@article{ART002240971},
author={Kim Seonghwan},
title={Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement},
journal={PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE},
issn={1975-1621},
year={2017},
number={24},
pages={219-239},
doi={10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009}
TY - JOUR
AU - Kim Seonghwan
TI - Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement
JO - PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE
PY - 2017
VL - null
IS - 24
PB - Research Institute for East-West Thought
SP - 219
EP - 239
SN - 1975-1621
AB - The aim of this paper is to argue that toleration as an engagement of state is more ideal than that as a non-engagement of it by analysing four examples such as Jew’s eruv, the hijab ban in France, the prohibition of female circumcision and the conscientious objection to military service. Galeotti proposes a conception of toleration as recognition to solve the problem of toleration in the public space. But her conception meets with the reputation that it is “quixotic” and gives only a mental satisfaction. An alternative is toleration as a non-engagement. The Millet system of Osman empire is a historical model of toleration of state’s non-engagement. But Millet did not respect human rights inside its own system. Newey proposes toleration as a murality and explains Jew’s eruv as a desirable model of it. But I argue that his conception of murality dose not presuppose the respect of human rights. I analyse Kant’s conception of mutual respect and Hegel’s conception of toleration as indifference as philosophical models of toleration as sates’s engagement and non-engagement and argue that Hegel’s conception is an ideal one.
KW - toleration;engagement;non-engagement;recognition;mutuality;murality;Millet;eruv;Kant;Hegel;Rawls
DO - 10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
ER -
Kim Seonghwan. (2017). Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement. PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE, 24, 219-239.
Kim Seonghwan. 2017, "Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement", PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE, no.24, pp.219-239. Available from: doi:10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
Kim Seonghwan "Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement" PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE 24 pp.219-239 (2017) : 219.
Kim Seonghwan. Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement. 2017; 24 : 219-239. Available from: doi:10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
Kim Seonghwan. "Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement" PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE no.24(2017) : 219-239.doi: 10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
Kim Seonghwan. Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement. PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE, 24, 219-239. doi: 10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
Kim Seonghwan. Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement. PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE. 2017; 24 219-239. doi: 10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
Kim Seonghwan. Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement. 2017; 24 : 219-239. Available from: doi:10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
Kim Seonghwan. "Toleration, Engagement and Non-engagement" PHILOSOPHY·THOUGHT·CULTURE no.24(2017) : 219-239.doi: 10.33639/ptc.2017..24.009
