News frames in the coverage of Emerging Infectious Disease (한국 언론의 신종 감염성 질환 보도 프레임 연구)

Park Esuri (박이스리)

doi:10.24172/hcr.2020.19.2.61

News frames in the coverage of Emerging Infectious Disease

Health Communication Research
2020, 19(2), pp.61-125
DOI : 10.24172/hcr.2020.19.2.61
Publisher : Korea Health Communication Association
Research Area : Social Science > Journalism and Broadcasting > Communication
Received : October 31, 2020
Accepted : December 18, 2020
Published : December 31, 2020

Park Esuri ¹

¹서울대학교

Candidate

ABSTRACT

This study is an attempt to find the role of the media in coping with the health crisis in the community by exploring the use of the frame. Using the concept of ‘collective action frame’ in Social movement theory, this study investigates text and visual information covering Emerging Infectious Diseases(EIDs) news of Korean daily newspapers. The results show that the Korean media emphasized the most on the diagnosis frame that conveys the status quotes such as spread the virus and confirmed cases of EIDs. Information related to the prevention, that is the prognosis frame and motivational frame for inducing participation, cooperation, and support of the public were minimal. These results point out that the coverage of the Korean newspapers in response to the outbreak of EIDs tends to be conveyed only simple information. Besides, the results of observation whether the media differ in the composition of social meaning through frames according to the stages in which EIDs spreads socially were not different. In the conclusion, the study proposes the future use of collective action frame.

KEYWORDS

news coverage of Emerging Infectious Diseases, Collective Action Frame, Health Communication

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 김선호 / 2020 / 코로나19 관련 시민 인식 조사: 집회 및 시위 제한과개인정보 수집은 방역을 위한 필수조치 / 미디어 이슈 6(5) : 1~11

[journal] 김여라 / 2010 / Exploring the Relationship between the Level of News Usage on Influenza A(H1N1) and Media Users’ Behavioral Intention toward Personal and Public Health Protection: Focusing on Protection Motivation Theory / 한국언론정보학보 / 한국언론정보학회 51(3) : 5~25

[book] 김영욱 / 2008 / 위험, 위기 그리고 커뮤니케이션 / 이화여자대학교 출판부

[journal] 김원제 / 2009 / 집중조명 신종플루 보도: 사망자 숫자에 초점, 불안감조성 / 신문과 방송 (468) : 72~75

[journal] 김춘식 / 2009 / 의료보건 이슈에 일반인 익명취재원 활용 신중해야 / 신문과 방송 (468) : 54~61

[journal] 박아란 / 2020 / 인포데믹 탐색하기: 코로나19 관련 뉴스 및정보 이용에 대한 6개국 조사 / 미디어 이슈 6(특별) : 1~11

[other] 박종근 / 2015 / 메르스 전사 조준성 “두렵지 않다 / 중앙일보 : 1~

[journal] 백선기 / 2009 / 대책 없는 공포 조성에 무력감 느끼는 시청자: 방송보도 분석 / 신문과 방송 (468) : 62~71

[other] 변진경 / 2020 / K방역은 있는데 ‘K언론’은 왜 없을까 / 시사IN 689호 : 30~35

[web] 송용회 / 2006 / 미디어, 프레임, 현실구성: 미디어 프레임 연구의 과제와 발전 방향 모색을 위한 소고 / 한국방송영상산업진흥원 / https://dl.nanet.go.kr/SearchDetailView.do

[journal] 양정혜 / 2010 / Constructing the Meaning of Rsk Society : How Korean Press Frame the Swine flu Pandemic / 정치커뮤니케이션연구 / 한국정치커뮤니케이션학회 (17) : 169~212

[journal] 유명순 / 2017 / News Framing and Efficacy Information in Climate Change News Coverage / 언론과학연구 / 한국지역언론학회 17(3) : 105~137

[journal] 유홍식 / 2009 / Effects of Headlines and Exemplars on Newsworthiness and Readers’ Issue Perception / 한국언론학보 / 한국언론학회 53(5) : 176~198

[journal] 이귀옥 / 2015 / 언론, 정보전달자 넘어 감시견 역할 다해야 / 관훈저널 (136) : 29~38

[other] 이대혁 / 2015 / 쉬쉬하는 정부 ··· ‘메르스 정보 독점’ 역효과도 / 한국일보 : 1~

[journal] 이소은 / 2020 / 코로나19 관련 정보 이용 및 인식 현황 / 미디어 이슈 6(2) : 1~18

[journal] 이정춘 / 1996 / 현대사회의 ‘위험’과 ‘위험보도의 쟁점’에 대한 고찰 / 한국언론학보 (37) : 62~91

[book] 임영호 / 2013 / 신문 원론 / 한나래 아카데미

[book] 임희섭 / 1999 / 집합행동과 사회운동의 이론 / 고려대학교 출판부

[journal] 주영기 / 2011 / Diagnostic or Prognostic? Analyzing the News Framing of H1N1 Coverage in Korea / 한국언론학보 / 한국언론학회 55(5) : 30~54

