Asia Review 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.86
-
pISSN : 2234-0386
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/asiareview
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Comparative Research on Educational Differentiation of the Philippines and Vietnam
- Asia Review
- Abbr : SNUACAR
- 2023, 13(3), pp.313~346
- Publisher : 아시아연구소
- Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
- Received : June 15, 2023
- Accepted : November 29, 2023
- Published : December 31, 2023
Kim, Jiin 1, Yoo, Sung-Sang 1
1서울대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This research explores how the Philippines and Vietnam have different systems of educational differentiation, which is closely related to educational inequality. This research adopts the comparative approach to explore educational differentiation in the Philippines and Vietnam. Based on the literature review, this research analyzes educational differentiation in three dimensions: vocation specific, special-purpose schools and standardization. The research results illustrate that Vietnamese education is highly differentiated compared to the one in the Philippines. Vietnamese education has a vocational track starting in lower secondary school, and have popular gifted high school system.
In contrast, Filipino education rarely specifies vocational tracks at the secondary school level, and there is a limited number of science high schools. Both countries’ curricula are standardized by education ministries. Educational differentiation among developing countries can be different. This implies that the educational inequality in developing countries needs further examination in relation to the country’s educational differentiation, moving beyond the issue of access to education.
Statistics
-
163 Viewed
-
85 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
Alexander, Robin
/ 2008
/ Education for All, the Quality Imperative and the Problem of Pedagogy. CREATE Pathways to Access
/ Research Monograph
20
[journal]
Asadullah, M. Niaz
/ 2020
/ Vietnam’s Extraordinary Performance in the PISA Assessment : A Cultural Explanation of an Education Paradox
/ Journal of Policy Modeling
42(5)
: 913~932
[book]
Blau, Peter M.
/ 1967
/ The American Occupational Structureoccupational Structure
/ John Wiley & Sons
[journal]
Bodovski, Katerina
/ 2017
/ Searching for the Golden Model of Education : Cross-national Analysis of Math Achievement
/ Compare
47(5)
: 722~741
[journal]
Breen, Richard
/ 2005
/ Inequality of Opportunity in Comparative Perspective : Recent Research on Educational Attainment and Social Mobility
/ Annual Review of Sociology
31
: 223~243
[journal]
Buchmann, Claudia
/ 2000
/ Family Structure, Parental Perceptions, and Child Labor in Kenya : What fActors Determine Who Is Enrolled in Schoolactors Determine Who Is Enrolled in School?
/ Social Forces
78(4)
: 1349~1378
[journal]
Buchmann, Claudia
/ 2001
/ Education and Stratification in Developing Countries : A Review of Theories and Research
/ Annual Review of Sociology
27
: 77~102
[journal]
Buchmann, Claudia
/ 2002
/ Interpersonal Influences And Educational Aspirations In 12 Countriesinfluences and Educational Aspirations in 12 Countries : The importance of institutional context
/ Sociology of Education
75(2)
: 99~122
[journal]
Buchmann, Claudia
/ 2009
/ Stratification and the Formation of Expectations in Highly Differentiated Educational Systems
/ Research in Social Stratification and Mobility
27(4)
: 245~267
[journal]
Buchmann, Claudia
/ 2011
/ Frontiers in Comparative and International Sociology of Education: American Distinctiveness and Global Diversity
/ Frontiers in Sociology of Education
: 35~51
[journal]
Carnoy, Martin
/ 2006
/ Rethinking the Comparative-and the International
/ Comparative Education Review
50(4)
: 551~570
[thesis]
Choi, Seongsoo
/ 2015
/ Educational Investment and Institutional Contexts: Three Essays on Educational Stratification in Comparative Perspective
/ Ph.D.
/ Yale University
[book]
Chmielewski, Anna K
/ 2017
/ Pathways to Adulthood: Educational Opportunities, Motivation and Attainment in Times of Social Change
/ UCL IoE Press
[journal]
Chmielewski, Anna K.
/ 2013
/ Tracking Effects Depend on Tracking Type : An International Comparison of Students’Mathematics Self-concept
/ American Educational Research Journal
50(5)
: 925~957
[journal]
Chung, BongGun
/ 2013
/ The Korean Model of ODA : A Critical Review of Its Concept and Practices Reflected in Educational ODA
/ Asian Education and Development Studies
3(1)
: 46~57
[journal]
Coleman, James
/ 1988
/ Social Capital in the Ccreation of Human Capital
/ American Journal of Sociology
94
: 95~120
[book]
Dang, Hai-Anh
/ 2008
/ Private Tutoring in Vietnam: An Investigation of Its Causes and Impacts with Policy Implications
/ Dr. Mueller Publishing House
[journal]
Dang, Hai-Anh H.
