Korean Review of French History 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.67
-
pISSN : 1229-702X
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/krfh
KJCKorea
Journal Central
The Paris Commune of 1871 and the Semaine sanglante viewed from the discussions about the death toll in the Semaine sanglante
- Korean Review of French History
- Abbr : KRFH
- 2021, (45), pp.5~44
- DOI : 10.51786/RCHF.2021.08.45.5
- Publisher : KOREAN SOCIETY FOR FRENCH HISTORY
- Research Area : Humanities > History
- Received : July 30, 2021
- Accepted : August 18, 2021
- Published : August 31, 2021
1한국해양대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
2021 is 150th anniversary of the Paris Commune of 1871, and so I review the discussions about the death toll of the Semaine sanglante and its significance, to which I have not paid attention proper so far. Robert Tombs, the British historian of the Paris Commune, has suggested the number of the persons killed during the Semaine sanglante to be about 5,000-7,000 by finding and analysing tightly the new relevant sources. Some historians has remarked the insufficiencies of his estimation suggesting the necessity of its supplements, but no article that would refute completely it has published. However, it is difficult for me to accept his attempts to give the distinct meanings from the Paris Commune to the Semaine sanglante. Nevertheless, I become realized that the Commune needs to be set in the context of ‘Civil war’ by reviewing these discussions.
Statistics
-
446 Viewed
-
1 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
노서경
/ 2018
/
‘La Misère,’ the Women of Commune, and the representation of Louise Michel & André Leo (1871)
/ 서양사연구
/ 한국서양사연구회
(59)
: 83~120
[book]
알랭 코르뱅
/ 2002
/ 시간, 욕망, 그리고 공포
/ 동문선
[book]
칼 마르크스
/ 1991
/ 프랑스 혁명사 3부작(개정판)
/ 소나무
[thesis]
현재열
/ 2000
/ 빠리 꼬뮈나르의 정체성과 이데올로기
/ 박사
/ 부산대학교 대학원
[journal]
현재열
/ 2004
/
Comparaison par catégories des actions
des Communardes de 1871
/ 프랑스사 연구
/ 한국프랑스사학회
(10)
: 3~3
[journal]
현재열
/ 2011
/ 실현된 유토피아 1871년 파리코뮌의 현재성
/ 문화과학
(68)
[journal]
현재열
/ 2019
/
French Division and Integration in the Paris Commune and the Early Third Republic (1871-1880)
/ 역사와경계
/ 부산경남사학회
(111)
: 431~481
[book]
Boime, Albert
/ 1995
/ Art and the French Commune: Imagining Paris after War and Reaction
/ Princeton University Press
[book]
Bourgin, Georges
/ 1971
/ La guerre de 1870-1871 et la Commune
/ Flammarion
[book]
Cavaterra, Eric
/ 2000
/ La Banque de France et la Commune de Paris
/ L’harmattan
[book]
Conte, Gérard
/ 1981
/ Eléments pour une histoire de la Commune dans le XIIIe arrondissement 5 mars-25 mai 1871
/ Editions de la Butte aux Cailles
[book]
Cordillot, Michel
/ 2021
/ La Commune de Paris 1871: Les Acteurs, L’Evénements, Les Lieux
/ Editions de L’Atelier
[book]
Dalotel, Alain
/ 1980
/ Aux origines de la Commune: Le mouvement des réunions publiques à Paris 1868-1870
/ François Maspero
[journal]
Dalotel, Alain
/ 1989
/ La place de la Semaine sanglante dans la commémoration de la Commune en France
/ Révolutiuons et mutaions au XIXe siècle
(5)
[journal]
Deluermoz, Quentin
/ 2011
/ Le morts de la Semaine sanglante: retour sur la violence sociale et politique française au XIXe siècle. Commentary on Robert Tombs’s ‘How Bloody was la Semaine Sanglante? A revision’
/ H-France Salon
3(1)
[book]
Deluermoz, Quentin
/ 2020
/ Une traversée des mondes au XIXe siècle
/ Editions de Seuil
[book]
Deluermoz, Quentin
/ 2021
/ La Commune de Paris 1871: Les Acteurs, L’Evénements, Les Lieux
/ Editions de L’Atelier
[book]
Deluermoz, Quentin
/ 2021
/ La Commune de Paris 1871: Les Acteurs, L’Evénements, Les Lieux
/ Editions de L’Atelier
[book]
Deluermoz, Quentin
/ 2021
/ La Commune de Paris 1871: Les Acteurs, L’Evénements, Les Lieux
/ Editions de L’Atelier
[other]
/ “Discussion”, Le Mouvement social 79: <Colloque universitaire pour la commémoration du centenaire de la Commune de 1871>
[book]
Edwards, Stewart
/ 1971
/ The Paris Commune 1871
/ Eyre & Spotiswoode
[book]
Eichner, Carolyn J
/ 2004
/ Surmounting the Barricades: Women in the Paris Commune
/ Indiana University Press
[book]
Fournier, Eric
/ 2008
/ Paris en ruine: Du Paris haussmannien au Paris communard
/ Imago
[book]
Furet, François
/ 1992
/ Revolutionary France 1770-1880
/ Blackwell
[book]
Godineau, Laure
/ 2010
/ La Commune de Paris par ceux qui l’on vécue
/ Parigramme
[book]
Gould, Roger V
/ 1995
/ Insurgent Identities: Class, Community and Protest in Paris from 1848 to the Commune