[web] 한국ABC협회 / 2019 / 2018 부수보고현황 / http://www.kabc.or.kr/

[book] 한국편집기자협회 / 2001 / 신문편집 / 한국편집기자협회

[journal] 허용강 / 2015 / 감염병 보도 지침에따른 에볼라 바이러스 언론보도 내용분석: 국내 주요 일간지를중심으로 / 헬스커뮤니케이션연구 (12) : 75~113

[book] 황치성 / 2009 / 신종플루와 언론 / 한국언론진흥재단

[journal] Adekunle, A. L / 2016 / Communicating health: Media framing of Ebola outbreak in Nigerian newspapers / Jurnal Komunikasi : Malaysian Journal of Communication 32(2)

[journal] Anderson, R. M / 2020 / How will country-based mitigation measures influence the course of the COVID-19 epidemic? / The Lancet 395(10228) : 931~934

[web] Bales, S. N / 2004 / Making the public case for child abuse and neglect prevention: A FrameWorks message memo / http://www.preventchildabuse.org/about_us/reframing/downloads/memo.pdf

[book] Baresch, B / 2010 / The Routledge Companion to News and Journalism / Routledge : 637~647

[journal] Barnett, M / 1999 / Culture, strategy and foreign policy change : Israel's road to Oslo / European Journal of International Relations 5(1) : 5~36

[journal] Berry, T. R / 2007 / SARS wars : an examination of the quantity and construction of health information in the news media / Health communication 21(1) : 35~44

[journal] Baum, N. M / 2009 / Listen to the people”: public deliberation about social distancing measures in a pandemic / The American Journal of Bioethics 9(11) : 4~14

[journal] Beaudoin, C. E / 2007 / SARS news coverage and its determinants in China and the US / International Communication Gazette 69(6) : 509~524

[journal] Bekkers, V / 2014 / Accountability and the framing power of visual technologies : how do visualized reconstructions of incidents influence public and political accountability discussions? / The Information Society 30(2) : 144~158

[journal] Benford, R. D / 1993 / Frame disputes within the nuclear disarmament movement / Social forces 71(3) : 677~701

[journal] Blendon, R. J / 2008 / Public response to community mitigation measures for pandemic influenza / Emerging Infectious Diseases 14(5) : 778~

[journal] Blumer, H / 1969 / Fashion : From class differentiation to collective selection / The sociological quarterly 10(3) : 275~291

[journal] Braunack-Mayer, A. J / 2010 / Including the public in pandemic planning : a deliberative approach / BMC public health 10(1) : 501~

[journal] Brown, J. D / 2002 / Effects of media on personal and public health / Media effects : Advances in theory and research 2 : 453~488

[journal] Brysk, A / 1995 / “Hearts and minds: bringing symbolic politics back in / Polity 27(4) : 559~585

[journal] Carragee, K. M / 2004 / The neglect of power in recent framing research / Journal of communication 54(2) : 214~233

[book] CDC / 2011 / Public Health Preparedness Capabilities: National Standard for State and Local Planning / Division of State and Local Readiness in the Office of Public Health Preparedness and Response (OPHPR), Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC).

[journal] Coleman, C. L / 1993 / The influence of mass media and interpersonal communication on societal and personal risk judgments / Communication Research 20(4) : 611~628

[book] Coleman, R / 2010 / Doing news framing analysis: Empirical and theoretical perspectives : 233~261

[journal] Cottle, S / 2008 / Reporting demonstrations: The changing media politics of dissent / Media, Culture & Society 30(6) : 853~872

[journal] Covello, V. T / 2001 / Risk communication, the West Nile virus epidemic, and bioterrorism : responding to the commnication challenges posed by the intentional or unintentional release of a pathogen in an urban setting / Journal of urban health 78(2) : 382~391

[journal] Cox, C. L / 2020 / ‘Healthcare Heroes’ : problems with media focus on heroism from healthcare workers during the COVID-19 pandemic / Journal of medical ethics 46(8) : 510~513

[journal] da Silva Medeiros, F. N / 2010 / . Pandemic on the air : a case study on the coverage of new influenza A/H1N1 by Brazilian prime time TV news / Journal of Science Communication 9(3) : A03~

