Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.61
-
pISSN : 1225-8539 / eISSN : 2671-5171
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/japs
KJCKorea
Journal Central
From “Developmental State Model” to “Neo-Liberal Model”: A Critical Review on the Debate over Korean Development Model
- Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies
- Abbr : JAPS
- 2014, 21(2), pp.129-164
- DOI : 10.18107/japs.2014.21.2.005
- Publisher : Institute of Global Affairs
- Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
Don Moon 1, Chung Jin-Young 1
1경희대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This paper critically reviews debates over Korean development model, which attracts increasing attention in academia as well as policy circles. We classify various debates into three categories. The first debate is about the Korean model from mid-1960s to 80s called ‘East Asian developmental state,’ and there has been a consensus that the key characteristics of the model fit well with Korean experiences of state-centric economic developments, export-oriented industrialization strategies, etc. The second debate is about the properties of ‘post-developmental state,’ and this debate is directly related to how we understand the drastic changes of the Korean political, economic, social system after the 1997-98 East Asian Financial Crises. In spite of disagreements among scholars, it is fair to define the current political/economic/social system as a neoliberal system. As for the final debate, the future development model of Korea, we examine the three most representative development models. Among the neo-developmental state model, the corporatist social-democratic welfare state model, and the regulatory state model, we find the last one is the most realistic and politically viable option, given political, economic, social, and cultural constraints and conditions under which a future model should be operative.
Statistics
-
886 Viewed
-
386 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
고세훈
/ 2003
/
‘Stakeholder Capitalism' as an Alternative: The Cases of Britain and South Korea
/ 국제정치논총
/ 한국국제정치학회
43(2)
: 245~271
[journal]
구종서
/ 1996
/ 동아시아 발전모델과 한국
/ 한국정치학회보
30(2)
: 209~224
[journal]
국민호
/ 2008
/
Korean Economic Crisis and Developmental State Model
/ 사회와 이론
/ 한국이론사회학회
(13)
: 213~249
[book]
김상조
/ 2012
/ 종횡무진 한국경제: 재벌과 모피아의 함정에서 탈피하라
/ 오마이북
[book]
김세균
/ 2009
/ 21세기 한국 정치의 발전방향
/ 서울대학교출판부
: 147~168
[book]
김영명
/ 1996
/ 동아시아 발전 모델의 재검토
/ 소화
[journal]
김윤태
/ 2007
/
Varieties of Capitalism' and Developmental Model in Korea
/ 동향과 전망
/ 한국사회과학연구회
(70)
: 45~75
[journal]
김일영
/ 1996
/ 동아시아 발전 모델의 재검토
/ 한국정치학회보
30(3)
: 463~468
[book]
김진업
/ 2001
/ 한국자본주의 발전모델의 형성과 해체
/ 나눔의집
[journal]
서익진
/ 2006
/
Which Development Model Existed in the Outbreak of the 'IMF Economic Crisis'? - Developmental Dictatorship or Korean Fordism -
/ 경제학연구
/ 한국경제학회
54(1)
: 137~169
[book]
김형기
/ 2007
/ 대안적 발전모델: 신자유주의를 넘어서
/ 한울 아카데미
[journal]
류석춘
/ 2007
/
Did the Financial Crisis Transform the Developmental State:Focused on the Public Fund in Korea
/ 한국사회학
/ 한국사회학회
41(5)
: 64~97
[journal]
박기덕
/ 1999
/ 동아시아발전모델의 구성과 동아시아 지역 경제위기의 원인
/ 한국정치학회보
32(4)
: 373~387
[journal]
박병영
/ 2003
/ 제2장 ‘개발국가’ 패러다임의 적실성: 남한 발전 모델의 사례
/ 비교사회
(5)
: 35~66
[journal]
박상영
/ 2012
/
Exploring Korea’s Emerging ‘Post-Developmental’ State: Research Trends and Agendas since the 1990s
/ 현대정치연구
/ 현대정치연구소
5(1)
: 63~90
[book]
박세일
/ 2008
/ 대한민국 국가전략
/ 21세기북스
[journal]
백종국
/ 1998
/ 『동아시아 모델 위기론』에 대한 비판적 고찰: 한국의 외환위기를 중심으로
/ 한국정치학회보
32(3)
: 95~116
[journal]
백종국
/ 2011
/
A Critical Review on Theories of Korean Development Model
