SUVANNABHUMI 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.03
-
pISSN : 2092-738X / eISSN : 2799-7839
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/svn
pISSN : 2092-738X / eISSN : 2799-7839
Each submitted manuscript is reviewed based on the qualitative criteria below:
1. Contribution
-To what extent does the manuscript contribute towards the extension of knowledge in any particular area of Southeast Asian studies?
2. Substance
-If the manuscript is theoretical or exploratory, is the literature cited up-to-date and relevant?
-If the manuscript is empirical, how well designed, executed, and analyzed is the research?
-If the manuscript is practitioner/policy orientated, is it useful and widely applicable?
3. Logical Structure
-Is the manuscript logically constructed, clearly written and suitably referenced?
4. Integrity
-Are the conclusions sufficiently derived from the analysis?
5. Format
-Does this manuscript conform to the Text and Manuscript Guidelines of SUVANNABHUMI?
Overall, the Peer Reviewers will make any of the following decisions:
1. Accept
-With minor editorial or technical amendments.
2. Accept with Minor Revision
-Subject to revision specified by the Peer Reviewers to improve the manuscript for publication suitability.
3. Revise and Resubmit
-Only subject to substantial changes being made by the Author(s) before the manuscript can be re-considered and without any guarantee or undertaking as to its future acceptance. Peer Reviewers should explain the suggested changes in detail.
4. Decline
-It should be rejected for the reasons given by the Peer Reviewers’.
As a matter of sole discretion, the Editor will make the final decision about the manuscript in light of the Peer Reviews.
Editorial Decision Guidelines (June 2016 ~ Present)
Review1 | Review2 | Review3 (optional) | Final |
Accept | Accept |
| Accept |
| | | |
Reveiw1 | Review2 | Review3 (optional) | Final |
Accept | Accept with minor revision |
| Accept with Revision |
Accept | Revise and Resubmit | Accept with minor revision | |
Accept | Decline | Accept with minor revision | |
Accept with minor revision | Accept with minor revision |
| |
Accept with minor revision | Revise and Resubmit | Accept with minor revision | |
Accept with minor revision | Decline | Accept with minor revision | |
| | | |
Reveiw1 | Review2 | Review3 (optional) | Final |
Accept | Decline | Decline | Revise and Resubmit |
Accept | Decline | Revise and Resubmit | |
Accept | Revise and Resubmit | Revise and Resubmit | |
Accept with minor revision | Decline | Decline | |
Accept with minor revision | Revise and Resubmit | Decline | |
Accept with minor revision | Revise and Resubmit | Revise and Resubmit | |
Revise and Resubmit | Revise and Resubmit | Revise and Resubmit | |
| | | |
Reveiw1 | Review2 | Review3 (optional) | Final |
Revise and Resubmit | Decline | Decline | Decline |
Revise and Resubmit | Revise and Resubmit | Decline | |
Decline | Decline |
|