[book] Danielson, W. A / 1997 / Text analysis for the social sciences: Methods for drawing statistical inferences from texts and transcripts : 103~116

[journal] Dauber, C / 2001 / Image as argument: The impact of Mogadishu on US military intervention / Armed Forces & Society 27(2) : 205~229

[journal] Davis, L. L / 1992 / Instrument review : Getting the most from a panel of experts / Applied nursing research 5(4) : 194~197

[journal] Diani, M / 1992 / The concept of social movement / The sociological review 40(1) : 1~25

[journal] DiFrancesco, D / 2011 / Seeing climate change: The visual construction of global warming in Canadian national print media / cultural geographies 18(4) : 517~536

[journal] DiFrancesco, D / 2011 / Seeing climate change : The visual construction of global warming in Canadian national print media / cultural geographies 18(4) : 517~536

[journal] Durfee, J. L / 2006 / Social change” and “status quo” framing effects on risk perception: An exploratory experiment / Science Communication 27(4) : 459~495

[journal] Entman, R. M / 1993 / Framing : Toward clarification of a fractured paradigm / Journal of communication 43(4) : 51~58

[journal] Entman, R. M / 2007 / Framing bias : Media in the distribution of power / Journal of communication 57(1) : 163~173

[journal] Erbring, L / 1980 / Front-page news and real-world cues: A new look at agenda-setting by the media / American Journal of Political Science : 16~49

[journal] Eveland Jr, W. P / 2009 / Exposure, attention, or"use"of news? Assessing aspects of the reliability and validity of a central concept in political communication research / Communication Methods and Measures 3(4) : 223~244

[journal] Fahmy, S / 2010 / Contrasting visual frames of our times : A framing analysis of English-and Arabic-language press coverage of war and terrorism / International Communication Gazette 72(8) : 695~717

[book] Fink, S / 1986 / Crisis management: Planning for the inevitable / American Management Association

[journal] Franceschet, S / 2004 / Explaining social movement outcomes: Collective action frames and strategic choices in first-and second-wave feminism in Chile / Comparative Political Studies 37(5) : 499~530

[journal] Freimuth, V. S / 2014 / Trust during the early stages of the 2009 H1N1 pandemic / Journal of health communication 19(3) : 321~339

[journal] Gamson, W, A / 1989 / Media discourse and public opinion on unclear power / American Journal of Sociology 95 : 1~37

[book] Gamson, W. A / 1975 / The strategy of social protest /

[book] Gamson, W. A / 1992 / Talking politics / Cambridge university press

[journal] Gibson, R / 2000 / Reading between the photographs: The influence of incidental pictorial information on issue perception / Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 77(2) : 355~366

[book] Gitlin, T / 2003 / The whole world is watching: Mass media in the making and unmaking of the new left / Univ of California Press

[book] Goffman, E / 1974 / Frame analysis: An essay on the organization of experience / Harvard University Press

[journal] Graber, D. A / 1990 / Seeing is remembering: How visuals contribute to learning from television news / Journal of communication 40(3) : 134~155

[journal] Graber, D. A / 1996 / Say it with pictures / The annals of the American academy of political and social science 546(1) : 85~96

[journal] Hallahan, K / 2007 / Defining strategic communication / International journal of strategic communication 1(1) : 3~35

[journal] Haynes, S. N / 1995 / Content validity in psychological assessment : A functional approach to concepts and methods / Psychological assessment 7(3) : 238~

[journal] Hodgetts, D / 2008 / Constructing health news: possibilities for a civic-oriented journalism / Health 12(1) : 43~66

[journal] Hong, T / 2007 / Information control in time of crisis : The framing of SARS in China-based newspapers and Internet sources / CyberPsychology & Behavior 10(5) : 696~699

[journal] Johnson, B. B / 1995 / Presenting uncertainty in health risk assessment : initial studies of its effects on risk perception and trust / Risk analysis 15(4) : 485~494

[journal] Jones, K. E / 2008 / Global trends in emerging infectious diseases / Nature 451(7181) : 990~

[book] Keck, M. E / 1998 / The social movement society: Contentious politics for a new century : 217~238

[journal] Khan, S / 2014 / Manufacturing consent?: Media messages in the mobilization against HIV/AIDS in India and lessons for health communication / Health Communication 29(3) : 288~298

[journal] Kinlaw, K / 2009 / Ethical guidelines in pandemic influenza: recommendations of the Ethics Subcommittee of the Advisory Committee of the Director, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention / Disaster medicine and public health preparedness 3(S2) : S185~S192

[journal] Klandermans, B / 1984 / Mobilization and participation: Social-psychological expansisons of resource mobilization theory / American sociological review : 583~600

