항의가 정책변화에 미치는 영향 분석: 환경부문을 중심으로

조성은

항의가 정책변화에 미치는 영향 분석: 환경부문을 중심으로

Korean Society and Public Administration
Abbr : KSPA
2010, 21(3), pp.195-223
Publisher : Seoul Association For Public Administration
Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration

조성은 ¹

¹고려대학교 BK21 아시아행정학허브사업단

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This research presents an empirical analysis of the effect of protest on policy change. Focusing on environmental issues and data-mining the PEDAK database, it suggests the impact of protest on policy change by analyzing factors associated with protest scale, protest strategies, protest demands, protesters and targets of protest action. Regarding protest scale, the research reveals a correlation between the number of participants and policy change. Furthermore, when protest methods vary, targets of protest action are more willing to make concessions on certain issues. Lastly, protest content plays a significant role in policy change. However, unlike other cases, greater cost burden on targets of protest action will dissipate the joint effect of ecological and political demands on policy change. This research has theoretical significance in that it seeks to enhance past research on unconventional participation and policy change by offering empirically grounded analysis of the effect of protest on policy change.

KEYWORDS

Environmental policy, unconventional participation, protest, policy change

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[other] 경향신문 / 2010 / 각계 ‘4대강 저지’ 행동 통일

[other] 경향신문 / 2010 / 개신교 목회자도 ‘4대강 시국선언’ 중단 때까지 저항

[other] 국민일보 / 2008 / 이 대통령 새로운 기적의 60년 만들자 저탄소 녹색 성장시대 선언

[journal] 김선혁 / 2006 / Democratization and Civil Society’s Protest against Government: Unconventional Participation and the ‘Governance’ Discourse in Korea / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 15(3) : 249~270

[book] 김영평 / 1991 / 불확실성과 정책의 정당성 / 고려대 출판부

[journal] 김종진 / 2007 / 미조직 화이트칼라 노동자들의 상태와 노조태도 / 노동사회 127 : 132~150

[journal] 김지섭 / 1994 / 화이트칼라의 내적 분화와 계층론적 함의: 대구시 전문, 관리, 사무직을 중심으로 / 한국사회학 28 : 71~99

[journal] 남상민 / 2005 / NGOs in Policy Process: Advocacy Coalition Framework and NGOs' roles in the Saemankum Reclamation Project / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 14(1) : 28~53

[book] 문태훈 / 1997 / 환경정책론 / 형설출판사

[journal] 문태훈 / 2008 / Evolution of Environmental Policy in Korea and It's Future Task, 1963-2007 / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 17(3) : 131~161

[journal] 박종민 / 1995 / 정치항의의 사회심리적 조건 / 한국정치학회보 29(1) : 1377~1396

[journal] 배응환 / 2001 / 환경변화, 제도변화 그리고 정책변화: 신제도주의 접근방법을 중심으로 / 행정논총 39(2) : 103~139

[journal] 유홍림 / 2009 / Policy Change of the Saemankum Reclamation Project: Based on the PSF / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 18(2) : 189~218

[journal] 유훈 / 2001 / 정책변동과 정책활동가 / 행정논총 39(1) : 23~42

[journal] 윤순진 / 2006 / The Siting Process of a Medium and Low Level Radioactive Waste Disposal Facility and Anti-nuclear Movements in 2005 in Korea / 시민사회와 NGO / 제3섹터연구소 4(1) : 277~311

[journal] 윤홍우 / 1997 / 화이트칼라 노동조합원의 이중몰입에 관한 연구 / 경영학연구 10 : 155~190

[book] 이시재 / 1998 / 한국의 시민사회와 신사회운동 / 나남출판 : 195~220

[book] 이종원 / 2007 / 계량경제학 / 박영사

[journal] 장지호 / 2004 / The Advocacy Coalition Framework and the Policy Change Analysis: The case of Diesel Vehicle Policy in Korea / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 38(1) : 175~196

