Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.61
-
pISSN : 1225-8539 / eISSN : 2671-5171
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/japs
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Analysis of Political Change Mechanism in Kyrgyzstan: Focusing on Clan Politics
- Journal of Asia-Pacific Studies
- Abbr : JAPS
- 2023, 30(4), pp.131-174
- DOI : 10.18107/japs.2023.30.4.005
- Publisher : Institute of Global Affairs
- Research Area : Social Science > Social Science in general
- Received : October 25, 2023
- Accepted : December 19, 2023
- Published : December 30, 2023
1경희대학교 일반대학원 유럽어문학
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Is the ‘revolution’ in Kyrgyzstan ‘democratic’ as commonly understood? Isn’t it ‘packaged’ and presented by images or propaganda? The main purpose of this paper is to answer these questions and analyze the mechanism of political change here based on ‘clan’, a very important factor in this region. For this purpose, the concept of “political survival” of Bueno de Mesquita among the concepts of “political elite survival” was presented as a framework for analysis, and the Kyrgyz cabinet was set as the target of analysis. And data was organized using the ‘a Who is Who’ of Kyrgyzstan and the concepts of “inner” and “outer” circles, which uses to evaluate whether leaders implement a policy of inclusion or exclusion to the posts that hold significant political or administrative power. In addition, the political changes in Kyrgyzstan that occur through interactions between leaders and clans were discussed based on Gurr’s concept of “relative deprivation theory.” As a result of the analysis, political change in Kyrgyzstan is based on ‘clan’ and the mechanism is as follows. When power among clans converges similarly(equally) in the cabinet (especially in the “inner circle”), the clans feel ‘relative deprivation’ and express dissatisfaction and anger towards the leader. This results in political instability, and if this intensifies, political changes will occur. The significance of this paper is that it brings a greater understanding of the political transition in Kyrgyzstan, which has been lacking in the conventional wisdom of ‘democratization’ alone, by examining ‘clan’ and empirical data. And this paper suggests that ‘clan politics’ will continue to influence the future here.
Statistics
-
274 Viewed
-
229 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
강봉구
/ 2009
/ 유라시아 읽기: 현대 중앙아시아의 ‘씨족 정치(clan politics)’: 키르기스스탄의 사례
/ e-Eurasia
11
: 49~53
[journal]
강봉구
/ 2009
/
From the World to the Celestial Mountains: The Changes of Kyrgyz Foreign Policy Orientation
/ 슬라브硏究
/ 러시아연구소
25(1)
: 171~204
[journal]
구자정
/ 2011
/
Why the Soviet Union Disintegrated?: Rethinking the Bolshevik Nationality Policies and the Soviet Collapse
/ 역사학보
/ 역사학회
(210)
: 357~405
[journal]
권현종
/ 2019
/
De-Sovietization and Central Asianization of Central Asian Countries During the Soviet Union Dismantling: Focusing on Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan
/ 한국 시베리아연구
/ 한국-시베리아센터
23(2)
: 95~133
[journal]
박상남
/ 2007
/
Changes in the Central Asian Political Culture: Focusing on Changes of Political Institution
/ 중동연구
/ 중동연구소
26(1)
: 265~292
[journal]
박상남
/ 2011
/
권위주의 국가 엘리트 구조의 변화와 작동원리:독립 이후 카자흐스탄 “후견 네트워크”를 중심으로
/ 중소연구
/ 아태지역연구센터
34(4)
: 165~187
[journal]
박태성
/ 2007
/
Ukraine's Orange Revolution and Response of the Surrounding Nations
/ 동유럽발칸학
/ 한국중동부유럽학회
9(2)
: 317~348
[journal]
양정훈
/ 2011
/
People's Revolution in Kyrgyzstan -Political changes before and after the Bakiyev administration -
/ 한국 시베리아연구
/ 한국-시베리아센터
15(2)
: 238~267
[journal]
엄구호
/ 2009
/
Democracy and Clan Politics in the Post-Soviet Central Asia
/ 세계지역연구논총
/ 한국세계지역학회
27(3)
: 181~220
[journal]
우평균
/ 2017
/
Russia’s Future War Strategy:Network Centric Warfare and its Implications
/ 중소연구
/ 아태지역연구센터
41(3)
: 213~249
[journal]
윤익중
/ 2010
/
The Study of 2010 Political Upheaval in the Republic of Kyrgyzstan and the Russian Federation
/ 슬라브학보
/ 한국슬라브․유라시아학회
25(4)
: 257~289
[journal]
이경원
/ 2021
/
A Preliminary Study on Kyrgyzstan’s Citizenship Education for Initiating the Global Development Partnership
/ 초등도덕교육
/ 한국초등도덕교육학회
(75)
: 233~264
[journal]
이영형
/ 2021
/
A Study on the Deviation of Dissertations Related to Central Asia in Korea. Nationality of Researcher, Level of Dissertations, Classification by Topic
/ 한국 시베리아연구
/ 한국-시베리아센터
25(3)
: 111~146
[journal]
임경훈
/ 2003
/
Is Transitology Unable to Explain the Post-Communist Transition in Russia?