[journal] Klandermans, B / 1989 / Introduction: social movement organizations and the study of social movements / International Social Movement Research 2 : 1~17

[journal] Krishnatray, P / 2014 / Construction of death in H1N1news in The Times of India / Journalism 15(6) : 731~753

[journal] Lee, S / 2017 / How partisan newspapers represented a pandemic : the case of the Middle East respiratory syndrome in South Korea / Asian Journal of Communication 27(1) : 82~96

[journal] Lennon, R / 2010 / SOCIAL MARKETING AND DISTRACTED DRIVING BEHAVIORS AMONG YOUNG ADULTS : THE EFFECTIVENESS OF FEAR APPEALS / Academy of marketing studies journal 14(2)

[journal] Lipkus, I. M / 2007 / Numeric, verbal, and visual formats of conveying health risks : suggested best practices and future recommendations / Medical decision making 27(5) : 696~713

[journal] Lipkus, I. M / 1999 / The visual communication of risk / JNCI monographs 1999(25) : 149~163

[journal] Liu, J / 2013 / Framing H1N1 influenza in Chinese TV news / Quarterly Journal of Chinese Studies 2(1) : 18~

[book] Noonan, R. K / 1995 / Sociological Forum / Kluwer Academic Publishers-Plenum Publishers : 81~111

[book] Norris, P / 2000 / A virtuous circle: Political communications in postindustrial societies / Cambridge University Press

[journal] Lubitow, A / 2013 / Collaborative frame construction in social movement campaigns: Bisphenol-A (BPA) and Scientist–Activist mobilization / Social Movement Studies 12(4) : 429~447

[journal] Luisi, M. L / 2018 / American Ebola Story : frames in US National Newspapers / Atlantic Journal of Communication 26(5) : 267~277

[journal] Lunn, P. D / 2020 / Using Behavioral Science to help fight the Coronavirus / Journal of Behavioral Public Administration 3(1)

[journal] Lunn, P. D / 2020 / Motivating social distancing during the Covid-19pandemic : An online experiment / Social Science & Medicine : 113478~

[journal] Luther, C. A / 2005 / Within the boundaries of politics : News framing of SARS in China and the United States / Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 82(4) : 857~872

[journal] McLeod, D. M / 1999 / Framing effects of television news coverage of social protest / Journal of communication 49(3) : 3~23

[journal] McLeod, D. M / 1992 / The manufacture ofpublic opinion'by reporters : informal cues for public perceptions of protest groups / Discourse & Society 3(3) : 259~275

[book] Messaris, P / 2001 / Framing public life : 337~353

[journal] Mummert, A / 2013 / Get the news out loudly and quickly:the influence of the media on limiting emerging infectious disease outbreaks / PloS one 8(8) : e71692~

[journal] Murat Yildirim / 2020 / The impacts of vulnerability, perceived risk, and fear on preventive behaviours against COVID-19 / Psychology, Health & Medicine

[journal] Oh, D. C / 2012 / Framing SARS : A case study in Toronto of a mainstream newspaper and a Chinese ethnic newspaper / Atlantic Journal of Communication 20(5) : 261~273

[journal] Ornell, F / 2020 / "Pandemic fear"and COVID-19 : mental health burden and strategies / Brazilian Journal of Psychiatry 42(3) : 232~235

[journal] Ostrom, E / 2000 / Collective action and the evolution of social norms / Journal of economic perspectives 14(3) : 137~158

[journal] Pan, Z / 1993 / Framing analysis : An approach to news discourse / Political communication 10(1) : 55~75

[journal] Parrott, S / 2019 / Hero, charity case, and victim : How US news media frame military veterans on Twitter / Armed Forces & Society 45(4) : 702~722

[journal] Payne, R. A / 2001 / Persuasion, frames and norm construction / European journal of international relations 7(1) : 37~61

[journal] Polit, D. F / 2007 / Is the CVI an acceptable indicator of content validity? Appraisal and recommendations / Research in nursing & health 30(4) : 459~467

[journal] Rao, H / 2000 / Power plays : How social movements and collective action create new organizational forms / Research in organizational behavior 22 : 237~281

[book] Reese, S. D / 2010 / Doing news framing analysis / Routledge : 33~58

[book] Reese, S. D / 2007 / 프레이밍과 공공생활 / 한울 아카데미

[journal] Rimer, B. K / 2006 / Advancing tailored health communication: A persuasion and message effects perspective / Journal of communication 56 : S184~S201

[journal] Rodriguez, L / 2011 / The levels of visual framing / Journal of visual literacy 30(1) : 48~65

