SUVANNABHUMI 2025 KCI Impact Factor : 0.12
-
pISSN : 2092-738X / eISSN : 2799-7839
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/svn
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Malaysia’s Flawed Democracy: A Stumbling Block Towards Becoming a First World Developed Nation
- SUVANNABHUMI
- Abbr : SVN
- 2023, 15(2), pp.271~303
- DOI : 10.22801/svn.2023.15.2.271
- Publisher : Korea Institute for ASEAN Studies
- Research Area : Social Science > Area Studies > Southeast Asia
- Received : January 5, 2022
- Accepted : July 10, 2023
- Published : July 31, 2023
Juli Ooi 1
1Pusan National University
Accredited
ABSTRACT
In 1991, Malaysia, under the leadership of then-Prime Minister Mahathir Mohamad, launched an ambitious 30-year national development program known as Vision 2020. The goal of this program was to transform Malaysia into a First World developed nation by the year 2020. One of the aspirations of the program was to create a psychologically liberated, secure, ethical, and mature democratic society. Vision 2020 is a failure and Malaysia is still not a mature democracy. This article identifies four main areas that make up a flawed democracy practiced in Malaysia, and shows how they work against the country's aspirations to become a developed nation. The electoral system is rigged to help the incumbent remain in power. The widespread practices of money politics have become a curse to the country. The press and media organizations are restricted. Civil society activities are suppressed. As a result of these issues, Malaysia will not be able to achieve the status of a developed nation, lacking democratic accountability and inclusive institutions.
KEYWORDS
Journal Copyright Policy
This license enables reusers to copy and distribute the material in any medium or format in unadapted form only, for noncommercial purposes only, and only if attribution is given to the creator.
Statistics
-
971 Viewed
-
641 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2025 are currently being built.
[web]
Acemoglu, Daron
/ 2021
/ Inclusive Institutions, Democracy and the Key Drivers for Economic Growth
/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KLdnISYOUo4
[book]
Acemoglu, Daron
/ 2012
/ Why Nations Fail
/ Crown PG
[report]
Acemoglu, Daron
/ 2004
/ Democracy Does Cause Growth
/ National Bureau of Economic Research
[web]
Amnesty International.
/ 1998
/ The Arrest of Anwar and His Political Associates
/ Refworld
/ https://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6a9ad14.html
[web]
ANFREL
/ 2013
/ Malaysia GE13: Serious Concerns about May 5th Election Require Sincere Investigation and Reform
/ https://anfrel.org/malaysia-ge13-serious-concerns-about-may-5th-election-require-sincere-investigation-and-reform/
[report]
Amran, Iman
/ 2021
/ Political Funding in Malaysia:Starting from the Ground Up, Working Paper Series System of Political Finance Across Asian Democracies
/ The East Asia Institute
[web]
Anand, Ram
/ 2020
/ Malaysian PM Muhyiddin's Emergency Proposal Disproportionate and Unjustified: Rivals, Civil Groups
/ Strait Times
/ https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/pm-muhyiddins-emergency-proposal-gets-frosty-response-from-rivals-civil-society
[web]
Azhari, Aira
/ 2021
/ Political Financing in Malaysia:Recent Developments and Plugging Potential Gaps
/ Ideas
/ https://www.ideas.org.my/publications-item/brief-ideas-no-33-political-financing-in-malaysia-recent-developments-and-plugging-potential-gaps/
[web]
Aziz, Adam
/ 2020
/ Commotion in Parliament as Ramkarpal Stopped from Playing Audio Clip of Purported Bersatu Plan to Woo Umno MPs
/ The Edge Markets
/ https://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/commotion-parliament-ramkarpal-stopped-playing-audio-clip-purported-bersatuplan-woo-umno
[web]
Aziz, Adam
/ 2021
/ Automated Voter Registration for All, Including Malaysians Overseas Deputy Minister
/ The Edge Markets
/ https://www.theedgemarkets.com/article/automated-voter-registration-all-including-malaysians-overseas--deputy-minister
[journal]
Azmi, Khairul Saidah Abbas
/ 2020
/ Money in Politics: A Recipe for Corruption in Malaysia
/ Journal of Financial Crime
[book]
Bagang, T. P.