/ 2017
/ Well Begun, but Aiming Higher : A Review of Vietnam’s Education Trends in the Past 20 Years and Emerging Challenges
/ Journal of Development Studies
54(7)
: 1171~1195
[book]
DepEd
/ 2012
/ K to 12 Toolkit
/ Department of Education
[other]
DepEd
/ 2012
/ Guidelines of the Assessment and Rating of Learning Outcomes under the K to 12 Basic Education Curriculum
/ Department of Education
[web]
DepEd
/ 2018
/ List of Senior High Schools
/ https://www.deped.gov.ph/k-to-12/senior-high-school/list-of-senior-high-schools/
[journal]
Dupriez, Vincent
/ 2006
/ Inequalities in School Systems : Effect of School Structure or of Society Structure?
/ Comparative education
42(2)
: 243~260
[journal]
Dyer, Caroline
/ 2005
/ Decentralisation for Educational Development? An Editorial Introduction
/ Compare : A Journal of Comparative and International Education
35(2)
: 105~113
[journal]
Gamoran, Adam
/ 1987
/ The Stratification of High School Learning Opportunities
/ Sociology of Education
60(3)
: 135~155
[journal]
Glewwe, Paul
/ 1999
/ The Role of the Private Sector in Education in Vietnam : Evidence from the Vietnam Living Standards Survey
/ World Development
27(5)
: 887~902
[web]
GOVPH
/ 2022
/ The Philippine Education And Training Systemeducation and Training System
/ https://pqf.gov.ph/Home/Details/16
[web]
GOVPH
/ 2022
/ The K to 12 Basic Education Program
/ https://www.officialgazette.gov.ph/k-12/
[journal]
Gruijters, Rob J.
/ 2020
/ Learning Inequality in Francophone Africa : School Quality and the Educational Achievement of Rich and Poor Children
/ Sociology of Education
93(3)
: 256~276
[web]
Hofstede Insights
/ 2021
/ Hofstede Insights
/ https://www.hofstede-insights.com/country-comparison/the-philippines,vietnam/
[web]
Huyen, Le
/ 2020
/ Is It Time to Remove Schools for the Gifted in Vietnam?
/ https://vietnamnet.vn/en/is-it-time-to-remove-schools-for-the-gifted-invietnam-653614.html
[journal]
Jimenez, Emmanuel
/ 2001
/ Public for Private : The Relationship between Ppublic and Private School Enrollment in the Philippines
/ Economics of Education Review
20(4)
: 389~399
[journal]
Kerckhoff, Alan C
/ 2001
/ Education and Social Stratification Processes in Comparative Perspective
/ Sociology of Education
74
: 3~18
[journal]
King, Kenneth
/ 2005
/ Re-targeting Schools, Skills and Jobs in Kenya : Quantity, Quality and Outcomes
/ International Journal of Educational Development
25
: 423~435
[journal]
King, Kenneth
/ 2009
/ Education, Skills, Sustainability and Growth : Complex Relations
/ International Journal of Educational Development
29(2)
: 175~181
[book]
Lareau, Annette
/ 2011
/ Unequal Childhoods
/ University of California Press
[book]
Lacey, Anne
/ 2007
/ Qualitative Research Analysis
/ The NIHR RDS for the East Midlands/Yorkshire & the Humber
[book]
Le, Duc
/ 2013
/ Why Children in Vietnam Drop Out of School and What They Do after That
/ Yong Lives
[journal]
London, Jonathan D
/ 2010
/ Globalization and the Governance of Education in Viet Nam
/ Asia Pacific Journal of Education
30(4)
: 361~379
[journal]
Lucas, Samuel R
/ 2001
/ Effectively Maintained Inequality : Education Transitions, Track Mobility, and Social Background Effects
/ American Journal of Sociology
10(6)
: 1642~1690
[journal]
Maaz, Kai.
/ 2008
/ Educational tRansitions and Differential Learning Environments : How Explicit between–School Tracking Contributes to Social Inequality in Educational Outcomes
/ Child Development Perspectives
2(2)
: 99~106
[thesis]
Magallanes, Kriza
/ 2013
/ Analysis of the Philippine Education Reformation Process: Enhanced Basic Education Act of 2013
/ M.A
/ Ewha Womans University
[journal]
Musa, Sajid
/ 2012
/ Features and Historical Aspects of the Philippines Educational System
/ European Journal of Contemporary Education
2(2)
: 155~176
[journal]
McEwan, Patrick J.
