A Study on the Request to Revise Errors of Errors in the Hwangmyungtonggi (「황명통기」 수록 곡필의 변무에 대한 연구)

Kim Dae Gyeong (김대경)

doi:10.17258/jib.2020..83.201

A Study on the Request to Revise Errors of Errors in the Hwangmyungtonggi

Journal of Studies in Bibliography
Abbr : JSB
2020, (83), pp.201~219
DOI : 10.17258/jib.2020..83.201
Publisher : Korean Society of Bibliography
Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science
Received : August 20, 2020
Accepted : September 18, 2020
Published : September 28, 2020

Kim Dae Gyeong ¹

¹동북아역사재단

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Hwangmyungtonggi chronicles the history of the Ming Dynasty focusing on “Gyungseron” and was re-published several times. It is a historical text with a wide readership, such that posterity added new content and revised the text in varying degrees. But there existed errors on Joseon’s history in the revised book. In particular, its errors on King Injo’s Restoration was a serious problem, sufficient to blemish the legitimacy of the dynasty. Joseon took this matter seriously and asked China to revise the errors several times, and China eventually revised them during the reign of King Yeongjo. Hence, this paper seeks to study the process of revision and the outcomes of this process using textual bibliography and history of historiography. Through these, this study seeks to clarify that Joseon’s desperate effort for correction was not simply a revision of errors in the historical record, but the manifestation of a neo-confucianist historical awareness.

KEYWORDS

Late Joseon Dynasty, Hwangmyungtonggi, King Injo’s Restoration, errors, request to revise errors

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[other] / 同文彙考

[other] / 東莞縣志

[other] / 明紀輯略

[other] / 承政院日記

[other] / 冶谷集

[other] / 兩朝從信錄

[other] / 朝鮮王朝實錄

[other] / 淸高宗實錄

[other] / 淸世宗實錄

[other] / 皇明十六朝廣彙紀

[other] / 皇明通紀

[other] / 皇明通紀輯要

[other] / 皇明通紀集要

[book] 강명관 / 2014 / 조선시대 책과 지식의 역사 / 천년의상상

[book] 천혜봉 / 2012 / 한국 금속활자 인쇄사 / 범우사

[book] 노경희 / 2007 / 명말 강남의 출판문화 / 소명출판

[book] 井上進 / 2013 / 중국 출판문화사 / 민음사

[book] 張秀民 / 2016 / 중국인쇄사(二) / 세창출판사

[book] 錢茂偉 / 2006 / 点校｢皇明通紀｣ / 中華書局

[journal] 강명관 / 1996 / 조선후기 서적의 수입․유통과 장서가의 출현 / 민족문학사연구 9 : 171~194

[thesis] 김대경 / 2019 / 조선후기 『황명통기집요』의 편찬과 유통 / 석사 / 한국학중앙연구원 한국학대학원

[journal] 부유섭 / 2011 / On the inflow of Chinese books, examined through the Yunhangrok of Chien Lung period / 대동한문학(大東漢文學) / 대동한문학회 (구.교남한문학회) (34) : 157~190

[journal] 부유섭 / 2010 / On the Inflow of Chinese Books into Chosun during the Kangxi-Yongzheng Era Seen in Yeonhaengrok / 漢文學報 / 우리한문학회 22 : 269~306

[journal] 부유섭 / 2013 / Book Circulation and Knowledge Reproduction of Jang-dong Kim Mun - Centered on books of Ming and Qing dynasties - / 민족문화 / 한국고전번역원 41 : 131~165

[journal] 신익철 / 2009 / Book Exchanges between Koreans and Chinese in the Early 18th Century: Focusing on the Records of Traveling to Beijing by Joseon Intellectuals / 태동고전연구 / 태동고전연구소 (25) : 227~264

[thesis] 안소라 / 2018 / 英祖代史冊辨誣에 관한 硏究 : "明史"의 朝鮮記事를 中心으로 / 성균관대학교 대학원 / 박사

[journal] 옥영정 / 2015 / An Exploratory Study on Book Collection of Joseon Missions to Imperial China and its Existing Old Books / 서지학연구 / 한국서지학회 (61) : 5~29