/ 2019
/ Sabah: The End of BN and Start of a New order? The Defeat of Barisan Nasional: Missed Signs or Late Surge
/ ISEAS Publishing
: 402~422
[web]
Balasundram, Nishyodhan
/ 2020
/ Should Malaysia Switch from a First-Past-The-Post (FPTP) to a Propostional Representation (PR) Electoral System?
/ Grin
/ https://www.grin.com/document/909568
[journal]
Banik, Dan
/ 2022
/ Democracy and Sustainable Development
/ Anthropocene Science
1
: 233~245
[web]
BBC
/ 2011
/ Malaysia: Police fire tear gas at banned rally
/ https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-pacific-14076424
[web]
Bernama
/ 2021
/ Is There No Media Freedom in Malaysia?
/ KKD
/ https://www.kkd.gov.my/en/public/news/18869-is-there-nomedia-freedom-in-malaysia
[web]
BERSIH
/ 2008
/ Postal Voting Facilitates Manipulation
/ https://BERSIH.org/2008/08/21/postal-voting-facilitates-manipulation/
[web]
BERSIH
/ 2017
/ Malaysia’s Electoral System Must Now Change
/ https://BERSIH.org/2017/12/07/media-statement-7-december-2017-BERSIH-malaysias-electoral-system-must-now-change/
[book]
Bowie, Alasdair
/ 2004
/ Civil Society and Democratization in Malaysia. Growth and Governance in Asia
/ Asia Pacific Center for Security Studies
: 193~201
[web]
Buang, Salleh
/ 2019
/ Freedom of Speech: Do Not Cross the Line
/ New Strait Times
/ https://www.nst.com.my/opinion/columnists/2019/01/446413/freedom-speech-do-not-cross-line
[other]
Bunbongkarn, Suchit
/ 2004
/ The Role of Civil Society in Democratic Consolidation in Asia
[journal]
Case, William
/ 1993
/ Semi-Democracy in Malaysia: Withstanding the Pressures for Regime Change
/ Pacific Affairs
66(2)
: 183~205
[journal]
Chan, Tsu Chong
/ 2018
/ Democratic Breakthrough in Malaysia Political Opportunities and the Role of BERSIH
/ Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs
37(3)
: 109~137
[web]
Chan, T.C.
/ 2021
/ Improving Access to Voting in Malaysia
/ BERSIH
/ https://www.BERSIH.org/download/improving-access-to-voting-in-malaysia
[report]
de Hann, Jarryd
/ 2020
/ Malaysia: Many Challenges to Wawasan 2020. Development Vision
/ Future Directions International Pty. Ltd
[journal]
Dettman, Sebastian Carl
/ 2020
/ Political Finance Reform: Politics, Policies, and Patronage in Malaysia
/ Journal of Contemporary Asia
50(1)
: 36~55
[web]
Diamond, Larry
/ 2004
/ What Civil Society Can Do to Develop Democracy
/ Stanford
/ https://diamond-democracy.stanford.edu/speaking/speeches/what-civil-society-can-do-develop-democracy
[journal]
NABAMITA DUTTA
/ 2016
/
DO LITERACY AND A MATURE DEMOCRATIC REGIME CURE CORRUPTION?
/ Journal of Economic Development
/ 경제연구소
41(2)
: 1~26
[journal]
Frank, Sina
/ 2006
/ Project Mahathir: ‘Extraordinary’ Population Growth in Sabah
/ Sudostasien aktuell: Journal of Current SouthEast Asia Affairs
25(5)
: 72~80
[book]
Fukuyama, Francis
/ 2011
/ The Origins of Political Order
/ Farrar, Straus and Giroux
[web]
Fukuyama, Francis
/ 2013
/ What Is Development?