/ University of Chicago Press
[book]
Gullickson, Gay L
/ 1996
/ Unruly Women of Paris: Images of the Commune
/ Cornell University Press
[book]
Haupt, Georges
/ 1986
/ Aspects of International Socialism 1871-1914
/ Cambridge University Press
[book]
Horne, Alistair
/ 1990
/ The Fall of Paris: The Siege and the Commune 1870-71
/ Macmillan
[book]
Johnson, Martin Phillip
/ 1996
/ The Paradise of Association: Political Culture and Popular Organization in the Paris Commune of 1871
/ University of Chicago Press
[journal]
Labrousse, Ernest
/ 1972
/ Conclusion générale
/ Le Mouvement social
(79)
[journal]
Lagana, Marc
/ 2018
/ Un Peuple révolutionnaire: la Commune de Paris 1871
/ Cahiers Bruxellois
[web]
Larrère, Mathilde
/ 2021
/ “Quand la Commune prend les murs”, Cahiers d’histoire. Revue d’histoire critique, No. 148
/ https://journals.openedition.org/chrhc/15521
[journal]
Maitron, Jean
/ 1972
/ Etude critique du rapport Appert, essai de ‘contre-rapport’
/ Le Mouvement social
(79)
[book]
Merriman, John
/ 2014
/ Massacre: The Life and Death of the Paris Commune of 1871
/ Yale University Press
[book]
Moissonnier, Maurice
/ 1971
/ La Nouvelle Critique
/ Mars
[book]
Noël, Bernard
/ 1978
/ Dictionniare de la Commune, Vols. 2
/ Flammarion
[journal]
Nord, Philip
/ 1987
/ The Party of Conciliation and the Paris Commune
/ French Historical Studies
(15)
[book]
Osterhammel, Jürgen
/ 2014
/ The Transformation of the World: A Global History of the Nineteenth Century
/ Princeton University Press
[book]
Quaretti, J
/ 2000
/ La Commune de 1871: Utopie ou modernité?
/ Presse Universitaire de Perpignan
[book]
Rials, Stéphane
/ 1985
/ Nouvelle histoire de Paris: De Trochu à Thiers 1870-1873
/ Hachette
[book]
Ross, Kristin
/ 1988
/ The Emergence of Social Space: Rimbaud and the Paris Commune
/ Macmillan
[journal]
Rougerie, Jacques
/ 1964
/ Composition d’une population insurgée: la Commune
/ Le Mouvement social
(48)
[book]
Rougerie, Jacques
/ 1971
/ Paris libre, 1871
/ Editions de Seuil
[journal]
Rougerie, Jacques
/ 1972
/ L’A.I.T. et le mouvement ouvrier à Paris pendant les événements de 1870-1871
/ International Review of Social History
(17)
[book]
Rougerie, Jacques
/ 1988
/ La Commune de 1871
/ PUF
[book]
Rougerie, Jacques
/ 1995
/ Paris insurgé-La Commune de 1871
/ Gallimard
[book]
Serman, Willam
/ 1986
/ La Commune de Paris(1871)
/ Fayard
[journal]
De Swaan, Abram
/ 2001
/ Dyscivilization, Mass Extermination and State
/ Thoery, Culture and Society
18(2-3)
[book]
Thomas, Edith
/ 1963
/ Les “Pétroleuses”
/ Gallimard
[book]
Tillier, Bertrand
/ 2004
/ La Commune de Paris, révolution sasns images? Politique et representation dans la France républicaine, 1871-1914
/ Champ Vallon
[book]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1981
/ The War Against Paris 1871
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1984
/ Harbingers or entrepreneurs? A Workers’ Cooperative during the Paris Commune
/ Historical Journal
27(4)
[journal]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1871
/ Paris and the Rural Hordes: An Exploration of Myth and Reality in the French Civil War of 1871
/ Historical Journal
29(4)
[journal]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1848
/ Victimes et bourreaux de la semaine sanglante
/ Révolutions et mutation au XIXe siècle
(10)
[book]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1997
/ La guerre contre Paris 1871
/ Aubier
[book]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1997
/ La barricade
/ Editions de la Sorbonne
[book]
Tombs, Robert
/ 1999
/ The Paris Commune 1871
/ Longman
[confproc]
Tombs, Robert
/ 2011
/ How bloody was la Semaine Sanglante? A revision
/ Paper presented at 57th Annual Meeting of the Society for French Historial Studies
3(1)
: 3~
[journal]
Tombs, Robert
/ 2011
/ Response to Commentaries
/ H-France Salon
3(1)
[journal]
Tombs, Robert
/ 2012
/ How Bloody was ‘La Semaine Sanglante’ of 1971? A Revision
/ The Historical Journal
55(3)
[journal]
Varley, Karine
/ 2011
/ Reassessing the Paris Commune of 1871: A Response to Robert Tombs, ‘How Bloody was the Semaine Sanglante? A Revision’
/ H-France Salon
3(1)
[book]
Willard, Claude
/ 1999
/ La Commune de Paris aujourd’hui, sous la coordination de Jacuqes Zwirn
/ Editions de l’Atelier
[book]
Wilson, Colette E
/ 2007
/ Paris and the Commune, 1871-78: The Politics of Forgetting
/ Mancester University Press
[book]
Zaidman, Pierre-Henri
/ 2021
/ La Commune de Paris 1871: Les Acteurs, L’Evénements, Les Lieux
/ Editions de L’Atelier