The Korean Journal of Archival Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.98
-
pISSN : 1229-7941 / eISSN : 2671-7891
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/ksas
KJCKorea
Journal Central
An Analysis of Discourses on Interpreting and Applying the Principle of Provenance in Archival Organization
- The Korean Journal of Archival Studies
- 2017, (52), pp.59-117
- DOI : 10.20923/kjas.2017.52.060
- Publisher : Korean Society Of Archival Studies
- Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science
- Received : March 31, 2017
- Accepted : April 21, 2017
- Published : April 30, 2017
1부산대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This study aims to logically investigate the changing interpretation and implementation of the principle of provenance by using an argument model for discourse analysis. First, it divides the history of discourses on the principle from the Dutch Manual publication of 1989 up to the present into four areas, which includes establishing, diffusing, transforming, and expanding or deconstructing, and articulates the core discourses of each. Second, it designs the argument model for analyzing the discourses on the principle by applying Toulmin’s argument model and Dunn’s policy argument model. Third, it selects the articles and books that cover the core discourses of the principle, and analyzes their contents in consideration of the argument model. Fourth and finally, it presents four argument models corresponding to each area of the discourses.
Statistics
-
1,290 Viewed
-
699 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[other]
국가기록원
/ 2011
/ 영구기록물 기술규칙. 기록관리업무표준(NAK/S 14:2011(v2.0))
[other]
국가기록원
/ 2007
/ 국가기록원 소장물 가이드
/ 국가기록원
[journal]
권명화
/ 2006
/
An Analysis on arguments about abolition of the patriarchal family registry system(‘Hojuje’) by using Cultural Theory and Argument Model
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
15(3)
: 203~240
[journal]
김대성
/ 2007
/
temp
/ 한국정책연구
/ 경인행정학회
7(2)
: 45~68
[journal]
박성진
/ 2002
/
일제하 조선총독부의 공문서 분류 방식
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(5)
: 179~208
[book]
박성희
/ 2014
/ 아규멘테이션 : 설득하고 설득당하는 사회의 논쟁법
/ 이화출판사
[journal]
방효순
/ 2002
/
A Study of Today's Concept and Application of the Principle of the Provenance in Archives management
/ 한국기록관리학회지
/ 한국기록관리학회
2(2)
: 69~92
[journal]
배성준
/ 2004
/
조선총독부 공문서 분류체계의 복원
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(9)
: 41~73
[journal]
설문원
/ 2012
/
Research Trends and Issues of Records and Archives Classification in Korea
/ 한국기록관리학회지
/ 한국기록관리학회
12(3)
: 203~232
[journal]
설문원
/ 2003
/
Function-Based Classification System for Public Records of Government-General of Chosun
/ 정보관리학회지
/ 한국정보관리학회
20(1)
: 457~488
[journal]
설진아
/ 2009
/
A Content Analysis on the Investigative Program, <PD Diary> Regarding ‘Stem Cell Speculation’ : Toulmin’s Argument Model Approach
/ 한국언론학보
/ 한국언론학회
53(3)
: 371~395
[journal]
유민봉
/ 1994
/ 정책분석틀로서의 정책논변모형
/ 한국행정학보
28(4)
: 1175~1190
[journal]
이승억
/ 2013
/
Accepting out of Boundary : Archival Science and the Impact of Postmodernism
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(38)
: 189~223
[journal]
이승억
/ 2002
/
전자환경에서의 기록관리 개념에 대한 재검토
/ 기록학연구
/ 한국기록학회
(6)
: 41~72
[journal]
이승일
/ 2006
/
A Plan for Classification of Public Records of the Japanese Government-General of the Joseon Preserved by the National Archives and Records Service
/ 서지학연구
/ 한국서지학회
(35)
: 113~143
[web]
Acland, G.
