A Multi-Level Analysis of Innovative Korean SME Activity and Related Innovation Ecosystem

Douglas R. Gress; Ronald V. Kalafsky; Sharmistha Bagchi-Sen

A Multi-Level Analysis of Innovative Korean SME Activity and Related Innovation Ecosystem

Asia Review
Abbr : SNUACAR
2021, 11(3), pp.15~55
Publisher : 아시아연구소
Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
Received : September 29, 2021
Accepted : November 30, 2021
Published : December 31, 2021

Douglas R. Gress ¹, Ronald V. Kalafsky ², Sharmistha Bagchi-Sen ³

¹Seoul National University, Korea
²University of Tennessee Knoxville
³School of Geographical Sciences and Urban Planning, Arizona State University

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Faced with waning exports and returns from innovation, the Korean government has prioritized the facilitation of small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) innovative activity and marketization. But are policies working? This research deploys a multi-level perspective to more holistically examine individual, firm, network, and industry-level factors, to include the regulatory environment, impacting Korean SMEs. Quantitative analyses of data from the 2016 national Korean Innovation Survey delve into 1) firm motivations, costs, and purchases; 2) internal R&D and external cooperation and knowledge sourcing; 3) innovation impacts on domestic and international market positioning and entry; and 4) sources of support for, and impediments to, innovation in order to provide a nuanced understanding of Korea’s innovation ecosystem. In a novel bifurcation, analyses compare firms engaged in new and incremental innovation and those engaged in only incremental innovation. Some key differences between the innovator groups emerge, such as training objectives, spending patterns on external knowledge, collaborate activity, and market positioning. Though there may be room for cautious optimism, perceived challenges to policy would appear to be equal for both groups of innovators, including those related to personnel, financing, and other government support and policy incentives. Implications for Korea’s future are discussed.

KEYWORDS

Innovation, Innovation Policy, Korea, Korean Firms, Multi-level Perspective, SMEs

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] Anderson, N. / 2004 / The Routinization of Innovation Research : A Constructively Critical Review of the State-of-the-Science / Journal of Organizational Behavior 25 : 147~173

[journal] Ardito, L. / 2015 / From Technological Inventions to New Products : A Systematic Review and Research Agenda of the Main Enabling Factors / European Management Review 12(3) : 113~147

[journal] Baba, Y. / 2010 / Embeddedness, Social Epistemology and Breakthrough Innovation : The Case of the Development of Statins / Research Policy 39 : 511~522

[journal] Bagchi-Sen, S / 2007 / Strategic Considerations for Innovation and Commercialization in the US Biotechnology Sector / European Planning Studies 15(6) : 753~766

[journal] Bao, Y. / 2012 / External Learning, Market Dynamics, and Radial Innovation : Evidence from China’s High-Tech Firms / Journal of Business Research 65 : 1226~1233

[journal] Barney, J. B / 1995 / Looking Inside for Competitive Advantage / Academy of Management Executive 9 : 49~61

[journal] Baumann, J. / 2016 / The Link between R&D, Innovation and Productivity: Are Microfirms Different? / Research Policy 45 : 1263~1274

[journal] 차영태 / 2015 / The Influence of Innovation Activities of Mainbiz Enterprise on Competitive Advantage and Management Performance / 한국경영공학회지 / 한국경영공학회 20(3) : 87~103

[journal] Chandy, R. K. / 1998 / Organizing for Radical Product Innovation : The Overlooked Role of Willingness to Cannibalize / Journal of Marketing Research 35 : 474~487

[journal] Chandy, R. K / 2000 / The Incumbent’s Curse? Incumbency, Size, and Radical Product Innovation / Journal of Marketing 64 : 1~17

[journal] Chataway, J. / 2004 / Understanding Company R&D Strategies in Agro Biotechnology : Trajectories and Blind Spots / Research Policy 33 : 1041~1057

[journal] Choung, J-Y. / 2014 / Transitions of Innovation Activities in Latecomer Countries : An Exploratory Case Study of South Korea / World Development 54 : 156~167

[journal] Chung, M-Y. / 2015 / How Absorptive Capacity is Formed in a Latecomer Economy : Different Roles of Foreign Patent and Know-how Licensing in Korea / World Development 66 : 678~694

