Broad Consent in Biobank Research (바이오뱅크 연구에서 포괄적 동의 )

SangMok Lee (이상목)

Broad Consent in Biobank Research

Journal of the Korea Bioethics Association
2012, 13(1), pp.15-24
Publisher : The Korean Bioethics Association
Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Interdisciplinary Research

SangMok Lee ¹

¹동아대학교

Candidate

ABSTRACT

An important ethical issue regarding biological samples stored in biobanks is unforeseen future sample use, when no or limited subject consent is obtained. Biobanks of biological samples have significant future research potential, but may cause conflicts of interest regarding the consent obtained,Some peoples argue that broad consent is valid ethically and should be recommended for biobank research provided that: personal information related to research is handled safely; donors of biological samples are granted the right to withdraw consent; and new research studies or changes to the legal or ethical authority of a biobank are approves by an IRB. We criticize that they ignore a basic requirement for autonomy, understanding. Combined with an over sized eagerness to promote research and recruitment, this combination of risk and information ignorance can become dangerous.

KEYWORDS

biobank, human material, informed consent, broad consent, research ethics biobank, human material, informed consent, broad consent, research ethics

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[other] 보건복지가족부 / 2008 / 유전자은행 표준운영지침 / 생명윤리정책연구센터 : 2~

[journal] 이상욱 / 2005 / 바이오뱅크: 현황과 문제점 / 생명윤리 6(1) : 35~47

[journal] 이상욱 / 2011 / The Need of Public Discussion for the Desirable Operation of a Biobank / 생명윤리 / 한국생명윤리학회 12(1) : 33~52

[book] Beauchamp T. / 2009 / Principles of Biomedical Ethics / Oxford University Press : 99~140

[journal] Hofmann B / 2009 / Broadening consent-and diluting ethics? / Journal of Medical Ethics 35 : 126~

[journal] Hansson M. G. / 2006 / Should donors be allowed to give broad consent to future biobank research? / Lancet Oncol 7 : 266~

[journal] Hansson M. G. / 1998 / Balancing the quality of consent / Journal of Medical Ethics 24 : 182~187

[journal] Hansson M. G. / 2005 / Building on relationships of trust in biobank research / Journal of Medical Ethics 31 : 412~418

[journal] Hansson M. G. / 2006 / Should donors be allowed to give broad consent to future biobank research? / Lancet Oncol 7 : 266~269

[journal] Hansson M. G. / 2009 / Ethics and biobanks / British Journal of Cancer 100

[journal] Maschke K.J. / 2005 / Navigating an ethical patchwork-human gene banks / Nat Biotechnol 33 : 539~545

[other] 보건복지가족부 / 유전자은행 표준운영지침 : 3~

[journal] McGuire A.L. / 2006 / No longer de-identified / Science 312 : 370~371

[journal] Hofmann B. / Broadening consent-and diluting ethics? / Journal of Medical Ethics 35 : 126~

[journal] Meslin E.M. / 2004 / Ethical issues in the collection, storage, and research use of human biological materials / Journal of Lab Clinical Medicine 144 : 229~234

[journal] S.J. Edwards / 2007 / Differences between research ethics committees / Internationa Journal of Assess Health Care 23 : 17~23

[journal] M G, Hansson / Should donors be allowed to give broad consent to future biobank research? / Lancet Oncology 7(2) : 266~269

[other] Hofmann B. / Broadening consent-and diluting ethics? : 127~

[journal] Wendler D. / 2002 / Does the Current Consent Process Minimize the Risks of Genetics Research? / American Journal of Medical Genetics 113 : 258~

[journal] Dave Wendler / 2002 / Does Current Consent Process Minimize the Risks of Genetics Research? / American Journal of Medical Genetics 113 : 258~262

[journal] Petrini C. / 2010 / “Broad” consent, exceptions to consent and the question of using biological samples for research purposes different from the initial collection purpose / Social Science & Medicine 70 : 219~210

[journal] K Matsui / 2005 / Informed consent, participation in and withdrawal from a population based cohort study involving genetic analysis / J Medical Ethics 31 : 385~392

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of the Korea Bioethics Association 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.55