/ 2000
/ The Effectiveness And Efficiency of Private Schools in Chile’s Voucher System
/ Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis
22(3)
: 213~239
[journal]
McGrath, Simon
/ 2010
/ Education and Development : Thirty Years of Continuity and Change
/ International Journal of Educational Development
30(6)
: 537~543
[journal]
Mesa, Eirene
/ 2007
/ Measuring Education Inequalities in the Philippines
/ Philippine Review of Economics
44(2)
: 33~70
[journal]
Namoco, Sarah
/ 2022
/ Narrative Inquiry To Understand the National Achievement Test of Primary and Secondary School Students in Misamis Oriental
/ Science International
34(5)
: 495~501
[book]
Nguyen, Thi Minh Phuong
/ 2012
/ Talent Development Around the World
: 223~235
[journal]
Park, Hyunjoon
/ 2008
/ The Varied Educational Effects of Parent-child Communication : A Comparative Study of Fourteen Countries
/ Comparative Education Review
52(2)
: 219~243
[web]
PSHS
/ 2022
/ Philippine Science High School System
/ https://pshs.edu.ph/contactus
[book]
Rizvi, Fazal
/ 2016
/ Privatization in Education: Trends and Consequences
/ UNESCO
[journal]
Rolleston, Caine
/ 2019
/ Beyond the Basics : Access and Equity in the Expansion of Post-compulsory Schooling in Vietnam
/ International Journal of Educational Development
66
: 223~233
[journal]
Saguin, Kidjie Ian
/ 2020
/ Bringing Governance Back into Education Reforms. The Case of the Philippines
/ International Review of Public Policy
2(2:2)
: 159~177
[report]
Sarma, Vengadeshvaran
/ 2017
/ Structural Transformation, Growth, and Inequality: Evidence from VietNam
/ ADBI
[book]
Seth, Michael
/ 2002
/ Education Fever: Society, Politics, and the Pursuit of Schooling in South Korea
/ University of Hawaii Press
[journal]
Stadelmann-Steffen, Isabelle
/ 2012
/ Education Policy and Educational Inequality―Evidence from the Swiss Laboratory
/ European Sociological Review
28(3)
: 379~393
[web]
Tien, Khoa. Vo
/ 2021
/ Top 100 Best High Schools In Vietnam
/ https://toplist.one/top-100-best-high-schools-in-vietnam-today/
[journal]
Trinidad, Jose Eos
/ 2020
/ Material Resources, School Climate, and Achievement Variations in the Philippines : Insights from PISA 2018
/ International Journal of Educational Development
75
: 102174~
[journal]
Truong, Thang Dinh
/ 2017
/ Confucian Values and School Leadership in Vietnam : Exploring the Influence of Culture on Principal Decision Making
/ Educational management administration &leadership
45(1)
: 77~100
[journal]
Turner, R. H
/ 1960
/ Sponsored and Contest Mobility and the School System
/ American Sociological Review
: 855~886
[book]
UNESCO-IBE
/ 2010
/ World Data on Education
/ UNESCO-IBE
[book]
UNESCO-IBE
/ 2010
/ World Data on Education
/ UNESCO-IBE
[book]
UNESCO-UNEVOC
/ 2018
/ Vietnam: TVET Country Profile
/ UNESCO-UNEVOC
[book]
UNESCO-UNEVOC
/ 2019
/ TVET Country Profile: Philippines
/ UNESCO-UNEVOC
[web]
VAS
/ 2010
/ VAS Hanoi Is One of the Top 200 High Schools in Vietnam That Have Highest University Entrance Marks
/ https://vashanoi.edu.vn/en-us/News/178/7053/VAS-Hanoi-is-one-of-the-Top-200-High-Schools-in-Vietnamthat-have-Highest-University-Entrance-Marks.html
[journal]
Ventura, Theresa
/ 2016
/ From Small Farms to Progressive Plantations : The Trajectory of Land Reform in the American colonial Philippines, 1900–1916
/ Agricultural History
90(4)
: 459~483
[web]
WENR
/ 2017
/ World Education News and Review
/ https://wenr.wes.org/
[web]
World Bank
/ 2022
/ World Bank Data
/ https://data.worldbank.org/
[web]
World Bank
/ 2022
/ Middle Income Countries Overview
/ https://www.worldbank.org/en/country/mic/overview#2
[journal]
Yamauchi, Futoshi
/ 2005
/ Why Do Schooling Returns Differ? Screening Private Schools, and Labor Markets in the Philippines and Thailand
/ Economic Development and Cultural Change
53(4)
: 959~981
[journal]
Zamora, Christian Marvin B.
/ 2015
/ Rural-urban Education Inequality in the Philippines Using Decomposition Analysis
/ Journal of Economics, Management & Agricultural Development
1
: 62~71