Informatization Policy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 4.08
-
pISSN : 1598-3498
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/nia
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Study on Ex-post Regulation of Zero-rating Service - Comparative Legal Study on Relevant Laws and NRA’s Decisions Between Domestic and Overseas Countries -
- Informatization Policy
- Abbr : 정보화정책
- 2019, 26(1), pp.83-105
- DOI : 10.22693/NIAIP.2019.26.1.083
- Publisher : NIA
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy
- Received : September 29, 2018
- Accepted : December 18, 2018
- Published : March 29, 2019
Cho， Dae-Keun 1, Hong, JoonHyung 2
1㈜잉카리서치앤컨설팅
2서울대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study is to analyze the domestic and overseas laws and regulators’ decisions related to zero-rating (ZR) practices through a comparative approach and to support development of the ex-post regulation. Although most countries are adopting ex-post regulatory approaches toward the globally increasing ZR practices, there is no uniform standards or an approach to consider when deciding whether to allow mobile ISPs' zero-rating practices in the market. However, in recent years, some countries have been improving their policy transparency with respect to ZR through enacting and amending relevant laws as well as making trial decisions. The comparative analysis shows that each country investigates restriction of the user choice and ISPs' adherence to the obligation of non-discrimination in order to judge whether the user benefits are damaged by the ZR practices. It also investigates ISP-CP's market positioning and ISP’s vertical integration for profit squeeze to find out whether they harm fair competition with ZR practices in the mobile ecosystem. Based on the results of the comparative analysis, we suggest the desirable ZR regulatory directions under the domestic legislative status.
Statistics
-
311 Viewed
-
1 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[other]
ACM
/ 2017
/ Ons kenmerk: ACM/DTVP/2017/205487_OV, Zaaknummer: 17.0475.53, Sep 26 2017
[other]
Ahn, C.
/ 2018
/ It is predicted that zero-rating debate faces rough going in win-win council on the Internet industry
/ Newstomato
[journal]
Ard, B.
/ 2016
/ Beyond Neutrality: How Zero Rating Can (Sometimes) Advance User Choice, Innovation, and Democratic Participation
/ L. Rev
984
[report]
Belli, L.
/ 2016
/ Net Neutrality reloaded : Zero Rating, specialised service, ad blocking and traffic management
/ FGV Direito Rio
: 227~
[other]
BEREC
/ 2016
/ BEREC Guidelineson the Implementation by National Regulators of European Net Neutrality Rules
/ BEREC
[report]
BEREC
/ 2017
/ Report on the implementation of Regulation (EU) 2015/2120 and BEREC Net Neutrality Guidelines
/ BEREC
[journal]
Berglind, O.
/ 2016
/ The Effect of Zero-Rating on Mobile Broadband Demand: An Empirical Approach and Potential Implications
/ International Journal of Communication
10
: 2442~2459
[other]
BIPT
/ 2017
/ Verslag Betreffende de Analyse Van de ZERO RATING Van Apps in de Aandiedingen Van PROXIMUS
[book]
Brake, D.
/ 2016
/ Net Neutrality Reloaded: Zero Rating, Specialised Service, Ad Blocking and Traffic Management
/ FGV
: 132~154
[other]
Brodkin, J.
/ 2015
/ T-Mobile’s data CP exemption for video gets FCC chairman’s approval-Wheeler:T-Mobile zero-rating is “pro-competition” and “pro-innovation
/ Ars Technica
[journal]
Carrillo, A. J.
/ 2016
/ Having Your Cake and Eating it Too? Zero-Rating, Net Neutrality and International Law
/ Stanford Technology Law Review
[other]
Case, C.
/ 1978
/ 27/76, United Brands Company and United Brands Continental BV v. Commission, [1978] ECR, 207
[journal]
조대근
/ 2017
/
A Study on the Strategy of Platform Operator for Free Mobile Data : from the Perspectives of Business Opportunity and Risk
/ 인터넷정보학회논문지
/ 한국인터넷정보학회
18(5)
: 123~131
[journal]
조대근
/ 2017
/
A Study on the Validity of Net Neutrality Regulation in Respect of Zero-Rating
/ 인터넷정보학회논문지
/ 한국인터넷정보학회
18(5)
: 133~141
[journal]
Choi, J.
