Analysis and Modeling of Essential Concepts and Process for Peer-Reviewing Data Paper (데이터논문 동료심사를 위한 핵심 개념 분석과 프로세스 모델링)

Sungsoo Ahn (안성수); Sung-Nam Cho (조성남); Youngim Jung (정영임)

doi:10.16981/kliss.54.3.202309.321

Analysis and Modeling of Essential Concepts and Process for Peer-Reviewing Data Paper

Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society
Abbr : JKLISS
2023, 54(3), pp.321-346
DOI : 10.16981/kliss.54.3.202309.321
Publisher : Korean Library And Information Science Society
Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science
Received : August 22, 2023
Accepted : September 20, 2023
Published : September 30, 2023

Sungsoo Ahn ¹, Sung-Nam Cho ², Youngim Jung ²

¹경상국립대학교 항공우주및소프트웨어공학부
²한국과학기술정보연구원

Accredited

ABSTRACT

A data paper describing research data helps credit researchers producing the data while helping other researchers verify previous research and start new research by reusing the data. Publishing a data paper and depositing data to a public data repository are increasing with these benefits. A domestic academic society that plans to publish data papers faces challenges, including timely acquiring tremendous knowledge concerning data paper structures and templates, peer review policy and process, and trustworthy data repositories, as a data paper has different characteristics, unlike a research paper. However, the need for more research and information concerning the critical elements of data paper and the peer-review process makes it difficult to operate for data paper review and publication. To address these issues, we propose essential concepts of the data paper and the data paper peer-review, including the process model of the peer-review with in-depth analysis of five data journals’ data paper templates, articles, and other guides worldwide. Academic societies intending to publish or add data papers as a new type of paper may establish policies and define a peer-review process by adopting the proposed conceptual models, effectively streamlining the preparation of data paper publication.

KEYWORDS

Data Paper, Elements, Essential Concepts, Peer Review, Process, Modeling

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[confproc] 김기동 / 2023 / GEO DATA 저널 데이터 논문 동료심사 현황 / 2023년 GeoAI데이터학회 춘계컨퍼런스 논문집 : 89~89

[journal] 서태설 / 2022 / 데이터 공유에서 데이터 출판으로 / KCSE Newsletter 41 : 9~12

[confproc] 이현정 / 2023 / 학술지 대상 데이터 공유/데이터 논문 정책 및 인식조사 / 2023년GeoAI데이터학회 춘계컨퍼런스 논문집 : 82~82

[journal] 정영임 / 2020 / A Study on the Strategies for Publishing Data Journals in the Field of Ecology: Focused on K Institution / 한국도서관·정보학회지 / 한국도서관·정보학회 51(4) : 83~100

[confproc] 정영임 / 2022 / 데이터 논문 출판 현황 분석 / 데이터출판 세미나 / 국립중앙도서관

[journal] 정용일 / 2022 / A Study on Science and Technology Scholarly Societies’ Understanding on Open Peer Review / 한국콘텐츠학회 논문지 / 한국콘텐츠학회 22(10) : 59~73

[confproc] 한종규 / 2023 / 지구과학분야 연구데이터 출판 현황 / 2023년 GeoAI데이터학회 춘계컨퍼런스논문집 : 88~88

[journal] 황혜경 / 2023 / A Study on Awareness and Experience of Data Publishing by Scientists / 한국도서관·정보학회지 / 한국도서관·정보학회 54(1) : 45~68

[confproc] Ahn, R. / 2021 / Validating business problem hypotheses: a goal-oriented and machine learning-based approach / International Conference on Big Data / Springer International Publishing : 17~33

[book] Booch, G. / 2005 / Unified Modeling Language User Guide, Addison-Wesley Object Technology Series

[journal] Candela, L. / 2015 / Data journals : a survey / Journal of the Association for Information Science and Technology 66(9) : 1747~1762

[book] Carpenter, T. / 2017 / What constitutes peer review of data? A survey of peer review guidelines / The Scholarly Kitchen

[journal] Chavan, V. / 2011 / The data paper : a mechanism to incentivize data publishing in biodiversity science / BMC bioinformatics 12 : 1~12

[book] Elmasri, R. / 2015 / Fundamentals of Database Systems / Pearson

[journal] Gomes, D. G. / 2022 / Why don't we share data and code? perceived barriers and benefits to public archiving practices / Proceedings of the Royal Society B 289(1987)

[journal] 김수영 / 2019 / Current and planned adoption of data sharing policies by editors of Korean scholarly journals / Science Editing / 한국과학학술지편집인협의회 6(1) : 19~24

[journal] Lawrence, B. / 2011 / Citation and peer review of data : moving towards formal data publication / International Journal of Digital Curation 6(2) : 4~37

[journal] Mylopoulos, J. / 1999 / From object-oriented to goal-oriented requirements analysis / Communications of the ACM 42(1) : 31~37

[journal] Tedersoo, L. / 2021 / Data sharing practices and data availability upon request differ across scientific disciplines / Scientific Data 8(1) : 192~

[book] White, S. A. / 2011 / BPMN 2.0 Handbook: Methods, Concepts, Case Studies and Standards in Business Process Management Notation / Future Strategies Inc., Book Division

[journal] Wilkinson, M. D. / 2016 / The FAIR Guiding Principles for scientific data management and stewardship / Scientific Data 3(1) : 1~9

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.02

Analysis and Modeling of Essential Concepts and Process for Peer-Reviewing Data Paper

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.02

Analysis and Modeling of Essential Concepts and Process for Peer-Reviewing Data Paper

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)

REFERENCES (21) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.