Public Land Law Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.14
-
pISSN : 1226-251X / eISSN : 2733-8371
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/toji
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Rethinking Freedom of Expression in South Korea
- Public Land Law Review
- Abbr : KPLLR
- 2019, 88(), pp.281-311
- Publisher : Korean Public Land Law Association
- Research Area : Social Science > Law
- Received : October 31, 2019
- Accepted : November 20, 2019
- Published : November 28, 2019
1한국법제발전연구소
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This paper discusses the boundaries of the freedom of expression and proposes an alternate definition in light of the recent controversy generated over the painting Dirty Sleep, a satirical piece depicting the former South Korean president, Park Geun-hye, in the nude. The authors compare and analyze landmark cases from America and Korea regarding the standards for freedom of expression in relation to concepts of serious value, community, and the standards of obscenity. Furthermore, the author reviews the level of recognition and understanding of freedom of expression in South Korea using an interdisciplinary method based in legal theory. Results demonstrate the need to reestablish national and community standards with respect to the definition of obscenity, as well as the need to establish a jury of experts to determine the boundaries of the freedom of expression.
Statistics
-
297 Viewed
-
0 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
Alistair Thomson
/ 1999
/ Moving Stories: Oral History and Migration Studies
/ Oral History
27(1)
: 24~37
[journal]
Allen Lynch
/ 2002
/ Woodrow Wilson and the Principle of ‘National Self-Determination’: A Reconsideration
/ Review of International Studies
28(2)
: 419~436
[journal]
Aurelie Hagstrom
/ 2003
/ The Catholic Church and Censorship in Literature, Books, Drama, and Film
/ Analytic Teaching
23(2)
: 147~151
[journal]
Bret Boyce
/ 2008
/ Obscenity and Community Standards
/ Yale Journal of International Law
33(2)
: 337~338
[thesis]
Christine Kim
/ 2017
/ The Comfort Women System: Sexual Slavery during World War II
/ Master’s
/ DePauw University
[journal]
Clare McGlynn
/ 2014
/ Would John Stuart Mill Have Regulated Pornography?
/ Journal of Law and Society
41(4)
: 500~522
[journal]
Dan Greenberg
/ 1993
/ The New Legal Puritanism of Catharine Mac Kinnon
/ Ohio State Law Journal
54
: 1378~
[journal]
Debra K. Braun-Courville
/ 2009
/ Exposure to Sexually Explicit Web Sites and Adolescent Sexual Attitudes and Behaviors
/ Journal of Adolescent Health
45(2)
: 152~162
[web]
Denis Byrne
/ Social Significance: A Discussion Paper
/ NSW National Parks and Wildlife Service
/ http://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/resources/cultureheritage/SocialSignificance.pdf
[journal]
Edward O. Correia
/ 1992
/ A Legislative Conception of Legislative Supremacy
/ Case Western Reserve Law Review
42
: 1139~
[book]
Douglas M. Fraleigh
/ 2010
/ Freedom of Expression in the Marketplace of Ideas
/ Sage
: 169~
[journal]
Erik Jones
/ 2017
/ Democracy without Solidarity: Political Dysfunction in Hard Times
/ Government and Opposition
52(2)
: 4~
[journal]
Frederick Schauer
/ 2007
/ Has precedent ever really mattered in the Supreme Court
/ Georgia State University Law Review
24
: 381~395
[journal]
Geoffrey R. Stone
/ 2007
/ Origins of Obscenity
/ New York University Review of Law & Social Change
31
: 711~713
[book]
Gerald Gunther
/ 1992
/ Individual Rights in Constitutional Law
/ The Foundation Press, Inc
: 744~
[report]
Grace Pretty
/ 2006
/ Psychological Sense of Community and its Relevance to Well-being and Everyday Life in Australia
/ The Australian Psychological Society
: 12~14
[thesis]
Gretchen Brooke Gould
/ 2010
/ Obscenity and Pornography: Author Historical Look at the American Library Association, the Commission on Obscenity and Pornography, and the Supreme Court
/ Master’s
/ University of Northern Iowa
[journal]
Harold Gardiner, S.J.
