Korea Social Policy Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 2.47
-
pISSN : 1226-0525
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/kasp
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Concept Structures, Functional Equivalence and the East Asian Welfare State Discussion: An Application of Set ‑Theory in Comparative Social Policy
- Korea Social Policy Review
- Abbr : KSPR
- 2012, 19(3), pp.185-214
- DOI : 10.17000/kspr.19.3.201209.185
- Publisher : Korean Association of Social Policy
- Research Area : Social Science > Sociology > Medical / Welfare / Social policy
1이화여자대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
After the introduction of the three welfare regimes by Esping ‑Andersen, discussion on ‘other’ types of welfare regimes was facilitated and the scholarly focus on East Asian economic development gradually shifted to the East Asian welfare states discussion from the late 1990s. Literature on East Asian welfare states increased our understanding on the characteristics of not only the East Asian welfare state as a whole but also of each country in the region. However, compared the attention given to developing variables and empirical studies on the East Asian welfare state, less attention has been given to the concept of East Asian welfare states.
Recognizing the limitation in developing comparable variables without a concept analysis of the East Asian welfare states, this study highlights the importance of conceptualization and concept analysis in comparative social policy studies. This paper first discusses on the concepts, conceptualization and on the use of set theory in comparative social policy research. Next, the study argues the validity of ‘functional equivalence’ in the East Asian welfare state studies and critically reviews the existing literature. Lastly, this paper suggests how the concept of functional equivalence can be successfully employed for the East Asian welfare states studies with a concept analysis and by applying a set theory including the fuzzy set theory.
Statistics
-
454 Viewed
-
191 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
김교성
/ 2010
/
Exploratory Measuring the Welfare State Change
/ 한국사회복지학
/ 한국사회복지학회
62(1)
: 5~30
[book]
김연명
/ 2002
/ (한국 복지국가)성격논쟁
/ 인간과복지
[journal]
김연명
/ 2004
/
Re-examination of East-Asian Welfare Regime : Methodological Problems in Comparing Welfare Regimes and the Possibilities of Identifying East-Asian Welfare Regime
/ 사회복지정책
/ 한국사회복지정책학회
20(20)
: 133~154
[journal]
김연명
/ 2011
/
Still Welfare Exceptionalism in East Asia?: Review and Prospect for the Recent Welfare Developments in East Asian Countries
/ 아세아연구
/ 아세아문제연구소
54(1)
: 7~22
[journal]
김영범
/ 2002
/ 한국 복지국가의 유형화에 대한 비판적 검토 : 제도의 미성숙성과 그에 따른 한계를 중심으로
/ 비판사회정책
11(1)
: 85~108
[journal]
김원섭
/ 2008
/ 참여정부에서 한국 복지국가의 발전, 신자유주의 국가?
/ 한국사회
9(2)
: 29~53
[confproc]
김진욱
/ 2005
/ 한국 복지국가 공급체계의 혼합(Mix) 구성
/ 한국사회복지학회 학술대회 자료집
2005(10)
: 35~56
[journal]
김희자
/ 1996
/ 한국 복지제도의 성격 규정에 대한 시론
/ 사회복지정책
3(1)
: 129~144
[journal]
나병균
/ 2010
/
A Study on the Applicability of East Asian Welfare State Discourse to the Development of Korean Welfare State(Regime)
/ 사회복지연구
/ 한국사회복지연구회
41(3)
: 5~27
[journal]
남찬섭
/ 2005
/ 한국 복지국가의 성과와 한계
/ 월간 복지동향
75(1)
: 30~40
[journal]
남찬섭
/ 2008
/ 한국 복지국가의 위상과 전망
/ 노동사회
136(1)
: 102~117
[journal]
노병일
/ 2005
/ 동아시아 복지 모델의 특징과 방향
/ 社會科學論文集
23(2)
: 293~310
[journal]