[journal] Rossmann, C / 2018 / The mediated amplification of a crisis : Communicating the A/H1N1 pandemic in press releases and press coverage in Europe / Risk analysis 38(2) : 357~375

[book] Salmon, C. T / 2003 / Handbook of health communication : 449~472

[journal] Sandell, T / 2013 / Framing risk : communication messages in the Australian and Swedish print media surrounding the 2009 H1N1 pandemic / Scandinavian journal of public health 41(8) : 860~865

[book] 이강형 / 2014 / 뉴스의 사회학 / 한국언론진흥재단

[book] Schudson, M / 2018 / Why journalism still matters / John Wiley & Sons

[journal] Schwalbe, C. B / 2015 / Visual coverage of the 2006Lebanon War: Framing conflict in three US news magazines / Media, War & Conflict 8(1) : 141~162

[journal] Semetko, H. A / 2000 / Framing European politics: A content analysis of press and television news / Journal of Communication 50(2) : 93~109

[journal] Shih, T. J / 2008 / Media coverage of public health epidemics : Linking framing and issue attention cycle toward an integrated theory of print news coverage of epidemics / Mass Communication & Society 11(2) : 141~160

[journal] Smith, R. D / 2006 / Responding to global infectious disease outbreaks : lessons from SARS on the role of risk perception, communication and management / Social science & medicine 63(12) : 3113~3123

[journal] Snow, D. A / 1988 / Ideology, frame resonance, and participant mobilization / International social movement research 1(1) : 197~217

[journal] Snow, D. A / 1992 / Master frames and cycles of protest / Frontiers in social movement theory 133 : 155~

[book] Snow, D. A / 2018 / The Wiley Blackwell companion to social movements / Wiley Blackwell : 392~410

[journal] Sturges, D. L / 1994 / Communicating through crisis: A strategy for organizational survival / Management communication quarterly 7(3) : 297~316

[book] Tankard Jr, J. W / 2001 / Framing public life / Routledge : 111~121

[book] Tilly, C / 2017 / Collective Violence, Contentious Politics, and Social Change / Routledge : 71~91

[book] Tuchman, G / 1978 / Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality / Free

[journal] Ungar, S / 2008 / Global bird flu communication: Hot crisis and media reassurance / Science Communication 29(4) : 472~497

[journal] Van Bavel, J. J / 2020 / Using social and behavioural science to support COVID-19 pandemic response / Nature Human Behaviour 2 : 1~12

[journal] Valkenburg, P. M / 1999 / The effects of news frames on readers' thoughts and recall / Communication research 26(5) : 550~569

[journal] Vasterman, P. L / 2013 / Pandemic alarm in the Dutch media : Media coverage of the 2009 influenza A(H1N1)pandemic and the role of the expert sources / European journal of communication 28(4) : 436~453

[journal] Vaughan, E / 2009 / Effective health risk communication about pandemic influenza for vulnerable populations / American Journal of Public Health 99(S2) : S324~S332

[journal] Walgrave, S / 2000 / The making of the white march : The mass media as a mobilizing alternative to movement organizations / Mobilization : An International Quarterly 5(2) : 217~239

[book] Wang, W / 2010 / Poster presented at the annual meeting of the International Communication Association / Singapore

[journal] Wanta, W / 1988 / The effects of dominant photographs: An agenda-setting experiment / Journalism Quarterly 65(1) : 107~111

[book] Wimmer, R. D / 2011 / Mass Media Research: An Introduction 10th edn

[confproc] Wong, N / 2010 / Framing the H1N1 flu pandemic: Effect of visual and textual frames on perceptions of flu susceptibility, severity, and attributions for its global outbreak / In annual meeting of the International Communication Association : 1~34

[web] World Health Organization / 2013 / Pandemic influenza risk management:WHO interim guidance / World Health Organization / https://www.who.int/influenza/preparedness/pandemic/influenza_risk_management/en/

[web] World Health Organization / 2018 / Annual Review of Diseases Prioritized Under the Research and Development Blueprint: Geneva / World Health Organization / http://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/2018prioritizationreport.pdf?ua=1

[web] World Health Organisation / 2020 / Who, coronavirus disease (COVID-19)outbreak / https://www.who.int/emergencies/diseases/novel-coronavirus-2019

[journal] You, M / 2017 / Emerging infectious disease content in newspaper editorials: Public health concern or leadership issue / Science Communication 39(3) : 313~337

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Health Communication Research 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.75

News frames in the coverage of Emerging Infectious Disease

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Health Communication Research 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.75

News frames in the coverage of Emerging Infectious Disease

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (2)

REFERENCES (143) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.