Policy Dispute in a Free Trade Agreement: A Case study of Investor-State Dispute Settlement (FTA 시대의 정책분쟁 연구: 투자자-국가간 분쟁(ISD) 사례 분석을 통한 발생 구조 탐색)

Kim Se Hoon (김세훈); Kim Jong Ho (김종호)

Policy Dispute in a Free Trade Agreement: A Case study of Investor-State Dispute Settlement

Korean Society and Public Administration
Abbr : KSPA
2008, 19(1), pp.261-282
Publisher : Seoul Association For Public Administration
Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration

Kim Se Hoon ¹, Kim Jong Ho ²

¹한국과학기술정보연구원
²경희대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Korea and the U.S. come to a settlement on Free Trade Agreement. The FTA will include investment chapter which is similar to the NAFTA investment chapter. The NAFTA investment chapter provides investors with strong investment protection and an arbitration mechanism to resolve disputes between an investor and the state. Since it was combined with FTA in the NAFTA, it has construed one of the most powerful mechanism to enforce provisions of investment agreements and to protect transnational capitals. This paper studies on the NAFTA investment dispute cases and considers their policy implications for Korea. Korea government has to increase its ability to manage the investor-state disputes effectively.

KEYWORDS

Policy Dispute, ISD(investor-state disputes settlement), KORUS FTA

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 강재권 / 2007 / WTO 분쟁해결 제도, 그것이 궁금하다 / 나라경제 / 한국개발연구원 202 : 82~84

[journal] 김관호 / 2006 / FTA and Investment Disputes / 국제통상연구 / 한국국제통상학회 11(1) : 77~98

[journal] 김관호 / 2007 / Investment Treaty Claims against Argentina / 국제지역연구 / 국제지역학회 11(1) : 399~420

[journal] 김인철 / 2007 / 대니 로드릭(Dani Rodirik)의 산업정책론과 한국 산업정책에 대한 시사점 / KIET 산업경제 : 43~54

[journal] 김종호 / 2006 / 한미 FTA의 영향과 협상의 중요성 / 아태 쟁점과 연구 / 한양대학교 아태지역연구센터 1(4) : 65~77

[confproc] 박경 / 2006 / 한미 FTA와 지역문제 in:한미FTA, 세계화 그리고 한국사회의 대안적 발전 전략 심포지움 자료집 / 한미FTA, 세계화 그리고 한국사회의 대안적 발전 전략 심포지움 / 학술단체협의회

[book] 송기호 / 2007 / 한미FTA 핸드북 / 녹색평론사

[book] 송호창 / 2007 / 투자자 국가 제소권(ISD)에 대한 헌법?법률적 평가 in:국회 간담회(2007. 8. 17)자료집

[book] 이성봉 / 2006 / 한미 FTA 투자분야 주요 쟁점이슈와 평가 / 대외경제정책연구원

[journal] 이재민 / 2006 / An Inquiry into the Investor State Dispute Settlement Procedure / 서울국제법연구 / 서울국제법연구원 13(2) : 103~109

[journal] 한상희 / 2007 / The Challenge to Constitutionalism of the New World Trade Regime-Some Critics on the Investor-State Dispute Settlement System of the KORUS FTA- / 법과사회 / 법과사회이론학회 (32) : 227~261

[book] 홍기빈 / 2006 / 투자자 국가 직접소송제 / 녹색평론사

[confproc] 전창환 / 2006 / 한미 FTA 협상 결정의 배경과 그 파장 in:한미 FTA 심포지움 자료집 / 한미 FTA 심포지움 / 대안연대회의

[journal] 정인교 / 2005 / 세계 지역주의 추세와 우리나라 FTA 추진정책 / 농정연구 / (사)농정연구센터

[journal] 최원목 / 2008 / 우리나라의 FTA 정책의 평가와 과제 / Neogotiations and Korea / 한국협상학회 1(1) : 28~30

[book] Harvey,D / 2005 / A Brief History of Neoliberalism / Oxford University Press

[book] Pastor,A.Robert / 2001 / Toward a North American Community: Lessons from the Old World for the New / Institute for International Economics

[book] Public Citizen / 2005 / NAFTA's Threat to Sovereignty and Democracy / Public Citizens Global Trade Watch

[book] Schott,Jeffrey J / 2007 / The Korea-US Free Trade Agreement: A Summary Assessment / Policy Brief 07-7, Washington, D.C: Peterson Institute

[other] Sornarajah, M. / 2003 / “Affidavit”in support of Canadian Union of Postal Workers(CUPW)'s application to the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Court File No. 01-CV-208141

[journal] Van Harten,Gus / 2005a / Private Authority and Transnational Governance: The Contours of the International System of Investor Protection / Review of International Political Economy 12(4)

[journal] Van Harten,Gus / 2005b / Judicial Supervision of NAFTA Chapter 11 Arbitration: Public or Private Law / Arbitration International 21(4)

[web] / Nafta Claims Web Site / Nafta Claims Web Site / http://www.naftaclaims.com_updated 29 January 2008

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korean Society and Public Administration 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.89