박용수
/ 2007
/
Major Background Instrumental in the Development of the Residual Welfare State in Korea since the 1990s
/ 국제정치논총
/ 한국국제정치학회
47(2)
: 97~122
[journal]
백승호
/ 2007
/
A Comparative Social Policy Study on the Structure and Characteristic of Korean Welfare State - Focused on the Development of Public Social Expenditure -
/ 사회복지연구
/ 한국사회복지연구회
(35)
: 337~362
[journal]
심상용
/ 2010
/
A Study on Formulation of Developmental Welfare Regime in Korea: Despotic Developmental Production Regime and Informal Security Welfare Regime
/ 사회복지정책
/ 한국사회복지정책학회
37(4)
: 1~25
[journal]
심창학
/ 2004
/
Searching for the Typology of East Asian Welfare Model: Focusing on Discourses and Real Analysis
/ 사회복지정책
/ 한국사회복지정책학회
(18)
: 55~82
[journal]
안상훈
/ 2003
/
A Socio-Political Comparative Study on Welfare State Cleavage of Pro-Welfare Alliance: Swedish Experience and Korean Experiment
/ 사회복지연구
/ 한국사회복지연구회
21
: 79~104
[journal]
양재진
/ 2005
/
The Corporate Unionism and its Impact on the Korean Welfare State
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
39(3)
: 395~412
[confproc]
이광찬
/ 2002
/ 21세기 한국사회복지정책의 전망과 과제
/ 한국사회복지학회 학술대회 자료집
2002(4)
: 332~347
[confproc]
정무권
/ 2004
/ 제3회의 : 한국 복지국가의 현실과 개혁과제
/ 춘계학술대회
2004
: 692~715
[book]
정무권
/ 2009
/ 한국 복지국가 성격논쟁 II
/ 인간과 복지
[journal]
정의룡
/ 2012
/
Change and Continuity of the Western and Korean Welfare States: A Fuzzy-set Analysis
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
46(1)
: 309~336
[journal]
최영준
/ 2009
/
Application of Fuzzy-set Theory in Social Sciences
/ 정부학연구
/ 정부학연구소
15(3)
: 307~336
[book]
Amsden, A. H.
/ 1989
/ Asia’s next giant: South korea and late industrialization
/ Oxford University Press
[journal]
Bonoli, G.
/ 2005
/ The Politics of the New Social Policies: Providing Coverage against New Social Risks in Mature Welfare States
/ Policy & Politics
33(3)
: 431~449
[journal]
Chung, M. K.
/ 2006
/ The Korean developmental welfare regime. Shakai Seisaku Gakkai Shi
/ Journal of Social Policy and Labor Studies, Japan
16
: 149~171
[journal]
Collier, D.
/ 1975
/ Prerequisites versus diffusion
/ American Political Science Review
69
: I299~I315
[journal]
Cutright, P.
/ 1965
/ Political structure, economic development, and national social security programs
/ American Journal of Sociology
: 537~550
[book]
Dogan, M.
/ 1990
/ How to compare nations(2nd ed.)
/ Chatham House
[book]
Esping-Andersen, G.
/ 1990
/ The three worlds of welfare capitalism
/ Princeton University Press
[journal]
Esping-Andersen, G.
/ 1997
/ Hybrid or unique?: The japanese welfare state between europe and america
/ Journal of European Social Policy
7(3)
: 179~189
[book]
Ito Peng
/ 1996
/ Welfare States in Transition
/ Sage
[book]
Margarita Estevez-Abe
/ 2008
/ Welfare and capitalism in postwar Japan
/ Cambridge University Press,
[book]
Goertz, G.
/ 2006
/ Social science concepts: A user's guide
/ Princeton Univ Press
[book]
Goodman, R.
/ 1996
/ The east asian welfare states: Peripatetic learning, adaptive change, and nation-building, In Welfare states in transition: National adaptations in global economies
/ Sage
[book]
Goodman, R.
/ 1998
/ The east asian welfare model: Welfare orientalism and the state
/ Routledge
[book]
Gough, I.
/ 1979
/ The political economy of the welfare state
/ Macmillan
[journal]
Gough, I.
/ 2001
/ Globalization and regional welfare regimes: The east asian case
1
: 163~189
[book]
Gough, I.
