근거기반설계 연구의 근거 특성과 의료건축의 근거기반실무를 위한 시사점 - HERD의 연구경향 분석을 중심으로 (The Characteristics of Evidence in Evidence-based Design Research and Their Implications to the Evidence-based Practice of Healthcare Architecture - Focused on Health Environments Research &amp; Design Journal)

김덕수 (Kim Duk-Su)

doi:10.15682/jkiha.2022.28.4.21

The Characteristics of Evidence in Evidence-based Design Research and Their Implications to the Evidence-based Practice of Healthcare Architecture - Focused on Health Environments Research & Design Journal

JOURNAL OF THE KOREA INSTITUTE OF HEALTHCARE ARCHITECTURE
Abbr : KIHA
2022, 28(4), pp.21-30
DOI : 10.15682/jkiha.2022.28.4.21
Publisher : Korea Institute Of Healthcare Architecture
Research Area : Engineering > Architectural Engineering
Received : November 3, 2022
Accepted : December 1, 2022
Published : December 15, 2022

Kim Duk-Su ¹

¹한밭대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Purpose: To prove the credibility of EBD, it is necessary to define concepts regarding the nature of credible knowledge and the hierarchy of evidence. In addition, the relationship between EBD and EBP needs to be addressed through a practical viewpoint. Methods: The systematic review is applied to define the nature of knowledge and the characteristics of research papers in architectural EBD while analyzing the field of study, knowledge focus and types of keywords of the first author. Results: As a whole, the types of research focus evaluated using the most frequent keywords include function(40.86%), specialized knowledge(30.52%), professional practice(21.37%), and health(5.78%). Empirical research(83.72%) is more likely to be found than theoretical research(13.95%). The EBD research papers ranked as top-tier are only 7(2.03%) among a total of 344, while the research papers ranked in the third to fourth tiers are 276(80.23%). Implications: There is a deficiency of reliable 1-2 tier research papers. From a practical viewpoint, it would be realistic to recommend that healthcare architects appropriately evaluate the quality of EBD research and apply it in practice, rather than to conduct EBD research themselves. This systematic review illustrates the nature of EBD research.

KEYWORDS

Evidence-based Design, Evidenced-based Practice, the Hierarchy of Evidence

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] Balshem, H. / 2011 / GRADE Guidelines: 3. Rating the Quality of Evidence / Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 64 : 401~406

[journal] Bosch, S. / 2011 / Outside the Ivory Tower: The Role of Healthcare Design Researchers in Practice / Journal of Interior Design 36(2) : 5~12

[journal] Burke, LM / 2018 / Methodologies for Investigating Performance Changes with Supplement Use / International Journal of Sport Nutrition and Exercise Metabolism 28(2) : 151~169

[web] / 2008 / CHD / https://www.healthdesign.org/certification-outreach/edac/about-ebd

[journal] Daly, J / 2007 / A Hierarchy of Evidence for Assessing Qualitative Health Research / Journal of Clinical Epidemiology 60 : 46~

[journal] Davidson, JE / 2017 / Organizing the Evidence for Healthcare Design Projects / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 10(2) : 13~22

[journal] Delvin, AS / 2003 / Health Care Environments and Patient Outcomes: A Review of the Literature / Environment and Behavior 35 : 665~694

[journal] Doherty, S. / 2005 / History of Evidence-Based Medicine. Oranges, Chloride of Lime and Leeches: Barriers to Teaching Old Dogs New Tricks / Emergency Medicine Australasia 17 : 314~321

[journal] Guyatt, GH / 2008 / GRADE: An Emerging Consensus on Rating Quality of Evidence and Strength of Recommendations / BMJ: British Medical Journal 336(7650) : 924~926

[journal] Halliday, TC / 1985 / Knowledge Mandates: Collective Influence by Scientific, Normative and Syncretic Professions / The British Journal of Sociology 36(3) : 421~447

[journal] Hamilton, DK / 2003 / The Four Levels of Evidence Based Practice / Healthcare Design 3(4) : 18~26

[journal] Hamilton, DK / 2011 / What Constitutes Best Practice in Healthcare Design? / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 4(2) : 121~126

[journal] Hamilton, DK / 2020 / Evidenced-Based Practice: Four Levels Revisited / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 13(3) : 26~29

[journal] Harris, DD / 2013 / The Role of Flooring as a Design Element Affecting Patient and Healthcare Worker Safety / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 6(3) : 98~

[journal] Ingham-Broomfield, R. / 2016 / A Nurses’ Guide to the Hierarchy of Research Designs and Evidence / Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 33(3) : 38~43

[journal] Mithun Pai, BH / 2012 / Research Design Hierarchy: Strength of Evidence in Evidence-Based Dentistry / Journal of Interdisciplinary Dentistry 2(3) : 158~163

[journal] Pati, D. / 2011 / A Framework for Evaluating Evidence in Evidence-Based Design / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 4(3) : 50~71

[journal] Peavey, E. / 2017 / Evidence-Based Design and Research-Informed Design: What’s the Differences? Conceptual Definitions and Comparative Analysis / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 10(5) : 143~156

[journal] Ranganathan, P. / 2018 / Study designs: Part 1 – Anoverview and classification / Perspectives in Clinical Research 9(4) : 184~186

[journal] Rashid, M. / 2013 / The Question of Knowledge in Evidence-Based Design for Healthcare Facilities: Limitations and Suggestions / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 6(4) : 101~126

[journal] Rashid, M. / 2008 / A review of the empirical literature on the relationships between indoor environment and stress in health care and office settings: Problems and prospects of sharing evidence / Environment and Behavior 40(2) : 151~190

[journal] Satterfield, JM / 2009 / Toward a Transdisciplinary Model of Evidence-Based Practice / The Milbank Quarterly 87(2) : 368~390

[web] Singh, AP / 2015 / What Is Hierarchy of Evidence / https://boneandspine.com/what-is-hierarchy-of-evidence/

[journal] Stankos, M. / 2007 / Evidence-Based Design in Healthcare: A Theoretical Dilemma / Interdisciplinary Design and Research e-Journal 1(1) : 1~15

[book] Stetler, C. / 2002 / Evidence-Based Practice and the Use of Research: A Synopsis of Basic Concepts & Strategies to Improve Care / NOVA Foundation

[journal] Stichler, JF / 2010 / Weighing the Evidence / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 3(4) : 3~7

[journal] Stichler, JF / 2013 / Applying Different Processes for Evidence-Based Design / Health Environments Research & Design Journal 7(1) : 8~13

[journal] Ulrich, RS / 2008 / A review of the research literature on evidence-based health-care design / Health Environment Research and Design 1(3) : 61~125

[journal] Zengul, FD / 2013 / A Review of Evidence Based Design in Healthcare from Resource-Based Perspective / Journal of Management Policy and Practice 14(2) : 19~36

KJCKorea
Journal Central

JOURNAL OF THE KOREA INSTITUTE OF HEALTHCARE ARCHITECTURE 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.46

The Characteristics of Evidence in Evidence-based Design Research and Their Implications to the Evidence-based Practice of Healthcare Architecture - Focused on Health Environments Research & Design Journal

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

JOURNAL OF THE KOREA INSTITUTE OF HEALTHCARE ARCHITECTURE 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.46

The Characteristics of Evidence in Evidence-based Design Research and Their Implications to the Evidence-based Practice of Healthcare Architecture - Focused on Health Environments Research & Design Journal

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)

REFERENCES (29) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.