[journal] 전영평 / 2008 / North Korean Defectors as Minority and Their Struggle for Policy Change in South Korea / 정부학연구 / 정부학연구소 14(4) : 239~268

[journal] 정규호 / 2007 / The Meaning and Assignments of Consensus-building Approach for Participatory Resolutions for Policy Conflicts: Focusing on Conflicts Around the Construction of the Hantan River Dam / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 16(2) : 91~118

[journal] 정민수 / 2008 / The Clustering Appearance of Social Movement Organizations and Its Determinants: Coalition Networks among Korean Voluntary Associations in 2005 / 시민사회와 NGO / 제3섹터연구소 6(2) : 135~174

[book] 정정길 / 2007 / 정책학원론 / 대명문화사

[journal] 정정화 / 2005 / The Activities of Environmental NGO in Policy Process and Policy Participation Models / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 14(3) : 57~80

[journal] 주선미 / 2003 / 환경정의운동과 지역정책과정: 공론장 모형에 의한 사례분석 / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 37(3) : 139~157

[journal] 주성수 / 2005 / The Protest of Public Opinion against Governmental Decisions: In search of institutional alternatives of deliberative democracy / 한국정치학회보 / 한국정치학회 39(3) : 147~166

[journal] 한세억 / 2002 / A Study on the change and characteristic of Informatization Policy in Korea / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 11(3) : 21~44

[report] 행정안전부 / 2009 / 보행환경 국민의식조사 보고서

[journal] 홍성만 / 2002 / 정부와비정부조직( N G O ) 의 정책경쟁과합의형성과정:영월(동강)댐 건설을 둘러싼 정책조직과 환경운동연합을중심으로 / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 36(1) : 21~40

[book] Barker, C / 2002 / Strategizing and the Sense of Context: Reflections on the First Two Weeks of the Liverpool Docks Lockout , September-October. in: Social Movements: Identity, Culture, and the State / Oxford University : 140~156

[book] Barnes, S. H / 1979 / Political Action / Sage

[journal] Beyer, C / 2007 / Non-Governmental Organizations as Motors of Change / Government and Opposition 42(4) : 513~535

[journal] Burstein, P / 1991 / Legal Mobilization as a Social Movement Tactic: The Struggle for Equal Employment / The American Journal of Sociology 96(5) : 1201~1225

[book] Burstein, P / 1999 / Social Movements and Public Policy. in: How Social Movements Matter / University of Minnesota Press : 3~21

[book] Crozat, M / 1998 / Are the Times A-Changin’? Assessing the Acceptance of protest in Western Democracies. in: The social movement society: contentious politics for a new century / Rowman & Littlefield Publishers : 59~81

[journal] Eisinger, P. K / 1973 / The Conditions of Protest Behavior in American Cities / American Political Science Review 67 : 11~28

[journal] Ekiert, G / 1998 / Contentious Politics in New Democracies: East Germany, Hungary, Poland, and Slovakia, 1989-93 / World Politics 50(4) : 547~581

[book] Ekiert, G / 1999 / Rebellious Civil Society: Popular Protest and Democratic Consolidation in Poland, 1989-1993 / University of Michigan Press

[journal] Frey, R. S / 1992 / Characteristics of Successful American Protest Groups: Another Look at Gamson’s Strategy of Social Protest / American Journal of Sociology 98 : 368~387

[book] Gamson, W. A / 1990 / The Strategy of Social Protest / Wadsworth Publishing

[book] Giugni, M / 2004 / Social Protest and Policy Change / Rowman & Littlefield Publishers, Inc.

