A Study on Securing the Quality of Trusted Digital Records as Evidence: Focusing on Analysis of Quality Concept and Requirements for Records and Evidence Respectively Covered in Records Management and Judicial Domain (증거로서 신뢰할 수 있는 전자기록의 품질 확보방안 연구: 기록관리영역과 사법영역에서 다루는 기록과 증거의 품질 개념과 요건 분석을 중심으로)

Gemma Lee (이젬마); Kyung-Mook OH (오경묵)

doi:10.14699/kbiblia.2021.32.3.217

A Study on Securing the Quality of Trusted Digital Records as Evidence: Focusing on Analysis of Quality Concept and Requirements for Records and Evidence Respectively Covered in Records Management and Judicial Domain

Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science
2021, 32(3), pp.217-246
DOI : 10.14699/kbiblia.2021.32.3.217
Publisher : Journal Of The Korean Biblia Society For Library And Information Science
Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science
Received : August 16, 2021
Accepted : August 28, 2021
Published : September 30, 2021

Gemma Lee ¹, Kyung-Mook OH ²

¹행정안전부 국가기록원
²숙명여자대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This study aimed to analyze the quality concepts and requirements of digital records as evidence and to find an implication to develop requirements for trusted digital records with securing authoritative qualities. To this end, this study compared requirements of records domain linking records process, records metadata and records systems with judicial domain on digital evidence, and identified the records requirements to secure the legal admissibility linking records and judicial domain. This study analyzed the relationship of quality concepts between digital records and digital evidence, found the legal admissibility is highly related to the reliability, and derived that it needs the measure to secure the reliability at the stage of records creation and capture. To prove authenticity of digital evidence, this study identified importance of records process, records metadata and records system, and proposed the necessity of measurement to secure records’ evidence.

KEYWORDS

Digital Records, Evidential Quality of Digital Records, Authoritative Records, Digital Evidence, Trusted Digital Records, Legal Admissibility

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[other] / 공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률 법률 제16661호

[other] / 공공기록물 관리에 관한 법률 시행령 대통령령 제31380호

[web] / 2021 / 법률용어사전 전문증거 / https://terms.naver.com/entry.naver?docId=3654451&cid=42131&categoryId=42131

[report] 사법정책연구원 / 2015 / 디지털 증거의 증거능력 판단에 관한 연구

[journal] 설문원 / 2005 / Quality Criteria for Measuring Authenticity, Reliability, Integrity and Usability of Records / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (11) : 41~90

[journal] 윤은하 / 2019 / A Study on the Concepts of Record from a Legal Perspective / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (60) : 89~121

[journal] 이경남 / 2019 / A Study on Authentication Model using Blockchain / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (59) : 47~78

[journal] 이상원 / 2012 / Electronic Evidence and Best Evidence Rule / 형사법의 신동향 / 대검찰청 (36) : 50~104

[journal] 이숙연 / 2017 / The Admissibility of Digital Evidence -The Status of Identity and Integrity in Assessing the Admissibility of Digital Evidence and the Interpretation of Article 313 of the Amended Criminal Procedure Act- / 저스티스 / 한국법학원 161 : 164~199

[journal] 이승억 / 2017 / A Study of Redesigning Electronic Records Management Policies / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (52) : 5~37

[journal] 이윤주 / 2009 / A Policy Framework for the Long-term Preservation of Authentic Digital Records: Based on InterPARES Studies / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (19) : 193~249

[thesis] 최영민 / 2018 / 전자기록의 증거능력 인정요건에 관한 기록학적 분석 / 석사 / 부산대학교대학원

[other] / 형사소송법 법률 제17572호

[journal] Duranti, L. / 1995 / Protecting electronic evidence: a progress report on a research study and its methodology / Archivi and Computer, Roma 3 : 213~250

[journal] Duranti, L / 1997 / The preservation of the integrity of electronic records: an overview of the UBC-MAS research project / Archivaria 42 : 46~67

[book] Duranti, L. / 2019 / Trusting Records in the Cloud / Facet Publishing

[journal] Duranti, L. / 1989 / Diplomatics: New Uses for an Old Science(Part I) / Archivaria 28 : 7~27

[journal] Duranti, L / 1995 / Reliability and authenticity: the concepts and their implications / Archivaria 39 : 5~10

[journal] Duranti, L. / 2001 / The impact of digital technology on archival science / Archival Science 1 : 39~55

[book] Duranti, L. / 2002 / Preservation of the Integrity of Electronic Records / Kluwer Academic Publishers

[other] Electronic records as documentary evidence / 2017 / Canadian General Standards Board

[other] / Federal Rules of Evidence

[other] / 2020 / Information and documentation - Records management - Core concepts and vocabulary / ISO 30300:2020

[other] / 2016 / Information and documentation - Records management - Part 1: Concepts and principles / ISO 15489-1:2016

[other] / 2017 / Information and documentation - Records management processes - Metadata for records: Part 1: Principles / ISO 23081-1:2017

[other] InterPARES 1 Authenticity Task Force / 2002 / Requirements for Assessing and Maintaining the Authenticity of Electronic Records(Appendix 2)

[other] InterPARES 2 Project / 2008 / Terminology Cross-domain Task Force Report(including Appendix 22)

[journal] Jansen, A. / 2015 / Object-oriented diplomatics: Using archival diplomatics in software application development to support authenticity of digital records / Records Management Journal 25(1) : 45~55

[web] MacNeil, H / 2005 / Authenticity Task Force Report, The Long-Term Preservation of Authentic Electronic Records / http://www.interpares.org/book/

[journal] Rogers, C / 2016 / A literature review of authenticity of records in digital systems: from 'machine-readable' to records in the cloud / acervo, rio de janeiro 29(2) : 16~44

[book] Shepherd, E. / 2003 / Managing Records: a handbook of principles and practice / Facet Publishing

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.82

A Study on Securing the Quality of Trusted Digital Records as Evidence: Focusing on Analysis of Quality Concept and Requirements for Records and Evidence Respectively Covered in Records Management and Judicial Domain

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Journal of the Korean Biblia Society for Library and Information Science 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.82

A Study on Securing the Quality of Trusted Digital Records as Evidence: Focusing on Analysis of Quality Concept and Requirements for Records and Evidence Respectively Covered in Records Management and Judicial Domain

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (3)

REFERENCES (31) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.