/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iG3G56YdFeE
[journal]
Geissel, Bridgitte
/ 2016
/ Measuring the Quality of Democracy: Introduction
/ International Political Science Review
37(5)
: 571~579
[journal]
Giersdorf, Stephan
/ 2011
/ Civil Societies and Competitive Authoritarianism in Malaysia
/ Journal of Civil Society
7(1)
: 1~21
[journal]
Gomez, Edmund Terence
/ 2012
/ Monetizing Politics: Financing Parties and Elections in Malaysia
/ Modern Asian Studies
46(5)
: 1370~1397
[report]
Gomez, Edmund Terence
/ 2021
/ Foundations and Donations: Political Financing, Corruption and Pursuit of Power
/ C4 Center
[book]
Gomez, James
/ 2018
/ Media and Elections
/ Strategic Information and Reserch Development Centre
[web]
Gomez, Terence
/ 2020
/ How Muhyiddin Consolidates Power through GLC Appointments
/ Malaysia Kini
/ https://malaysiakini.com/news/520044
[web]
Hadi, Mohd Zaini Samsu
/ 2021
/ Proclamation of Emergency Has Hidden Agenda Jomo Kwame
/ Malaysia Gazette
/ https://malaysiagazette.com/2021/04/19/proclamation-of-emergency-has-hidden-agenda-jomo-kwame/
[journal]
Harridon, Mohd.
/ 2022
/ Think Tanks in Malaysia and Their Attributes
/ International Journal of Research and Scientific Publications
12(11)
: 167~171
[journal]
Hazis, Faisal S
/ 2009
/ The Politics of Development in Sarawak
/ Akademika
77
: 91~111
[journal]
Heo, Uk
/ 2015
/ Democracy, Institutional Maturity, and Economic Development
/ Social Science Quarterly
96(4)
: 1041~1058
[web]
Herrera-Lim, Bob
/ 2018
/ It’s in the Turnout
/ Teneo
/ https://www.teneo.com/malaysia-election-preview-its-in-the-turnout/
[web]
Hisamudin, Hakimie Amrie
/ 2022
/ Delay in Political Funding Act Shows Both Sides Guilty, Says Economist
/ Free Malaysia Today
/ https://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/nation/2022/06/23/delay-in-political-funding-act-shows-both-sides-guilty-says-economist/
[web]
Hornbill, Unleahed
/ 2018
/ BERSIH: Court Decision on Segamat Army Voters a Blow to Democracy
/ BERSIH
/ https://hornbillunleashed.wordpress.com/2018/03/23/BERSIH-court-decision-on-segamat-army-voters-a-blow-to-democracy/
[report]
Houghton, Tessa J
/ 2013
/ ‘Watching the Watchdong’: Malaysian Media Coverage of GE13
/ University of Nottingham in collaboration with Centre for Independent Journalism
[other]
Human Rights Watch
/ 2021
/ Malaysia : Government Steps Up Attack on LGBT
[web]
Hussin, Rais
/ 2023
/ Malaysia’s RM4.5 Trillion Losses to Corruption &Leakages - It Is Time to TRAC!