/ 1999
/ The end of the beginning; the SPIRT Recordkeeping Metadata Project
/ http://www.sims.monash.edu.au/research.rcrg.publiccations/asaq99.html
[journal]
Barr, Debra
/ 1988
/ The Fonds concept in the Working Group on Archival Descriptive Standards Report
/ Archivaria
25
: 163~170
[journal]
Barr, Debra
/ 1989
/ Protecting provenance: Response to the report of the Working Group on Description at the Fonds Level
/ Archivaria
28
: 141~145
[book]
Bastian, Jeanette Allis
/ 2003
/ Owning Memory: Howa Caribbean Community Lost its Archives and Found its History
/ Libraries Unlimited
[journal]
Bastian, Jeanette Allis
/ 2004
/ In a ‘House of Memory’: Discovering the provenance of place
/ Archival Issues
28
: 9~19
[book]
Bearman, David
/ 1994
/ Electronic Evidence
/ Archives & Museum Informatics
[journal]
Bearman, David
/ 1985
/ The Power of the Principle of Provenance
/ Archivaria
21(Winter)
: 14~27
[journal]
Brothman, Brien
/ 1991
/ Orders of value: Probing the theoretical terms of archival practice
/ Archivaria
32
: 78~100
[journal]
Bunn, Jenny
/ 2014
/ Questioning autonomy : an alternative perspective on the principles which govern archival description
/ Archival Science
14
: 3~15
[journal]
Cook, Terry
/ 2001
/ Archival science and postmodernism : New formulations for old concepts
/ Archival Science
1
: 3~24
[journal]
Cook, Terry
/ 1997
/ What is past is prologue : a history of archival ideas since 1898, and the future paradigm shift
/ Archivaria
43
: 17~63
[journal]
Cook, Terry
/ 1993
/ The concept of the archival fonds in the post-custodial era : theory, problems and solutions
/ Archivaria
35
: 24~37
[book]
Cook, Terry
/ 1992
/ The concept of the archival fonds: Theory, description and provenance in the post-custodial era. In: The Archival Fonds; From Theory to Practice
/ Bureau of Canadian Archivists
[book]
Douglas, Jennifer
/ 2010
/ Currents of Archival Thinking
/ Santa Barbara: Libraries Unlimited
: 23~43
[journal]
Duchein, Michel
/ 1983
/ Theoretical principles and practical problems of Respect des fonds in archival science
/ Archivaria
16
: 64~82
[journal]
Duff, W. M.
/ 2002
/ Stories and names: Archival description as narrating records and constructing meanings
/ Archival Science
2
: 263~285
[book]
Eastwood, Terry
/ 2010
/ Currents of Archival Thinking
/ Libraries Unlimited
: 3~21
[journal]
Eastwood, Terry
/ 2000
/ Putting the parts of the whole together: Systematic arrangement of archives
/ Archivaria
50
: 93~116
[journal]
Holmes, O. W.
/ 1964
/ Archival arrangement : Five different operations at five different levels
/ American Archivist
27
: 21~41
[journal]
Horsman, Peter
/ 2002
/ The last dance of the phoenix, or the de-discovery of the archival fonds
/ Archivaria
54
: 1~23
[report]
Horsman, Peter
/ 1993
/ Taming the elephant: An orthodox approach to the principle of provenance. In: The Principle of Provenance: Report from the First Stockholm Conference on the Archival Principle of Provenance
/ Swedish National Archives
[journal]
Horsman, Peter
/ 1999
/ Dirty hands : A new perspective on the original order
/ Archives and Manuscripts
27
: 42~53
[web]
Hurley, Chris
/ 2004
/ Relationships in records
/ http://www.sims.monash.edu.au/research/rcrg/publications/relationships-in-records-rev-3b.rtf
[journal]
Hurley, Chris
/ 1995
/ Problems with provenance
/ Archives and Manuscripts
23
: 234~259
[book]
International Council on Archives
/ 2000
/ General International Standard Archival Description
/ International Council on Archives
[journal]
Ketelaar, Eric
/ 2005
/ Sharing: Collected memories in communities of records
/ Archives and Manuscripts
33
: 44~61
[journal]
Ketelaar, Eric
/ 2001
/ Tacit narratives : The meaning of archives
/ Archival Science
1
: 131~141
[book]
Lowry, James
/ 2017
/ Displaced Archives
/ Routledge
[journal]
MacNeil, Heather
/ 2005
/ Picking our text : Archival description, authenticity, and the archivist as editor
/ American Archivist
68
: 265~278
[journal]
MacNeil, Heather
/ 2008
/ Archivalterity: Rethinking original order
/ Archivaria
66
: 1~24
[book]
Meehan, J.
