interpretive policy inquiry: A response to the limitations of the received view
/ Policy Sciences
19
: 381~396
[other]
House, E.
/ 2003
/ Qualitative evaluation and changing social policy
/ Unpublished paper
[thesis]
Hutchinson, I.
/ 2012
/ Reading complexity in social policy contexts: The value of Q methodology
/ Victoria University of Wellington
[journal]
Jessop, B.
/ 1999
/ The changing governance of welfare: Recent trends in its primary functions, scale and modes of coordination
/ Social Policy & Administration
33(4)
: 348~359
[journal]
Johansen, E.
/ 1986
/ Evaluation as social policy
/ Policy Studies Review
6(1)
: 26~35
[journal]
Klein, R.
/ 1982
/ Evaluation and social policy: Some reflections on ideas and institutions
/ Evaluation and Program Planning
5
: 133~140
[book]
Krueger, R.
/ 2010
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 404~423
[book]
Krueger, R.
/ 2010
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 378~403
[book]
Lasswell, H.
/ 1971
/ A Preview of policy sciences
/ American Elsevier
[book]
Love, A.
/ 2004
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 63~97
[book]
Macdonald, G.
/ 2000
/ What works?: Evidence-based policy and practice in public services
/ The Policy Press
: 117~140
[book]
Martinson, K.
/ 2010
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 163~181
[book]
McLaughlin, M.
/ 1985
/ Social science and social policy
/ Sage Publications
: 96~120
[journal]
Miller, M.
/ 1986
/ A conceptual and analytic framework for applied policy and evaluation research
/ Rural Sociology
51(3)
: 278~288
[book]
Myrdal, A.
/ 1968
/ Nation and family: The swedish experiment in democratic family and population policy
/ MIT Press
[book]
Newcomer, K.
/ 2004
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: xxxiii~xxxxvi
[book]
Newcomer, K.
/ 2010
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 5~29
[book]
Newman, K.
/ 2001
/ Studies of welfare populations: Data collections and research issues
/ Committee on National Statistics, National Research Council
: 55~383
[book]
Nutley, S.
/ 2000
/ What works?: Evidence-based policy and practice in public services
/ The Policy Press
: 13~41
[journal]
Österle, A.
/ 2002
/ Evaluating equity in social policy: A framework for comparative analysis
/ Evaluation
8(1)
: 46~59
[book]
Patton, M.
/ 2002
/ Qualitative research & evaluative methods
/ Sage Publications
[journal]
Peck, E.
/ 2001
/ The meanings of culture in health and social care: A case study of the combined trust in Somerset
/ Journal of Interprofessional Care
15(4)
: 319~327
[book]
Pierson, J.
/ 2013
/ The routledge handbook of the welfare state
/ Routledge
: 71~83
[journal]
Pleschberger, S.
/ 2011
/ Interviews on end-of-life care with older people: Reflections on six European studies
/ Qualitative Health Research
21(11)
: 1588~1600
[journal]
Pollitt, C.
/ 1990
/ No hiding place: On the discomforts of researching the contemporary policy process
/ Journal of Social Policy
19(2)
: 169~190
[journal]
Popay, J.
/ 1998
/ Rationale and standards for the systematic review of qualitative literature in health services research
/ Qualitative Health Research
8(3)
: 341~351
[web]
Pope, C.
/ 1995
/ Qualitative research: Reaching the parts other methods cannot reach:An introduction to qualitative methods in health and health services research
/ BMJ
/ www.bmj.com.ep.fjernadgang.kb.dk/cgi/content/full/311/6996
[book]
Pressman, J.
/ 1974
/ Implementation: How great expectations in Washington are dashed in Oakland
/ University of California Press
[book]
Rein, M.
/ 1983
/ Ethics, the social sciences and policy analysis
/ Plenum Press
: 83~111
[report]
Riccio, J.
/ 2001
/ Extending the reach of randomized social experiments: New directions in evaluations of american welfare-to-work and employment initiatives
/ Manpower Demonstration Research Corporation
[journal]
Rittel, H.
/ 1973
/ Dilemmas in a general theory of planning
/ Policy Sciences
4
: 155~169
[book]
Rogers, P.
/ 2010
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 429~453
[book]
Rossi, P.
/ 2004
/ Evaluation: A systematic approach
/ Sage Publications
[journal]
Sale, J.
/ 2002
/ Revisiting the quantitative-qualitative debate: Implications for mixed-methods research
/ Quality & Quantity
36
: 43~53
[journal]
Sanderson, I.
/ 2002
/ Evaluation, policy learning and evidence-based policy making
/ Public Administration
80(1)
: 1~22
[book]
Saunders, P.
/ 2013
/ The routledge handbook of the welfare state
/ Routledge
: 59~70
[report]
Saunders, P.
/ 1995
/ Evaluation and research in social policy
[journal]
Schaffer, B.
/ 1976
/ Comparing administrations: Researching and reforming
/ Public Administration Bulletin
: 2~24
[book]
Scheirer, M.
/ 1994
/ Handbook of practical program evaluation
/ Jossey-Bass
: 40~68
[book]
Schneider, A.
/ 1990
/ Policy theory and policy evaluation: Concepts, knowledge, causes and norms
/ Greenwood Press
: 77~102
[journal]
Schwandt, T.
/ 1997
/ Evaluation as practical hermeneutics
/ Evaluation
3(1)
: 69~83
[book]
Sechrest, L.
/ 1985
/ Social science and social policy
/ Sage Publications
: 63~95
[journal]
Shaw, I.
/ 2003
/ Qualitative research and outcomes in health, social work and education
/ Qualitative Research
3(1)
: 57~77
[journal]
Shura, R
/ 2011
/ Culture change in long-term care: Participatory action research and the role of the eesident
/ Gerontologist
51(2)
: 212~225
[journal]
Silva, Maria Ozanira da Silva e Silva.
/ 2011
/ Constructing a participatory approach for the evaluation of social policies and programmes
/ International Journal of Action Research
7(1)
: 101~125
[book]
Simons, H.
/ 2009
/ Case study research in practice
/ Sage Publications
[journal]
Smith, N.
/ 1987
/ Toward the justification of claims in evaluation research
/ Evaluation and Program Planning
10
: 309~314
[journal]
Stanley, L.
/ 1990
/ Doing ethnography, writing ethnography: A comment on hammersley
/ Sociology
24(4)
: 617~627
[journal]
Teater, B.
/ 2010
/ A qualitative evaluation of the section 8 housing choice voucher program: The recipients perspectives
/ Qualitative Social Work
10(4)
: 503~519
[journal]
Unrau, Y.
/ 1993
/ Expanding the role of program evaluation in social welfare policy analysis
/ Evaluation Review
17(6)
: 653~662
[journal]
Van de Walle, D.
/ 1998
/ Assessing the welfare impacts of public spending
/ World Development
26(3)
: 365~379
[journal]
Weiss, C.
/ 1995
/ The haphazard connection: Social science and public policy
/ International Journal of Educational Research
23(2)
: 137~150
[web]
/ 2014
/ 통계기반 정책평가 범위 1월부터 확대… 사후점검도 강화
/ www.newsis.com