/ 1995
/ Comparative Methodology in the Studies of Law
/ Journal of Cross-Cultural Studies
(2)
: 143~166
[book]
Chung. H.
/ 2016
/ Competition and Consumer Law
/ Pak Young Sa
[web]
CRTC
/ 2017
/ Framework for assessing the differential pricing practices of Internet service providers
/ Telecom Regulatory Policy CRTC
/ https://crtc.gc.ca/eng/archive/2017/2017-104.pdf
[other]
/ 2017
/ Detailed Criteria on unjust behaviors of imposing unreasonable and discriminatory condition and restriction between operators(KCC Ordinance 2017-4) Enforcement Date August 16. 2017
[report]
Eisenach, J. A.
/ 2015
/ The Economics of Zero Rating
/ NERA
[other]
EU
/ 2015
/ Regulation (EU) 2015/2120 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 25 November 2015 laying down measures concerning open internet access and amending Directive 2002/22/EC on universal service and users’ rights relating to electronic communications networks and services and Regulation (EU) No 531/2012on roaming on public mobile communications networks within the Union
/ European Union:Official Journal of the European Union
[other]
European Commission
/ 2017
/ Zero-rating practices in broadband markets
/ DirectorateGeneral for Competition(European Commission)
[web]
European Commission Fact Sheet
/ 2015
/ Roaming charges and open Internet: questions and answers
/ http://europa.eu/rapid/press-release_MEMO-15-5275_en.htm
[web]
FCC
/ 2017
/ Wireless Telecommunications Bureau Report: Policy Review of Mobile Broadband Operators’Sponsored Data Offerings for ZeroRated Content and Services
/ https://www.fcc.gov/document/release-report-policy-reviewmobile-zero-rating-practices
[web]
FCC
/ 2017
/ Chairman Pai Statement on free data programs
/ https://www.fcc.gov/document/statement-chairman-pai-free-data-programs
[other]
FCC
/ 2018
/ Restoring Internet Freedom, 47 CFR Parts 1, 8, and 20 [WC Docket No. 17-108;FCC 17-166]
/ Federal Register
[journal]
Gerpott, T.
/ 2018
/ Zero-rating arrangements of mobile Internet access service providers - An analysis of main factors shaping the need for regulatory interventions
/ Telecommunications Policy
42(6)
: 489~500
[journal]
Laure Jaunaux
/ 2017
/ Zero Rating and End Users' Freedom of Choice: An Economic Analysis
/ SSRN Electronic Journal
/ Elsevier BV
[journal]
Kim, H.
/ 2010
/ Characteristics of the Telecommunication Market and Ex Post Regulation of Anticompetitive Conducts in the Telecommunications Business Act
/ Journal of Law & Economic Regulation
3(2)
: 55~71
[journal]
김상찬
/ 2009
/
A Comparative Legal Study on ADR - Focusing on Major Asian Countries -
/ 중재연구
/ 한국중재학회
19(3)
: 67~91
[journal]
김윤정
/ 2012
/
Common Carrier’s Non-discriminatory Obligation and the Regulation Changes under the US Communications Act
/ 경제규제와 법
/ 법학연구소
5(2)
: 37~61
[journal]
고형석
/ 2012
/
A Study on the Right of Withdrawal in the EU Consumer Rights Directive
/ 법학논총
/ 법학연구소
29(4)
: 263~300
[other]
Korea Communications Commission
/ 2018
/ Win-Win council on the Internet industry, Submitted policy recommendation report to KCC
[other]
Korea Communications Commission
/ 2017
/ Prohibiting unfair behaviors between operators using superior position-KCC has established 「Detailed Criteria on unjust behaviors of imposing unreasonable and discriminatory condition and restriction between operators」
[report]
Krämer, J.
/ 2018
/ A Fresh Look at ZeroRating
/ Centre on Regulation in Europe
[journal]
Landes, W.
