Journal of Korean society of Dental Hygiene 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.8
-
pISSN : 2287-1705 / eISSN : 2288-2294
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/jksdh
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Turnover intention among dental hygienists in Korea : a systematic review and meta-analysis
- Journal of Korean society of Dental Hygiene
- Abbr : J Korean Soc Dent Hyg
- 2022, 22(4), pp.259-272
- DOI : 10.13065/jksdh.20220029
- Publisher : Korean Society of Dental Hygiene
- Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > Dentistry
- Received : June 28, 2022
- Accepted : July 22, 2022
- Published : August 30, 2022
Da-Som Lee 1, Hae-Kyung Hong 2, Gyeong-Soon Han 3
1가천대학교 일반대학원 보건과학과
2경동대학교 치위생학과
3가천대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Objectives: To identify the factors influencing the turnover intention of registered South Korean dental hygienists and analyze the effect sizes. Methods: Overall, 54 studies based on criteria of PICO from 1 January 2000 to 11 January 2022 were extracted.
The factors related to turnover intention were applied to the ecological system theory and categorized. Subsequently, the effect size of the correlations was comprehensively meta-analyzed by dividing it into protective and risk factors depending on the negative or positive correlation direction. Results: For the overall effect size, the protective factor (ESr=-0.458) was higher than the risk factor (ESr=0.352). In the protective factors, organizational commitment and perceived organizational support belonging to the microsystem yielded the largest effect size. Furthermore, as for risk factors, burnout, job stress, work harassment, role conflict, and emotional labor belonging to the microsystem showed a moderate effect size. Conclusions: Factors belonging to the microsystem demonstrated a large effect size in both protection and risk factors for dental hygienists’ turnover intention.
Additionally, the factor showing the largest effect size was protective factor categorized into a microsystem.
Statistics
-
194 Viewed
-
125 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
Patel BM
/ 2021
/ Job Satisfaction, burnout, and intention to leave among dental hygienists in clinical practice
/ J Dent Hyg
95(2)
: 28~35
[journal]
Max W. Seitz
/ 2019
/ Current Knowledge on Correlations Between Highly Prevalent Dental Conditions and Chronic Diseases: An Umbrella Review
/ Preventing Chronic Disease
/ Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)
16
[journal]
이경진
/ 2015
/
The Factors Affecting the Intention of Career Discontinuity of a Married Women Dental Hygienist
/ 치위생과학회지
/ 한국치위생과학회
15(6)
: 786~793
[journal]
Christopher D Allen
/ 2003
/ Recruitment and Retention of Dental Nurses and Dental Hygienists in General Practice
/ Primary Dental Care
/ SAGE Publications
os10(3)
: 65~68
[journal]
Basile SV
/ 2007
/ Dental hygiene workforce issues : a Minnesota study
/ J Dent Hyg
81(1)
: 11~
[journal]
Yuko Yamamoto
/ 2021
/ Improvement of Workplace Environment That Affects Motivation of Japanese Dental Hygienists
/ International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
/ MDPI AG
18(3)
: 1309~
[web]
Ministry of Health and Welfare
/ 2019
/ Basic data collection for nurturing high - quality health and medical personne
/ MOHW
/ http://www.mohw.go.kr/react/al/sal0301vw.jsp?PAR_MENU_ID=04&MENU_ID=0403&CONT_SEQ=351956
[journal]
이효진
/ 2019
/
Issues and Challenges of Dental Hygienist Workforce Policy in Korea
/ 한국콘텐츠학회 논문지
/ 한국콘텐츠학회
19(2)
: 409~423
[journal]
ROBERT P. TETT
/ 1993
/ JOB SATISFACTION, ORGANIZATIONAL COMMITMENT, TURNOVER INTENTION, AND TURNOVER: PATH ANALYSES BASED ON META‐ANALYTIC FINDINGS
/ Personnel Psychology
/ Wiley
46(2)
: 259~293
[journal]
Laureen J. Hayes
/ 2006
/ Nurse turnover: A literature review
/ International Journal of Nursing Studies
/ Elsevier BV
43(2)
: 237~263
[journal]
유은미
/ 2011
/
A Study on the Work and Turnover of Clinical Dental Hygienists
/ 치위생과학회지
/ 한국치위생과학회
11(1)
: 41~46
[book]
Borenstein M
/ 2009
/ Introduction to meat - anaylsis
/ West Sussex
: 41~43
[journal]
Hyeoneui Kim
/ 2021
/ A meta‐analysis on predictors of turnover intention of hospital nurses in South Korea (2000–2020)
/ Nursing Open
/ Wiley
8(5)
: 2406~2418
[journal]
오희균
/ 2014
/
Core Deterrent Factors of Hoteliers' Turn-over Intention by Meta-Analysis : Application of Hedges-Olkin Effect Size Model
/ 호텔경영학연구
/ 한국호텔외식관광경영학회
23(6)
: 209~235
[journal]
Cem Oktay Guzeller
/ 2019