[journal] Crossan, M. M. / 2010 / A Multi-Dimensional Framework of Organizational Innovation : A Systemic Review of the Literature / Journal of Management Studies 47(6) : 1154~1190

[journal] Czarnitzki, D. / 2011 / Evaluating the Impact of R&D Tax Credits on Innovation : A Microeconometric Study on Canadian Firms / Research Policy 40 : 217~229

[confproc] Doo, M-K. / 2008 / Productivity Improvement of Manufacturing SMEs via Technology Innovation in Korea / 7th WSEAS International Conference on Artificial Intelligence, Knowledge, Engineering and Data Bases(AIKED08) / University of Cambridge

[journal] Eom, B-Y. / 2010 / Determinants of Industry-Academy Linkages and Their Impact on Firm Performance : The Case of Korea as a Latecomer in Knowledge Industrialization / Research Policy 39 : 625~639

[report] Ernst, D / 2000 / Global Production Networks and the Changing Geography of Innovation Systems: Implications for Developing Countries / East-West Center

[journal] Freel. M. S / 2005 / Patterns of Innovation and Skills in Small Firms / Technovation 25 : 123~134

[book] Freeman, C. / 1988 / Technological Change and Economic Theory / Pinter : 38~66

[journal] Gress, D. R / 2015 / Knowledge Bases, Regional Innovation Systems, and Korea’s Solar Photovoltaic Industry / Environment and Planning C : Government and Policy 33(6) : 1432~1449

[journal] Gress, D / 2020 / Examining Korea’s International Science and Business Belt Project through an Evolutionary Economic Geography Lens / GeoJournal 85 : 1241~1255

[journal] Gress, D. R. / 2020 / Relational Economic Geography and Firm Level Export Activities at Trade Fairs : Insights from a Study of South Korean Advanced Machine Tool Manufacturers / The Pennsylvania Geographer 58(1) : 1~24

[journal] Gupta, A. K. / 2007 / Innovation at and across Multiple Levels of Analysis / Organization Science 18(6) : 885~897

[book] Hemmart, M / 2007 / Innovation and Technology in Korea: Challenges of a Newly Advanced Economy / Springer : 1~10

[journal] Hobday M / 2004 / Approaching the Innovation Frontier in Korea: The Transition Phase to Leadership / Research Policy 33 : 1433~1457

[report] Hwang, Y. -S / 2002 / Techno-Economic Paradigm Shift and Evolution of STI Policy in Korea and the United States / STEPI (Science & Technology Policy Institute)

[journal] 전성희 / 2006 / Effects of R&D Subsidy Policy for Small and Medium Sized Firms on their Economic Performances / 중소기업연구 / 한국중소기업학회 28(3) : 217~241

[book] Keenan, M / 2012 / Korean Science and Technology in an International Perspective / Springer-Verlag : 15~40

[report] KEIA / 2015 / Korea’s Economy / Korea Economic Institute of America

[journal] Kim, S-Y / 2012 / Transitioning From Fast-Follower to Innovator : The Institutional Foundation of the Korean Telecommunications Sector / Review of International Political Economy 19 : 140~168

[journal] 구원모 / 2018 / Systematized Government R&D Portfolio using Determinants of Technological Innovation in SMEs / 중소기업연구 / 한국중소기업학회 40(2) : 1~20

[journal] 이후성 / 2015 / Technological Performance Analyses of SMEs Based on Type of Government R&D Support / 기술혁신학회지 / 한국기술혁신학회 18(1) : 73~97

[journal] 이철주 / 2012 / Factors influencing commercialization of government SME R&D project: effect of patent and certification / 기술혁신연구 / 기술경영경제학회 20(3) : 229~254

[journal] Lee, Y-G / 2012 / Strengthening Competency Linkage to Innovation at Korean Universities / Scientometrics 90(1) : 219~230

[journal] Lee, Y-G. / 2009 / Which Is Better for a Firm’s Financial Performance, An Externally Oriented or Inwardly Oriented Innovation Strategy? An Empirical Study of Korean SMEs / Asian Journal of Technology Innovation 17(1) : 57~73

[journal] Li, Q. / 2013 / Top Management Attention to Innovation : The Role of Search Selection and Intensity in New Product Introductions / Academy of Management Journal 56 : 893~916