[journal] 유탁일 / 1991 / 古小說의 流通構造 / 동아어문논집 / 동아어문학회 1 : 5~17

[journal] 이민희 / 2008 / A Study on Book-Brokers and the Culture of Book Distribution in the 16th~19th Century in Korea and China / 동방학지 / 국학연구원 (141) : 323~363

[book] 이성규 / 1993 / 李公範敎授停年紀念東洋史論叢 : 503~568

[thesis] 장민영 / 2011 / 조선 영조대 '명기집략사건'의 정치적 성격 / 석사 / 서강대학교 대학원

[journal] 정길수 / 2004 / Gyujanggak / 규장각 / 규장각한국학연구원 (27) : 95~116

[journal] 정병설 / 2016 / Meaning of Pro-Chinese History Corrections in the Joseon Dynasty / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (116) : 250~276

[journal] 한명기 / 2002 / 17․8세기 韓中關係와 仁祖反正 / 한국사학보 13 : 9~41

[journal] 허태용 / 2007 / The Consolidation of Notion on Confucian-Cultural Succession and Compilation of historiographies on Chinese Song and Ming Dynasty in King Yeongjo and Jeongjo's reign period / 조선시대사학보 / 조선시대사학회 (42) : 237~269

[journal] 新宮學 / 2005 / 陳建"皇明資治通紀"の禁書とその續編出版(一) / 山形大學歴史․地理․人類學論集 6 : 65~77

[journal] 新宮學 / 2006 / 陳建"皇明資治通紀"の禁書とその續編出版(二) / 山形大學歴史․地理․人類學論集 7 : 111~138

[journal] 莊興亮 / 2013 / 明代史家陳建的學述生平及其｢皇明通紀｣硏究述評 / 史學史硏究 (4) : 27~38

[journal] 錢茂偉 / 2007 / ｢通纪｣歷史叙事的特点與成就 / 中國社会科學院研究生院學报 (5) : 129~134

[journal] 錢茂偉 / 2008 / 陳建｢通紀｣書名與版本考 / 古籍整理硏究學刊 2008(3) : 44~49

[journal] 錢茂偉 / 2009 / 明末清初明史编纂特点三論 / 史学月刊 2009(4) : 112~119

[journal] 孫衛國 / 1998 / ｢明紀輯略｣之東傳及其引發之事件－中韓書籍交流史研究之一例 / 書目季刊 1998(2) : 60~65

[journal] 孫衛國 / 2009 / ｢皇明通紀｣及其續補諸書對朝鮮之影響 / 中國史硏究 2009(2) : 27~38

[journal] 楊緖敏 / 2010 / ｢大明會典｣｢明史｣與朝鮮辨誣 / 南開學報 2010(2) : 79~139

[journal] 楊艷秋 / 2014 / ｢皇明通紀｣續補諸作考述 / 古籍整理硏究學刊 2014(1) : 31~35

[journal] 楊艷秋 / 2016 / ｢皇明通紀輯要｣與朝鮮王朝的經筵進講 / 南開學報 2016(5) : 90~102

[journal] 向燕南 / 1993 / 陳建｢皇明資治通紀｣的與編纂特點及影響 / 史學史硏究 1993(1) : 48~56

[web] / 국사편찬위원회 한국사데이터베이스 승정원일기 / http://sjwhistory.go.kr

[web] / 국사편찬위원회 한국사데이터베이스 조선왕조실록 / http://sillokhistory.go.kr/main

[web] / 국사편찬위원회 한국사데이터베이스 청실록 / http://sillokhistory.go.kr/mc

[web] / 한국고전적종합목록시스템 / https://www.nl.go.kr/korcis/

[web] / 한국고전종합DB / http://db.itkc.or.kr/

[web] / 全國漢籍データベース / http://kanji.zinbun.kyoto-u.ac.jp

[web] / 高校古文献資源庫读者检索系统 / http://rbsc.calis.edu.cn:8086

[web] / 중국학술정보원 CNKI / http://gb.oversea.cnki.net/Kns55

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Studies in Bibliography 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.65

A Study on the Request to Revise Errors of Errors in the Hwangmyungtonggi

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of Studies in Bibliography 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.65

A Study on the Request to Revise Errors of Errors in the Hwangmyungtonggi

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (1)

REFERENCES (55) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.