본문 바로가기
  • Home

The Multistate System in Pre-Mongol East Asia

  • Journal of Manchurian Studies
  • Abbr : 만주연구
  • 2005, (3), pp.43~59
  • Publisher : The Manchurian Studies Association
  • Research Area : Social Science > Area Studies > East Asia > China
  • Received : September 16, 2005
  • Accepted : September 30, 2005
  • Published : October 31, 2005

Peter Yun 1

1영산대학교 학부대학

ABSTRACT

Before the Mongol Yuan period, Northeast Asian interstate relations were governed by a treaty sys­tem based on the principle of reciprocity among a number of legitimate and equal regimes. While the Manchurian conquest dynasties confronted the Chinese Song states, Korean Koryo and Tangut Xia states functioned as balancers in the Northeast Asian military balance of power. Each state asserted its own ethnocentric world-view in the Northeast Asian multistate system, and the diplomatic formalities of investitures and tributes were not signs of submission, but peace and accommodation. Chinese historians have employed the tribute system to reinforce their territorial and historiographical claims over non-Han ethnic groups. However, the official theory of interstate rela­tions with the Chinese state at the center was nothing more than a myth perpetuated to justify the rule of Chinese rulers to their subjects. The Chinese attempt to impose contemporary political bounda­ries on the past is a case of blatant presentism that reads history backwards by applying today’s so­cial and political standards and conditions to the past. Today’s boundaries of China are of recent cre­ation, and the term zhongguo (Central Kingdom) must be taken as a subjective and geopolitical desig-­nation.

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.