/ 국제정치논총
/ 한국국제정치학회
43(3)
: 477~494
[book]
임희섭
/ 1999
/ 집합행동과 사회운동의 이론
/ 고려대학교 출판부
[book]
진덕규
/ 1997
/ 현대정치학
/ 학문과 사상사
[journal]
황성우
/ 2010
/
A study on Lemon Revolution in Kyrgyzstan and a Possibility of East-West Hegemony
/ 국제지역연구
/ 국제지역연구센터
14(2)
: 477~498
[book]
Anderson, John
/ 1999
/ Kyrgyzstan：Central Asia’s Island of Democracy
/ Taylor & Francis
[journal]
Clionadh, Raleigh
/ 2020
/ Elite Coalitions and Power Balance across African Regimes: Introducing the African Cabinet and Political Elite Data Project (ACPED)
/ Ethnopolitics
(1)
: 22~47
[journal]
Collins, Kathleen
/ 2004
/ The Logic of Clan Politics : Evidence from the Central Asian Trajectories
/ World Politics
56(2)
: 224~261
[book]
Collins, Kathleen
/ 2006
/ Clan Politics and Regime Transition in Central Asia
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Collins, Kathleen
/ 2011
/ Kyrgyzstan’s Latest Revolution
/ Journal of Democracy
22(3)
: 150~164
[journal]
de Mesquita, Bruce Bueno
/ 2002
/ Political Institutions, Policy Choice and the Survival of Leaders
/ British Journal of Political Science
32(4)
: 559~590
[book]
de Mesquita, Bruce Bueno
/ 2005
/ The Logic of Political Survival
/ The MIT Press
[journal]
Francois, Patrick
/ 2015
/ How is Power Shared in Africa?
/ Econometrica
83(2)
: 465~503
[journal]
Hale, Henry E.
/ 2005
/ Regime Cycles: Democracy, Autocracy, and Revolution in Post-Soviet Eurasia
/ World Politics
58(1)
: 133~165
[book]
Jones, Kevin D
/ 2010
/ A Culture of Protests: The Government Overthrow in the Kyrgyz Republic in 2010
/ Center for International &Security Studies
[journal]
Juraev, Shairbek
/ 2008
/ Kyrgyz Democracy? The Tulip Revolution and Beyond
/ Central Asian Survey
27
: 253~264
[journal]
Kopstein, Jeffrey S.
/ 2000
/ Geographic Diffusion and the Transformation of the Postcommunist World
/ World Politics
53(1)
: 1~37
[book]
Kreuzer, Peter
/ 2005
/ Politics Political Clans and Violence in the Souther Philippines
/ Peace Research Institute Frankfurt
[journal]
Lewis, David
/ 2008
/ The Dynamics of Regime Change: Domestic and International Factors in the ‘Tulip Revolution’
/ Central Asian Survey
27(3-4)
: 265~277
[journal]
Lindemann, Stefan
/ 2011
/ The Ethnic Politics of Coup Avoidance : Evidence from Zambia and Uganda
/ Africa Spectrum
46(2)
: 3~41
[journal]
Linz, Juan J.