/ Examining the relationship between organizational commitment and turnover intention via a meta-analysis
/ International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research
/ Emerald
14(1)
: 102~120
[journal]
Boshra H. Namin
/ 2021
/ Workplace Incivility and Turnover Intention in Organizations: A Meta-Analytic Review
/ International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health
/ MDPI AG
19(1)
: 25~
[journal]
Bora Yildiz
/ 2021
/ Relationship between work–family conflict and turnover intention in nurses: A meta‐analytic review
/ Journal of Advanced Nursing
/ Wiley
[journal]
Ahmet Hakan Özkan
/ 2022
/ The effect of burnout and its dimensions on turnover intention among nurses: A meta‐analytic review
/ Journal of Nursing Management
/ Hindawi Limited
30(3)
: 660~669
[journal]
김기영
/ 2010
/
Impact of human resource management and development on turnover intention of dental hygienist in Korean dental settings - Focusing on the moderating effect of career commitment
/ 대한구강보건학회지
/ 대한예방치과·구강보건학회
34(4)
: 505~515
[journal]
김은숙
/ 2011
/
Impact of Servant Leadership Perception on Job Satisfaction, Organizational Commitment and Turnover Intention of Dental Hygienists
/ 병원경영학회지
/ 한국병원경영학회
16(4)
: 1~16
[journal]
한세영
/ 2016
/
Covariance Structure Analysis on the Impact of Job Stress, Fatigue Symptoms and Job Satisfaction on Turnover Intention among Dental Hygienists
/ 한국산학기술학회논문지
/ 한국산학기술학회
17(7)
: 629~640
[journal]
이미림
/ 2017
/
The Effect of Job Stress and Turnover Intention in Dental Hygienists
/ 한국엔터테인먼트산업학회논문지
/ 한국엔터테인먼트산업학회
11(3)
: 249~258
[journal]
김연우
/ 2019
/
Exploring Antecedent Factor that Influence Dental Hygienist’s Job Satisfaction and Turnover Intention
/ 한국산학기술학회논문지
/ 한국산학기술학회
20(3)
: 329~337
[journal]
한지연
/ 2018
/
The Effect of Organizational Social Capital on Job Stress, Job Satisfaction and Turnover Intention : Focusing on Dental Hygienists
/ 경영컨설팅연구
/ 한국경영컨설팅학회
18(4)
: 187~195
[journal]
김한홍
/ 2021
/
The Influence of Job Stress, Job Satisfaction and Organization Communication on Turnover Intention for Dental Hygienists
/ 한국컴퓨터정보학회논문지
/ 한국컴퓨터정보학회
26(5)
: 69~76
[journal]
이정화
/ 2021
/
Analysis of the factors of turnover intention of dental hygienists in dental hospitals
/ 대한구강보건학회지
/ 대한예방치과·구강보건학회
45(2)
: 92~99
[journal]
Kang BW
/ 2002
/ A study on organizational commitment and turnover intention among dental hygienists
/ Bulletin of Dongnam Health University
20(1)
: 83~91
[journal]
지민경
/ 2016
/
The Effect of Turnover Intention on the Job Stress, Burn out and Organizational Commitment - Focused on New Dental Hygienists -
/ 한국엔터테인먼트산업학회논문지
/ 한국엔터테인먼트산업학회
10(6)
: 379~387
[journal]
민희홍
/ 2015
/
Influencing factors of turnover intention in the clinical dental hygienists
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
15(5)
: 831~839
[journal]
최규일
/ 2016
/
Effect of mentoring function on job satisfaction, organization commitment, and turnover intention in the newly employed dental hygienists
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
16(1)
: 69~75
[journal]
이선미
/ 2013
/
Influencing factors of turnover intention of dental hygienists using by the path analysis
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
13(6)
: 941~949
[journal]
이춘선
/ 2012
/
The Effect of the Intramural Marketing Activities in Dental Hygienist' on Job Satisfaction and Turnover Intention in Dental Hygienist
/ 치위생과학회지
/ 한국치위생과학회
12(1)
: 15~22
[journal]
Bronfenbrenner U
/ 1979
/ The ecology of human development : experiments by nature and design
/ USA : American psychologist
34(10)
: 844~
[web]
University of South Australia
/ Critical review form - quantitative studies
/ UNISA
/ http://www.unisa.edu.au/siteassets/episerver-6-files/global/health/sansom/documents/icahe/cats/mcmasters_quantitative-review.pdf
[journal]
Sue Duval
/ 2000
/ Trim and Fill: A Simple Funnel-Plot-Based Method of Testing and Adjusting for Publication Bias in Meta-Analysis
/ Biometrics
/ Wiley
56(2)
: 455~463
[book]
Littell JH
/ 2008
/ Systematic reviews and meta-analysis
/ Oxford University Press
: 79~110
[book]
Cohen J
/ 1988
/ Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nd ed)
/ Routledge
: 1~567
[journal]
William G. Cochran
/ 1954
/ The Combination of Estimates from Different Experiments
/ Biometrics
/ JSTOR
10(1)
: 101~
[journal]
J. P T Higgins
/ 2003
/ Measuring inconsistency in meta-analyses
/ BMJ
/ BMJ
327(7414)
: 557~560
[journal]
Charles E. Michaels
/ 1982
/ Causes of employee turnover: A test of the Mobley, Griffeth, Hand, and Meglino model.