[book] Goldstone, J. A / 2003 / Introduction: Bridging Institutionalized and Noninstitutionalized Politics. in: States, Parties, and Social Movements / Cambridge University Press : 1~26

[book] Gujarati, D. N / 2009 / Basic Econometrics / McGraw-Hill

[book] Hall, P. A / 1992 / The movement from Keynesianism to monetarism: Institutional analysis and British economic policy in the 1970s. in: Structuring Politics / Cambridge University Press : 90~113

[journal] Hayes, G / 2006 / Vulnerability and Disobedience: New Repertories in French Environmental Protests / Environmental Politics 15(5) : 821~838

[journal] Heath, O / 2008 / Triggers for Protest: Modelling responses to the political context in Britain, 2000-2002 / European Journal of Political Research 47 : 489~509

[book] Hogwood, B / 1983 / Policy Dynamics / St. Martin’s Press

[journal] Jancar-Webster, B / 1998 / Environmental Movement and Social Change in Transition Countries / Environmental Politics 7(1) : 69~90

[journal] Kim, H / 1997 / The Structure and Dynamics of Movement Participation / American Sociological Review 62(1) : 70~93

[book] Kingdon, J. W / 1984 / Agenda, Alternatives, and Public Policies / Little, Brown and Co.

[journal] Kousis, M / 2007 / Local Environmental Protest in Greece, 1974-94: Exploring the Political Dimension / Environmental Politics 16(5) : 785~804

[journal] Lowry, W / 2006 / Potential Focusing Projects and Policy Change / The Policy Studies Journal 34 : 313~335

[book] Luder, J / 2003 / Countermovements, the State, and the Intensity of Racial Contention in the American South. in: States, Parties, and Social Movements / Cambridge University Press : 27~45

[journal] McAdam, D / 1983 / Tactical Innovation and the Pace of Insurgency / American Sociological Review 48 : 735~754

[book] McAdam, D / 1988 / Social Movements. in: Handbook of Sociology / Sage Publications : 695~738

[journal] McCarthy, J. D / 1977 / Resource Mobilization and Social Movements / American Journal of Sociology 82 : 1212~1241

[book] McCarthy, J. D / 2002 / Resource Mobilization Theory. in: Social Movements in an Organizational Society: Collected Essays / Transaction Books : 15~48

[journal] Metcalfe, D / 2008 / The Protest Game: Animal Rights Protest and the Life Science Industry / Negotiation Journal April : 125~143

[book] Meyer, D. S / 2007 / The Politics of Protest / Oxford University Press

[book] Meyer, D. S / 1998 / The social movement society : contentious politics for a new century / Rowman & Littlefield Publishers

[book] Milbrath, L. W / 1977 / Political Participation / Rand McNally

[journal] Mirowsky, J / 1981 / Protest Group Success: The Impact of Group Characteristics, Social Control and Context / Sociological Focus 14 : 177~192

[book] Moore, K / 1999 / Political Protests and Institutional Change: The Anti-Vietnam War Movement and American Science. in: How Social Movements Matter / University of Minnesota Press : 97~119

[book] Mucciaroni, G / 1995 / Reversals of Fortunes: Public Policy and Private Interests / Brookings Institution

[book] Norris, P / 2002 / Democratic Phoenix: Reinventing Political Activism / Cambridge University Press

[journal] Olzak, S / 1989 / Analysis of Events in the Study of Collective Action / Annual Review of Sociology 15 : 119~141

[book] Schneider, M / 1995 / Public entrepreneurs : agents for change in American government / Princeton University Press

[journal] Snyder, D / 1976 / Industrial Violence in Italy, 1878-1903 / American Sociological Review 45 : 787~801

[journal] Steedly, H. R / 1979 / The Success of Protest Groups: Multivariate Analyses / Social Science Research 8 : 1~15

[book] Tarrow, S / 1998 / Power in Movement: Social Movement and Contentious Politics / Cambridge University Press

[book] Tilly, C / 1978 / From Mobilization to Revolution / Addison Wesley

[book] Tilly, C / 1984 / Social Movements and National Politics. in: Statemaking and Social Movements / University of Michigan Press : 297~317

[journal] Weissert, C. S / 2002 / Nonincremental Policy Change: Lessons from Michgan’s Medicaid Managed Care Initiative / Public Administration Review 62(2) : 206~216

[journal] Wilson, C. A / 2000 / Policy Regimes and Policy Change / Journal of Public Policy 20(3) : 247~274

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Korean Society and Public Administration 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.89