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
45(1)
: 211~233
[journal]
성태규
/ 2002
/
The political order-policy in german "order-liberalism"
/ 국제정치논총
/ 한국국제정치학회
42(2)
: 217~236
[journal]
손호철
/ 2006
/
Globalization and the Transformation of the Korean State
/ 동아연구
/ 동아연구소
(51)
: 5~33
[book]
신장섭
/ 2004
/ 주식회사 한국의 구조조정
/ 창비
[journal]
안재홍
/ 2002
/
Globalization and Changes in the Political Economy of Tripartism: A Comparative Study of Sweden, the Netherlands, and Austria
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
36(3)
: 397~420
[journal]
양재진
/ 2005
/
Developmentalism after Development: The Growth, Crisis, and Future of the Korean Developmental State
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
39(1)
: 1~18
[report]
오승구
/ 2003
/ 유럽식 경제모델의 성과와 한계
/ 삼성경제연구소
[book]
유철규
/ 2004
/ 박정희 모델과 신자유주의 사이에서: 산업화 이념의 재고찰과 대안의 모색(II)
/ 함께읽는책
: 63~82
[journal]
윤상우
/ 2006
/
(서평)한국형 발전모델의 역사적 해부
/ 경제와 사회
/ 비판사회학회
(70)
: 242~248
[journal]
윤상우
/ 2009
/
외환위기 이후 한국의 발전주의적 신자유주의화-국가의 성격변화와 정책대응을 중심으로
/ 경제와 사회
/ 비판사회학회
(83)
: 40~68
[book]
윤영관
/ 1999
/ 동아시아: 위기의 정치경제
/ 서울대학교 출판부
[journal]
이연호
/ 1999
/ 김대중정부의 경제개혁과 신자유주의적 국가등장의 한계: 동아시아 개발도상국의 한 사례
/ 한국정치학회보
33(4)
: 287~307
[journal]
이연호
/ 2002
/
The Rise of the Regulatory State and Government-Business Relations in South Korea
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
36(3)
: 199~222
[journal]
이제민
/ 2007
/
Korean Foreign Exchange Crisis: Causes, Resolution and Consequences
/ 경제발전연구
/ 한국경제발전학회
13(2)
: 1~43
[book]
박용수
/ 2009
/ 신투자국가론: 포스트 통상국가 시대와 한국의 성장전략
/ 나남
[book]
박삼옥
/ 2009
/ 지속가능한 한국발전모델과 성장동력
/ 서울대학교출판문화원
[book]
장하준
/ 2006
/ 국가의 역할: Globalization, Economic Development, and the Role of the State
/ 부키
[book]
장하준
/ 2012
/ 무엇을 선택할 것인가
/ 부키
[journal]
전기원
/ 2009
/
Search for Korean Development Model after Global Economic Crisis: Soft Power and Restructured Developmental State Model
/ 한국시민윤리학회보
/ 한국시민윤리학회
22(2)
: 225~252
[book]
전창완
/ 2004
/ 박정희 모델과 신자유주의 사이에서: 산업화 이념의 재고찰과 대안의 모색(II)
/ 함께읽는책
: 85~126
[book]
정성화
/ 2005
/ 박정희 시대 연구의 쟁점과 과제
/ 선인
[journal]
정연승
/ 2004
/
A Critical Review of the Domestic Literature on the Causes of Korean Foreign Exchange Crisis
/ 경제학연구
/ 한국경제학회
52(3)
: 33~64
[journal]
정진영
/ 2000
/ 외환·금융위기와 동아시아 발전의 미래: 발전모델, 구조조정, 지역협력을 둘러싼 논쟁을 중심으로
/ 한국과 국제정치
16(2)
[journal]
제갈현숙
/ 2008
/
A critical Analysis of the Discussion about the Korean Welfare Regime: Focusing on Social Investment State
/ 사회복지정책
/ 한국사회복지정책학회
(35)
: 379~404
[journal]
지주형
/ 2009
/
The Shift in the State Form and Mode of Power Exercise in South Korea: From the Authoritarian Developmental State to Neoliberal State Power
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
43(4)
: 175~203
[book]
Amsden, Alice H
/ 1989
/ Asia’s Next Giant: South Korea and Late Industrialization
/ Oxford University Press
[journal]
Chu, Yin-wah
/ 2009
/ Eclipse or Reconfigured?: South Korea's Developmental State and Challenges of the Global Knowledge Economy
/ Economy and Society
38(2)
: 278~303
[book]
Chung, Duck-Koo
/ 2004
/ The Korean Economy Beyond the Crisis
/ Edward Elgar
: 1~24
[book]
Deans, P
/ 2000
/ State Strategies in the Global Political Economy
/ Pinter
: 78~102
[book]
Esping-Andersen, Gosta
/ 1990
/ The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism
/ Princeton University Press
[journal]
Fisher, Stanley
/ 1998
/ In Defence of the IMF
/ Foreign Affairs
: 77~
[journal]
Furman, Jason
/ 1998
/ Economic Crisis: Evidence and Insights from East Asia
/ Brookings Papers on Economic Activity
2
: 1~135
[book]
Giddens, Anthony
/ 2001
/ The Third Way and Its Critics
/ Polity
[book]
Haggard, S.