/ 1955
/ Moral Principles Towards a Definition of the Obscene
/ Law and Contemporary Problems
20(4)
: 560~571
[journal]
Irene M. Ten Cate
/ 2013
/ Speech, Truth, and Freedom: An Examination of John Stuart Mill's and Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes's Free Speech Defenses
/ Yale Journal of Law & the Humanities
22(1)
: 35~81
[book]
Joachim Klose
/ 2009
/ Recasting Reality
/ Springer
: 8~15
[other]
Joe S. Cecil
/ 1993
/ Court-AppointedExperts:DefiningtheRoleofExperts AppointedUnderFederalRuleofEvidence706
/ Federal Judicial Center
: 3~95
[journal]
Joseph O' Meara
/ 1964
/ Obscenity in the Supreme Court: A Note on Jacobellis v. Ohio
/ Notre Dame Law
40
: 1~12
[book]
John H. Laub
/ 2005
/ Historical influences on lives and aging
: 208~228
[journal]
Kellie A. Cairns
/ 2008
/ Morse v. Frederick: Evaluating a Supreme Hit to Students' First Amendment Rights
/ Pace Law Review
29(1)
: 154~155
[journal]
Laura E. Little
/ 2011
/ Just a Joke: Defamatory Humor and Incongruity's Promise
/ Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal
21
: 118~156
[journal]
Lynda Nead
/ 1990
/ The Female Nude: Pornography, Art, and Sexuality
/ Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society
15(2)
: 321~
[confproc]
Marcella Tambuscio
/ 2015
/ Fact-Checking Effect on Viral Hoaxes: A Model of Misinformation Spread in Social Networks
/ Proceedings of the 24th International Conference on World Wide Web, ACM
: 977~982
[journal]
Marvin Ammori
/ 2009
/ Beyond Content Neutrality: Understanding Content-Based Promotion of Democratic Speech
/ Fedral Communication Law Journal
61(2)
: 284~
[book]
Michael Kent Curtis
/ 2000
/ Struggles for Freedom of Expression in American History
/ Duke University Press
[journal]
Natalia Dziewięcka
/ 2017
/ Larry Flynt as a Controversial Advocate for Freedom of Speech in The People vs. Larry Flynt
/ New Horizons in English Studies
1
[book]
Patrick Devlin
/ 1965
/ The Enforcement of Morals
/ Oxford University Press
: 1~139
[journal]
Robert C. Post
/ 1988
/ Cultural Heterogeneity and Law: Pornography, Blasphemy, and the First Amendment
/ California Law Review
76
: 297~335
[journal]
Steven G. Gey
/ 1994
/ Is Moral Relativism a Constitutional Command?
/ Indiana Law Journal
70
: 331~404
[journal]
Steven M. Fish
/ 2004
/ Does Diversity Hurt Democracy?
/ Journal of Democracy
15(1)
: 154~166
[journal]
William N. Eskridge Jr
/ 1997
/ Democracy, Kulturkampf, and the Apartheid of the Closet
/ Vanderbilt Law Review
50
: 419~448
[web]
Rahn Kim
/ 2017
/ Painting depicting NAKED PARK GEUN-HYE stirs controversy
/ The Korean Times
/ http://m.koreatimes.co.kr/pad/news/view.jsp?req_newsidx=222705
[journal]
Raphael Cohen-Almagor
/ 2016
/ Hate and Racist Speech in the United States, A Critique
/ Philosophy and Public Issues
6(1)
: 81~
[journal]
Robert F. Flinn
/ 1971
/ The National Security Exception to the Doctrine of Prior Restraint
/ William & Mary Law Review
13
: 219~
[book]
Robert L. Maddex
/ 2006
/ Encyclopedia of Sexual Behavior and the Law
/ CQ Press
: 152~153
[journal]
Robert S. Tanenbaum
/ 2006
/ Preaching terror: free speech or wartime incitement
/ Am. U.L. Review
(55)
: 799~800
[journal]
Rodney A. Smolla
/ 1988
/ Emotional Distress and the First Amendment: An Analysis of Hustler v. Falwell
/ Ariz. St. LJ
20
: 465~467
[book]
Roger Cotterrell
/ 1997
/ Law's Community: Legal Theory in Sociological Perspective
/ Oxford University Press
: 19~
[journal]
Stanley Ingber
/ 1984
/ The Marketplace of Ideas: A legitimizing Myth
/ Duke Law Journal
(1)
: 22~
[journal]
Steven G. Gey
/ 1996
/ The Case Against Postmodern Censorship Theory
/ University of Pennsylvania Law Review
145(2)
: 196~254
[web]
The Justice Department
/ 2016
/ Department of Immigration Information, Sojourning Foreigner in South Korea, 2016
/ http://www.index.go.kr/potal/main/EachDtlPageDetail.do?idx_cd=2756
[book]
Theodore Schroeder
/ 1976
/ Literature, Obscenity, & Law
/ Southern Illinois University Press
: 157~
[journal]
Toni M. Massaro
/ 1991
/ Equality and Freedom of Expression: The Hate Speech Dilemma
/ William & Mary Law Review
32(2)
: 221~
[journal]
Weston Labarre
/ 1955
/ Obscenity: An Anthropological Appraisal
/ Law and Contemporary Problems
20(4)
: 536~537
[journal]
Haesook Han
/ 2004
/ Women’s Life during the Chosŏn Dynasty
/ International Journal of Korean History
6
: 121~
[journal]
김형찬
/ 2014
/
THE THEORY AND PRACTICE OF SAGE POLITICS: THE POLITICAL PHILOSOPHIES AND NEO-CONFUCIAN BASES OF YI HWANG AND YI I
/ Acta Koreana
/ 한국학연구원
17(1)
: 255~284
[journal]
한인섭
/ 2009
/
Criminal Jury Trials in South Korea: Issues and Initial Experiments
/ 서울대학교 법학
/ 법학연구소
50(2)
: 681~710
[journal]
Joongtak Sung
/ 2014
/ The Relationship of Constitutional Transition (change of constitutional values) and the Constitutional Court
/ Lawyer
47
: 76~77
[other]
Juyun Park
/ 2017
/ Silent Women’s Rights Group on Exhibition on the Nude of the President by Changwon Pyo in Question?