[journal] Lim, Y / 2000 / Development of the Public Sector in the Korean Innovation System / International Journal of Technology Management 20(5-8) : 684~701

[book] Mahlich, J. / 2007 / Innovation and Technology in Korea: Challenges of a Newly Advanced Economy / Springer : 1~10

[journal] Maine, E / 2008 / Radical Innovation through Internal Corporate Venturing : Degussa’s Commercialization of Nanomaterials / R&D Management 38 : 359~371

[journal] Molina-Castillo, F. J. / 2011 / Product Competence Exploitation and Exploration Strategies : The Impact on New Product Performance through Quality and Innovativeness / Industrial Marketing Management 40 : 1172~1182

[book] Mumford, M. D. / 2008 / Multi-Level Issues in Creativity and Innovation (Research in Multi-Level Issues, Vol. 7) / Emerald Group Publishing Limited : 107~154

[report] OECD / 2018 / OECD Economic Surveys. Korea 2018 / OECD Publishing

[journal] 오동윤 / 2015 / A Study on Policy Implementation for Innovation in Manufacturing SMEs / 질서경제저널 / 한국질서경제학회 18(2) : 135~155

[journal] Oh, K-M. / 2017 / Extra-Firm Networks and Firm Performance : Insights From a Study of South Korean Solar PV Frms and Associated Extra-Firm Actors / Growth and Change : A Journal of Urban and Regional Policy 48(4) : 991~1011

[journal] Park, H. W. / 2010 / Longitudinal Trends in Networks of University Industry Government Relations in South Korea : The Role of Programmatic Incentives / Research Policy 39 : 640~649

[journal] Park, J-B. / 2010 / Facilitating Public-to-Private Technology Transfer through Consortia : Initial Evidence from Korea / Journal of Technology Transfer 35(2) : 237~252

[journal] 박규호 / 2018 / A Research on the Innovation Ecosystem and Innovation of Korean SMEs / 사회과학연구 / 사회과학연구원 57(1) : 297~320

[book] Park, S-O / 2000 / Globalization, and the Knowledge-Base Economy / Oxford University Press : 328~348

[journal] Reichstein, T. / 2006 / Investigating the Sources of Process Innovation among UK Manufacturing Firms / Industrial and Corporate Change 15(4) : 653~682

[journal] Sofka, W. / 2010 / Specialized Search and Innovation Performance : Evidence across Europe / R&D Management 40(3) : 310~323

[journal] 서문성 / 2012 / The Study on Plan of Practical Application of Marketing for Securing Global Competitiveness of Small-Medium Sized Enterprises / 무역학회지 / 한국무역학회 37(1) : 257~286

[book] Suh, J-H. / 2007 / Korea Development Institute and the World Bank Institute / The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development/The World Bank

[journal] Teece, D. J / 1986 / Profiting from Technological Innovation : Implications for Integration, Collaboration Licensing and Public Policy / Research Policy 15 : 285~305

[web] The Korea Times / 2021 / Korea’s technology trade balance lowest among OECD members / m.koreatimes.co.kr/phone/news/view.jsp?req_newsidx=119527

[journal] Therrien, P. / 2011 / Innovation Novelty and(Commercial)Performance in the Service Sector : A Canadian Firm Level Analysis / Technovation 31 : 655~665

[web] TWA Netwerk / 2011 / Trendwatchers vor innovatie en technologie. Newsletter, 27 November 2011 / https://www.rvo.nl/sites/default/files/bijlagen/International%20Science%20Busie%elt%20to%20the%20future%20Korean%20Nobel%20Prize%20winner.pdf

[journal] Van Oorschot, K. / 2010 / Get Fat Fast : Surviving Stage-Gate in NPD / Journal of Product Innovation Management 27 : 828~839

[journal] Weber, K. M. / 2012 / Legitimizing Research, Technology and Innovation Policies for Transformative Change : Combining Insights from Innovation Systems and Multi-level Perspective in a Comprehensive ‘Failures’Framework / Research Policy 41(6) : 1037~1047

[journal] 윤효진 / 2018 / The effects of R&Ds, technology innovation capability and the innovation support system of small- and medium-sized businesses on the company performance / 한국혁신학회지 / 한국혁신학회 13(2) : 209~239

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Asia Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.86