/ Emir Research
/ https://www.emirresearch.com/malaysias-rm4-5-trillion-losses-to-corruption-leakages-it-is-time-to-trac/
[web]
IFJ
/ 2016
/ Malaysian Pro-Government Protesters Demand Closure of Malaysiakini
/ https://www.ifj.org/media-centre/news/detail/category/press-releases/article/malaysian-pro-governmentprotesters-demand-closure-of-malaysiakini
[web]
IFJ
/ 2021
/ Malaysia: Press Freedom Drops to New Low
/ https://www.ifj.org/media-centre/news/detail/category/asia-pacific/article/malaysia-press-freedom-drops-to-new-low
[confproc]
Ismail, Adibah
/ 2017
/ Investigative Journalism in Malaysia: The Battle Between Outside and Inside Newsroom Challenges
/ SHS Web of Conferences
: 33~
[journal]
Ismail, Muhamad Takiyuddin
/ 2022
/ The Uncivil Side of Civil Society: The Case of BERSIH in Malaysia
/ Akademika
92(2)
: 1~13
[book]
Jayasooria, Denison
/ 2021
/ Role of Civil Society Organisations in Localising SDGs in Malaysia. Making SDGs Matter: Leaving No One Behind
/ Institute of Strategic and International Studies
: 183~198
[web]
Kannan, Hashini Kavishtri
/ 2018
/ All Should Respect Court Decision on Delineation Exercise
/ New Strait Times
/ https://www.nst.com.my/news/nation/2018/02/337644/all-should-respect-courtdecision-re-delineation-exercise
[web]
Karim, Khairah N
/ 2019
/ Tian Chua Never Lost Eligibility to Contest in Elections
/ New Strait Ttimes
/ https://www.nst.com.my/news/crime-courts/2019/11/536354/tian-chua-never-lost-eligibility-contest-elections
[report]
Khemani, Stuti
/ 2013
/ Buying Votes vs. Supplying Public Services:Political Incentives to Under-invest in Pro-poor policies
/ World Bank Group
[web]
Khoo, Ying Hooi
/ 2018
/ Civil Society and Democratisation in Malaysia: Between Resistance and Co-optation
/ Civicus
/ https://www.civicus.org/index.php/re-imagining-democracy/stories-from-the-frontlines/3428-civil-society-and-democratisation-in-malaysia-between-resistance-and-co-optation
[journal]
Khoo, Ying Hooi
/ 2020
/ Post-legislative Scrutiny in the Process of Democratic Transition in Malaysia
/ Journal of Southeast Asian Human Rights
4(1)
: 52~68
[report]
Landman, Todd
/ 2007
/ Developing Democracy: Concept, Measures and Empirical Relationships
/ Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Sweden
[web]
Lee, Kuan Yew
/ 1990
/ Last National Day Speech (Part 9)
/ https://youtu.be?IWqoErLFMTY
[other]
Lee, Long Hui
/ 2019
/ Numbers Show It Parliament Is in the Executive Pocket
/ Malaysiakini
[book]
Lemiere, Sophie
/ 2019
/ Illusions of Democracy: Malaysian Politics and People
/ Amsterdam University Press
[web]
Li, Eric X.
/ 2013
/ A Tale of Two Political Systems
/ https://youtube/s0YjL9rZyR0
[web]
Lim, Sue Goan
/ 2017
/ Mahathir the Scandal King
/ Malaysia Today
/ https://www.malaysia-today.net/2017/07/02/mahathir-the-scandal-king/
[web]
Loh, Jason
/ 2021
/ Reforming Our Political Funding Culture to Be More Transparent
/ Malay Mail
/ https://www.malaymail.com/news/what-you-think/2021/05/06/reforming-our-political-funding-culture-to-be-more-transparent-jason-loh/1972117
[web]
Mohamad, Mahathir
/ 1991
/ Malaysian: The Way Forward (Vision 2020). YPFS Documents Series 1: 14377
/ https://elischolar.library.yale.edu/ypfs-documents/14377
[web]
Malaysiakini
/ 2019
/ Zahid Hamidi Charged with CBT
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/464791
[web]
Malaysiakini
/ 2021
/ CIJ Warns of Arbitrary Arrests under the Cloak of Emergency
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/558795
[web]
Malaysiakini Team
/ 2020
/ Umno - From King to Kingmaker
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/546520
[web]
Malaysiakini Team
/ 2022
/ Four Takeaways from Johor Polls
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/614183
[web]
Mokhtar, Mariam
/ 2017
/ Focus on Malaysian Sub Scandal Surfaces
/ https://www.asiasentinel.com/p/malaysia-submarine-scandal-surfaces-abdul-razak-baginda
[web]
Neo, Jacklyn L.