/ 2000
/ Why do levels of human welfare vary across nations?, In Global capital, human needs and social policies: Selected essays, 1994-99
/ Palgrave
: 105~130
[book]
Hall, P. A.
/ 2001
/ An introduction to varieties of capitalism, In Varities of capitalism: The institutional foundations of comparative advantage
/ Oxford University Press
[journal]
Hacker, J.
/ 2004
/ Privatizing Risk without Privatizing the Welfare State: The Hidden Politics of Social Policy Retrenchment in the United States
/ American Political Science Review
98(2)
: 243~260
[journal]
Holliday, I.
/ 2000
/ Productivist welfare capitalism, Social Policy in East Asia
48
: 706~723
[report]
Holzmann, R.
/ 1999
/ Social protection as Social Risk Management: Conceptual Underpinning for the Social Protection Sector Strategy Paper
/ World Bank
[report]
Holzmann, R.
/ 2000
/ Social Risk Management: A New Conceptual Framework for Social Protection, and Beyond
/ World Bank
[journal]
Hort, S. E.
/ 2000
/ The coming of east and south east asian welfare states
/ Journal of European Social Policy
10(2)
: 162~184
[book]
Johnson, C. A.
/ 1982
/ MITI and the japanese miracle: The growth of industrial policy, 1925-1975
/ Stanford University Press
[book]
Jones, C.
/ 1993
/ The pacific challenge: Confucian welfare states, In New perspectives on the welfare state in Europe
/ Routledge
: 198~217
[journal]
Kim, P. H.
/ 2010
/ The East Asian welfare state debate and surrogate social policy: an exploratory study on Japan and South Korea
/ SOCIO-ECONOMIC REVIEW
/ Oxford University Press
8(3)
: 411~435
[book]
Kwon, H. J.
/ 2005
/ Transforming the developmental welfare state in east asia
/ UNRISD/Palgrave
[journal]
Kwon, H. J.
/ 2009
/ Economic development and poverty reduction in Korea: Governing multifunctional institutions
/ Development and Change
40(4)
: 769~792
[journal]
이승윤
/ 2011
/
The Evolution of Welfare Production Regimes in East Asia: A Comparative Study of Korea, Japan, and Taiwan
/ The Korean Journal of Policy Studies
/ 서울대학교행정대학원
26(1)
: 49~75
[journal]
Lee, S. SY.
/ 2011
/ A Critique of Fuzzy-set Method in Comparative Social Policy
/ Quality and Quantity
[journal]
Lewis, J.
/ 1992
/ Gender and the development of welfare regimes
2
: 159~173
[book]
Mahoney, J.
/ 2003
/ Comparative historical analysis: Achievements and agenda, In Comparative historical analysis in the social science
/ Cambridge Univ Press
[book]
Mayer, L.C.
/ 1989
/ Redefining Comparative Politics
/ Sage
[book]
OECD
/ 1981
/ The welfare state in crisis
/ OECD
[book]
Offe, C.
/ 1984
/ Contradictions of the welfare state
/ MIT Press
[journal]
Orloff, A.
/ 1996
/ Gender in the welfare state
/ Annual Review of Sociology
: 51~78
[book]
Rieger, E.
/ 2003
/ Limits to globalization: Welfare states and the world economy
/ Polity Press in association with Blackwell Pub
[book]
Ragin, C.
/ 2008
/ Redesigning Social Inquiry: Fuzzy sets and Beyond
/ The University of Chicago Press
[book]
Satori, G.
/ 2009
/ Guidelines of concept analysis, In Concepts and methods in social science
/ Rouledge
[journal]
Seeleib-Kaiser, M.
/ 2002
/ Globalisation, political discourse, and welfare systems in a comparative perspective: Germany, Japan, and the USA
/ Czech Sociological Review
38(6)
: 749~769
[book]
Tang, K. L.
/ 2000
/ Social welfare development in east asia
/ Palgrave
[book]
White. G.
/ 1998
/ Welfare Orientalism and the search for an East Asian welfare model, In The East Asian Welfare model
/ Routledge
[book]
Wilensky, H. L.
/ 1975
/ The welfare state and equality: Structural and ideological roots of public expenditures
/ University of California Press