A Study on Admissibility Framework for Establishing Trust in Digital Records : Focused on the Development of the Trustworthiness Model for Public Digital Records (전자기록의 신뢰가치 확립을 위한 증거능력 구현체계 연구 우리나라 공공 전자기록의 신뢰가치 모델 개발을 중심으로)

Hyun, Moonsoo (현문수)

doi:10.20923/kjas.2022.73.005

A Study on Admissibility Framework for Establishing Trust in Digital Records : Focused on the Development of the Trustworthiness Model for Public Digital Records

The Korean Journal of Archival Studies
2022, (73), pp.5-46
DOI : 10.20923/kjas.2022.73.005
Publisher : Korean Society Of Archival Studies
Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science
Received : June 30, 2022
Accepted : July 18, 2022
Published : July 31, 2022

Hyun, Moonsoo ¹

¹부산대학교 사회과학연구원

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This study aims to develop the trustworthiness model for public digital records, as an admissibility framework for establishing trust. The trustworthiness model is deemed to used to identify the qualities of the digital records in their lifecycle, including the identity that could be identified at the time of the creation, integrity obtained from the chain-of-custodial management, the evidence of relationship between business activities and records, and the technical or cognitive accessibility. 전자기록의 신뢰가치 확립을 위한 증거능력 구현체계 연구 7 Based on the analysis of the QADEP model, it was decided to develop a model that could measure the trustworthiness of public digital records in the external measurement type, which are authenticity, reliability, and usability. In line with this direction, the model expanded measurement areas and indicators of the QADEP model through the analysis of ISO 16175-1:2020, and measuring metrics was also proposed so that it could be a measuring instrument for public digital records in Korea, after analysing NAK 19-3. It would be useful to expand the model and to test the approach of the trustworthiness model for public digital records.

KEYWORDS

trustworthiness of digital records, legal admissibility, trustworthiness model, quality requirement, electronic records management, digital records management

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 박서인 / 2020 / A Study on the Analysis and Improvement of Public Enterprises’ Record Management for the Utilization of Record as Legal Evidence / 한국기록관리학회지 / 한국기록관리학회 20(2) : 41~65

[journal] 서혜란 / 2003 / Maintaining the Authenticity of Electronic Records in the Electronic Records Management Systems / 정보관리학회지 / 한국정보관리학회 20(2) : 241~262

[journal] 설문원 / 2005 / Quality Criteria for Measuring Authenticity, Reliability, Integrity and Usability of Records / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (11) : 41~90

[journal] 설문원 / 2022 / Archival Meaning of Legal Evidence / 한국기록관리학회지 / 한국기록관리학회 22(1) : 219~235

[journal] 설문원 / 2016 / Business Records and Information Management as Preparation for e - Discovery Risks / 한국기록관리학회지 / 한국기록관리학회 16(4) : 7~30

[journal] 윤은하 / 2019 / A Study on the Concepts of Record from a Legal Perspective / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (60) : 89~121

[journal] 이승억 / 2017 / A Study of Redesigning Electronic Records Management Policies / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (52) : 5~37

[journal] 이젬마 / 2020 / A Study on the Judgment of Authoritative Records by Applying the Concept of Authenticity and Reliability / 한국기록관리학회지 / 한국기록관리학회 20(3) : 77~97

[journal] 이젬마 / 2021 / A Study on Securing the Quality of Trusted Digital Records as Evidence: Focusing on Analysis of Quality Concept and Requirements for Records and Evidence Respectively Covered in Records Management and Judicial Domain / 한국비블리아학회지 / 한국비블리아학회 32(3) : 217~246

[journal] 정미리 / 2016 / A Study on the Records Management for Evidence-Based Accountability of Corporations : Focusing on Sustainability Reports / 기록학연구 / 한국기록학회 (48) : 45~92

[thesis] 최영민 / 2018 / 전자기록의 증거능력 인정요건에 관한 기록학적 분석 / 석사 / 부산대학교 대학원

[book] 현문수 / 2018 / 기록관리의 이론과 실제 / 조은글터 : 353~408

[book] Cook, M / 1986 / The Management of Information from Archives / Gower : 129~

[journal] Duranti, L. / 2010 / Digital records forensics: A new science and academic program for forensic readiness / Journal of Digital Forensics, Security and Law 5(2) : 45~62

[journal] Jansen, A. / 2015 / Object-oriented diplomatics : Using archival diplomatics in software application development to support authenticity of digital records / Records Management Journal 25(1) : 45~55

[book] Jenkinson, H / 2003 / 힐러리 젠킨슨의 기록관리편람 / 정부기록보존소

[journal] MacNeil, H. / 2000 / Providing grounds for trust: Developing conceptual requirements for the long-term preservation of authentic electronic records / Archivaria 50 : 52~78

[web] Mason, S / 2006 / Proof of the authenticity of a document in electronic format introduced as evidence / ARMA International Educational Foundation / https://armaedfoundation.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/06/Proof_of_authenticity_of_a_document-1.pdf

[journal] Rogers, C. / 2016 / A literature review of authenticity of records in digital systems: From ‘machine-readable’ to records in the cloud / Acervo-Rio de Janeiro 29(2) : 16~44

[thesis] Makhlouf Shabou, B. / 2010 / Étude sur la définition et la mesure des qualités des archives définitives issues d’une évaluation / doctor / Université de Montréal

[book] Makhlouf Shabou, B. / 2014 / De la préservation à la conservation : Stratégies pratiques d’archivage / demia-L’Harmattan : 87~98

[journal] Makhlouf Shabou, B. / 2015 / Digital diplomatics and measurement of electronic public data qualities : What lessons should be learned? / Records Management Journal 25(1) : 56~77

[journal] Makhlouf Shabou, B. / 2020 / Algorithmic methods to explore the automation of the appraisal of structured and unstructured digital data / Records Management Journal 30(2) : 175~200

[journal] Xie, S. L / 2011 / Building foundations for digital records forensics: A comparative study of the concept of reproduction in digital records management and digital forensics / The American Archivist 74(2) : 576~599

[other] / 2016 / 문헌정보 - 기록관리 - 제1부: 개념과 원칙. KS X ISO 15489-1

[other] / 2015 / 전자기록생산시스템 기록관리 기능요건- 제3부: 업무관리시스템(v1.0). NAK 19-3

[other] / 2020 / Information and documentation — Processes and functional requirements for software for managing records - Part 1: Functional requirements and associated guidance for any applications that manage digital records / ISO 16175-1

This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.

KJCKorea
Journal Central

The Korean Journal of Archival Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.98

A Study on Admissibility Framework for Establishing Trust in Digital Records : Focused on the Development of the Trustworthiness Model for Public Digital Records

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

The Korean Journal of Archival Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.98

A Study on Admissibility Framework for Establishing Trust in Digital Records : Focused on the Development of the Trustworthiness Model for Public Digital Records

ABSTRACT

KEYWORDS

Statistics

Tools

Issue List

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)

REFERENCES (27) * References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

Search PDF

Citation

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.