/ 1981
/ Market Power in Antitrust Cases
/ Harvard Law Review
94(5)
: 937~996
[journal]
Roslyn Layton
/ 2015
/ Zero Rating: Do Hard Rules Protect or Harm Consumers and Competition? Evidence from Chile, Netherlands and Slovenia
/ SSRN Electronic Journal
/ Elsevier BV
[other]
Nkom
/ 2016
/ Analysis of the market for access and call origination on public mobile telephone networks
/ Norway Nkom
[other]
Nkom
/ 2017
/ Vurdering av Telias nulltakseringstilbud 《Music Freedom》, Sak 1703653, 18. desember 2017
/ Norway Nkom
[web]
NMHH
/ 2016
/ NMHH decision on non-discriminatory Internet
/ http://english.nmhh.hu/article/172521/NMHH_decision_on_nondiscriminatory_Internet
[other]
Ofcom
/ 2018
/ Monitoring compliance with the EU Net Neutrality regulation A report to the European Commission
/ Ofcom
[other]
Ofcom
/ 2018
/ Own initiative investigation into Hutchison 3G UK Limited (Three)’s compliance with the net neutrality and roaming regulations, August, 02(Case reference: CW/01218/04/18)
[other]
Ofcom
/ 2018
/ Own-initiative investigation into Vodafone’s traffic management practices, and other practices covered by the EU Open Internet Access Regulation, August, 02(Case reference: CW/01219/04/18)
[journal]
Roslyn Layton
/ 2015
/ Zero Rating: Do Hard Rules Protect or Harm Consumers and Competition? Evidence from Chile, Netherlands and Slovenia
/ SSRN Electronic Journal
/ Elsevier BV
37
[journal]
Rossini, C.
/ 2015
/ Exploring ZeroRating Challenges: Views from Five Countries
/ Public Knowledge
28
[web]
Sørensen, F.
/ 2014
/ Net neutrality and charging models
/ Nkom
/ http://eng.nkom.no/topical-issues/news/net-neutrality-and-chargingmodels
[book]
Sørensen, F.
/ 2016
/ Net Neutrality Compendium
/ Springer
: 231~239
[other]
Szczepański, M.
/ 2017
/ The new European electronic communications code., Briefing EU Legislation in Progress
/ European Parliamentary Research Service
[other]
/ 2017
/ Table 4 Types of and standards for prohibited acts in Enforcement Decree of the Telecommunications Business Act
/ Presidential Decree No.27789
[other]
/ 1993
/ Telecommunications Act (S.C. 1993, c. 38)
[other]
/ 2018
/ Telecommunications Business Act, [Act No.14576, March 13. 2017]
[web]
/ Telenor Homepage
/ https://www.telenor.no/privat/mobil/yng/
[web]
TRAI
/ 2016
/ TRAI Releases the 'Prohibition of Discriminatory Tariffs for Data Services Regulations, 2016
/ http://www.trai.gov.in/sites/default/files/Press_Release_No_13_28_08-02-2016.pdf
[journal]
Van Schewick, B.
/ 2015
/ Network Neutrality and Zerorating, Attachment to Barbara van Schewick's Ex Parte in the Matter of Protecting and Promoting the Open Internet submitted February
19
: 14~28
[report]
Van Schewick, B.
/ 2016
/ T-Mobile’s Binge On Violates Key Net Neutrality Principles
/ Stanford Law School’s Center for Internet and Society
[other]
Yang, T.
/ 2017
/ 플랫폼 중립성·제로레이팅 ‘탄력’ 예고방통위 포털 차별행위 규제-제로레이팅 소비자 편익증가-
/ 아이뉴스24
[other]
Yoo, C.
/ 2016
/ Christopher Yoo’s E-mail to Ms. Vinod Kotwal Advisor (F&EA) Telecom Regulatory Authority of India
[book]
Jeitschko, T.
/ 2017
/ Zero-rating and vertical content foreclosure
/ Michigan State University
[report]
Somogyi, R.
/ 2017
/ The economics of zero-rating and net neutrality. Unpublished manuscript
/ Université catholique de Louvain, Center for Operations Research and Econometrics