Strafrecht als Botanik/ Die Anspruchlosigkeit des awissenschaftlichen Strafrechts (미국 형법교수가 본 독일 형법과 미국 형법의 특징)

Son, Mi-Suk (손미숙)

Strafrecht als Botanik/ Die Anspruchlosigkeit des awissenschaftlichen Strafrechts

DONG-A LAW REVIEW
2012, (55), pp.401~422
Publisher : The Institute for Legal Studies Dong-A University
Research Area : Social Science > Law

Son, Mi-Suk ¹

¹홍익대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

이 글은 토론토 대학교 마쿠스 두버교수가 독일 형법과 미국 형법의 특색에 관하여 쓴 글인 “식물학으로서의 형법학”(Strafrecht als Botanik, in: Empirische und dogmatische Fundamente, kriminalpolitischer Impetus. Symposium für Bernd Schünemann zum 60. Geburtstag. Herausgegeben von Roland Hefendehl, Köln, Berlin, München 2005, 245—256면)과 “학문성을 원치 않는 형법의 단순성”(Die Anspruchlosigkeit des awissenschaftlichen Strafrechts, ZStW 121 (2009), 977—984면)이라는 두 논문의 번역이다. 우리나라 독자들의 이해를 돕기 위해 두 논문을 “미국 형법교수가 본 독일 형법과 미국 형법의 특징”이라는 제목 하에 하나로 묶었다: 제1장은 독일 형법의 특징에 관한 것이며, 제2장은 미국 형법의 특징에 관한 것이다; 제2장은 또 두버교수가 2009년 5월 독일 형법교수들 학회(Strafrechtslehrertagung)에서 미국 형법학과 미국 형사사법의 관계에 대해 발표한 내용이기도 하다. 이 번역을 통해 우리나라 독자들이 독일 형법과 미국 형법에 대한 인상을 동시에 가질 수 있는 기회가 되기를 바란다.

KEYWORDS

no data found.

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2024 are currently being built.

[journal] Kadish / 1988 / The Model Penal Code’s Historical Antecedents / Rutgers L.J 19 : 521~

[book] Williams / 1953 / Criminal Law: The General Part 1. Aufl

[book] Williams / 1961 / Criminal Law: The General Part 2. Aufl

[other] / 1985 / Model Penal Code Official Commentaries (1985), § 3.02 : 11~

[other] / 1985 / Model Penal Code Official Commentaries (1985), § 210.3 : 65~

[book] Mueller / 1970 / Comparative Criminal Law in the United States

[other] Robinson / 2000 / Criminal Law Case Studies : 102~105

[journal] Michaels / 1998 / Acceptance: The Missing Mental State / S. Cal. L. Rev 71 : 953~1028

[book] Dressler / 1995 / Understanding Criminal Law 2. Aufl : 69~

[book] Robinson / 1995 / Fundamentals of Criminal Law 2. Aufl : 488~490

[journal] Finkelstein / 1995 / Duress: A Philosophical Account of the Defense in Law / Ariz. L. Rev 37 : 251~275

[book] Duff / 2002 / Theories of German Criminal Law in: The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy

[journal] von Hirsch / 2002 / / GA 149 : 2~

[book] Kaplan / 1996 / Criminal Law: Cases and Materials, 3. Aufl : 18~20

[book] Dubber / 2005 / American Criminal Law: Cases, Statutes, and Comments

[other] Dubber / 2002 / Criminal Law: Model Penal Code

[other] / 1997 / Spunaugle v. State 946 P.2d 246 (Ct. Crim. App. Okla. 1997)

[other] / 1987 / United States v. Lopez, 662 F. Supp. 1083 (N.D. Cal. 1987)

[other] / 1983 / State v. Leidholm, 334 N.W.2d 811 (N.D. 1983)

[book] Blackstone / 1769 / Commentaries on the Laws of England, 4. Bd : 182~

[other] Schüemann / 2001 / FS Roxin

[book] Gimbernat / 2001 / Ordeig, In Krise des Strafrechts und der Strafrechtswissenschaften? : 152~165

[journal] Schüemann / 2001 / / GA 148 : 205~218

[book] Jescheck / 1996 / Strafrecht AT 5. Aufl

[journal] Speziale / 1980 / Langdell’s Concept of Law as Science: The Beginning of Anti-Formalism in American Legal Theory / Vt. L. Rev 5 : 1~

[book] Baumann / 1966 / Alternativentwurf eines Strafgesetzbuches Allg. Teil

[journal] Dubber / 2000 / Penal Panopticon: The Idea of a Modern Model Penal Code Buff / Crim. L. Rev 4 : 53~

[book] Schüemann / 1984 / Grundfragen des modernen Strafrechtssystems : 1~

[journal] Dubber / 1997 / American Plea Bargains, German Lay Judges, and the Crisis of Criminal Procedure / Stan. L. Rev 49 : 547~

[other] Hirsch / 2002 / FS Lüerssen : 253~260

[journal] Kohlrausch / 1924 / / ZStW 44 : 21~33

[book] Roxin / 1997 / Strafrecht, AT I 3. Aufl. § 8 Rn. 61 (“Maßegeln”)

[other] Jakobs / 2002 / FS Lüerssen : 560~574

[other] Roxin / 2003 / Strafrecht AT II (2003) § 30

[web] Dubber / 2004 / The Promise of German Criminal Law / http://ssrn.com/abstract=508643

[other] Hefendehl / 2002 / Kollektive Rechtsgüer im Strafrecht

[book] Schüemann / 2003 / Rechtsgutstheorie : 133~

[book] Schüemann / 1998 / Positive Generalpräention: Kritische Analysen im deutsch-englischen Dialog : 109~

[journal] Naucke / 1984 / An Insider’s Perspective on the Significance of the German Criminal Law Theory’s General System for Analyzing Criminal Acts / BYU L. Rev : 305~

[book] Schüemann / 1985 / Beiträe zur Rechtsanthropologie —Beiheft 22 zur ARSP : 68~

[journal] Hoeflich / 1986 / Law & Geometry: Legal Science from Leibniz to Langdell / Am. J. Legal Hist 30 : 121~

[journal] Schweber / 1999 / The Science of Legal Science: The Model of Natural Sciences in Nineteenth-Century American Legal Education / L. & Hist. Rev 17 : 421~

[journal] Herget / 1987 / The German Free Law Movement as the Source of American Legal Realism / Virginia L. Rev 73 : 399~

[book] Schüemann / 2008 / Aufgabe und Grenzen der Strafrechtswissenschaft im 21. Jahrhundert, In Festschrift fü Herzberg : 39~

[book] Dubber / 2005 / Strafrechtsdogmatik als Botanik, In Empirische und dogmatische Fundamente, kriminalpolitischer Impetus : 245~

[other] Dubber / 2005 / Einfürung in das US-amerikanische Strafrecht

[book] Dubber / 2008 / New York Criminal Law: Cases and Materials

[journal] Dubber / 2001 / Policing Possession: The War on Crime and the End of Criminal Law / Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 91

[other] / 2002 / Victims in the War on Crime: The Use and Abuse of Victims‘ Rights

[journal] Dubber / 2004 / Toward a Constitutional Law of Crime and Punishment / Hastings Law Journal 55 : 509~

[journal] Sayre / 1933 / Public Welfare Offenses / Columbia Law Review 33 : 55~

[book] Dubber / 2005 / The Police Power: Patriarchy and the Foundations of American Government : 167~176

[other] Dubber / Model Penal Code

KJCKorea
Journal Central

DONG-A LAW REVIEW 2024 KCI Impact Factor : 0.76