/ 1983
/ The Antinomies of Interdependence
/ Columbia University Press
: 131~190
[book]
Haggard, S
/ 1990
/ Pathways from the Periphery: The Politics of Growth in the Newly Industrializing Countries
/ Cornell University Press
[journal]
Haggard, S
/ 2004
/ Institutions and growth in East Asia
/ Studies in Comparative International Development
38(4)
: 53~81
[book]
Hall, P. A.
/ 2001
/ Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage
/ Oxford University Press
[journal]
Hall, Rodney
/ 2003
/ The Discursive Demolition of the Asian Development Model
/ International Studies Quarterly
47
[report]
International Monetary Fund
/ 1998
/ Republic of Korea: Article IV Consultations
/ IMF
[book]
Johnson, Chalmers
/ 1982
/ MITI and the Japanese Miracle: The Growth of Industrial Policy, 1925-1975
/ Stanford University Press
[book]
Katzenstein, Peter J.
/ 1985
/ Small States in World Markets: Industrial Policy in Europe
/ Cornell University Press
[book]
Kim, Byung-Kook
/ 2011
/ The Park Chung Hee Era: The Transformation of South Korea
/ Harvard University Press
[other]
Krugman, P
/ 1998
/ Asia: What Went Wrong
/ Fortune
[journal]
Lim, Haeran
/ 2010
/ The Transformation of the Developmental State and Economic Reform
/ Journal of Contemporary Asia
40(2)
: 188~210
[journal]
Lim, Linda Y. C
/ 1998
/ Whose “Model” Failed? Implications of the Asian Economic Crisis
/ Washington Quarterly
21(3)
: 25~36
[journal]
McCord, W
/ 1989
/ An East Asian model of development: growth with equity
/ The Pacific Review
2(3)
: 209~217
[journal]
Minns, John
/ 2001
/ of Miracles and Models: The Rise and Decline of the Developmental State in South Korea
/ Third World Quarterly
22(6)
: 1025~1043
[other]
Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development
/ 1999
/ Economic Surveys: Korea
[journal]
Pang, Eul-Soo
/ 2000
/ The financial crisis of 1997-98 and the end of the Asian development state
/ Contemporary Southeast Asia
22(3)
: 570~593
[journal]
Park, Yong Soo
/ 2011
/ Revisiting the South Korean developmental state after the 1997 financial crisis
/ Australian Journal of International Affairs
65(5)
: 590~606
[journal]
Pirie, Iain
/ 2005
/ The New Korean State
/ New Political Economy
10(1)
: 25~42
[journal]
Radelet, Stephen
/ 1998
/ The East Asian Financial Crisis: Diagnosis, Remedies, Prospects
/ Brookings Papers on Economic Activity
1
: 1~90
[book]
Stubbs, Richard
/ 2005
/ Rethinking Asia’s Economic Miracle: The Political Economy of War, Prosperity and Crisis
/ Palgrave Macmillan
[journal]
Stubbs, Richard
/ 2009
/ What Ever Happened to the East Asian Developmental States? The Unfolding Debate
/ The Pacific Review
22(1)
: 1~22
[journal]
Thurbon, Elizabeth
/ 2006
/ Investing in Openness: The Evolution of FDI Strategy in South Korea and Taiwan
/ New Political Economy
11(1)
: 1~22
[book]
Wade, Robert
/ 1990
/ Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Role of Government in East Asian Industrialization
/ Princeton University Press
[book]
Woo-Cumings, M. J.-E
/ 1998
/ Behind East Asian Growth: The Political and Social Foundations of Prosperity
/ Routledge
: 319~337
[book]
Woo-Cumings, M. J.-E.
/ 1999
/ The Developmental State
/ Cornell University Press
[report]
World Bank
/ 1993
/ The East Asian Miracle: Economic Growth and Public Policy. Policy Research Report
/ World Bank
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.