/ 2018
/ Restoring the Independence and Integrity of Malaysia’s Judiciary: Proposals for Reform and Challenges Ahead
/ Constitutionnet
/ https://constitutionnet.org/news/restoring-independence-and-integrity-malaysias-judiciary-proposals-reform-and-challenges-ahead
[web]
Netto, Anil.
/ A Y2K Crackdown
/ Aliran
/ https://aliran.com/oldsite/high9912d.htm
[web]
Netto, Anil.
/ 2000
/ Media-Malaysia: Silencing the Opposition Mouthpiece
/ Iner Press Service
/ https://www.ipsnews.net/2000/03/mediamalaysia-silencing-the-opposition-mouthpiece/
[report]
Ng, Chak Ngoon
/ The Influence of Electoral Laws on the Conduct of Elections in Malaysia. A research report done for Tindak Malaysia, an NGO to educate voters and work towards a 2-party state system
[web]
Ng, Eileen
/ 2018
/ In Malaysia’s Largest Constituency, Opposition Incumbent Sees Sharp Spike in Voters and Competition
/ Today Online
/ https://www.todayonline.com/malaysias-largest-constituency-opposition-incumbent-sees-sharp-spike-voters-andcompetition
[report]
Ooi, Kok Hin
/ 2021
/ Public Funding of Political Parties in Malaysia:Debates, Case Studies and Recommendations(BERSIH 2.0)
/ The Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections
[web]
Palansamy, Yiswaree
/ 2020
/ Art Harun Named New Speaker without a Vote, Boots Amanah MP Khalid Samad Out of Parliament
/ Malay Mail
/ https://www.malaymail.com/news/malaysia/2020/07/13/new-speaker-art-harun-taunted-by-opposition-after-swearing-in-boots-khalid/1884006
[web]
Pemantau
/ 2013
/ Preliminary Observation Report on GE13
/ BERSIH
/ https://BERSIH.org/2013/05/06/pemantau-preliminary-observation-report-on-ge13/
[report]
Pemantau
/ 2018
/ Election Observation Report of the 14th General Elec tion. A report for The Coalition for Clean and Fair Elections (BERSIH 2.0)
/ BERSIH
[web]
Ramakrishnan, P.
/ 2020
/ Muhyiddin Running Scared-No Majority Support?
/ Malaysia Kini
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/letters/522205
[web]
Rashid, Hidir Reduan Abdul
/ 2021
/ Malaysiakini Fined RM500,000 for Contempt of Court
/ Malaysiakini
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/563554
[web]
Reilly, Benjamin
/ 2019
/ Malaysian Electoral Reform Three Proposals
/ Research Impact
/ https://researchimpact.uwa.edu.au/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/Malaysia-electoral-reform-options.pdf
[web]
Reuters
/ 2018
/ Watchdogs Believe Flaws to Malaysia Voter List ‘Tip of the Iceberg’
/ https://www.reuters.com/article/us-malaysiaelection-BERSIH-idUSKBN1I410T
[web]
Ruzki, Rafidah Mat.