/ 2013
/ Archives and Recordkeeping: Theory into Practice
/ Facet Publishing
[journal]
Millar L.
/ 2002
/ The death of the fonds and the resurrection of provenance : archival context in space and time
/ Archivaria
53
: 1~15
[book]
Muller, Samuel
/ 2003
/ Manual for the Arrangement and Description of Archives: Drawn up by Direction of the Netherlands Association of Archivists
/ Society of American Archivists
[journal]
Nesmith, Tom
/ 2006
/ The concept of societal provenance and records of nineteenthcentury Aboriginal-European relations in Western Canada : Implications for archival theory and practice
/ Archival Science
6
: 351~360
[journal]
Nesmith, Tom
/ 2005
/ Reopening archives : Bringing new contextualities into archival theory and practice
/ Archivaria
60
: 259~274
[journal]
Nesmith, Tom
/ 2002
/ seeing archives : Postmodernism and the changing intellectual place of archives
/ American Archivist
65
: 24~41
[journal]
Nesmith, Tom
/ 1999
/ Still fuzzy but more accurate : Some thoughts on the ‘ghosts’ of archival theory
/ Archivaria
47
: 136~150
[report]
Pohjola, Raimo
/ 1994
/ The principle of provenance and the arrangement of records/archives. In: The Principle of Provenance: Report from the First Stockholm Conference on Archival Theory and the Principle of Provenance
/ The Swedish National Archives
: 87~98
[book]
Posner, Ernst
/ 1950
/ Archives and the Public Interest: Selected Essays by Ernst Posner
/ Society of American Archivists
: 36~44
[book]
Posner, Ernst
/ 1940
/ Archives and the Public Interest: Selected Essays
/ Society of American Archivists
: 23~35
[book]
Ridener
/ 2011
/ From Polders to Postmodernism: A Concise History of Archival Theory
/ Litwin Books
[journal]
Savoja, Maurizio
/ 2007
/ Authority control for creators in Italy: Theory and practice
/ Journal of Archival Organization
5
: 121~147
[book]
Schellenberg, Theodore R.
/ 2001
/ 현대 기록학개론
/ 진리탐구
[journal]
Scott, P. J.
/ 1966
/ The record group concept : A case for abandonment
/ American Archivist
29
: 493~504
[journal]
Shilton, Katie
/ 2007
/ Participatory appraisal and arrangement for multicultural archival collections
/ Archivaria
63
: 87~101
[journal]
Stapleton, Rick
/ 1984
/ Jenkinson and Schellenberg: A comparison
/ Archivaria
17
: 75~85
[journal]
Taylor, H, A.
/ 1987
/ Transformation in the Archives: Technological Adjustment or Paradigm Shift
/ Archivaria
25
: 12~28
[journal]
Wurl, Joel
/ 2005
/ Ethnicity as provenance: In search of values and principles for documenting the immigrant experience
/ Archival Issues
29
: 65~76
[journal]
Yakel, Elizabeth
/ 2003
/ Archival representation
/ Archival Science
3
: 1~25
[journal]
Yeo, Geoffrey
/ 2012
/ The conceptual fonds and the physical collection
/ Archivaria
73
: 43~80
[journal]
Yeo, Geoffrey
/ 2012
/ Bringing things together : Aggregate records in a digital age
/ Archivaria
74
: 43~91
[book]
Yeo, Geoffrey
/ 2010
/ Currents of Archival Thinking
/ Libraries Unlimited
: 89~14
[journal]
Zhang, Jane
/ 2012
/ Original oder in digital archives
/ Archivaria
35
: 167~193
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.