/ FutureKorea (2017b), 24 January 2017
[web]
Kangok Lee
/ Yi Hwang
/ Encyclopedia of Korean Folk Culture
/ http://folkency.nfm.go.kr/en/topic/YiHwang/5639
[journal]
Seunguk Baek
/ 2007
/ The Politics of Chinese Workers' Memory-Focusing on Memory in Cultural Revolution Period
/ Politeia
: 18~19
[thesis]
朴永哲
/ 1994
/ 憲法體系論에 관한 연구 : 통치구조를 중심으로
/ 박사
/ 慶熙大學校 大學院
[book]
Young Huh
/ 2010
/ The Theory of the Constitutional Law of Republic of Korea
/ Pakyoungsa
: 56~
[book]
Yuha Park
/ 2013
/ Comfort Women of the Empire: Colonial Domination and the Struggle of Memory
/ Roots and Yipari
[other]
/ Ackerman v. UnitedStates,293 F.2d 449(9thCir.1961)
[other]
/ Brockett v. SpokaneArcades,Inc.,472 U.S.491(1985)
[other]
/ BVerfGE30,173,194ff. Mephesto-KlausMann, accessed11March2017, http://www.servat.unibe.ch/ dfr/bv030173.html;S.C.R.O.K.,94Do2413(1995);R.O.K.Const.art.37,§2(1987)
[other]
/ City of Paducah v. Investment Entertainment, Inc., 791F.2d463 (6thCir.1986)
[other]
/ CurtisPub.Co.v.Butts,388U.S.130(1967),132–64
[other]
/ Ginsberg v. NewYork, 88S.Ct. 1274,390 U.S.629 (1968), 1278–1279
[other]
/ Glassv.StateofTexas,761S.W.2nd806(Texas,1988)
[other]
/ Jenkinsv.Georgia,418U.S.153,27(1974)
[other]
/ Jacobellis v. Ohio, 378 U. S. 184 (1964)
[other]
/ Memoirs v. Massachusetts, 383U.S.413 (1966)
[other]
/ Miller v. California, 413U.S.15, 23-48 (1973)
[other]
/ Near v. Minnesota ex rel. Olson, 283 U.S. 697 (1931). Near, 713
[other]
/ Pinkus v. United States, 436 U.S. 293 (1978)
[other]
/ Powell’s Books,Inc. v. Myers, 599F. Supp. 2d1226 (D.Or.2008)
[other]
/ Reed v.Town of Gilbert, 576 U.S.(2015), 13–15
[other]
/ Schenck v. United States, 249 U.S.47 (1919):48–52
[other]
/ Smith v. United States, 431 U.S. 291 (1977)
[other]
/ Tenn. Code Ann. §39-17-901 (2010)
[other]
/ United States v. Bennett, 24 Fed. Cas.1093 (1879)
[other]
/ Const.Crt.09sentenceHunMa747(2013)
[other]
/ Const.Crt28,2006HunBa109(2009), “Ban on Internet Distribution of Obscene Materials Case”
[other]
/ Const.Crt,2013HunDa1(2014), “Dissolution of Unified Progressive Party Case“
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,06Do2074(2007)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,08Do10914(2009)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,70Do1879(1970)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,74Do976(1975)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,90Do1485(1990)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,91Do1550(1991)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,94Do2266(1995)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,94Do2413(1995)
[other]
/ S.C.R.O.K.,99Da6203(2000)
[web]
BBC
/ 2017
/ Canadian town refuse store move swastik as from park
/ The BBC News
/ http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-41028895?ocid=socialflow_facebook&ns_mchannel=social&ns_campaign=bbcnews&ns_source=facebook
[web]
Future Korea
/ 2017
/ Pyo Changwon, “Introduce of the National Assembly Member,”
/ The National Assembly of The Republic of Korea
/ http://www.assembly.go.kr/assm/memPop/memPopup.do?dept_cd=9770994
[web]
Hoeyoung Kim
/ 2017
/ Pyo, Changwon, Disciplinary Measure of Suspension from Duty of a Party Post for 6months A mid Intense Public Furor about a Nude Satire of the President Park Guen-He
/ Hankookilbo
/ http://www.hankookilbo.com/v/e313a92740eb4b95aa77b922a19f757a
[web]
Jaeyung Park
/ 2017
/ Parksamo sue to cooperate Pyo’s Dirty Sleep (2017a), ‘I’ll also strip your wife,’
/ MBN
/ http://www.sedaily.com/NewsView/1OAYEDBE35
[web]
Jibong Im
/ 2008
/ Free of Expression and Pornography
/ Law Times
/ https://www.lawtimes.co.kr/Legal-Opinion/Legal-Opinion-View?serial=41033
[web]
Preserve Articles
/ 2012
/ What is the Definition of Social Values?
/ http://www.preservearticles.com/2012053132822/what-is-the-definition-of-social-values.html