/ Journal of Applied Psychology
/ American Psychological Association (APA)
67(1)
: 53~59
[journal]
James L. Price
/ 1981
/ A Causal Model of Turnover for Nurses
/ Academy of Management Journal
/ Academy of Management
24(3)
: 543~565
[journal]
서영준
/ 2002
/
Determinants of Intent to Leave among Physicians Working at General Hospitals After the Separation Program of Prescribing and Dispensing
/ 보건행정학회지
/ 한국보건행정학회
12(4)
: 68~90
[journal]
Lee SR
/ 2006
/ The bodyguard job stress on job satisfaction and turnover intention is influenced
/ J Korean Phys Educ
45(1)
: 227~236
[thesis]
Park HS
/ 2002
/ Relationship between perceived nursing care role orientation, job characteristics, and turnover among nurses
/ Master
/ Univ. of Yonsei
[thesis]
Go EJ
/ 2009
/ Factors affecting intent to leave for dental hygienists
/ Master
/ Univ. of Inje
[journal]
문숙자
/ 2011
/
A Predictive Model on Turnover Intention of Nurses in Korea
/ Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing
/ 한국간호과학회
41(5)
: 633~641
[thesis]
Ju JH
/ 2009
/ ER nurses’s job stress main factors influencing on the organizational effectiveness
/ Master
/ Univ. of Kyunghee
[journal]
김혜영
/ 2012
/
The effect of self-efficacy and job satisfaction of Dental Hygienists’on the organizational commitment and turnover intention
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
12(1)
: 213~223
[journal]
박영남
/ 2015
/
Influence of organizational communication satisfaction on job satisfaction, organizational commitment, and turnover intention : Focused on the mediated effects of interpersonal stress
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
15(5)
: 797~804
[journal]
최하나
/ 2011
/
Factors associated with turnover intention of public health dental hygienist
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
11(3)
: 343~351
[journal]
이병호
/ 2010
/
Analysis of the Correlation of Burnout, job Satisfaction and Turnover of Dental Hygienists
/ 한국콘텐츠학회 논문지
/ 한국콘텐츠학회
10(11)
: 217~227
[journal]
S. Turner
/ 2011
/ Job satisfaction among dually qualified dental hygienist-therapists in UK primary care: a structural model
/ British Dental Journal
/ Springer Science and Business Media LLC
210(4)
: E5~E5
[journal]
Jan J. Reinders
/ 2017
/ Attitudes among dentists and dental hygienists towards extended scope and independent practice of dental hygienists
/ International Dental Journal
/ Elsevier BV
67(1)
: 46~58
[journal]
문상은
/ 2020
/
A comparative study of the perceptions of dental hygienists and dentists of nonsurgical periodontal therapy : application of a co-orientation model
/ 한국치위생학회지
/ 한국치위생학회
20(1)
: 107~116
[journal]
김종경
/ 2016
/
Meta Analysis of Variables related to Emotional Labor of Hospital Nurses
/ 기본간호학회지
/ 기본간호학회
23(2)
: 115~125
[journal]
김신향
/ 2015
/
A Meta analysis of variables related to Burnout of nurse in korea
/ 디지털융복합연구
/ 한국디지털정책학회
13(8)
: 387~400
[journal]
이영옥
/ 2018
/
Related Factors of Turnover Intention among Korean Hospital Nurses: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis
/ 성인간호학회지
/ 한국성인간호학회
30(1)
: 1~17
[journal]
Sabine Kaiser
/ 2018
/ Linking interprofessional work to outcomes for employees: A meta-analysis
/ Research in Nursing & Health
/ Wiley
41(3)
: 265~280
[journal]
Nicole Malcolm
/ 2020
/ Occupational stressors of dental hygienists in the United States
/ Work
/ IOS Press
65(3)
: 517~524
[journal]
허성은
/ 2010
/
The Mediating Effects of Burnout on the Relationships between Job Stress and Turnover Intention for Dental Hygienists
/ 대한보건연구
/ 사단법인 대한보건협회
36(2)
: 35~55
[journal]
Song KH
/ 2013
/ A study on the job satisfaction and turnover intention of dental hygienists and nursing aids
/ J Korean Soc Dent Hyg
15(1)
: 1~11
[journal]
임지영
/ 2006
/
An Analysis of Internal Marketing Activies affecting on Nurse's Motivation - Based on Herzberg's Motivation-Hygiene Factor Theory -
/ 간호행정학회지
/ 간호행정학회
12(1)
: 5~13
[journal]
Kang DW
/ 2018
/ Characteristics of regional mobility of young people : focusing on new graduates
/ Monthly Labor Review
158
: 7~18