/ 2020
/ 49 Syor Pembaikan Sistem Pilihan Raya [49Election Reform Recommendations]
/ Berita Harian
/ https://www.bharian.com.my/berita/nasional/2020/08/725329/49-syor-pembaikan-sistem-pilihan-raya
[journal]
Sani, Mohd Azizuddin Mohd
/ 2015
/ Media Freedom in Malaysia
/ Journal of Contemporary Asia
35(3)
: 341~367
[journal]
Sani, A
/ 2014
/ Malaysia’s 13th General Election: Political Partisanship in the Mainstream Print Media
/ Asia Pasific Media Educator
24(1)
: 61~75
[journal]
Sarune Beh
/ 2020
/ Universal Periodic Review: The Role of Civil Society Organisations in Malaysia
/ Journal of Administrative Science (Universiti Teknologi Mara)
17(2)
: 156~185
[web]
Shukry, Anisha
/ 2015
/ Malaysia’s Brief, Rich History of Suspending Newspapers
/ The Edge Malaysia
/ https://theedgemalaysia.com/article/malaysia%E2%80%99s-brief-rich-history-suspendingnewspapers
[web]
Singh, Gopal
/ 2013
/ Mature Democracy & Principles
/ Boloji
/ https://www.boloji.com/articles/15306/mature-democracy-principles
[book]
Tapsell, Ross
/ 2018
/ New Media, Old Rule in Malaysia. Regime Resilence in Malaysia and Singapore
/ Strategic Information and Research Development Center
[journal]
Tayeb, Azmil
/ 2021
/ Malaysia in 2020: Fragile Coalitional Politics and Democratic Regression
/ Asian Survey
61(1)
: 99~105
[web]
Teoh, Shannon
/ 2011
/ DAP Claims Rasah Postal Voters Using Army Spouses’ IC Numbers
/ Malaysia Today
/ https://www.malaysia-today.net/2011/09/06/dap-claims-rasah-postal-voters-usingarmy-spouses-ic-numbers/
[web]
Teoh, Shannon
/ 2021
/ Umno Says Muhyiddin Has Lost Majority as 11 MPs Pull Out; Minister Quits
/ Strait Times
/ https://www.straitstimes.com/asia/se-asia/umno-minister-quits-cabinet-piling-on-the-pressure-on-malaysian-pm-muhyiddin
[book]
Ting, Helen Mu Hung
/ 2022
/ Electoral System Change for a More Democratic Malaysia? Challenges and Options
/ Penerbit Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia
[journal]
Ufen, A
/ 2020
/ Clientelist and Programmatic Factionalism within Malaysian Political Parties
/ Journal of Current Southeast Asian Affairs
39(1)
: 59~81
[book]
Wain, Barry
/ 2009
/ Malaysian Maverick : Mahathir Mohamd in Turbulent Times
/ Palgrave Macmillan UK
[web]
Weiss, Meredith L.
/ 2017
/ Elections without Democracy: How Singapore and Malaysia Prevent Dissent from the Ground Up
/ Democratic Audit
/ https://www.democraticaudit.com/2017/12/11/elections-without-democracy-how-singapore-and-malaysia-pre-empt-dissent-from-the-ground-up/
[book]
Welsh, Bridget
/ 2020
/ Malaysia’s Political Polarization: Race, Religion and Reform. Political Polarization in South and Southeast Asia
/ Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
[web]
Welsh, Bridget
/ 2021
/ How the Pakatan Harapan Legend Crumbled in M alacca
/ https://bridgetwelsh.com/articles/how-the-pakatan-harapan-legend-crumbled-in-malacca/
[book]
Whiting, Amanda
/ 2018
/ The Curious Incident of the Seditious Dog Training Video. Regime Resilence in Malaysia and Singapore
/ Strategic Information and Research Development Center
[journal]
Whiting, Amanda
/ 2017
/ A Constitutional Alternative Proposal for Delimitat ion of Federal and State Constituencies in Selangor
/ Selangor Alternatif Proposal
[web]
Wong, Chin Huat
/ 2017
/ Time for Malaysian States to Introduce “Non-Constituency Seats” (NSCs)
/ Penang Institute
/ https://penanginstitute.org/publications/issues/982-time-formalaysian-states-to-introduce-non-constituency-seats-ncss/
[web]
Wong, Chin Huat
/ 2018
/ A New Electoral System for a New Malaysia
/ New Mandala
/ https://www.newmandala.org/a-new-electoral-system-for-a-new-malaysia/
[book]
Wong, Chin Huat
/ 2012
/ Democracy at Stake
/ Strategic Information and Research Development Centre
[book]
Wong, Kean
/ 2000
/ Malaysia in the Grip of the Government. Losing Control: Freedom of the Press in Asia
/ Asia Pacific Press
[web]
Yatim, Hafiz
/ 2018
/ Umno No.2 Loses Rantau Seat, Court Orders Fresh Polls
/ Malaysia Kini
/ https://www.malaysiakini.com/news/452137