/ 1992
/ Political Identities and Electoral Sequences : Spain, the Soviet Union, and Yugoslavia
/ Daedalus
121(2)
: 123~139
[journal]
McFaul, Michael
/ 2002
/ The Fourth Wave of Democracy and Dictatorship : Noncooperative Transitions in the Postcommunist World
/ World Politics
54(2)
: 212~244
[book]
Mosca, Gaetano
/ 1939
/ The Ruling Class
/ McGraw-Hill Book Company
[book]
Przeworski, Adam
/ 1991
/ Democracy and the Market: Political and Economic Reforms in Eastern Europe and Latin America
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Radnitz, Scott
/ 2006
/ What Really Happened in Kyrgyzstan?
/ Journal of Democracy
17(2)
: 132~146
[journal]
Raleigh, Clionadh
/ 2020
/ Elite Coalitions and Power Balance across African Regimes: Introducing the African Cabinet and Political Elite Data Project (ACPED)
/ Ethnopolitics
21(1)
: 22~47
[journal]
Schmitter, Philippe C.
/ 1994
/ The Conceptual Travels of Transitologists and Consolidologists: How Far to the East Should They Attempt to Go?
/ Slavic Review
53(1)
: 173~185
[journal]
Way, Lucan A.
/ 2007
/ Linkage, Leverage, and the PostCommunist Divide
/ East European Politics and Societies : And Cultures
21(1)
: 48~66
[book]
Way, Lucan A.
/ 2010
/ Competitive Authoritarianism : Hybrid Regimes after the Cold War
/ Cambridge University Press
[book]
О. И. Брусина
/ 2016
/ Кыргызы. Ин-тэтнологии и антропологии им Н.Н. Миклухо-Маклая РАН, Ин-т истории и культурного на следия НАН КР
/ Наука
[journal]
Болпонова, А.Б.
/ 2013
/ Формирование Кыргызского Политического Клана Середины XX - Начала XXI вв
/ Вестник КРСУ
13(6)
: 3~5
[journal]
Болпонова, А.Б.
/ 2015
/ Политические кланы Кыргызстана: история и современность
/ Центральная Азия и Кавказ
18(3-4)
: 57~72
[journal]
Бородин, Е.
/ 2013
/ Клановый характер устройства киргизской республики
/ Россия и мусульманскиймир
(5)
: 48~59
[journal]
Воронин, С.А.
/ 2019
/ Клановая иерархия как основа‘тюльпановой ре волюции’ в Кыргызстане
/ Вестник Российскогоуниверситета дружбы народо в. Серия: Всеобщая история
11(2)
: 161~171
[book]
Егоров, В.Г.
/ 2020
/ Кланы в Актуальном ПолитическомПроцессе Постс оветских Стран Центральной Азии
/ ВестникМосковского госдарственного об ластного университета
: 36~47
[journal]
Комкова, С. С.
/ 2018
/ Политические элиты в государствах ЦентральнойАзии: общ ие черты и коренные различия
/ Архонт
(2)
: 90~97
[journal]
Ханин В.
/ 2000
/ Кыргызстан: этническийплюрализм и политическиеконфликты
/ Центральная Азия и Кавказ
(3)
: 81~85
[web]
/ African Cabinet and Political Elite Data Project (ACPED)
/ https://versus-erc.com/data-acped
[web]
/ AKIpress
/ https://who.ca-news.org/
[web]
Economist Intelligence Unit
/ 2022년 EIU 민주주의 지수 보고서(EIU report Democracy Index 2022)
/ https://www.eiu.com/n/campaigns/democracy-index-2022/
[web]
Freedom House
/ NIT 2022년 보고서(Nations in Transit 2022)
/ www.freedomhouse.org
[web]
Freedom House
/ NIT 지수 2012년 보고서(Nations in Transit 2012)
/ www.freedomhouse.org
[web]
/ Rulers
/ https://www.rulers.org/
[web]
/ Кыргыз санжырасы
/ https://sanjyra.net/
[web]
/ Кыргыз Республикасынын Министрлер Кабинети
/ https://www.gov.kg/ky
[web]
/ ЦентрАзия
/ https://centrasia.org/person.php